Пікірлер
@jem7636
@jem7636 5 күн бұрын
The weather in the Alaska area makes air campaigns very difficult to execute.
@Kevin15301
@Kevin15301 8 күн бұрын
You should send a small surface task force to raid the Kuril islands. With the bombing he may assume you may be invading. Several destroyers and maybe a light cruiser or two. He may take the bait and transfer forces there and away from places important to you.
@gillynt
@gillynt 7 күн бұрын
I love this idea. I was toying with what I could do there to further distract him up there. I have reason to believe he has air units on Hokkaido and possibly one of the southern Kuril islands. But it's possible that small enough ships can sneak through undetected and also evade any bombs/torpedoes that might come if discovered. It's definitely something I'll seriously consider.
@Kevin15301
@Kevin15301 8 күн бұрын
Regarding the bombers and damage. You know what damage you have received. However, there could be fog of war at play. You could be doing more damage than what the computer is showing you.
@gillynt
@gillynt 7 күн бұрын
Right; that makes sense.
@Rayrard
@Rayrard 11 күн бұрын
No sounds for the discussion so skipped it. Good of your opponent to keep fighting despite things going rapidly downhill. It's fun to see the Allies start driving back and it will be good practice for you if you fight a skilled Japanese player in the future, and just give you experience with the island hopping dynamic. Also your opponent has to practice too, and can see how far he can get before defeat. It will be fun to see where he makes his stand because his pilot pool must be completely shot by now.
@gillynt
@gillynt 9 күн бұрын
A shrinking Japanese pilot pool is my goal. As for how good my opponent is, I know he doesn't use the same strategies as some players, but he has more experience than I do. So I imagine that he knows some things I don't--whether or not that's true. As for island hopping dynamic, I plan to start looking into using barges at some point. It's something I've been thinking about recently. Never tried that before.
@dedraedwards8526
@dedraedwards8526 11 күн бұрын
same here
@Kevin15301
@Kevin15301 12 күн бұрын
No sound with the Feb 28 turn and analysis
@gillynt
@gillynt 9 күн бұрын
That's a shame, sorry. But thanks for letting me know.
@jem7636
@jem7636 13 күн бұрын
The CLAAs are very valuable for task forces subject to air attack. They can also do good damage fighting smaller ships.
@thelodrik2182
@thelodrik2182 13 күн бұрын
Like Jochen and others said long ago, the Japanese player is not really playing. I am always free to offer you a new real match.
@jochenheiden
@jochenheiden 13 күн бұрын
I'm in utter shock and awe and how badly the Japanese player has whiffed this campaign. 😀
@Rayrard
@Rayrard 13 күн бұрын
There are some surviving bases and dot bases in the eastern DEI. Can you load up some small ships or APD's and get a base working deep in enemy territory. If you get it up to level 1-2 you can get fighters in from Darwin and threaten that whole area. Also it may force him to act with carriers.
@gillynt
@gillynt 13 күн бұрын
Great suggestions. I don't have the assets set aside for that just yet. But it's definitely something I can begin planning.
@Rayrard
@Rayrard Ай бұрын
Kusaie is possibly within range of Truk. I doubt he has Kusaie undefended. That may trigger KB to sortie.
@gillynt
@gillynt Ай бұрын
For sure; good points. I intend to do some recon in the near future, but not too soon to give it away yet. Regarding Truk and KB sorties, I will definitely have my CVs in the area to cover that kind of invasion. It's possible I'll wait for USS Essex to arrive even. To be determined...
@Rayrard
@Rayrard Ай бұрын
@@gillynt Given you sank a few of his carriers off Moresby, you can probably take on KB, but if you are in range of Nells/Betty too that kind of negates your advantage. I'm not sure if he built Yamato?
@Rayrard
@Rayrard Ай бұрын
I guess you will always lose light landing craft to landings but there was also a Fortress unit defending it with bigger guns. I think the invasion was the perfect number of troops and the landing craft helped them all participate in the shock attack.
@gillynt
@gillynt Ай бұрын
It seems as much. I'm definitely regularly showing my inexperience. Which of course includes using landing craft. And in so many ways, I'm still learning how things work together (and independently). In this case, I had no idea what to expect with my Mili invasion. Thanks for the input.
