#2 Tommy Thayer - Movie Star & Black N Blue. #3 Mark Saint John - White Tiger #4 Vinnie Vincent - Vinnie Vincent Invasion. #5 Bruce Krulak - Grand Funk Railroad just doesn't suit KISS style.

Mark St.Jhon - White Tiger

"Mark Saint John" from White Tiger is the best guitar player he plays Speed Metal .

Fan since 74 when I was 14. !00% agree with the order.

Ace is 31 by far.

does anyone know where i can find i higher quality version of this entire show?

Yep, 100% agree with your list. Bruce is god!

PETER & ERIC CARR

ACE AND Bruce hands down - the 2 BEST

Why just why ace at 2

Peter Criss without a doubt, look at how many drummers he influenced , including Eric Carr and Eric Singer

No offense but your list sucks. You changed the criteria from player to player. At first, you were going by who contributed the most, then who was the most fluid player, then the most technically proficient, then who was the best fit stylistically. Technically, Vinnie Vincent and Mark St.John would be at the top of the list. The Most fluid player could be any of the players except Ace (he's always been sloppy-ish). Best fit stylistically, would be Ace then Tommy Thayer. Over all, I would pick Ace. Without him, there would be no Kiss as we know it today.

Thanks for posting this. I remember asking you to make this video.

She plays the guitar, harmonica, piano, drums

My favourites are the debut hotter than hell destroyer creatures of the night and Revenge. The one I hate the most is Asylum.

This is a 100% accurate list. I was expecting 2 and 1 to be swapped.

your list would be quite different than mine, but we agree with the #1 Revenge

You might be forgetting Underwood IS a country artist and world class vocalist. kzbin.info/www/bejne/nJzWqIqAm6qdgNk - kzbin.info/www/bejne/kIiblZR-i92BfJo - kzbin.info/www/bejne/mqKWYaCHjZirmNE - kzbin.info/www/bejne/paucc3yLlNqloNU - kzbin.info/www/bejne/rGbXiKZooKyHoac - kzbin.info/www/bejne/ZmHGkKuijs-jmbM COUNTRY having fun covering rock...more importance on vocals than music but it still rocks.

Saw Zep In 73, 75, and 77. Saw the Page plant tour. Saw the Page Outrider tour. Page is a better gutarist of course. But to pick on the 4 guitarrists playing is nuts. They dont crowd each other with a rhythm and two distinct leads. The 4th slide guy barely plays unless it calls for it. There are better cuts of all three of these songs too.

I have listened to the first album's Ace played guitar on to 1979 dynasty album! I love the original Ace Frehley's guitar sound the best!!! 1 . Ace Frehley 2. Bruce kulick 3. Tommy Thayer 4. Vinnie Vincent 5. Mark St. John

What about Bob Kulick ?

Nice video. I saw Peter once and Singer twice and I thought Eric stole the show both times. Eric Carr was a thunderous drummer and was a beast on the Unmasked tour if you care to look at the concert Sydney 1980. Us Australians consider him to be the true Kiss drummer.

Great video Any hope lf you posting a ranking of all the Kiss line ups. Greetings from Melbourne.Australia.

I agree 100%!!! Bruce is so underrated, and I think he is amazing. Great video my friend!!!

Another excellent song ... Hope to say the same about the record ... 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷

Tommy is unoriginal as hell. Should’ve got Bruce back.

Bruce and Carr was the peak of kiss. They are great.

Eric was the best drummer for kiss. My fav era.

Ace may not be the most technically talented guitarist but he was the best KISS have had no doubt. His work on those early albums is phenomenal.

Total douche that will never be in Mangini's league as a player or a person.

