This movie stinks, technically, historically, and factually. From a 8 year Navy man who was at NSWC Indian Head during the propellant powder part of the investigation.
@zippyzipster4620 сағат бұрын
“You see something Tinker?” “A polar bear fell on me..”
@jgesselbertyКүн бұрын
Great performance, but not pleased with the staging. Frankly the nuns looked more like they were wearing burqas than habits.
@soundknightКүн бұрын
How embarrassing!😊
@lotto123ishКүн бұрын
This ship is one huge garbage bag.
@jbrobertson6052Күн бұрын
This film disgusts me by the way sailors and their families were treated. The higher up the food chain corruption is sickening and maddening to the point I am angry and so freakin mad that I am not even sure that I am going to watch past 53:55. I'm a Canadian who was a civilian employee of our Canadian Navy as a Marine Engineer on the Canadian Forces Auxiliary Vessels (CFAV) under the Queens Harbor Master (QHM) and there is corruption everywhere but not at the level and as frequent as in the States
@fredrezfield16292 күн бұрын
finally a great quality
@theresas7402 күн бұрын
Marcia Gay Harden is a stellar actress as well. I could really feel her terror as she wanted to g.t.f.o. that bar, and she spoke not ONE line! Brilliant performance from her, too.
@CC_Fan20243 күн бұрын
Hold me, just hold me...
@jetplane103 күн бұрын
Cool 🤩
@CC_Fan20243 күн бұрын
I appreciate this movie at this time, I has helped me see the roots of the rot we are experiencing to an extreme today. Thank you for making this available to us for free.
@lukedaniel22944 күн бұрын
Even if his wife and kids never realized it, they were better off without him.
@starlingbird4 күн бұрын
If I was there in person, I couldn't applaud at the end (even though they certainly deserve it) because I am so choked with grief and emotion. A powerful opera and amazing performance. Thank you.😢💔
@coleyounger58824 күн бұрын
No film ever made about our navy or any of our military branches disgust me more than this depiction of events. The fact that many of us can attest to similar events throughout decades gone by is deeply distressing.
@tyrell96725 күн бұрын
This movie makes me not appreciate cops
@tyrell96725 күн бұрын
46:34 our pathetic justice system
@cathyshinkoskey1256 күн бұрын
Damon looks soo young
@CC_Fan20243 күн бұрын
I think it is because he was so young. This movie wasn't made yesterday.
@bonitaroberts12176 күн бұрын
Great movie!!!
@CC_Fan20243 күн бұрын
I think so too.
@pgreen85316 күн бұрын
Nothing changes with corruption on any decade 💯 anything to expand their careers 😮😮
@THEFALCON587 күн бұрын
Officers/ captain/government tried to scapegoat the sailers than them selfs, officers/ captain/government.corruption
@marioalbertohernandez36517 күн бұрын
Ese tenor seguramente posee una de las voces mas bellas de tenor de rodos los tiempos.
@danielrutschman46188 күн бұрын
I see some comments criticizing the accuracy of some of the scenes and props. So what? It's the truth of the story that matters, not whether the actors all wore the correct uniforms or whatever. Save your complaints for the corrupt navy officers who tried to scapegoat a dead victim rather than admit error.
@melodygarrison75318 күн бұрын
I live in south west Indiana we have more jobs than people right now. So move here if you need a job
@ElizabethTyler-rv5lk9 күн бұрын
This movie breaks my heart I'm 73 this year and I have lived through this and watched my friends go One by one.
@jetplane103 күн бұрын
Hello Elizabeth 🙋♀️
@ElizabethTyler-rv5lk9 күн бұрын
We got trouble. Right here in river city
@ElizabethTyler-rv5lk9 күн бұрын
Put America back to work for America. No foreign products. USA made
@ElizabethTyler-rv5lk9 күн бұрын
I was blessed phone tech had a great union still retired with great. benefits. Verizon land line. 40 years. This country needs good unions again. Companies treat employees like shit. CWA UNION
9 күн бұрын
i watched a story of the investigation after the explosion. one of the men interviewed , i think from turret # 1 , said that the static electricity in the air was so bad , the hair on your arms was standing up . could that have been the cause of the spark that caused the explosion.? did anyone pay attention to that statement ?
@jbrobertson6052Күн бұрын
I have seen 1st hand what static electricity can do and what you said could and can be true for the cause and I never would have thought of it if it wasn't for your comments
@JamesKeiley9 күн бұрын
Couldn't leave people alone evil dude demon
@JamesKeiley9 күн бұрын
What a weirdo narasist
@kcbh249 күн бұрын
15:52 that's funny because Matt Damon sang My Funny Valentine in The Talented Mr. Ripley.