@Rayrard
@Rayrard Ай бұрын
@@gillynt I havent seen any Allied games going this far, so I'm really not sure how many landing craft are ideal to lose each time.I think losing a couple is fine given U.S. production but I'm sure Japanese airstrikes would be much more devastating
@VirgoShelter
@VirgoShelter Ай бұрын
The video is set to the lowest quantity and I can't turn it up, so I can't tell much apart
@gillynt
@gillynt Ай бұрын
I'm sorry to hear that @VirgoShelter. The uploads are all 1080, but the quality improves for later videos.
@orjeetghrajshingbade-d3d
@orjeetghrajshingbade-d3d Ай бұрын
Young Charles Johnson Brian Perez Susan
@dutovdevlich3781
@dutovdevlich3781 Ай бұрын
Subs could be doing a mine laying mission if directly on a port.
@e.najorodnerolf2688
@e.najorodnerolf2688 Ай бұрын
I think you should give the robin / victorious to the Brits cuz they rlly need it. If it is rlly necessary to put it in the Pacific best not to unit it to the American taskforce but rather unite it to the Aussies with the last remaining rn ships, cuz her speed is not compatible with the American carriers though shes tougher than her American counterpart but she can slowdown the whole taskforce if she's present
@gillynt
@gillynt Ай бұрын
Well I replied, but it didn't stick. In summary, I'll evaluate my options when Victorious gets to Sydney.
@jacobmartin1100
@jacobmartin1100 Ай бұрын
Regarding *Victorious*, she was historically temporarily re-flagged as the USS Robbin and deployed to SOPAC on loan while the Essex class began to come off the slipways. Honestly would just concentrate it with the other CVs and use all that strength for a big raid on Truk depending on how degraded his Solomons/NG bases are.
@gillynt
@gillynt Ай бұрын
Thank you @jacobmartin1100. You've confirmed my decision was the right one. It's obviously going to have less aircraft than US CVs, but it will be a nice complement to my TFs in the SOPAC. Especially with USS Wasp in repairs. I appreciate the history also!
@Rayrard
@Rayrard Ай бұрын
Resistance doesn't seem to be that significant in the islands you plan to take in the Marshalls? What is it showing for defenders for the islands there?
@gillynt
@gillynt Ай бұрын
My reconnaissance flights indicate small units roughly the size of regiments through most of the Marshalls. I'll have to double check the further away/more strategic islands of Kwajalein, Roi Namur, and Eniwetok.
@thelodrik2182
@thelodrik2182 2 ай бұрын
DB are really better for ship hunting and not ground strikes. The choice is yours.
@gillynt
@gillynt 2 ай бұрын
I have them set to both.
@jem7636
@jem7636 2 ай бұрын
You are better off without Rangoon.
@gillynt
@gillynt 2 ай бұрын
Indeed. I'm feeling better already. Most importantly, I saved myself a lot of ground losses with what would otherwise have been a significant defeat against his next assault, thus saving the equivalent of two divisions.
@Rayrard
@Rayrard 2 ай бұрын
The zigxag position form Prome to Toungoo seems like a good defensive position in Burma. That 1400AV can probably stand up to the Japanese in that hex even with the Rangoon force added to it, and his airforce is infrior to your own.
@gillynt
@gillynt 2 ай бұрын
I appreciate your suggestions. As a result, I've changed my mind on withdrawal. In addition, I have another British brigade and Australian division on the way.
@Rayrard
@Rayrard 2 ай бұрын
Meh, night bombing of ships is a complete waste of supply. The strafing attack with fighters was the only successful ship attack you've made, but why not try and port strike Tavoy? I guess it really doesn't matter now that Rangoon is taken.
@gillynt
@gillynt 2 ай бұрын
My airfields Prome and Bassein are pretty full as is. To add my bombers would be overstacked. And maybe I didn't show it (sorry if not), but he has about 140+ fighters at Tavoy. It's possible he's got them all on CAP.
