MY TOP 5 BOOKS OF 2023
7:35
5 ай бұрын
I READ TWO BOOKS ON PARENTING
3:51
TANGLED ROOTS BOOK REVIEW
5:34
11 ай бұрын
Пікірлер
@nakulagnihotri4933
@nakulagnihotri4933 11 сағат бұрын
Correction: 16th century not 14th*
@user-bi2sy3md6f
@user-bi2sy3md6f 5 күн бұрын
❤❤❤
@phaddu7737
@phaddu7737 9 күн бұрын
More power to you Purva, I was hoping(waiting) for the audiobooks in all languages.
@kapilnautiyal2706
@kapilnautiyal2706 27 күн бұрын
Keep working for dharma ❤️ this is the need of time
@gomaram285
@gomaram285 28 күн бұрын
Ohh didi hindi m ho to btao ,,itni English nhi aati ,,koi bole to smjh aa jati h ,,pr padhne me aur ese smjhne m problem aati h
@iamjorasia
@iamjorasia Ай бұрын
If you want, I can recommend few more books 📚.
@geetanshkaul3419
@geetanshkaul3419 28 күн бұрын
go ahead.
@manisshthakur621
@manisshthakur621 Ай бұрын
I love the oratory skills of Palki Sharma, very few people uses pauses as better as her.
@sunny_Singh206
@sunny_Singh206 Ай бұрын
I am pretty sure, the book on Putin needed approval from Putin , to get published. Adding it to my reading list. Kindly do some fiction reviews too,for readers like us.
@shrivkumarsemwal4532
@shrivkumarsemwal4532 Ай бұрын
आप ammi ganatra को जानती हैं?????......... कृपया उनकी पुस्तक पढ़ें.
@purvaabhyankar2307
@purvaabhyankar2307 Ай бұрын
Yep. Meri list me hai
@shrivkumarsemwal4532
@shrivkumarsemwal4532 Ай бұрын
@@purvaabhyankar2307 kk aatiuttam
@JCGrinwald
@JCGrinwald 2 ай бұрын
Is there any understanding when Book 2 is going to be released? I just completed Book 1 and NEED Book 2 now!! I think I got hooked on Anglid, who is so precious, and I also loved The Elder!! Who do you think that mysterious character, the sniper is? The sniper seems to have a strange "accent" and I am thinking that the sniper who was talking to the Elder in Episode 28 is from the Central Kingdom!!!!!
@purvaabhyankar2307
@purvaabhyankar2307 2 ай бұрын
I’m excited too! Hope the book releases soon !
@JCGrinwald
@JCGrinwald 2 ай бұрын
Excellent!
@jayashreegodbole4109
@jayashreegodbole4109 2 ай бұрын
नेमके,स्पष्ट, मुद्देसूद परीक्षण एवढ्या मोठ्या पुस्तकाचे असे थोडक्यात आणि तरीही सर्वसमावेशक परीक्षण करणे अवघड आहे.. हे तूच करु शकतेस...🎉
@shrivkumarsemwal4532
@shrivkumarsemwal4532 2 ай бұрын
बहुत सुंदर पक्ष रखा आपने..... कृपया आनंद रंगनाथन जी की पुस्तक hindus in hindurashtra भी पढ़ें और उसके बारे मे बताएँ
@shrivkumarsemwal4532
@shrivkumarsemwal4532 2 ай бұрын
आपका Instagram channel ढूंढ़ किन्तु मिला नहीं..... क्या आप Instagram पर नहीं हैं?
@purvaabhyankar2307
@purvaabhyankar2307 2 ай бұрын
धन्यवाद! मैं अभी वही किताब पढ़ रही हूँ! अगला वीडियो उसी का आएगा! 🙏
@shrivkumarsemwal4532
@shrivkumarsemwal4532 2 ай бұрын
@@purvaabhyankar2307 धन्यावाद प्रतीक्षा कर रहा हूं.... आपने Instagram का नहीं बताया बहना
@purvaabhyankar2307
@purvaabhyankar2307 2 ай бұрын
@shrivkumarsemwal4532 instagram.com/p/Cki5juXyVZK/?igshid=YmMyMTA2M2Y=
@shrivkumarsemwal4532
@shrivkumarsemwal4532 2 ай бұрын
@@purvaabhyankar2307 धन्यावाद
@shrivkumarsemwal4532
@shrivkumarsemwal4532 2 ай бұрын
मैंने आपका Instagram पेज देखा लेकिन मुझे मिला नहीं...
