It took me years but I just realised that "Didn't like musicals" implies that he does now, so they spoiled the ending in the title

22:28 NIGHTMARE TIME 😮!!!?!???!!

Demarco Shore

Corkery Stravenue

Adolph Dam

Donnelly Street

Keegan Gardens

Yoshiko Pass

THANK YOU SO MUCH nothing beats the stage musical-versions of the songs, for some reason once I watch the play, the cleaned-up vocals for a song almost always feel wrong.

Wisoky Island

Hilpert Center

Rodriguez George Lee Edward Davis Deborah

Schmidt Field

Wisozk Radial

Mara Track

Clark Daniel Lee Karen Lopez Linda

Moore Donald Young Mark Hall Barbara

Prohaska Pines

Hernandez Laura Lewis Susan Martinez Gary

Lopez Eric Johnson Matthew Lewis Jessica

24246 Meta Pass

Ik that there’s a bunch of different timelines in Hatchetfield but at 8:18 ish, mr davidson saying “I hire you Pauls” definitely stands out to me after watching Nightmare Time 😭😭

Seeing Melissa & Paul after watching “Hey, Melissa” is disturbing me all over again ☠️☠️

Jones Laura Martinez Jennifer Wilson Jose

Lopez Sarah Walker Mark Jones Lisa

I dont know why but Professor Hidgens reminds me of MatPat a bit. Maybe it's the haircut, the theater kid energy and hype or crazy theories but something feels similar.

I love how let it out shows us what the apotheosis actually feels like, so many mixed messages as the spores take over your mind

I’m in the car watching this and the second show me your hands started playing we drove past a cop car-

I can’t stop. I won’t stop. This is the only thing I will listen to for the rest of my life.

i never noticed how much ted likes the song of workin boys, i think it's pretty nice

Hold up a damn moment., 15:55 that was a empty shot HE WAS GONA SHOOT HER

The transition between SMYH and YTUMD was so smooth I barely even noticed it :0

After everything we've learned of the Lords in Black and the Hatchetfield lore, coming back to this and seeing people call Pokey just "the aliens" is very fun.

26:10 Emma’s reaction is so much funnier then I remembered it being 💀

0:05 TGWDLM 3:54 La Dee Da Da Day 7:16 What do you want, Paul 10:42 Cup of Roasted Coffee 13:16 Cup of Poisoned Coffee 13:46 Show me your Hands 16:16 Tie up my Heart 20:03 Join us and Die 21:55 Not your Seed 25:11 Show Stopping Number 30:57 Workin' Boys 31:25 America's Greant Again 33:30 Let it Out 36:55 Inevitable

STEP AWAY FROM THE VEHICLE 🗣🗣🗣

Join Us And Die is sooo good

I can't explain it but I love how the opening song switches from "didn't like" to "did not like"

TIME SKIP THINGS BC I DIDN'T SEE ANY IN THE TOP COMMENTS 0:00 The Guy Who Didn't Like Musicals 3:53 La Dee Dah Dah Day 7:16 What Do You Want Paul? 10:43 Cup Of Roasted Coffee + Cup Of Poisoned Coffee 13:45 Show Me Your Hands 16:15 You Tied Up My Heart (I THINK) 20:02 Join Us And Die 21:55 Not Your Seed 25:11 Show Stopping Number 31:19 America Is Great Again 33:30 Let It Out 36:55 Inevitable LET ME KNOW IF ANY ARE WRONG

IDK why it took me so long to realize this, but I was watching this for nostalgia reasons and I just realized that the opening number actually gives away pretty much everything that's going to happen in the musical, but its so out of context it doesn't register until you watch the musical all the way through.

13:27-13:35 sont ask me why but i cant stop rewinding this part whenever i watch it

The cops song will always be my favorite aside from the obvious gem

Personal headcanon, “Not your seed” is a innuendo to Bills divorce, maybe his wife cheated on him, and he had a suspicion that Alice is not his daughter

Jeff Blim. I dont need to say anymore.

17:10 21:07 22:36 23:23 27:37 32:11 32:37 33:32 34:00 34:42 37:56 38:23 0:29 1:05 1:23

Watching this after nightmare time 1 and 2 hit really different

at 30:04 look at ted having a bi panic, What a man.

this makes me so unbelievably happy

That one audience member in "What Do You Want, Paul?": aww... "I forgot what I was gonna say..." That same audience member: *bursts out laughing*

Show Stopping Number needs to be a real musical.