@Rayrard
@Rayrard 2 ай бұрын
It really doesnt matter if he is producing airframes... the Japanese airforce simply cannot take the losses they've taken. More than 800 Tojos destroyed. The Japanese pilot quality is crashing rapidly and your planes and pilots are improving.
@Rayrard
@Rayrard 2 ай бұрын
In no way should you withdraw even a hex (except cede Rangoon of course). Even if he gets Rangoon he can't go anywhere. He has no bombardment target anymore, Rangoon is destroyed, and you have total air superiority. He cannot dislodge your troops from any hex besides Rangoon, especially if you have units consolidate. If you retreat you make the loss of all the troops, planes, and British ships 100% worthless. The Japanese are losing the attrition war in Burma.
@gillynt
@gillynt 2 ай бұрын
I appreciate this feedback. Makes me rethink what I'm actually working on during the current turn. Very timely that I read this right now actually. Reviewing the situation just north of Rangoon, as of February 3, I have made a couple of changes that will help (fingers crossed) and hold the line where it is.
@jacobmartin1100
@jacobmartin1100 2 ай бұрын
I don't think you should give up Prome. You hold command of the air over everywhere except Rangoon and can thus hold the clear terrain ahead of Prome or the hex itself. Prome is a lynchpin which connects Burma to India, and losing it means you lose access to reinforcements from the Raj overland (at least as easily as anything marching overland from the Raj can be). The new defensive line is probably sensible for the north, but you can't just give up Prome like that, not after forcing him to bleed over Rangoon. He won't have the shore bombardment, he has more than lost the air war and will continue to do so, you will only gain more troops in India who can be brought to bear in Burma, and your strength in bombers will only grow, allowing you to dominate clear terrain and slow his advance. Ceding Prome surrenders these advantages and puts you on the back foot in a way that is not desirable. With the forces presently available trying to relieve Rangoon, you could easily hold Prome while keeping the armor in reserve, reconstituting the forces from Rangoon, and shoring up the rest of the defensive line, all the while receiving a steady stream of supplies and troops from India.
@gillynt
@gillynt 2 ай бұрын
I love it Jacob. Great advice. I am pulling out of Rangoon, if he lets me. Otherwise, those guys will be trashed and have to rail to safety at Prome. Additionally, I'll have to pull back in other areas. However, I love your advice to hold Prome. And I like your points about air dominance. Even with Rangoon, he will have trouble bringing air power in, as I can keep all bases from Moulmein north in a destroyed state. With forts and better supply, Prome should be defensible, as you say. Thank you very much!
@thelodrik2182
@thelodrik2182 2 ай бұрын
Nice intro, the beginning to be a Pro.
@gillynt
@gillynt 2 ай бұрын
Thank you Lodrik.
@Brazouck
@Brazouck 2 ай бұрын
hello, what mods are you using please ?
@gillynt
@gillynt 2 ай бұрын
Hi @Brazouck. I'm sorry I didn't see this message until just now. I can't remember, but I'll try to find it and let you know.
@Rayrard
@Rayrard 2 ай бұрын
I think your play is good for the Allies except the British navy. Your play elsewhere is fine, even if it's more cautious. I do think your one turn of naval strafing was devastating and you hit a bunch of his ships. You can probably get the DD's and CL's if he operates from Moulmein. I think if he operates from Tavoy he is going to have fuel issues because he will have to operate at full speed constantly to cover the 5-6 hexes to Rangoon. I think it ends up being moot since Rangoon will fall eventually but hopefully you can defeat the Imperial Guards in the next couple turns and stabilize the front.
@e.najorodnerolf2688
@e.najorodnerolf2688 2 ай бұрын
cool intro
@gillynt
@gillynt 2 ай бұрын
Thank you!
@jem7636
@jem7636 2 ай бұрын
Great job by your son on the intro
@gillynt
@gillynt 2 ай бұрын
Thank you very much jem
@jem7636
@jem7636 2 ай бұрын
I forgot to mention that I appreciate the work you and your opponent have done to provide us with interesting battles. Please keep sharing your campaign.