@sunny_Singh206
@sunny_Singh206 2 ай бұрын
Nice review. Putting it in my reading list, after the book, Three body Problem.
@deepshikhaphogat
@deepshikhaphogat 2 ай бұрын
Hey, can you please tell me from where did you get this information that this book will be adapted by Ashutosh Gowariker as a motion picture?
@purvaabhyankar2307
@purvaabhyankar2307 2 ай бұрын
It’s written on the book cover of the new edition.
@sidharthmak
@sidharthmak 3 ай бұрын
No wonder he recommended 4000 weeks. The special "Is this it" feels like an extension of the book itself.
@purvaabhyankar2307
@purvaabhyankar2307 3 ай бұрын
Ditto! I also felt the exact same way!
@sayantan777
@sayantan777 3 ай бұрын
Finally, Martand Sun temple will be re built. Glorious!!!
@martuzachoudhury9311
@martuzachoudhury9311 3 ай бұрын
Thank you for the review. I was skeptical whether to buy it or not since I thought it had more to do with books. I think i will buy it... can't wait to read it.
@martuzachoudhury9311
@martuzachoudhury9311 3 ай бұрын
i was not sure to buy it or not, thanks to your review now i am sure to enjoy this read
@sunny_Singh206
@sunny_Singh206 3 ай бұрын
Looks like very serious reading.
@purvaabhyankar2307
@purvaabhyankar2307 3 ай бұрын
More of like an immersive experience
@clobo01
@clobo01 3 ай бұрын
I came across this video a few days back but time didn't permit me to respond earlier. This is going to be a super long critical analysis of your video, so bear with me and I would expect to receive a response for the same. The video is titled ''I read two books recommended by J Sai Deepak''. When one is trying to gather an accurate understanding of such a complex topic as history especially when it ain’t contemporary history, one needs to make sure he is well read in the numerable amount of books on the topic available to be objective, to confirm that a particular book has no bias and that the books can quote sources from primary sources. When J Sai Deepak recommends a book about such a complex historical topic as the Goa Inquisition by Anant Priolkar without asking his viewers to read others he is doing so because of his confirmation bias and you will understand through the course of this response why. In your video, you repeatedly state that Goan Christians were forcefully converted which Priolkar also mentions in his book which is far from the actual truth, and recent studies in academia confirm this too. While there was a section of Christians who were converted forcefully there were many others who converted because of the benefits, better social status, and new jobs that the Portuguese brought to the new colony, and in many instances, the caste clans converted entirely as a village once the village leaders (gaunkars) converted and also not to forget the heavy proselytizing of the Christian faith by the Portuguese missionaries. If conversions were only ''forceful'' how does one explain about the Goan Catholics who fled to Mangalore during the Portuguese Inquisition some as early as the 1560s itself but never ever renounced their new faith, how does one explain that after the end of the Goan Inquisition in Goa the Catholics never went back to their original faith or there was never a movement for the same? Priolkar's argument is a very simplistic view of the conversion of Christians. I would recommend you to read the book Conversion and Citizenry by Delio Mendonca wherein he studies the anthropology of the time and its primary sources to talk about this topic and I'm not aware of anyone who has been able to critically debunk his work from the sources. Even if one has to leave aside the studies in recent years I haven't been able to come across any scholarly work of someone been able to prove the claim of outright forceful conversions of the Goan Christians from primary sources. You state in your video that the majority of the Goans are Christians and have names like DSouza’s this is according to which statistics? Ever since the first census was published in the early 1900’s Hindus have always been the majority community so make sure you are factually correct. You later go on in more depth about Priolkar's book about the Inquisition itself and the tortures. One needs to first understand who the Inquisition was primarily for and its objective(s). The Inquisition was a tribunal to study the cases of HERESY by the Jews, Muslims, and newly converted Christians and there is no dispute among scholars in this regard through the records this is why even Catholic priests were charged with heresy. While anti-Hindu laws existed these were primarily for those who had already converted to Christianity and to prevent them from going back to their native religion hence the establishment of the Holy Tribunal. There is no evidence of Hindus who didn’t convert being put to death by burning under the inquisition through any of the archival records and Priolkar doesn’t even cite his source for the same, the only instances of the handful of Hindus who were tried in the tribunal were largely because they aided the new converts to follow their previous native culture and none were burnt at the stake. I explain about the archival records in the later part of my comment too. You also