While the US was doing genocide against the Apache, how many asked, "Do you condemn Geronimo?"

The interview with the kid, Nemr, is so painful to watch and listen.

I condemn them who condemn HAMAS.

Would be interesting to hear a conversation outside the echo chamber, with people that actually support Zionism and the existence of Israel. It would be a lot more interesting and educating.

But question remains Do you comdomn Khaamaas!!

While this is a not the nazi zionist stance you are still adopting a lot of their views, its like you show up when a criminal is being served a sentence and you feel bad for them because you chose to be blind to their crimes. First to condemn someone you need to know what they did and what made them do it. So far no one can claim they know what exactly happened on Oct 7. What we know so far is that the main target was the Gaza squad which already had a lot of blood on their hands. What you don't know is that the plan to ethnically cleanse Gaza has been in the works for decades, in 2021 and after years of preparing Sinai to take Palestinians, the Egyptian zionist agent El Sisi offered part of Sinai so that the nazi zionist takes Gaza and the oil within its waters and the Neten yaho map in the UN 2 weeks before Oct 7 is proof. So just like the nazi zionist terrorists claim the Arabs were going to attack them so that is why they launched the 6 day war, Hamas was fed up being on the defensive all the time and knew they are sitting ducks thus had to act. Notes: 1. 15:05 the outfit is for protection as they have more humanity in them than you will ever understand 2. 15:22 Resistance fighters will never shoot or bang the heads of a boy or a girl, they only go after nazi zionist terrorists 3. The nazis keep asking this condemn question because they don't accept that humans are equal, to them it's okay to occupy, colonize and ruin the lives of generations and if anyone dare take a swipe at them then that is terror, if you try to list their crimes they shrug it 4. The nazis think this is a trick question because if you say No then they follow up with so you support terrorists when in fact they are the real terrorists 5. The nazis will repeat many lies like rape, so during a few hours of battle they decided to rape but during a 50 days being hostages no one touched them?? 6. There are two main groups of people, those who benefit from zionist evil actions (directly or indirectly) and of course these are just racist nazis, and those that their lives were ruined by the nazi zionists and of course they understand the resistance better than anyone 7. There are some people like this Shapiro who have some humanity in them, and for that I salute you, but are not connected so they dance on the fence Finally do a video on the questions: does Israel have the right to defend itself and does Israel have the right to exist

Thank you, Jay, for this wonderful philosophical analysis of the question. I can assure you that your answer is complete. As a Palestinian, I understand what Nimr goes through and what he thinks about if he were to join the resistance. That boy is no typical child like the ones you see in the West. While in captivity, he was thinking about feeding his younger sister-this boy is more of a man than one might think. In fact, most Palestinian boys are, and this is a result of the situation they were born into. Let me assure you, the moment he becomes a fighter, he will only seek victory, and victory doesn’t come from harming the innocent. He knows that very well and doesn’t wish to make innocents suffer as he has suffered. Fighters in the H group have shown humanity on multiple occasions with the captives they took. We all heard their testimonies in the past few months following the truce in November of last year. These young men just want to liberate themselves; the only vengeance they seek is from the combatants, not the people collectively.

You have taken the wrong meaning of the word condemn. In this context it simply means expressing strong disapproval. And anyone who values human life irrespective of what side they are on should condemn Hamas as well as what Israel is doing to innocent lives.

Great show. Thanks Jay. Forgiveness is the key to diplomacy. Apologies are powerful An apology is the first step in forgiving yourself and forgiving others. Apologies are powerful. How often do you hear those two lines? Often in our society we think of apologies as a sign of weakness. “Never say you’re sorry. “ How many times of you heard that? I say that an apology can level the playing field. It can defuse an explosive situation like a magic incantation. Ultimately, it allows others to see and hear that you can take responsibility for your actions. And the most beautiful side effect? You can forgive yourself for carrying around that burden in the first place. Powerful Healing is a matter of time and forgiveness. But it is also a matter of great opportunity. Let it go. Apologize. Unburden. Communicate

Wow what a lot hogwash I’ve listened to 6mins and I’ve learned nothing Anyway if any people have been condemned more then the Jews up until this day, let me know

Condemnation should be based on how well informed a person is.

What a fantastic and refreshing perspective focusing on the psyche. More of this kind of communication is needed to build bridges and achieve success in peace

Jeremiah 17:9 The heart is deceitful above all things, and desperately wicked: who can know it? A Hebrew prophet

I condemn the system and the enablers for the system that creates things like Hamas.

Thank you; so well put. There was an investigation, sometimes in the 90's or 2000's to see just what makes suicide bombers tick. Israeli psychologists interviewed people who had known or been around suicide bombers. There findings indicated that they almost invariably had been people who had lost family members or more often, their ENTIRE family. Mostly, these people had become "little Samsons", determined - right or wrong - in their extreme existential trauma to bring as many of "the enemy" with them as they could.. So, in view of this, the present "leadership" seem dead set on sewing an entirely NEW crop of "dragons teeth" to be contended with further on down the road. Are they any wiser than Armstrong Custer?

