** JANUARY 29th at 10:52pm is when the group chat between Michael Proctor and his buddies took place. ** according to Day 23 of the trial which is during cross examination by the defense. So that proves that they had Karen's phone since then.

We will never see their dog because they moved Chloe out of the area a day or two after John was killed to start covering up what really happened. Then they probably Killed her and cremated her so there would be no evidence that will connect her to the attack.

Aug of 2022 was when proctor looked for nudes. It was jan and Feb of 2022 when he made prior comments to friends troopers and family.

KR is a sneaky snake when she remembered she hit John with her taillight and told McCabe she broke her taillight BEFORE she deliberately went out and hit Johns car with her passenger side taillight to coverup. THAT is the biggest coincidence AND coverup to this case!

Happy New Year Melanie 🎉 catching up on the Karen Read case, thank you for breaking it down for us ❤ Replay crew!

I'm wondering if all those butt dials were quick "call me on my burner phone" calls. Police know all the tricks that criminals use to avoid detection of their crimes. I wouldn't put it past any of the McAlberts to utilize burner phones. Also, I keep wondering what Higgins did at the police station (or was it sallyport?) that night. Maybe he got rid of evidence, or picked up some burner phones that were in evidence for some old cases? Just a theory. But his off duty visit to work that night seems very suspicious. Is there any indication if he ever did that any other time in his career?!?! Who was the stranger that Higgins saw in the house that night? I still have LOTS of questions.

Thank you Melanie 💗💪🙏

Judge Bev will not help This case at all !!!

I think that when they use the leaf blower to supposedly look for glass or pieces of light, I think it was really to cover up footsteps in the snow that would’ve been leading to the house from his body

Im really glad you went through this testimony again. I mis-remembered and under estimated the importance and his actual findings. He seems like a very kind man.

The worry here is Auntie Bev who always show leaning towards CW😡

So karen supposedly hit him and he flew 80 feet, he wasn't even found 80 feet from the road.

i heard the free billy tibbets comment on a show with miss shorty reviewing the pre trial hearing to recuse cannone

Wait… about JM heart rate.. didn’t she and her husband get a little frisky in the 2am hour? My heart rate tends to go up during such events.

Replay Crew Here! I would LOVE for courts allow for the 2 opposing experts to cross examine each other. I think this would be a fascinating way to get to the bottom of the matter.

So we might as well have a coronation for Brian, Albert and Jennifer, McCabe, as king and queen of Massachusetts, considering the fact that they are above all citizens, apparently in the commonwealth of Massachusetts, right?

Why does the CW want to cover for the Albert’s and the McCabe’s so much?

Karen’s phone data was not deleted by Karen, but there’s was by the real villains in this story….. So who is hiding things?

Olivia is soooo smart x

Every single person for the most part has proven that she’s innocent. Even the Commonwealth witnesses are either clearly lying or aren’t being accurate. How is it gonna be a second trial? Its insane

1 step at 12.23 when she said she saw ryan come

Also running round at 12.35

Alot of steps at 12.19 for JM

Sorry. On the replay. Am I stupid? If. I mean if. Karen hit him at 1230 am. How could he still be alive at 6am? How can the CM get around that?

I disagree with the DA opinions that John O’Keefe died of a car accident. People in that police department are not qualified to do anything.

Lally and Auntie Bev are deplorable

🤓 looking forward to your review of the Lively filing Dec 31 in New York federal court, and Dec 31 Baldoni suit against New York Times.

Replay . Mr Greene actually answers well, when Lally actually asks a sensible question that makes sense !

Replay Crew Here! I would LOVE for courts allow for the 2 opposing experts to cross examine each other. I think this would be a fascinating way to get to the bottom of the matter.

Melanie you are my favorite 🧁

Kerry got the phone

12:33 HER HEART RATE?😮😮😮😮

I believe the snowplow driver's testimony. I think the body was moved from the backyard in that Ford Edge. Whatever happened to John happened in the back yard as soon as he got there, when the dog was out. Someone else was apparently back there, and they took John's phone into the house and left his body in the backyard for hours, until people left the party. Then the body was moved in the Ford Edge to the property line in front of the house. And someone carried John's phone from inside the house and placed it near his body. It seems unlikely that a dozen people are lying about John not entering the house. I don't think he ever entered the house. He entered the backyard and died there almost right away, and his phone was carried into the house by person or persons unknown who were out in the yard with Chloe when John entered.

thank you so much for covering this really interesting case ... weekend catch-up crew here and watching in reverse ... the more recent ex-publicist Stephanie Jones filing great too. ✌🏻🤓🇨🇦

I write checks for my farm all the time.

You know what I find funny….how SOME lawyers think, they know more than an expert with degrees with years of experience. Bev needs to go away and we need a fair and honest judge

Ads literally every 5 minutes 😫

Asian people said they took pictures. Where are they?

Asian people said they took pictures. Where are they?

Why wouldn’t the police officers not gone Brian Albert to see if you heard anything or saw anything

What is her heart rate when she is dancing to raining men🤔 is that why she testified to dancing to cover up her heart rate

JM could use some beauty sleep

JOK's heart rate data could be interesting

I feel like we need to review Jessica Hyde’s testimony next. A refresher on the differences between she and Green.

Melanie, is there anyway that you can see what evidence was not allowed in by the defense

Yes Melanie uncle B is creepy to have in your phone

All of the interviews should have been conducted in a PD and recording.

He is qualified as expert, experts duke it out on stand, jury decides.🤷

All The Commonwealth has done is hire Hanky panky to be a defense attorney for Mcalberts... This is such a waste of tax payers dollars

I would love to see Jen McCabe's pattern of behavior PRIOR to JOK murder and if that was a change of behavior to be up all night.