mention from his book about the tortures such as limbs being cut, rape, pulleys to stretch victims, and water torture which is also far from the truth there is a reason why Hindu nationalists use the book for their own agenda. Because if going by Charles Dellon’s account in his book he never mentions about the tortures except for the burnings in which those found guilty were only punished. In 2003 the archival records were studied from the Vatican archives of the time which is available to the public today and this denies all the allegations about the rape and limb cutting in his book. This is not to say that the burning of victims who were held guilty of heresy is also justified. Next, you go to the list of temples and deities in your video, while it's true that people did move to prevent themselves from being converted and they were primarily the upper caste Saraswat Brahmins, there were other Saraswat Brahmins who also did convert for various reasons some of which I have already mentioned above. In some cases, families would be split wherein one brother converted while the other didn’t and moved/ fled away with their deity. Also, it's not entirely true that every upper-caste Hindu who didn't convert also moved outside of the Portuguese territories back then. Properties owned by the Saraswats Brahmins who had converted and others were given for the construction of Christian religious structures, and many were confiscated from those who also fled which is a plausible fact. Next, you are wrong about the entire burning of the records and this is what Priolkar also mentions in his own book that he got some records from the Goa archives about the Inquisition. Any serious scholar on the topic knows that the archives about the Inquisition were never ever kept in Goa but rather in Portugal, Brazil, and the Vatican. While individual trials of every person tried in the tribunal were burnt their names, offenses, villages they came from, etc are still available and these were declassified and are available to the public and even online by the Portuguese and Brazilian libraries in the last 2 decades which Priolkar was never able to study them. After studying these archival records you will realize why I have earlier stated and it confirms that the Inquisition was primarily for those who had converted through their names and their villages. I suggest you read the book by Allan Machado’s book Goa Inquisition: Facts, Fiction, and Factoids who has studied these archival records and documented the findings in his book. Last you talk about the 2 protestant accounts who were convicted in the Inquisition. Charles Dellon himself mentions in his accounts that he never once saw a Hindu within the tribunal and he mentions in the very same book he was charged because of his own personal animosity against the government. I will not comment about the second book because I haven't read the book but will write a review once I'm able to at least read the synopsis of the book and maybe do so in the next few days/ weeks.
@veerswami7175
@veerswami7175 Ай бұрын
And bro can u tell me how they declare non christains as Christians when they don't even want to convert
@clobo01
@clobo01 Ай бұрын
@@veerswami7175 Can you be a lot more specific what are you trying to say so accordingly I can answer in more detail.
@akashbart2765
@akashbart2765 26 күн бұрын
Downloaded the English translation of Charles Dellon's book. I recently became interested in historical studies - and I doubt I will get enough time to finish reading both books - the one by Charles Dellon and also the one by Pariolkar. Thanks for your detailed comment - I will come back here after a few months (hopefully :) )
@ankitamaheshwari7686
@ankitamaheshwari7686 4 ай бұрын
Thanks for sharing!!
@Reckless_Samy_06
@Reckless_Samy_06 4 ай бұрын
Thank u for the review Was thinking to buy the book
@rajatnirkhe6321
@rajatnirkhe6321 4 ай бұрын
Madam I know that Hindus used to Rule Russia and the USSR
@mdavisco
@mdavisco 5 ай бұрын
Audiobooks are best when you're driving, cooking, and getting ready for your day, great for multi-tasking. I would really prefer to sit with a book, but in the busy time of today's world, time is not available.
@purvaabhyankar2307
@purvaabhyankar2307 5 ай бұрын
True that.
@sunny_Singh206
@sunny_Singh206 5 ай бұрын
Ebooks are best.
@purvaabhyankar2307
@purvaabhyankar2307 5 ай бұрын
When you’ve a kid and no time, yeah! They’re the best
@Decoloniality_Bharat
@Decoloniality_Bharat 5 ай бұрын
J sai deepak witers recommendation 1) Sitaram goel 2) Ram Swarup 3) RC Majumdar 4) Minakshi Jain 5) Jadhunath Sarkar 6) Anand Ranganathan 7) Vikram Sampath 8) Sanjeev Sanyal 9) Harbila sarda 10) Rajeev Manhotra
@sushantamishra5390
@sushantamishra5390 5 ай бұрын
Sir Namate, when the hindi version of the 2nd book India, Bharat and Pakistan coming ?
@miliciousss8213
@miliciousss8213 5 ай бұрын
Your content is nice but you can improve it by proper edits
@purvaabhyankar2307
@purvaabhyankar2307 5 ай бұрын
Thanks for the advice! Working on it
@venomwastaken5835
@venomwastaken5835 5 ай бұрын
Great! Variety of books Thanks.. ❤❤🎉
@bharatiabhyankar1517
@bharatiabhyankar1517 5 ай бұрын
Nice concept of ranking the books. Loved it !
