Why TCGs Are Impossible to Balance
17:30
Why Are Trading Cards So Expensive?
9:20
How the Spore Creature Creator Works
13:55
How To BREAK a Trading Card Game
13:34
Super Smash Bros. Themed Pokemon Team
10:03
Пікірлер
@mandrakeking
@mandrakeking 2 күн бұрын
Overall, I'd say this is good, but you lean too heavy on "Just copy magic". One of the first steps should be deciding how "factions" are defined, how many the game will have, and how closely they'll interact. For example, While Magic has 5 [colors], Yugioh started out with 20 [Monster-Types] before the focus shifted to named archetypes. The current Digimon TCG does all three at the moment, though it's been building up to this. The number of factions will determine how many mechanics can to tied to each one. Also, while it's up to the person to decide if their game even uses a draft format, they will have to choose if and how different factions interact in the same deck. Some games will have factions that just dilute each other's resources, while other games might have factions that synergize really well
@matiesponja
@matiesponja 3 күн бұрын
So in my htcg, i made three types of cards, the commons which you can put any amount of cards in your deck, the uniques, which are limited to 1 copy for deck, and the legendaries, which are op BUT you can activate it's effect ONLY IF it's the only legendary card on the Zone, that counts for your cards or the other players'. So are you tired of your oponent beating your with their OP legendary cards? Bring yours to the table to counter them and even activate the legendaries of yours!
@nobafan7515
@nobafan7515 3 күн бұрын
I know this is 3 years late, but what approach do you think works best for an ai to learn how to play pokemon? (Aside from essentially everyone spamming chatgpt clips from their pokemon battles)
@manosmavrakis8132
@manosmavrakis8132 6 күн бұрын
i refuse to play with auctions
@YammoYammamoto
@YammoYammamoto 6 күн бұрын
Looking at the screenshot I was seeing "Green, Blue, Red, White, Black, Black." Not only is purple an actually r-word choice, but the dynamic of Color X being the enemy of TWO colours would get destroyed... which is one of the most foundational and poetic parts of MTG. That every force, has two forces controlling it.
@thetable7660
@thetable7660 7 күн бұрын
How Gwent got mentioned without referring to the Provision system which actually addresses the Queen's problem is baffling. Dividing a card pool into factions only shifts the Queen's problem to which faction has the best cards; it can help if the best cards are properly distributed but why make OP cards in the first place?
@christiangreen2324
@christiangreen2324 13 күн бұрын
Or make it so no one can attack until turn 4
@Statalyzer
@Statalyzer 14 күн бұрын
I find Tech Cards (Answer Cards) to usually be a poor attempt at balancing. If they are all around useful PLUS shut down an otherwise op strategy, then they themselves become op. So instead they are weak against any other strategy, making them insanely swingy. If they face one type of deck, they rule, if not, they suck. That's only worthwhile if that one single deck type is used to a tiresome degree over all others. And if one deck types predominates like that you have lost variety and need something better than one clumsy patch.
@nrrork
@nrrork 17 күн бұрын
My favorite strategy is find a good source of one resource and settle there and either directly on that resource's port, or close to it. It doesn't have to be a monopoly, but if you got 2 or 3 good sources of wood, yeah, the wood port is about the best thing you could have. And you can stay out of a lot of player disputes that way, you just trade with the bank. It keeps your resource card count low, too. Nothing worse than finally getting that last resource you need to make your next move, and that damn 7 gets rolled, and you have 8 cards! So much for that city upgrade.
@nrrork
@nrrork 17 күн бұрын
A 2:1 trade still beats having to trade with the bank, though. Especially if it's a resource that's in abundance versus one that's scarce. I've had games where the wood and wheat were on like all 6s and 8s, and all the ore was on 3 or 12, etc. Ore is worth more on that board. And you know giving them the ore is essentially handing them a victory point, so what should you really be expecting in return? Not all resource cards have the same value, so 1:1 is not always a fair trade.
@shawnnbits
@shawnnbits 19 күн бұрын
You look so cute in this one
@shawnnbits
@shawnnbits 19 күн бұрын
What track starts playing at the 21:00 mark
@DatDude-po5dq
@DatDude-po5dq 19 күн бұрын
These Are Some Of The Strategies Used By My KZbin Friend Kidd Perfeck He Has The Highest Game Score I have Ever Seen Before!!!🙃
@Tungdil_01
@Tungdil_01 24 күн бұрын
Do you know FutureSightAI? I'm not sure whether it was released at the time of your video, but if you have plans to revisit this idea again, I think this might be useful. I remember that a couple of years ago it was quite popular, but I'm not sure if it's still is.