Bassam Youseff’s response to being asked this question is the best. He lays it out very simply and undresses it to show the blatant bias and hypocrisy.

This victim statement changed my life: kzbin.info/www/bejne/ZouYhHp_aq-XpNU From condemnation to salvation.

Nemir did not say he wanted to avenge himself on random Israelis. He wants to avenge himself specifically, on the soldier who brutalized and humiliated him. I think this is important to observe. The more condemnable party is the one who both harms directly, and then twists the psyche of their victim through their infliction of harm and degradation. Even Jesus, for those who call themselves Christian, tells followers that to ruin the innocence of any is condemnable (ie., “a stone hung around his neck and thrown into the sea”).

No I don't. At this point they are defending themselves just like any military would do. Isra3l and America are so arrogant they think people should just take their abuse lying down.

Interesting that he takes the example of being woke as being aware that “what your boss wants is not what’s good for you”. In a world where the most active real-work manifestation of wokeness is in corporate reeducation programs used to bully employees into submission, what does that say about the self-awareness of this woke advocate? EDIT: ok so he does mention the capture of wokeness by corporations. He doesn’t go as far as drawing any questions about a potential woke grift, and that this could be the main source of its cultural energy, and instead puts the blame on capitalism. But what does it say about a movement that it gets so perfectly adopted by capitalist corporations? Surely that’s an interesting question. Socialism, and basically working class politics don’t seem to be co-opted so well. On the contrary, wokeness is precisely the thing that obfuscates these class and labour questions. There are reason why the labour questions are “not discussed nearly enough in the woke conversation”. I think it’s worth wondering whether that not the entire purpose of why this movement exists as something that everybody can painlessly subscribe to, especially in society’s aspiring managerial class.

Post modern boogyman, that “they want a 6ft4 man play with your middle school daughter”? What I hear is more of a strawman of the “anti-woke” position here, especially by the method of obfuscating the reality of what’s being opposed. There are activists, who have literally succeeded in a very short amount of time, at putting “only” a 5’9” dude who’s been training for 3 months in a position where they can win the trophies that your daughter has been training to win for the past 10 years. That has actually happened, it’s not a right-wing fantasy. It’s the real world, in the realm that makes up 90% of some people’s enjoyment of life. We can have a discussion about how right, fair, just it is and so on. But let’s not pretend it hasn’t happened….

Man, what an essay. I’m so glad I found you. I’m struggling to keep a coherent moral stance in this mess. This was a beautiful journey. I almost dread to look up the rest of your content and find out that the rest of it is yet another culture wars boilerplate channel 😅

Respects ❤

Huge respect from pakistan.

A different kind of Shapiro.

Do you know how damned is Zionism?

THE FAMOUS GERMAN LINGUIST AUGUST SCHLOZER UNLIKE,SHAKESPEARE WHO COINED/ INVENTED MORE THAN 1700 TERM/WORD !!!! THE LINGUIST JUST COINED/INVENTED ONE 1️⃣ TERM/WORD : " SEMITE/ SEMITIC " TO DESCRIBE: " ALL THE TRIBES ( PEOPLES) AND THE LANGUAGES SPOKEN SINCE THE BRONZE AGE IN SOUTHWEST ASIA " ARAB/ARABIC, AMHARA/AMHARIC,JEWS/HEBREW ARE THE 3 SURVIVORS OF OVER 28 THAT ARE EXTINCT NOW - ARABIC IS SPOKEN BY OVER 500 MILLIONS WORLDWIDE AND UNDERSTOOD IN VARIOUS LEVELS BY ANOTHER CLOSE TO 2 BILLION MUSLIMS, SINCE ARABIC IS THE LANGUAGE OF THE QURAN ... - AMHARIC IS SPOKEN BY NEARLY 35 MILLIONS MAINLY IN ETHIOPIA 🇪🇹 AND ERITREA 🇪🇷 .... - HEBREW IS SPOKEN BY NEARLY 14 MILLIONS WORLDWIDE ... SURPRISINGLY " SEMITE/SEMITIC IS USED EXCLUSIVELY FOR JEWS AND HEBREW WHILE THE FAMOUS LINGUIST AUGUST SCHLOZER COINED/ INVENTED THE TERM/WORD TO DESCRIBE " ALL THE TRIBES AND LANGUAGES " SO LOGICALLY AND ACCORDING TO THE DEFINITION: - ARAB/ ARABIC - AMHARA/ AMHARIC - JEWS/ HEBREW ARE ALL " SEMITE/ SEMITIC !!!! SOME COULD ARGUE THAT THE LINGUIST IS GERMAN !!!! YES AUGUST SCHLOZER IS GERMAN BUT HE COINED/ INVENTED THE TERM/WORD 156 YEARS BEFORE THE HOLOCAUST !!! YES 156 YEARS BEFORE THE HOLOCAUST!!!! ARAB/ARABIC IS A CULTURAL IDENTITY REGARDLESS OF RELIGION OR ETHNICITY LIKE THE LATE PALESTINIAN SCHOLAR EDWARD SAID WHO IS A PALESTINIAN CHRISTIAN BORN IN JERUSALEM BUT HE IS ALSO AN ARAB SINCE HE SPOKE THE LANGUAGE AND HAD THE SAME TRADITION AND CUSTOMS !!! THE ISRAELI SCHOLAR PROF. AVI SHLAIM INTRODUCES HIMSELF: " I AM AN ARAB JEW AND WAS BORN IN BAGHDAD. .....