@jem7636
@jem7636 2 ай бұрын
It is good to remember that all losses are sunk costs (in this case literally sunk). Don't risk losses just to redeem past losses. In the future, deploy your naval attack forces where you can use your ground air superiority.
@Rayrard
@Rayrard 2 ай бұрын
That CLAA was a good escort ship... not sure why your threw it away when you knew Japanese CA's were present in the area (bombardments). The Japanese probably had the CA force on maximum react and they reacted when you drove your fleet into the Rangoon hex, so the CL's retreated while the big boys stepped up. It may have been a great time for a carrier strike given how weak the mini-KB seems to be in the area, and the air superiority you have over Pegu and Moulmein.
@thelodrik2182
@thelodrik2182 2 ай бұрын
Dutch and British DD are always the best ASW ships to hunt and escort. They are not front line DD.
@gillynt
@gillynt 2 ай бұрын
Again, based on how the campaign has gone to this point, I expected my opponent to disappear when he saw the USN in the area. He had mentioned the possibility of them arriving in an email a couple weeks ago, so based on his email, I anticipated that once he saw my CV's, he would run away and my CVs would waste another week or so hunting open sea and getting sniped by Betties for no gain. Well, obviously I'm wrong. I'm acting on intel + his responses. My advisors on here have hindsight. I unfortunately do not.
@thelodrik2182
@thelodrik2182 2 ай бұрын
@@gillynt yes don't worry, you have hundreds of DD to push forward. At the end the allies have nearly unlimited equipment in 1944/45.
@Rayrard
@Rayrard 2 ай бұрын
Are you serious getting the British navy slaughtered again. You are playing the navy game excellent in the Pacific, but you hate the British navy apparently. Also, please stop attacking Wuchan or else your 2000 AV advantage will evaporate. You can't take a city with level 5 forts and 4 Japanese divisions with Chinese troops. You should just keep that 3500AV in place beseiging the city for months. You already accomplished your mission with the Chinese offensive and now you are just giving him free ground points.
@e.najorodnerolf2688
@e.najorodnerolf2688 2 ай бұрын
Well to be fair he doesn't really know How to use the British Navy's ships cause it's not as modern as the American ships and the ijn ships like their heavy cruisers are more superior than the British when it comes to fire power, But it still hurts to see them perish, the first month's of the Bay of Bengal campaign was a smooth ride then suddenly turned into a bumpy one with the mission to resupply Rangoon.
@e.najorodnerolf2688
@e.najorodnerolf2688 2 ай бұрын
Okay this is getting ridiculous its like were handing him free kills at this point.
@thelodrik2182
@thelodrik2182 2 ай бұрын
Yes I guess Friedrich did that on purpose to keep the Japanese player happy. I saw no navy search and strike from him for months in that area. He is using his strike and dive bombers for ground and strikes what is nonsense. But he won the war months ago so this is more for entertainment.
@gillynt
@gillynt 2 ай бұрын
I do have naval search that is supposed to cover that whole area between Port Blair and south of Moulmein. But the British naval and air forces are underperforming, even though they've been practicing war for over 3 years now.
@Rayrard
@Rayrard 2 ай бұрын
I agree with the other poster that you stopped pressuring him on the map. At least before he was paranoid about the Marshalls and Rabaul and now there are no invasions. He can almost focus 100% on the Indian Ocean in the last 2 weeks which is an advantage for him to get local superiority at least on land but also move KB to the Indian Ocean if he wants to.
@gillynt
@gillynt 2 ай бұрын
Sure, but I've still got the initiative in these areas. If nothing else, I have air superiority in the three Pacific theaters, and I'm consolidating that superiority now. As for invasion action, these are being developed. Anywhere in the Solomons or Central Pacific that I've got in my sights, can't be effectively reinforced anymore. Plus, other than the VPs that I want to get from as many bases as I can, I could even bypass some of the islands. It may not make as good entertainment for the viewer, but I'm working on logistics and base-building for my new forward bases, to make my next leap defensible.
