that selfie was so wholesome

Terrific but Morgan was definitely the main star, this was her ‘15 minutes of fame’ and no one has ever been more deserving! The icing on the cake was seeing Alyson again in 2024 at her loveliest! Big disappointment the camera not showing us Morgan again at the end.

"Get the hell off the stage" are, probably, the clearest code words Penn has ever said in this show. 🤣 What an amazing and funny performance, Matt! 👏👏👏

This entire performance was so much fun to watch! Do you have more custom props that you use in magic?

Matt I got to play the "Penn" role for this bit at the Cincinnati show this past weekend! You also did the best card stab I've ever seen (and I must have seen at least 3).

That a top class performance

I can't get over how hot she is. When did that happen??!!? :P

Well, you fooled me, here you go.

This was very well written!

I don't believe I have ever seen a woman blush as much on this show as Morgan did!

This was awesome! So funny and a really cool trick.

Amaaaaazing maaaaaaan ❤

I loved it, they looked so goofy

So that's the second time this year , that a version of the magic bullet is presented to P&T :)

Matt! What an amazing performance. It was hilarious - like all of Matt Donnelly's shows are. But it was also honestly a brilliant piece of magic. And I have to say, I did *not* see where this was going, despite it being a very common trope of stage magic - the whole "person in box swaps with the magician thing. I actually kind of dislike that classic bit because it's so easy to anticpate - but here I honestly had no idea where this was going. Really wonderful!

Wonderfully silly and a darn good trick 👌

Good job, Matt! As a regular congregationalist, I was excited to see this clip, and I figured Penn would bust your balls. He didn't disappoint.

They cut out the key reveal with a camera change. But, that was just outstanding. Come to Illinois and Ill see you!

Now Brook, have you ever made it rain on 3 male performers before, 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

"on the edge of your seat" I like that little clue.

Regardless of the trick, getting Penn & Teller that involved was hilarious.

you may ask "but when did he switch the shirts ?" but I don't think this is the point the point is he made all three Penn, Teller and Brooke have a hell of a time and a good laugh for the public

Great act

Great performance. Just minor thing but I think the head hole (is that the correct word?!) should be a bit wider on the red t shirt so when the blue t shirt is pulled over it you can’t see the red t shirt is still on.

“Great trick, Matt Donley, I see you everday, you fooled us, but I don’t think you fooled us.” 🤔🤔🤔

Gods that was so fun to watch. I was totally fooled simply from the misdirection of comedy. That put a big grin on my face. Bravo

Former vice president

This was hilarious! Not only a fun trick but loaded with laughs. Loved the inside references, too!

Have you ever made it rain on three male performers before!? Ha! Oh I am sure Penn's mind went somewhere on that laugh!🤣

That was funny, but I knew something was up when I didn't see arm holes.

Good stuff! 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼

Wonderful act Matt, awesome combination of comedy and magic!! Absolutely loved it, respect from India :)

"If you don't have a joke, a fact will do!" - Susan B. Anthony

He a got a tshirt instead of a trophy. 🤣🤣🤣 How did he switch the tshirt? One thing for sure. The tshirt he place in the cannon is not tshirt decorated by Penn.

I found that act very clever and entertaining. It is a joy enducer. Well done!

SALT PORK!!!! Love the Ham Days shoutout!!! 😆🙌🐷

Well, I rewatched and.. you fooled me. So here it is.. 🎊 🏆 🎊

That was fun. Did they edit out a little bit when you showed Penn how to trigger it? He seemed to know exactly how to use it. Maybe he was familiarized with it backstage or something? P.S. For anyone else reading this, no I’m absolutely not suggesting the guys were “in on it” or anything like that. I just like getting a feel for how it all works over there. Considering applying to be on the show at some point in the future.

Can't believe you got a T-shirt signed by Penn, or the fact that his signature looks like a peace sign

😅 good one

So ......did he get his trophy??

I remember the brainstorming session where you came up with this, I'm so glad you got it working, well done!

Salt Pork! Go Matty Go! Loved this so much

I've watched so many times but still haven't figured it out unless he fed her her guesses. Im too busy laughing to keep up

OMG! Matt, you are original and funny! I automatically am interested in watching effects that are not card tricks. Your trick was super good, and you fooled me, that's for sure. I couldn't even imagine what the punch line, so to speak, was going to be. To your credit, I watched AGAIN and STILL couldn't figure out how you did it. What a pleasant surprise! All good wishes.

hilarious! Such a cumbersome set up- it feels like you were pranking P&T.

Wonderful….

Huge fan Matt, have listened to practically every Penn's Sunday School and Ice Cream Social. You are always a delight. Glad you're really making it in the magic scene.

I haven’t even made it to the trick yet and I’m in stitches. I don’t care if he doesn’t win. I’m here to be entertained.

SO AWESOME! And an honor to be on an episode with you. You're hilarious :)