I love this som

1st kiss concert, rossevelt stadium nj 1976. last show , everett wa 2011. There were alot of in betweens. Kiss at their best is a live act. All the shows with Ace are better than non-Ace shows. So my choice is Ace. Drunk or noyt Ace represents the true Kiss spirit better than anyone. Let face it, no one goes to see Kiss for virtuoso instrimentation. Its the raw energy and specticle. Ace rules1

Love Love love love it … your perspective and commentary is equally refreshing and yes. pls do more Carrie reaction videos …. 🔥🔥🔥

Experience!

ACE all the way

Something I just thought of. If Dream Theater actually did go on extended hiatus when Portnoy wanted, would Labries live vocals be in a different place right now? Good video personally I love that Portnoy is back. I saw them twice with Portnoy and will happily see them a third time.

Ace IS the King of Kiss..........Bruce Is great, But Not the one that grabbed the imagination of millions of teen boys to pick up the guitar.............Vinny the wiz Vincent just ok and Mark wasn't around long enough to even care

Ace is criminally overrated ! Meathead player ! Kulick & St John are tops her , not even debatable ! VV is great if u suffer from ADHD ! Thayer is a fine player , how hard can playing Aces parts actually be ?

Portnoy is such a vital cog in the DT machine - he was and is the soul of the band, so it was never just a case of changing drummers - the Mangini albums are fine, but there's just something missing from the process. And I still think they should have taken on board what Portnoy said before leaving, as I think they were creatively burnt out, even if they didn't realise it at the time. Whilst I enjoy parts of the Mangini era, it just felt less special and more DT-by-numbers at times. I hope this reunion helps to recharge the batteries of the band for the latter stage of their career.

1. Ace - Great all around!! 2. Peter - Love his voice and sound of the drums 3. Gene/Paul Both have good and ridiculous sounding songs. But I still havent been able to get through Paul's whole album lol!🤷‍♂️

Kiss wouldn’t have been with out ace but Bruce is by far the best guitarist. He can do it all but knew when and how to do it for the songs. I guess he was a better musician than the others. As a teen I hated him because he wasn’t ace or Vinny but with age I see his genius

ACE

I have to say that your post has been one of the better ones on this subject. I will say from the start, I'm disappointed in this decision. Now, if Mangini comes out and says down the road that this was his decision, then I'm good. But, I have the feeling that's not what happened. I think he was straight up fired to bring the buddy back. That's some bad shit. I haven't ever bought or listened to a Portnoy-era recording and thought wow, this is some excellent songwriting. That's a lame point. I like what you said. Portnoy can not, or should never, reproduce Mangini' s compositions. I have no desire to hear Portnoy try to do that. Hopefully, you're correct in that they should put those tracks to rest. Let Mangini's work stand as they are and be done. I think they took a major step backwards and here we go, again. Portnoy left. Why bring him back. I have to think that Manginis years will not be easily forgotten and they will be missed. Just on a last note: the Grammy years are all during the Mangini years. Not just the win but the other nominations, as well. He made these guys better. That was their best lineup. That's a fact. Excellent video but we can agree to disagree. Hope your channel is successful. Have a good holiday season.

great chorus, catchy as hell, super guitar work and nice melody. Fresh air from Mick.

I agree! The guitar solo needed to be longer and more involved. Slide guitar is missing on this New Mick Mars song in my opinión. Im sure the previous music he was working on for this album that got erased was mind blowing Bad Boy Boggie Hard Rock n roll!! Iprefer that raw classic Mick Mars sound !!

What about Bob Kulick

The realese date is Feb 23. You can order the vinyl now. This song kicks ass on a good system.

What happened to your Kiss Alive -The Movie video??!!

All three were very good and each suited to the time in which they played. The first to do it always deserves credit for inventing things the others built on. Peter will always be Kiss' drummer to me and the other two are very capable replacements. Eric Singer has the best voice, but I'd rather hear Peter do Beth. All three did a good job on Black Diamond.

Ace, Gene, Paul, Peter but they were all pretty bad. They should have taken the best of each and made one decent Kiss album that would have cost us a quarter as much to buy.