A great fight scene one greatest of its era in films

La mejor película del Oeste de todos los tiempos

Hasn’t been a greater western movie ever since. 🤷🏼

Omg those punches turn me on!!

"Where you think you're goin?"

This re edit is actually really good

An exact repeat is not a re-edited version.

Wait, people thought the movie was real? There are still people dumb enough to think movies “based on true events” are real? Documentaries aren’t even real. The news isn’t real. And they expect a Hollywood movie to be real? Crazy

I think those 2 marines who killed him shouldnt got let off regardless of given a camand. They knew the law

Why in the world would the guy Sue? Does this movie claim to be based on a true story? Does it even claim to be inspired by a true story? Not to my knowledge! So the only thing your lawsuits going to do is to actually point fingers at yourself that nobody else realizes, you were part of this. Dumbass.

Joe Start- TOP BLOKE. This is a superb piece of film work. Outstanding.

We are always here. The people who Fight for freedom, Fight against tyranny and Fight to think free and be free. We are called Democrats. IMO. Go to Hell right wingers. My dad fought hard in WW2. FU.

Seven samurai farmers "farmers don't know how to fight! We'll hire samurai!" Meanwhile Joel here

Scena di violenza di straordinaria veracità

One of the best fight scenes in any movie. I hate the self-righteous and dated dialogue though. Even as a kid, I could never stand the hippocracy of the cowardly sod busters. It never made sense why Shane would risk his neck for these people. My Dad used to say that this would've been a great western if it wasn't for the kid.

I served with him in STA 3/4, he was a good friend and took his job as a Marine very seriously. I Wish he were still here.

davids fight for what he believed in made this movie a reality.

This is great

This is hilarious

The movie was " Inspired" by events at Gitmo. Screenwriter Aaron Sorkin had a JAG sister who worked on the real case. The movie is more Hollywood than a biopic.

When Start pulls the wooden axe handle out of the barrel and walks in.... Goose bumps everytime..

Shane come back!

I'm sure you noticed the sounds right when a person gets hit in the face, well that's about as real as your going to get in real life.In today's movie's they put sound effects,fake sounds, and believe me it doesn't sound like that at all.One of the nice things about movie's that were made back in those day's compaired to now day's, sound effects, there's a big difference, it's more realistic back then.

Mr. Schachter, not looking at a side by side on 2 devices or screens it took a couple reviews to see any difference. Didn't feel I lost content, the music came in at the same place on the back to back, with acknowledged grins. What I noted you took away was part of the directors signature. He put us in the fight before stark had entered the barroom. Perhaps not as dramatic on a small device as a 50ties 🎥 screen. I expect the principles are long dead, that's not the point. Just because you can doesn't mean you should. It may not be paint on a canvas but to some of us it's art 🎨 not to be molested or altered. When you create your own work you may cut them anyway you like. If this is an area within film you enjoy there are films that need to be restored to original director's cut that have been censored, or cut to fit in a television time constraint. Technology allows us to create fictitious renditions or insertions of things that never happened. Outside of a direct family members involvement it's best left alone. Film restoration & preservation is a noble cause and contribution to society.