@venomwastaken5835
@venomwastaken5835 5 ай бұрын
मराठी पुस्तक आणि तेही सावरकरांचे ...छान वाटले तुझा वाचण्याचा स्पीड थक्क करणारा आहे पुस्तकांची निवड एक नंबर Happy reading.. Happy New year
@maitreyeedeshmukh6126
@maitreyeedeshmukh6126 5 ай бұрын
Found the first book in your list in library here... Hurrah!
@purvaabhyankar2307
@purvaabhyankar2307 5 ай бұрын
Happy reading. Do share your reading experience after you’re done
@maitreyeedeshmukh6126
@maitreyeedeshmukh6126 5 ай бұрын
@@purvaabhyankar2307 definitely 💯
@vardhamanam
@vardhamanam 5 ай бұрын
thodi books mujhe bhi de dijiye 🗿
@purvaabhyankar2307
@purvaabhyankar2307 5 ай бұрын
Haha ! Khushi se
@harshitd254
@harshitd254 5 ай бұрын
I too felt the same after reading Revolutionaries by Sanjeev Sanyal, ❤
@Chaoscontroll64
@Chaoscontroll64 6 ай бұрын
Wow, this book review of 'The New Tsar' by Stephen Lee Meyers is absolutely captivating! The author's in-depth exploration of Vladimir Putin's rise to power and reign as Russia's president is both informative and thought-provoking. I highly recommend this video to anyone interested in understanding the complexities of Putin's leadership and its impact on the world stage. Kudos to the reviewer for providing such a comprehensive analysis!"
@jayashreegodbole4109
@jayashreegodbole4109 6 ай бұрын
Thanks for introducing variety of books throughout the year. Happy new year
@jayashreegodbole4109
@jayashreegodbole4109 6 ай бұрын
It happens with both,men and women. In fact men have a burden to earn for the whole family unto the last.
@adilsidan2193
@adilsidan2193 7 ай бұрын
Do your videoes in a more quite environment,the is noises from every side and it feels like you are in a big hall talking echo is too much,hope you continue better
@purvaabhyankar2307
@purvaabhyankar2307 7 ай бұрын
Yep. Thanks for the advice . Will try to improve in the following videos
@sunny_Singh206
@sunny_Singh206 8 ай бұрын
Some books change the way we see in life. This is one of them
@jayashreegodbole4109
@jayashreegodbole4109 8 ай бұрын
खरंय पिढ्यानपिढ्याचा मित्र हरपला
@ashishd.chindarkar2602
@ashishd.chindarkar2602 8 ай бұрын
Amazing book. I have listened on kuku FM . truly inspiring book👏👏
@purvaabhyankar2307
@purvaabhyankar2307 8 ай бұрын
It really is!
@abhss
@abhss 9 ай бұрын
Not worth reading really, if you are beginners, I discovered only three stories worth reading. Wasted hour, cuckold and who killed the mayor. Don't waste your time. Rest of the stories are written kind of forcefully.
@hellaaro8033
@hellaaro8033 9 ай бұрын
few days back I was reading 'bandi jeevan' and it stuck me with the thoughts of Ullaskar dutt's heart wrenching story. Sanjeev sir knows exactly how to bring life into words
@purvaabhyankar2307
@purvaabhyankar2307 9 ай бұрын
So true! I was truly amazed by stories of our real heroes and what fate they had at the end!
@vaidikpathanugami7971
@vaidikpathanugami7971 9 ай бұрын
🔥🔥🔥🔥
@vardhamanam
@vardhamanam 9 ай бұрын
currently I am also reading this book 🙏🏼
@purvaabhyankar2307
@purvaabhyankar2307 9 ай бұрын
Please share your thoughts after you complete it!
@gk-bc4di
@gk-bc4di 9 ай бұрын
Its the exact kind if video i was looking for ❤ Can you also list the books suggested by kanan gill other than these two 😅😅 I am trying compile his suggestions. It would be helpful
@purvaabhyankar2307
@purvaabhyankar2307 9 ай бұрын
Hi! Happy that you got what you were looking for! You can go to his Instagram page and he has made highlights of the books. Like July 2020 books. Etc
@bharatiabhyankar1517
@bharatiabhyankar1517 9 ай бұрын
Will try to read the books
@venomwastaken5835
@venomwastaken5835 9 ай бұрын
Very nice