I have only one comment to make: why can't it be both ? I mean we can have same thing like hierarchal reservation, first extreme sc, then sc, then extreme deprived OBC and than OBC. And while what you are saying is correct the barrier to the issue is the documentation of proving yourself extreme OBCs when it shd be other way around. I.e, you can fill whatever you are but then govt shd take steps to correctly identify the categorization, and remove burden from people to go through this harrowing process. But then the issue that germinates from this is that it would invite rent seeking for certification by local bureaucracy. But what you are suggesting is good on paper , but it will make caste dynamics afroze. In the state they are in and be captured by elites groups and people of a sub classification. The representation point is foundation of caste based reservation of modern times. But representation is not only for optics but to create sensetization of issues within a administration. If the person who occupied this position have no lived experience regarding the same, then in the long run it will entrench new hierarchies, that is the point of caste census and periodic revision of communities and taking account of new bais software relative deprevation like class, these are not and cannot be the only factors . But the sadly the way our society and government function, it is extremely limited by these parameters. Just calling others as moron shows that you either unwilling to acknowledge new realites or belive that caste consciousness shd be the foundation of Indian politucs(nothing wrong in that) , but ignoring the point of all these claims in politics is to deliver empowerment to those left behind, the current EWS doesn't do that neither does current SC/ST quota. And while you are Correct in identifying NFS issue, the solution is not this or that but a combination of such strategies to deliver justicemore meningfully.
@harshrox26 күн бұрын
Let us take a hypothetical scenario, let us assume we create category that sees that regular people who sell vegetables on the road side or those who sell fruits in the streets are a deprived class, so for "administrative convinence we designed a category said falwah and said , okay these people shd get x amount of reservation and then let us see all your and mine argument from this lens . You will get why ambanis who claim to to be fal walh or multiple retail brand owners or those who do bulk purchase and supply of fal or those who own high shops and own juice shops shd be excluded, it is not because fal walah are not deprived but rather it because the classification is not well targeted, doesn't account for change in socio-economic status within the community, relative deprivation and the structure remains frozen and is not readily updated due to political compulsions.
@harshrox26 күн бұрын
Moreover categories like fal walha make state free of its responsibility to do actual meanifuful justice like enfirmcemt of minimum wage that is flexible to geo-economic realities and its failure to provide essential service like health. Eduaction etc
@harshrox26 күн бұрын
At best fal walah categorization is partial solution to multidimensional issue , that obscure real issue and tries a quick band-aid solution to ground reality and its inertia to to change with social reality, which is evolving while the system is stuck in its antiquity and used for politicsand "caste consciousness" rather than actual issues of tacking ground issues.
@harshrox26 күн бұрын
On grandfather comment, please don't reduce reservation to an individual issue it was never that it was always about categorization of people based on relative deprevation and segrgartion in society as a unit. My grandfather and father also faced similar circumstances, I have literally livedand played with pigs who eat their own shit And I being a general guy don't crib for getting reservation and will criticize EWS, this is not about individual it is about justice as concept that can help most people more effectively.
@prateekgautam29127 күн бұрын
For the very first time I came to know a place where people are talking very intellectually about all these topics especially when they belongs to our community. Nothing want to add is please also make videos in Hindi because most of the people belong to our community does not understand English that well and whatever you talking about is very necessary to reach up to the Grass root level
@VijayLaxmi-kg2qo7 күн бұрын
Great work, more videos on different topics like entrepreneurship, mental health, foreign education, community building and creating a feedback loop.
@ajaynikalje38577 күн бұрын
I think we need to make obc and other sc st and nt people who dont recognize Ambedkarite movement feel caste descrimination by asking them to talk about actrocities by higher caste people on their subordinate castes and asking them to say they are better than higher caste people with the metric of merit system and ask them to wish for privileges that higher caste people gets in indian caste system.
@StudiousSon7 күн бұрын
I'm studying at Ramjas College DU, sc/st cell never works in our clg, there's a big lock outside the room which in my three years of college I have never seen opened
@chirasreepal8 күн бұрын
Professor Ravikant, this was a very informative episode. Absolutely loved your insights. Thank you very much!
@apoorvajain8 күн бұрын
So true. Even going out with friends or weekly outings feel like bedrot. We just sit in a circle drinking with nothing to talk about. No one has opinions or anything to contribute. This is my first episode of the buffalo intellectual and I loved it. Also, drinking milk on the pod is crazyy.
@TheOneEyedLion8 күн бұрын
Smoking is injurious to health 🚭
@TheOneEyedLion8 күн бұрын
🗿💙☸️
@Zelda2950-k7y8 күн бұрын
रिजर्वेशन को गाली देने वालों को जब 10% सुदामा कोटा मिला तो इसमें कुछ बुरा नहीं लगा इनको...लेकिन अब भी ये बहुजन रिजर्वेशन को पेट पकड़ पकड़ के गाली देते हैं...दिक्कत इनको रिजर्वेशन से नहीं बहुजनों को क्यों मिल रहा है सारा दर्द इसी बात का है।
@drjagritisingh65698 күн бұрын
Majority obcs are the biggest andhbhakt and hater of affirmative actions but still in college, i did find a few obcs who were open about their views and crux of brahminical society. I have one yadav friend from Uttar pradesh and one from haryana. Uttar pradesh one is aware about caste based discrimination in the campus but haryana one is truly delulu.
@locus12897 күн бұрын
acknowledgement of casteism is basically giving up your own privilege to be casteist and feel better about yourself, by clinging to denial. anyways most obcs you met are likely forward landowning obcs. obc is not a very homogeneous category.
