8 ай бұрын
Пікірлер
@rkj5480 2 сағат бұрын
Not “my life as Inukai’s Dog” 😭
@legogoka-boomstudio1838 4 сағат бұрын
Egg Arc was definitely the beginning of the end The entire event was essentially everyone taking their turns to make a massive twist that I barely cared about until technoblade came in and started killing people and then the entire plot was over All the other events had massive fights and a mind control war could be cool af in a lot of different ways but it took all of like 3 people and they died in seconds or ran So in short Techno MVP
@juststop5768 7 сағат бұрын
The typical dream stan
@James-nm8dr 10 сағат бұрын
The dream smp may be cringy now but we all loved it in lockdown
@jpaul8284 21 сағат бұрын
cringe, all of em, cringe
@aquaspidermc 22 сағат бұрын
"Wilbur, as far as any viewer can tell, is just a relatively healthy streamer" NOT ANYMORE BUDDY
@Andrew-hm8no 22 сағат бұрын
nah don't worry, bocci the rock isn't cringe, probably the 2nd funniest show I've watched period. I bet techno would have loved its craziness...
@Thph793 Күн бұрын
Finnaly someone mentioned the absolute abomination of a 2nd season that is The Promised Neverland SE 2
@sazawa__ Күн бұрын
6:22 You dont need to disect their sentences. That's just overdoing. Speedsilver's story telling is just as good. Not a fan. But you seem like a hater by disecting one sentence he said and turning it against him.
@rhiansebastian1767 Күн бұрын
Who let this man cook,!!!
@notaliveagain 2 күн бұрын
Ish has GREAT videos on the matter but just remember that MagicGum Started the category and has some great previous content that shows the full realm that these videos could be so I HIGHLY Recommend you look at those
@shaquilleandrew2282 2 күн бұрын
I don't know if you'll see this but I've had a lot of these thoughts for a while. Every team in a civilisation video just seemed really savage and only really out to get the other teams before I realised it was just the admin pointing everyone to it. There was little to no diplomacy or friendly relations between each faction on top of your points of them having little-to-no desire of doing anything or having really any objectives to complete. Its cool watching each new build-up of a new base but having them go to war for no choice of their own definitely seemed artificial. Not only Minecraft but ARK Civilisation videos as well had that exact same problem. It's good you're showing praise for ish and I really do hope other people looking into making this type of content implements world and maybe faction objectives in a more seamless way and give the players a lot more agency.
@Charliez_3 3 күн бұрын
It just kind of shows that if enough people were in a civilization, sooner or later a "villain" will appear, someone who in the eyes of the majority, is a bad person
@fesmity 4 күн бұрын
<3
@lukethekuya 6 күн бұрын
They took it way seriously, and with the high emotions of the fandom because of this, yep it went down to the depths of insanity.
@cosmicjeon 7 күн бұрын
nothing will ever bear the genshin community. the amount of incels and femcels in this game im not proud to be part of the community in is just sad
@rocco6260 8 күн бұрын
ive always notcied this to, player driven sotry arcs are alwasy better because they actualyl have the ability to be emtional since theirs a since of attchment either to thier "home" or relationships and player made goverments are alwasy better since goverments are a social constcut and its more intresting to see how power dynamics work when theyre not fully backed by "now pick a leader" its so mcuh more raw and real, its mroe emcaptivating to see the way players recognize nations even when the power of nations are based on the players recognizing its leadership.
@DeadMedia-vf4je 8 күн бұрын
3:44 Maid Boshi
@GammaHunter 8 күн бұрын
Another problem with other civ videos is that while Ish looks at nations and people from the perspective of a God watching over people, other civ creators put themselves into the worlds. This severely limits their ability to tell stories as you only get stuff from one perspective, theirs. You can only root for them because, other than allies, they're the only ones you really get to know. Its biased storytelling. Ish looks at every nation, every group and every significant player, allowing you to really see what's going on, not just what's happening to this one guy. Just making the whole video so much more fun to watch.
@ojwizzardgames6339 8 күн бұрын
I still get goosebumps from the ending of the prison video
@Sanstheavatar 8 күн бұрын
I always rewatch the 1000 players civilization because is kind epik and more educational then other.
@Grapelordz 8 күн бұрын
7:35 cool that you have PopularMMOS here. Im not sure if it’s just me, but I always felt like he was less talked about during those years despite being a massive channel
@FlantisFroggu 9 күн бұрын
The true main flaw I see with this series is that they never give anyone the spotlight. What I mean is the main center of attention, make everyone look at someone else instead of looking at the person who made the video. This is something I only realized after watching (some) lifesteal videos. I really don't care to know who any of these people are, like Fundy or the guy with the totem skin (see? I even forgot their names, some I don't even recognize), but with lifesteal? I had been checking out the channels of some of the people that star on the videos, and that is how I get to know them. I don't think the writing on Lifesteal is as good as what Wilbur provided to DreamSMP, but it's slowly getting there, and I really think Lifesteal or other SMPs could greatly benefit by introducing some youtubers who specialize in story telling and that's their main content. People like Zeemyth. Also, a lot of these people are just really bad writers, and like you said it made no sense in plot for them to talk normally
@morningbowl3156 9 күн бұрын
I was only interested in Techno’s pov nothing else really interested me
@lee7869 9 күн бұрын
Apporach
@pedroespiritosanto2959 10 күн бұрын
@ChunkyNosher are you a Pathfinder? You seemed to be one in min 3:24. Pls anser me.