Now that's a bar fight

I went to Needham High School with David “Coxie” Cox. He was a bully who tortured me and other kids smaller than he was with another one of his friends during the years 1982-1985. I was a small, skinny kid while growing up in Needham and a very late bloomer, but I grew to be 6’3” 220 Lbs and Cox didn’t. So, that’s always been enough retribution for me towards Cox or anyone who caused harm to me like that. If in fact the tragic character Private Louden Downey is based upon David Cox, then perhaps karma found him. If he was a loving soul, I certainly didn’t catch any of that. I caught beatings and humiliation from Cox. So, when I learned that he got whacked, I didn’t shed a tear, but I didn’t applaud, either, because I appreciate his service for our country, and the military has a way of changing people for the better (usually, but not always). The history of his father’s alcoholism and abuse is sad, but no excuse for what he did to me or the other kids he tortured. Either one is smart enough to learn not to follow our parent’s negative behavior and bad habits or they acquire their weaknesses. After researching Cox’ death and the circumstances which occurred during his experience in the United States Marine Corps, it’s obvious that the reason for his death is open for much speculation and discussion. Other people who David bullied may have taken much pleasure in his financial plight and shocking demise. It’s quite possible that David Cox had more enemies than law enforcement and his friends and family were aware of, and it’s conceivable that the suspect was unrelated to the pitiful loser he was portrayed as in Hollywood Cinema by actor James David Greenblatt, and any connection to “A Few Good Men”. The pain and suffering that the character Private Santiago received from Private Downey and others involved in that fictitious plot are consistent with the behavior from the David Cox I knew. So, when I discovered that Private Downey was based upon Cox, it made perfect sense to me, because I knew that side of him all too well. I bumped into him at a gas station after his release from the usmc. He was a cocaine addicted mess. When I saw the loser he had become, I didn’t need revenge. However, one of the other kids Coxie tortured became a connected guy in the New England La Cosa Nostra.I saw him as a reunion and he brought up David Cox and the bad memories we shared. He told me eventually he would “deal with him”. I often wonder if the detectives were deceived and didn’t look into his past to learn if he had enemies.

It’s my hunch that the Colonel that was put away was the fall man and it was really our own United States government that was trying to invoke a war with Cuba and the communist during the Cold War, and Massachusetts state police didn’t want to go sniffing around the feds especially so far away in Guantánamo with The crazy stuff going on there

Hey man any updates? I’m a Marine and saw unsolved mysteries air, my biggest hunch is the Marine Corps covered it up and retaliated? Or Hollywood killed him because he was starting a lawsuit

I saw this movie for the first time around 1993 and later ended up joining the USMC almost one year exactly after David's murder (Jan 1995). One of my instructors at my mos school was even in the movie. He and another Marine played the two airmen in the court room that were going to testify. They didn't have speaking roles but appeared on camera. Up until a year ago I had no idea the movie was loosely based on real events. Really makes me sad what happened to David. I really hop e his killer is brought to justice.

0:15, fat guy with the gray beard: "I wouldn't go in there Joe, you'll get us in trouble". Just the other night he told Joe "We can't count on him" (referring to Shane). He and the others were calling Shane a coward for walking away from a fight with Calloway. And here, Shane just beat the hell out of Calloway, and now getting jumped by Ryker's entire gang, and the fat guy stands there doing nothing, and telling Joe not to do anything. Who's the coward?

good old fashioned country ass whooping

I don't hate the last book, it ended up resolving the main conflict (though he don't know the fate of sooo many characters) but MAAAAN what a goddamn tease that last line is.

"Holeface as himself". Cute.

Muy buenas raíces

The re-edit is well done, smooth and conventional. However..... director Stevens edited the bar fight to have jarring cuts that were Not smooth edits..... they were joined pieces of film intentionally mismatched to create the staccato abrupt feeling and emphasize the violence of the fight. Director Arthur Penn did the same thing in The Miracle Worker with Anne Bancroft's fight with Patty Duke/Helen Keller in the famous dining room battle scene... working with both his cinematographer & editor to make their fight jarring to the audience. The new edit, good as a Michael Bay action sequence, would not be remembered and studied by editors and film historians 60 years later.

من افضل الافلام في ذللك الزمان

Very cute girl but this gives me the Creeps , like a clip from Twilight Zone 🙀

This is bullshit I just expected Shane and starret to come back in with Thompsons blazing

Hella creepy! I love that effect on the eye! Reminds me of Dr Moreau, happy to see you’re still creating Noah! :)

And then Posidon the chad ask him to be his chariot and his wife. They later have a child who is a greek god of pure love.

Is this a joke? They are both 1:59 long!

What's the difference?

3/4 LIMA CO. SEMPER FI MARINE!

Only thing wrong is the fight wasn't longer. Why did they stop? Should have trashed the GD joint and killed Ryker.

A Few Good Men doesn’t claim to be true. At the end it says any resemblance is unintentional and the story is fictional. Yet, the Marines wouldn’t agree to be in it. Reiner got the Texas A&M Corp of Cadets to do the cadence. 4:20

This is the way things should be settled, not gun shots in to a crowd of people.

I love Shane!

💙

Hey Noah, It's Ted from Maine Media! Can I get an email contact from you?