No sane person condemns resistance to illegal military occupation

As an Irishman, no, I do not condemn resistance. I want nobody hurt, but Izrahell started this.

What’s this Blacks with machetes cloaked in religious ecstasy……..Please school me on this

I was 4 years old in Rwanda when the genocide took place.. I lost everyone except my mum, And I remember before the genocide I wanted to be a doctor or a priest, immediately after the genocide all I wanted was to join the Army so I can find people responsible for killing my siblings and injuring my mum. I wanted this for a long time but luckily I was able to leave that environment and live in the UK where I was allowed to grow and play and feel safe. I stopped feeling the urge to join the army and my Drive to help people returned and it what I now do.

The problem is when it comes to Israelis' obvious war crimes people like Piers would say how its not “black and white” and there are “nuances”. But when they ask if you condemn Hamas all of sudden its now a binary question with clear distinctions. The question gives away the person's intentions. Great video and the kid was heartbreaking

I went into the video thinking it 'd be safe to watch in the sense that it'll be an intellectual discussion of the issue, hopefully of course it won't be from a zio nist angle because I can definitely spare my blood some boiling it doesn't need. I thought it was safe because surely zio nists would never attempt any serious discussion about Ha mas or Palestinians and Palestine in general. And most importantly I thought it was safe because my eyes were already puffy from crying them out last night and yesterday's morning and the helpless on and off crying I've been doing for the past 8 months. I said to myself that could be potentially informative and not so heartbreaking at the same time but then Nemr's tears found their way to me and broke me again.

So many shapiros who are nothing like ben shapiro if you know what I mean 😏

I could say the same thing towards the algerian revolution against the french

One word .... Resistance

O condemn the genocidal state of israel

This was eloquently argued. I would answer "I don't condemn Hamas because they, alongside all Palestinians are already condemned for the last 56 years to live in a brutal military occupation, so what you're really asking me is to condemn them twice. What you really want from the Palestinians isn't for them to be peaceful, you're expecting from them to be masochists, because this is what someone would be when they're being peaceful and docile in the face of blatant and constant impingement of their most basic human rights."

It’s a very intriguing, interesting and amazing analysis of the condemnations. I despise Piers and people like him when starting the interviews with the condemnations. It’s very tricky and traps for this question when a person can and will lose a career. I just see Piers looking for profits and audiences. I love your show and subscribe to it. I hope you will invite into your show giant inspiration, intellectual, knowledge, academic and character such as Norman Finkelstein, Noam Chomsky, Rashid Khalidi, Ali Abunimah, Max Blumenthal, Mehdi Hasan, and Bassem Yousef. Peace, Salom and Salam.

@Jay shapiro can you try and talk to a political stream destiny? Hes a quite pro isreali and pro isreali war against hamas, hes one of the most powerful, and i believe unfair voices on isreal v Palestine and would love to hear you guys talk, hes a pretty easy to talk abt

Asking "Do you condemn Hamas?" is a trap because it forces a binary response to a complex issue, creating a false dichotomy. It pressures the person to align with one side, oversimplifying their views and potentially misrepresenting their stance. The question diverts the conversation from more nuanced discussions about the broader conflict, underlying causes, and possible solutions. It is designed to corner the respondent into making a politically charged statement, rather than fostering genuine dialogue.

Thank you for this video. I hope it gets to a lot of people.

How de we know that the native american thought of the europeans as scum, because they were racist? Maybe that was just anger that manifests in hatred and racism. Kind of like the Palestinians now. A lot of them do not like jewish people at all. But that is because the people who are mistreating them, happen to be jewish.

Maybe an interesting case to explore is how Holocaust survivors massacred innocent Arab civilians and dispelled thousands to conquer the city Lydda in 1948. Meanwhile, though minority, other Holocaust survivors refused Zionism. How they get there? Is it abstract mental metamorphosis or actually a combination of power and ideology?

Well said.

Nimr is likely also crying over the memories of the pain and fear and massive loss of family. Multigenerational trauma breeds more of it.

Nope. I condemn Jews everywhere period

Thanks 🙏🙏

A new type of Hasbara 😘

I honestly wonder what you expect them to do if not armed resistance? This is the only direct action that woke up the entire world and put Palestine back on the fucking map! It took the mask off not only Zionism, but the hypocrisy of democracy amongst the great powers of the West!! It shattered it at the very core and started crumbling the Zionist Entity, forever will Israel be exposed and seen for what it truly is. And don't tell me there were other options, they tried everything and was repeatedly shut down time after time again for 75 + years. But as of now, yes I hope for this to be solved through political actions and direct pressure amongst the international community.