@ChunkyNosher 10 күн бұрын
no sorry, it's just stock footage on pexels lol, you're the second person to point that out tho
@pedroespiritosanto2959 10 күн бұрын
@@ChunkyNosher lol thank you btw great video😄
@Spitfire14 11 күн бұрын
imo the only reason the plot had any sustenance was from the SAD-ist animatics. Other than those it was extremely cringe.
@maninanikittycat4238 11 күн бұрын
I thought the narrative getting that serious was lowkey dumb
@mcfat1039 12 күн бұрын
I don’t think the KZbinrs creating personas/characters going against their real life personalities is one of the fundamental flaws that lead to the downfall. I think freedom is vital for writing. You could argue that making characters contrasting themselves IRL adds dimension due to contradiction. I think what failed the SMP is the lack of a understanding the fundamentals that bring a bunch of subplots together, to paraphrase Robert Mckee, “if you don’t have a subplot that contradicts or resonates the controlling idea, if it doesn’t complicate the main story or set up the main story’s inciting incident, if it merely runs alongside the story, it will destory its effects.” I am sure there were other flaws but I think there were so many subplots that failed what Robert McKee said that it destroyed the SMP, making the only story interesting being the original story(DREAM vs. Tommy) and Technoblade subplot since his plot complicated the “main” plot. That’s all.
@jalianibeara6477 12 күн бұрын
12:50 Moon knight is peak don’t compare it to she-hulk and Ironheart 😭
@chromea 12 күн бұрын
16:20 this didnt age very well...
@MaksHuang 13 күн бұрын
It all started when avernus got buffed
@bartoneast3083 13 күн бұрын
Most civilization videos are like "reincarnated as a fridge" but Ishes one was like Re-Zero or any other ACTUALLY good shows
@Flamne 13 күн бұрын
(Anime schizo) Being compared to the Dream SMP community feels eerie or downright disgusting
@Flamne 13 күн бұрын
Sad-ist has banger animations though and it's just "That" side of the community I really have a problem with
@buddy6507 14 күн бұрын
As someone who was present when the SMP died, I think the primary reason was how Technoblade’s death was handled
@Somewhere_Bagel 14 күн бұрын
Dream still gromer, also i think the downfall was mainly just because they had like 30 plots happening at once. even during lockdown people still had online classes, they dont have time to watch 30 5 hour streams every week
@blep8895 14 күн бұрын
18:00 except Quackity’s acting is actually really good, and his production quality was excellent compared to Eggpire or Tommy’s stuff
@name-hy7zd 14 күн бұрын
“As far as anyone could tell, Wilbur was a very stable streamer” Aged ljke milk.
@blep8895 14 күн бұрын
I was just about to say that lmao
@sweetlemonadartanimations369 15 күн бұрын
I stopped watching completely after Techno’s passing. I just couldn’t watch it knowing that someone, not just a “character”, but someone REAL, had gone for good. There were many others who had good stories to tell, but I just couldn’t go forward after the night I found out.
@vanessarosa6509 15 күн бұрын
I always thought it was try-SAW-rus😂
@gabbyes 15 күн бұрын
where's madoka magica video
@ChunkyNosher 15 күн бұрын
sorry maybe in a few years, I need to gather a more consistent following before I start making video essays about anime
@elobservadorobservante1605 15 күн бұрын
>subaru and homura nah, they also have plot armor, specially homura after rebellion
@ChunkyNosher 15 күн бұрын
nah, the entire premise of Re:Zero is that Subaru remains one of the weakest characters in the series, having to use social engineering to survive and forcing his character to grow as a result, and while saying Homura has plot armor is more understandable, my own theory on why Homura was able to do what she did in Rebellion was because she never got her wish granted. The one exchange that needs to happen when one becomes a magical girl is to have their wish granted, which was fulfilled by everyone in the series except Homura, where she was unable to protect Madoka because she transcended reality to rewrite the system that makes magical girls witches, but at the cost of being written out of existence. To circumvent this, Homura was able to break some rules to get her wish fulfilled, because like I said, that HAS to happen for one to become a magical girl. And also, Homura acting the way she did wasn't entirely out of character; she was already pretty jaded and indifferent to everyone except Madoka, who she was excessively obsessed over. By the time of Rebellion, she already fell into despair, so I think it's at the very least plausable and understandable why she did what she did. Sorry for long explanation lol