@sixtysense9 күн бұрын
Watching this in 2025 is such an insight. 75 years later, this is truer than ever and only those suffering know it. Thank you so much for posting this.
@aussiedave124810 күн бұрын
The truth and facts don't matter when it comes to the so called big boys they cover each other's asses and lied their butts off. Many low ranks that had important info were hidden away, not allowed to give evidence. The problem is that no one will ever be held accountable because corruption is written into the big boy's club of cover my ass and I will cover yours code. I am amazed they were allowed to make this movie or release it, we know there was a cover up, we know they lie and the W.H. backs this B.S. up. Now 2025 it's about to get a whole lot worse, corruption will be written into the constitution if performed by a Maga politician or approved by said person for others to commit on said politician's behalf. He or maybe she will be above the law and is given licence to lie their ass off for said politician or a representative without repercussions.
@Yalnif520010 күн бұрын
If you watched this and the only thing you came away with is the wrong term for a sailor, the beer, and the size and location of a berth, you are truly not worth listening to. The story is and still is today of the the officers and the major leaders of our combined military units still have zero care about screwing enlisted personnel while covering the stars blatant and disgusting behavior and the lies that they will go to for their own protection. (22 years active duty)
@OdeeOz11 күн бұрын
Never could find out WHY Hollyweird didn't have the correct "Naval Lieutenant" Silver Collar Bar (aka Army Captain) on the main Lieutenant in the film.
@drekovskio11 күн бұрын
typical high officers protection. that is the scandalous thing about armies. soldiers die and high officers get medals
@andylees294011 күн бұрын
What a disgrace. How much of this Hollywood clap is real? Either way the USN command are a bunch of cowards. Too scared to do the right thing and get to the bottom of the accident and highlight that the USN was not providing the support required to safely maintain the turrets. This is a clear charge of delinquency on the part of senior officers. That this sort of behaviour was allowed if not encouraged is criminal. God rest the dear fellows that needlessly lost their lives serving their country that treated them like dirt.
@MichaelCerovski12 күн бұрын
Typical government transparency full of crap.
@Sugarmountaincondo12 күн бұрын
@08:20 The cans of beer being consumed is a joke, alcohol has not been allowed to be consumed onboard U.S. Navy ships since 1914 and certainly no Chief Petty Officer would do so onboard let alone drink with a lower ranked sailor except during shore leave when out of uniform. @14:00 That is an officer's quarters for 2 Lt.'s and not a 1st class petty officers berthing area. @14:33 The ship would have been at GQ (General Quarters) and all personnel on the bridge would have had a steel helmet on. @23:15 The ship would have already been at General Quarters for a "Live-Fire" gun exercise, so calling for it after the explosion is just stupid Hollywood drama. The correct call to action over the 1MC would have been for which Damage Control Parties should respond. Obviously, the Director either ignored the U.S. Navy military advisors or the advisor(s) didn't know jack! @27:00 No one would be running down the passageway with bulkhead doors wide open as they would all be dogged shut and would have to be opened 1 at a time and then shut behind you and dogged shut again. The only doors that would be allowed to be left open during General Quarters would be if a damage control party was working in that area and had fire hoses strung through it. @33:15 and again @33:38 The word should be "Sailors", not "Soldiers". @39:31 The #1 Turret Officer as an Ensign would not have done an inspection of all 3 turrets, that would have been the duty of the Gunnery Officer. The Ensign would have only done a review and written a report on his own #1 turret. @39:31 and @45:49 The armed sailor in dress white uniform is all wrong, no armed sailor would have been in the interview room and if any security would have been required, it would have been a Chief Petty Officer Master at Arms or 2 Marines in Fatigues, also no cover (hat) would have been worn anywhere inside Officer's Country. @51:30 When I was in the Navy we regularly got a group of sailors together and shared a hotel/motel room in order to cut our costs and party our asses off, I even split a room with my cousin who was in the Marines and came down from his base to my base to visit me. @52:20 The KY-Jelly would have been for self-pleasure. This movie is a joke as is the technical advisory and I grew weary of pointing out all of the mistakes. It is my point of contention that this was purely an accident based on bad powder and a simple spark ignited by failure to follow safety protocols. 👎👎
@PeterWTaylor12 күн бұрын
A very interesting read thanks. If I ever get involved in a naval war movie I'll get in touch.