@KarmaGeeGee
@KarmaGeeGee Ай бұрын
the 4 stations have decided the outcome of every game of Monopoly ive ever played
@birdofdoom1024
@birdofdoom1024 Ай бұрын
Good Video but I think you forgot to mention, that the companies don't have an interest in creating a balanced game because that wouldn't be good for the sales. They much rather power creep with every new set
@Casual.Gamer_0000
@Casual.Gamer_0000 Ай бұрын
"businesses fight for the death, with that said, choose your weapon:" - Microsoft: acquire every studio - Nintendo: "i sue you" - Valve: makes a single product in every half a decade
@royalecrafts6252
@royalecrafts6252 Ай бұрын
Well......start to say the very first problem is that tcgs are pay to win by definition
@DanielK-rk2jq
@DanielK-rk2jq Ай бұрын
9:03 You can always fortify ur troops, but then again it would be better to use that fortification to even out the troops between Brazil and Venezuela
@account-yi2cn
@account-yi2cn Ай бұрын
lol the evolution of your appearance throughout this video
@jonathantheologus8624
@jonathantheologus8624 Ай бұрын
Business-Rex 🎉
@carolinablueee4406
@carolinablueee4406 2 ай бұрын
The quiz and explanation why was a cool touch. Appreciate the video man🫡💯
@saimonewd
@saimonewd 2 ай бұрын
just great
@potato7640
@potato7640 2 ай бұрын
A house rule I use is for jail, instead of getting 1 role on your turn to get a double, we use all 3 roles in 1 turn then pay if we dont get it. That way it stops stalling for late and mid game, helps in early game, and is mostly used so you don't get your $200 for passing go amd having to go through the jail half again.
@KalinTheZola
@KalinTheZola 2 ай бұрын
With the gen 4 change suggestion you gave for Purugly, I agree with the sentiment but I can't agree with the change you made. I feel that without the widesweeping ears, it actually makes the design feel uneven and ironically unfinished while still looking overly complicated, just now in the wrong areas. I feel like without the swooping ears it makes the design look way too bottom heavy. You'd think that would be a good thing but it just kind of looks still cluttered but in a more unbalanced way. I think if you kept the general shape language but without the purple finger look, it would be much better. I also think the shape of the origjnal ears mostly work because it goes in a similar swooping motion of the body but in the opposite direction.
@soupcastle8210
@soupcastle8210 2 ай бұрын
This why I like Marvels Snap. On have one copy of a card and each card can be a support or main depending on how you use them
@GregoryGlessnerViolin
@GregoryGlessnerViolin 2 ай бұрын
Bad rolls blow all of this apart, and if the robber sits on one of your hexes that actually gets rolled, you can't win. Edit to add: 6:52 The wheat on 6 is all well and good, until the dice just won't turn up a 6.
@AmityvilleFan
@AmityvilleFan 2 ай бұрын
Aaand we learnt nothing.
@Bralore125
@Bralore125 2 ай бұрын
I’m working on a tcg, and this problem has been in my mind sense I started. The idea of limitations of what cards you can use is great. I made a rule that you declare a type, and the monsters you use have to be of that type, except 5. Idk, I feel that is the best way to handle it, unless those five cards are extremely good.
@kennethwright5664
@kennethwright5664 2 ай бұрын
In the old Cyberpunk 2077 TCG, the Runner Card Zane Red was an absolute unit that was a key part of every "High Noon" deck and nearly every other deck as well. was easily the most powerful runner in the game and could be bought at the very beginning of the game if you drew him, and then he wasn't even Legendary, so you could have 4 of him in your deck to boot.
@MrNemitri
@MrNemitri 2 ай бұрын
A simple answer: Chase cards and filler cards.
@keeler1160
@keeler1160 2 ай бұрын
I always thought the sixth color would be yellow for lightning.
@RobertoECC
@RobertoECC 2 ай бұрын
Can I download these creatures as skins?
@leodaza2151
@leodaza2151 2 ай бұрын
I have said for many years that the Queen in chess needs to be nerfed, it is too OP and has dominated the meta for centuries. I would propose limiting how many squares it can move in one turn, as this would keep its original ability, but reduce it in power so that the Rook and Bishop still have a use
@sofia_ffemboy
@sofia_ffemboy 2 ай бұрын
🎲😉 Thank you very much for your video!
@TheTomdog23
@TheTomdog23 3 ай бұрын
I built a “purple” deck for commander, since most of the cards i saw in purple felt sort of like phasing i made a phasing deck with Taniwha
@jaschabull2365
@jaschabull2365 3 ай бұрын
One thing I noticed about gen 9 is how many vehicle-based pokémon there are. From the box art legends to the varoom line and orthworm, shoot, I've heard someone compare dudunsparce to one of those carnival rides made to look like a dragon. I totally see it. I've heard it suggested that it looks as if the Pokémon Company was preparing to make a theme park. Honestly, I really like gen 9's roster, I'm largely drawn to fun designs, and gen 9 had some real doozies.
@koboldqueen3055
@koboldqueen3055 3 ай бұрын
magic has in fact added a 6th color in colorless/devoid giving colorless cards a very specific identity and their own mana symbol and other experiments such as pherixian mana and snow mana act similarly tho are less developed at the moment
@Nefiron-v1
@Nefiron-v1 2 ай бұрын
Agreed. And the way they have flipped card effects to other colors, it doesn't really matter what color you choose anymore, because you can find the same effect in almost any of them. Adding a sixth would be a waste and just fluff.