@pranitlm10268 күн бұрын
I agree with buffalo about the pune part....calling it mediocre is being nice imo
@AmolSampatraoRamteke9 күн бұрын
Smoking is injurious to health.
@KamalJhamat-ly8oy9 күн бұрын
Thanks for discussing this much needed issue. Great salute to Disha Vadekar ji she’s doing great work
@fireStorm0709 күн бұрын
This caste problem lies across generations, ages and classes. The major Victims of it are from SCs and STs. Anthropologically it has so many angles and trenches to fill up, which might take a lot of generations for it in exchange for a lot of lives spent on this but still it will not be resolved ever. To every SC and ST guy I would say, this society godforsaken and rotten to its core, and we cant fight it even Through the state, which will make even the state futile, and so will the country itself. There is nothing to save here. It will fall one day. Leave this country for western nations and use our talent whatever we have for those countries, and try to convince them to accept us. The west accepting us is more possible than our own Fellow Indians. For our own Fellow Indians and Hindus we are nothing less than vermins and gutter insects let's be very real. Next generation is going to explore life more holistically in terms of education, schooling, dating, occupation, and every one in India will enjoy it, accept for SCs and STs. Let's be real and accept it, I don't want my child to be born and be raised here in this backward society. I am leaving India next month anyway, good riddance
@minimathew61489 күн бұрын
OBC's have mostly become hardcore Bhakts and many fight against reservations.
@Morpheus_neo_trinity5 күн бұрын
It's actually the OBC's who commit violent crimes against sc/st's. They also don't face the brunt of discrimination since their cut off is almost the same as Upper castes
@kanishk59629 күн бұрын
1:01:50 Her smile mutely screams "Dilip Mandal!"
@manoharlalsolanki88729 күн бұрын
Is it only government and private colleges that are required to have such cells? What about all government institutions?
@manoharlalsolanki88729 күн бұрын
Why not include all government institutions?
@minimathew61489 күн бұрын
Thank you for this discussion. Thank you Adv Wadekar for your work.
@vinaydeepake33719 күн бұрын
Batman slander not allowed 😤😡🤣🤣🤣🤣
@yamanmoury9 күн бұрын
Such Ladies are Truly Messenger of Ambedkarite Movement. She is highly knowledgeable and Hardworking person and is working for greater cause.
@ARVINDKUMAR-if9er9 күн бұрын
Adv Disha should file a pil in High court and Apex court for the continued publication of baws .
@MisbaHamid9 күн бұрын
India needs more women like this . Such a smart persona and great intellect she has unlike many other people here.
@imaginieiota62989 күн бұрын
🙏🏻✨
@Rpatqd6bi9 күн бұрын
Dish, I would like to know about the discrimination on language basis , like discrimination between English medium students and vernacular medium students. When I was in engineering collage most of the professors were Brahmin community, and English speaking background, during viva most of the vernacular particular students come Marathi medium at highschool level who were studying engineering either get low marks or failed while in written exams they scored very good marks. In opposite, the English medium highschool level students get very good marks in viva and in written exams either they get low marks or failed. Is this not a discrimination? Please reply.
@imaginieiota62989 күн бұрын
Bro this totally depends on the students. Were their answers in Marathi correct? Did they cross check after the exam? If not y'all should gather all the students who got discriminated against and either file a petition or go to the principal.
@drscience_xo9 күн бұрын
sir do also consider making some podcast in hindi too as majority of our bahujans don’t understand english
@penntemp7 күн бұрын
Also in Marathi, Kannada, Tamil, Telugu, Bengali, Punjabi, and Assamese.
@Rpatqd6bi9 күн бұрын
Dish is doing very good job and fighting for social justice
@Rpatqd6bi9 күн бұрын
The discrimination is not just with SC ST students in India but discrimination with lots of farmers kids coming from rural India and vernacular medium students.
@RupeshKumar-ni1vd6 күн бұрын
Those are mostly SC/STs
@locus12899 күн бұрын
Can you talk more about OBCs and their stance on anti caste in the present and in the future. where do you see themself, is it in the hindutva or the anti caste/socialist fold?
@CaptainScorpio2410 күн бұрын
Man i used to listen yuh guys on twitter spaces in 2021
@BuffaloIntellectual10 күн бұрын
pretty sure I wasnt on a twitter space in 2021
@CaptainScorpio2410 күн бұрын
@BuffaloIntellectual oh may b in 2022 i guess . sorry my bad memory. 2021 and 2022 was a year of twitter spaces for our folks
@AksharaAbigail-hh1yr10 күн бұрын
Glad you're bringing actual intellectuals rather than clowns like standup comedians, Ashrafs and internet historians. 💙
14:35 I was fed this propaganda throughout school and bought it when applying for colleges. I regret saying what I did and understood its value over the years.
@shreyashgamre379510 күн бұрын
❤❤❤
@ARCHxPRO10 күн бұрын
@PokhrajRoy.10 күн бұрын
Great guest and topic to start the year with.
@ritwikatiwari221110 күн бұрын
you know its a good video if you find Pokhraj in the comments, I hope you are doing well and that you come across even better content on youtube this year!!
@ekilosurp10 күн бұрын
🎉
@Tehsilprashashan16 күн бұрын
The prophecy was spot on.
@dishayy16 күн бұрын
Happy new year, Professor! :) This content should be behind a paywall (But that's just my opinion xd). Hope you make all the monies this year🙏🏻
@alishamulla130416 күн бұрын
How do I become a member on KZbin ?
@shubhamchande436016 күн бұрын
India will become Viksit bharat by 2147. And bro BRAIN ROT is the official word of the year 2024 by oxford.