@karenwilson-r2d11 күн бұрын
thank you, you know your stuff, thank you for your service
@robertstrovers57311 күн бұрын
all very good points you've made, I did 6 yrs, half of 'em on a guided missile cruiser, so I noticed the same errors. I think the USN advisors went AWOL !
@USSBB6211 күн бұрын
You're right on with all the points. GMG2 5th Div. 5"/38. USS BB-62 Viet Nam era
@danielrutschman46188 күн бұрын
So what? Did you expect them to blow up a real gun turret and actually kill some people to make this movie as realistic as possible? It's a movie about a real cover-up of a real tragedy by the Navy. Who cares if some of the props and petty details aren't 100% accurate? It's the truth of the story that matters, not whether the actors all wore the correct uniforms or whatever.
@dast54012 күн бұрын
Thanks for sharing it! I always enjoy watching Great Movies though. 👍👌👏 And of course, I'm a subscriber! Thanks Again Though.
@Anonymouslyhere9812 күн бұрын
1:20:56 Fuck yeah this is the American way if you can't get help do it yourself and get rid of evil
@railroad900012 күн бұрын
My dad served on Mighty Mo, BB 63
@tex148th12 күн бұрын
I remember the shameful sham investigation of the IOWA explosion and how Seamen were scapegoated. Typical of the USN and its CYA mentality of the Navy Officer Corp. . Thank God I joined the USCG instead.. .
@jbrobertson6052Күн бұрын
I was Canadian Coast Guard and CFAV Canadian Forces Auxiliary Vessels for almost 20 years and I know first hand that you and your country are not alone with this behavior and even though I was a party hard Harley rider on the outside world you wouldn't have known it when I was on duty... Cheers
@charlesbromberick424713 күн бұрын
Things were better before.
@kcbh249 күн бұрын
Before what?
@charlesbromberick42479 күн бұрын
@@kcbh24 They´re gonna be worse now - that´s for sure
9 күн бұрын
@@kcbh24 Any idea what you think this comment means? "Before what"
@kcbh249 күн бұрын
Before Christmas? Before Reagan? Before the Civil Rights era? It's a genuine question and I am asking the OP, not you.
@charlesbromberick42479 күн бұрын
@@kcbh24 Well they sure as heck were.
@juliewoods653413 күн бұрын
A submarine is not a ship. It is a boat. Another fax pax the new ensign on deck without a cover. Alcohol is not allowed on any US military vessel. Who wrote this? Sailors are not soldiers. I quit watching at 34:05.
@jbrobertson6052Күн бұрын
You quit watching 2 minutes before I did lol
@juliewoods6534Күн бұрын
@@jbrobertson6052 That could have been a good documentary.
@julianmounser324114 күн бұрын
Glad I clicked on this film. Good interesting comments. Not watching the film.
@robertbabcock401414 күн бұрын
I remember following this incident after it occurred! As A US Army Field artillery Officer. I was very interested in the finding of this case, and very perplexed by its findings. I was on active duty in the early 80's and there were many occasions where we did not receive sufficient funds to properly maintain our guns. We weren't the branch of the armed forces that where insufficient funds abounded.
@dpeter639614 күн бұрын
The FBI was properly shown as a bunch of lying bastards more interested in their story than the truth. That's still going on today. F 'em!!
@MS_SUPEREd_SUPPORTER_power14 күн бұрын
same old story but don't forget how the USA was formed, on greed , theft & violence,,,they resold this story to the world and invade u if u disagree,,, and today there are people who kid u that Ai wont take away your jobs ...so who is REALLY stupid???
@charlesbromberick424713 күн бұрын
AI sucks - it will be the demise of us all.
@tOrangePeel197212 күн бұрын
Everywhere, every institution, state and culture was formed on greed and violence whilst claiming not to be. This continues to this day.
@trauma50disaster111 күн бұрын
those farm boys from the midwest and my grandpa from appalacia with no shoes didn't invade shit, THEY were invaded at Pearl Harbour. You prefer stalin, sitting bull, adolph, invading norse, moore's or persians? cmon you wern't born Tuesday...
@MS_SUPEREd_SUPPORTER_power10 күн бұрын
@@trauma50disaster1 ha ha u ASSume, but the point is valid, and USA was stolen from the natives of that continent, and what has been the result, pollution, war, a massive poverty problem, gun crime & obesity...wowwawewa what a success you gave to the rest of us... ;)