@CharlesLeeRay812
@CharlesLeeRay812 Ай бұрын
From the rules 105.4 If a player is asked to choose a color, they must choose one of the five colors. “Multicolored” is not a color. Neither is “colorless.”
@koboldqueen3055
@koboldqueen3055 Ай бұрын
@@CharlesLeeRay812 a Changeable rule doesn't change the existence of cards made under a designer principal to treat them as a 6th color. Rules change how cards work changes the design principles behind cards only changes when those principles become widely adopted into evergreen set printing.
@comradecameron3726
@comradecameron3726 Ай бұрын
No. Notrlelayk at akskbd bjt whatevev.
@elesvazul
@elesvazul 3 ай бұрын
It is not a good idea to balance a TCG, LCG, CCG game nor board games in general! If you want to play a boring unenjoyable balanced game, go ahead and play chess! If you want a game to be exiting and fun, keep it unbalanced, and keep the random in it! I don't like board games with 0 random factor.
@jaschabull2365
@jaschabull2365 3 ай бұрын
You may say gen 2 doesn't have a lot of common, repeating design trends, but I seem to remember going through the gen 2 dex and noticing just how many of them have black/dark colours around or near their eyes. All 3 legendaries at the end of the dex have them, and that's just the beginning. Though I guess that was just a precursor to gen 3, even if there, the range of colours is broader. The montage of side-by-side comparisons really made it really occur to me how contrary tyranitar is, as most of the gen 2 equivalents are much smoother and softer-looking than their gen 1 counterparts, but tyranitar looks like a kaiju, much like several gen 1 pokémon, whereas dragonite is all curves and cuddly shapes. I guess the pseudo-legends are kind of like those dots in the yin yang symbol when comparing the 2 gens, in a way. I never was that fond of ambipom, but looking back, it just hit on me that its nose was probably a reference to a snub-nosed monkey. Now that's got me wondering if there was a more appealing way to implement that sort of monkey's nose as a design principal. Though I could see why it wouldn't really work on ambipom, whose original form appears to be an exaggeration of a monkey's prehensile tail, which would apply to the likes of spider monkeys rather than an Asian species like the snub-nose. Though I suppose with Sinnoh's being the northernmost Japanese region, it would make sense to base the form introduced there on a snow monkey? More food for thought than I expected. I beg to differ regarding gen 5's version exclusives. They can be subtle, but I'd say the differences really tie into the versions' themes in a way that's never been matched in other gens. Reuniclus is in a bubble, basically in its own little world, kind of like an idealist that refuses to acknowledge any sort of bitter truths. Gothitelle, on the other hand, is a psychic seer which literally gets a vision of when you are going to die, basically being forced to behold a bitter truth of the world. I could go on. Also, I guess you never felt like waiting to catch something with sweet honey trees, considering combee and cherubi apparently completely evade your attention, regarding multiple-headed pokémon. The one theme you left out regarding gen 7 is alchemy, which is particularly apparent in the legendaries, with the box art legendaries incorporating the alchemic properties of the sun and moon into their designs, and magearna and type: null and silvally basically being alechemy experiments.
@NathanieiJerry-s9v
@NathanieiJerry-s9v 3 ай бұрын
Jeffery Mills
@Rel3D
@Rel3D 3 ай бұрын
Hey you got some really cool vids can't wait to go back and watch them. Excited to see what ideas you have next! The tcg one is what brought me here!
@da_boss_man_joofu5
@da_boss_man_joofu5 3 ай бұрын
ok but where can i make it, i need a website where i can alter the values on cards
@mikerenfro4608
@mikerenfro4608 3 ай бұрын
Welcome back Rempton Games!
@el_1776
@el_1776 3 ай бұрын
Now ill feel personally insulted if some fool opens with rock against me. What a scrubby move.
@Izelor
@Izelor 3 ай бұрын
The only way for a card game to be balanced is to be a single set with no further expansions. Imagine a card game that is a single purchase and is a box of, say, 500 cards, and you can build whatever you want with them, just like a Cube in Magic the Gathering.
@tommassspunis8184
@tommassspunis8184 3 ай бұрын
Based on what you said, i think this weird strategy could help your chances at this game: at the beginning of the game pick up your favourite string of numbers, f.e. your phone number and start playing according to your numbers modulo 3, in order, so that against experiences players you would be playing truly random and they cant trick you, you spend no energy thinking about the moves and can play some aggressive mind games like the one of playing scissors when oppo played two rocks in a row to win the game, like 52% of time?
@womancandyxxx8556
@womancandyxxx8556 3 ай бұрын
John 1: 17
@StephanTrube
@StephanTrube 3 ай бұрын
Found and victory is ensured (Fountain: Victory is ensured) Just kidding and leaving a comment for the algorithm. Thanks, keep it up!
@MistaManlyGuy
@MistaManlyGuy 3 ай бұрын
Ah, now I have context to what I watched 😸