@Rayrard
@Rayrard 2 ай бұрын
I got caught up finally. The anticipation of the carriers was kind of a debby downer. Maybe it's the old Indian Ocean curse but the moment Allied ships enter the Indian Ocean you somehow find a way for Japanese torpedoes to hit you
@gillynt
@gillynt 2 ай бұрын
Yeah, it's a mix of bad dice rolls (I think because of what I've seen from other RN ship results in campaigns that I'm not commanding) and my opponent either planning well with backup fleets, etc or simple luck. Either way, the Bay of Bengal has had the worst results for my ships, and I'm counting the terrible early KB strikes in the South Pacific.
@thelodrik2182
@thelodrik2182 3 ай бұрын
That is your game so feel free to do whatever is in your mind. I only have the feeling it is far too slow and inactive. You could build up more pressure and use your carriers and ships. Calling back all carriers because 1 is damaged is a little strange.
@gillynt
@gillynt 3 ай бұрын
It is because I lost the element of surprise. As a result, I expected him to stop sending his Cruiser bombardments and didn't want to waste a trip into the Bay of Bengal. We shall see. My game is pretty much caught up here now. I have only two more days recorded to upload. My opponent is on vacation and is in a place with bad (or no) wi-fi. So it may be a few days before I can get some more turns. Regarding too slow and inactive, I'm working on plans, even without my CVs, in the South.
@thelodrik2182
@thelodrik2182 3 ай бұрын
Oh that means you are doing only 1 or 2 turns a week? So we have to wait some days and check how you will take Rabaul ​@@gillynt
@gillynt
@gillynt 2 ай бұрын
He is back home in a few days. We should get back to almost daily turn speed after that.
@jem7636
@jem7636 3 ай бұрын
The APDs are very useful ships for small invasions and resupply in risky waters. You are also accumulating AK and tanker sinkings that will hinder Japan in the future. It has been a long time since Japanese subs sank one of your merchant ships. The PT boats not only force expenditure of ammunition but time. If the bombardment group spends enough time fighting with small naval craft, they might not make it back to base during the night. Then they would be vulnerable to air attack.
@thelodrik2182
@thelodrik2182 3 ай бұрын
That are not real PT ship. You need to separate between Harbour defense and ocean going PT boats. Not sure why there are no DB in Rangoon to hit these Japanese ship months ago. Add 750 mines in the hex of Rangoon and there is a safe port long ago.
@gillynt
@gillynt 3 ай бұрын
@jem7636 - would be nice!
@gillynt
@gillynt 3 ай бұрын
Lodrik - trust me, I've learned a lot this game. I cannot go back in time within this one, but as soon as I realized what was happening, it was too late to mine it. There are more than a few things I'd have done differently. In any case, Rangoon holding into '43 isn't too bad. While yes, I could be in an even stronger position, I've definitely seen some Rangoon captures much earlier than this campaign.
@Kevin15301
@Kevin15301 3 ай бұрын
Not sure but isn't sweeping an opponents base the same as flying cap over your own base?
@gillynt
@gillynt 3 ай бұрын
It might be, but not the way I was wanting to use it. If he is using LR-CAP over his units in Rangoon, I do not think me using LR-CAP over Rangoon does anything unless he actually flies in to bomb. So it's not like my LR-CAP and his LR-CAP tango in the air over Rangoon, as if it was a sweep. I could be wrong, however.
@jem7636
@jem7636 3 ай бұрын
@@gillynt part of the fog of war in this game is uncertainty about what the rules are
@gillynt
@gillynt 3 ай бұрын
Great comment!
@jem7636
@jem7636 3 ай бұрын
Later in the war the US have a purpose built night fighter (P61). In addition, the USN had specially trained hellcat squadrons with radar.
@gillynt
@gillynt 3 ай бұрын
Looking forward to it!
@jem7636
@jem7636 3 ай бұрын
Good recovery from the 17th setback. This game is a test of character as well as skill
@gillynt
@gillynt 3 ай бұрын
Yes indeed.
@Silverhks
@Silverhks 3 ай бұрын
Dumb question alert. You didn't show the sweep squadron pages but you did give them a destination, right? 2nd question. Why not use 1-2 of those squadrons to escort the bombers? F4U-1 Corsairs are NOT carrier capable so there isn't a decision to be made. More for the Marines baby!
@gillynt
@gillynt 3 ай бұрын
Yes, the F4F's on the CVs upgrade to F6F's. But yeah, Marines have their first F4U squadron! As for the sweeps, I had them destined to Rangoon. In any case, I figured it out, and I've made some modifications to my sweep destinations. And indeed have some good results soon (oops--spoiler).
@Silverhks
@Silverhks 3 ай бұрын
@@gillynt glad you sorted it
@gravyship5058
@gravyship5058 3 ай бұрын
Good game
@Silverhks
@Silverhks 3 ай бұрын
The group admin number (10) is the number of squadrons with missions but modified slightly. Any number of training squadrons count as 1 and i think search squadrons are counted the same way. There is also some modification when you have the HQ squadrons early war. The plane number is a simple addition of the engines of all planes located on base, I think. The limit comes from multiplying the airbase size x50.
@gillynt
@gillynt 3 ай бұрын
Thanks so much @Silverhks!
@Rayrard
@Rayrard 3 ай бұрын
Animations are fun for fighter/ship engagements and bombings of ships, not so much for air bombardments or ASW. Feel free to pick and choose when to use them but don't turn them off. The fast forward is fine.
@gillynt
@gillynt 3 ай бұрын
I agree on the air bombardment. Usually, unless I am not paying attention, I do skip the aerial bombardments, with one important exception: if I want to see how my bombers do against the enemy aircraft on the ground. As for ASW, I acknowledge there isn't much substance there, but I like to see how bad the damage is, especially when I'm the one firing depth charges. I still won't know for sure if I sank the sub, but seeing that the # of hits is DIRECT or simply some Near Misses makes a difference in my mind.
@Rayrard
@Rayrard 3 ай бұрын
Amazing how you can kick the crap out of him in Pegu/Moulmein yet he still manages to get poorly or unopposed naval strikes at your Royal Navy ships. It's almost like we are roleplaying a IJN/IJA rivalry where the RAF won't help out their naval brethren. I can't see how you couldn't just slaughter those naval bombers by running them under CAP from Prome or Rangoon set at 100% where you have dozens of planes and it would be easy to break up or destroy the Betty/Nell formations. Instead you get the RN slaughtered for like the 3rd or 4th time in the game to the SAME Japanese bombers you know are there.
@gillynt
@gillynt 3 ай бұрын
Yeah, I thought the CAP was better set for this RN run, but then one misstep with lack of waypoints for the return journey put them just one hex out of Ground LR-CAP range. I know what you're saying about the SAME Japanese bombers, but I was expecting a slightly different result. One due to LB-CAP and another due to Full Speed, not realizing there was a CV presence, and the aforementioned range issue. Overall it was definitely something I was willing to do, just expected different results due to better planning. Implementation of the planning is where it fell apart (and also his sneaky CVs).
@Rayrard
@Rayrard 3 ай бұрын
Where are your British carriers? I saw Illustrious in the list and Hermes in port. Don't you have Formidible or was it withdrawn already?
@gillynt
@gillynt 3 ай бұрын
Yeah, keep watching. For one, they do show up soon enough, both Illustrious and Hermes. But yes, those are the only two British CVs available to me to this point in the campaign.
@Rayrard
@Rayrard 3 ай бұрын
Doesn't seem like KB is strong enough to resist a CV counterattack. I guess we shall see. You lost a decent number of ships (the CVE's sucked to lose) but you also hurt his strike aircraft.
@gillynt
@gillynt 3 ай бұрын
Yeah, I weakened him, though it came at severe loss of my own. Based on seeing your last comment, surely you already saw the (somewhat anticlimactic) CV action in the South Pacific.
@Rayrard
@Rayrard 3 ай бұрын
That little base in the rear of Rangoon contatnly flips to the Japanese despite you having more forces adjacent. If you keep something there you could trickle supply into Rangoon. No clue why you are leaving that base unoccupied as it keeps Rangoon surrounded.
@gillynt
@gillynt 3 ай бұрын
I had recaptured it twice only for the Japanese to eliminate the units that captured it from the air. But as you continue to watch, you'll see this get resolved soon.