The Ottawa Treaty Today: A Discussion
1:09:35
Пікірлер
@markperry4165
@markperry4165 25 күн бұрын
Where on earth did you get those photos?
@farabiahmed165
@farabiahmed165 Ай бұрын
Hello Brother I am contacting you because I am following your KZbin channel and I am fascinated by your content. Your video quality is very good and you are struggling a lot but not getting good results. I found some problems in your channel, your channel videos are not related to SEO. That's why the videos are not getting more views and subscribers. If you SEO your videos, your videos will rank on KZbin. You will get good results from KZbin. If you want, I can help you get video views and subscribers .Let's collaborate on implementing these tactics to grow your channel organically.
@johndonaldredmond3990
@johndonaldredmond3990 Ай бұрын
This was a very interesting lecture. Thank you. I look forward to more in the future. The modern CAF still has lessons to learn from research and experimentation done at Fort Churchill.
@lequelle2580
@lequelle2580 Ай бұрын
Thank you. Another great talk that shines a light on the hard work invested into the knowledge base during this period.
@HonestlyYours516
@HonestlyYours516 Ай бұрын
This video would be a lot better if they took out the background music.
@DavidKyne-r6j
@DavidKyne-r6j 2 ай бұрын
You and your pro - "kanadian" fucking propaganda can fuck off.
@johnthekeane
@johnthekeane 3 ай бұрын
I hope the book is better than the lecture.
@howardjolley2215
@howardjolley2215 4 ай бұрын
For a country of with a relatively small population, Canada fought above it's weight in all areas of the war. The RCAF provided a large number of fighter pilots and had the 6th Bomber Group. The Canadian Army ( 1st Canadian Army divided into the 1st and 2nd Corps) fought hard and long in Italy, at Juno Beach in Normandy and the hard fighting in Northwest Europe. The RCN became the 3rd largest navy in the war. Many Canadians served with great distinction and Canadians earned many medals including 16 Victoria Crosses.
@michaelbossenberry
@michaelbossenberry 4 ай бұрын
My granfather is alvin bossenberry he was squadron leader of the 408 goose squadron if anyone can send me any info to learn more please do
@bobsakamanos4469
@bobsakamanos4469 5 ай бұрын
Waterloo Lutheran Univ? There were more Canadians in RAF units than in RCAF Units unfortunately. However, many rose to leadership roles for expanding the RCAF. Stocky Edwards for example was one of the best.
@chrisevans7020
@chrisevans7020 6 ай бұрын
Terry Copp, in one of his hallmarks, tackles a complex subject and relates it in a clear and thoughtful manner. Perhaps most salient of all is his reference to Collingwood near the end that it is the historian’s (and I would say also the general reader of military history) to “think the thoughts of past actions” and not superimpose our later understanding of events. The role of air power in the Normandy campaign deserves nothing less.
@stephenm.fochuk7795
@stephenm.fochuk7795 6 ай бұрын
Well, hello there, Chris. It has been a while...a long time. How are things?
@chrisevans7020
@chrisevans7020 6 ай бұрын
@@stephenm.fochuk7795 Hey! Things are well. I’m still in NYC working in publishing and writing my next novel and my next history book. How about you?
@ilostmypickle
@ilostmypickle 6 ай бұрын
I've been studying this era for my own personal curiosity and know quite a lot thanks to the internment legacy fund - they have all the internment camps and each has archived news clippings from the papers of that time. When you mentioned that 106 internees were placed into institutions afterward, my heart broke. It was an aspect of the war that I had nelected to consider. Thank you for bring that sensitive topic into your documentary. It's important.
@fromthehorsesmouth3790
@fromthehorsesmouth3790 8 ай бұрын
Why is your book $182?
@cotepierre68
@cotepierre68 9 ай бұрын
Excellent présentation. Merci Caroline! Nunquam Retrorsum
@peteranthony51
@peteranthony51 9 ай бұрын
Sounds like a grade 5 schoolgirl's social justice critique of the RCAF...pretty lame...I love the RCAF and the role it has played....my dad flew Spits during the war...this subject deserves a much more professional effort.
@bobsakamanos4469
@bobsakamanos4469 5 ай бұрын
That's the agenda of the education system today.
@Vikingocazar
@Vikingocazar 10 ай бұрын
Only a Canadian educational institution could take an insanely awesome subject and make it fucking boring. Bye.
@wendigo63music55
@wendigo63music55 5 ай бұрын
Spectacle is in the eye of the beholder.
@trevorfuller1078
@trevorfuller1078 10 ай бұрын
Leo Major (Regimente de La Chaudiere) was nominated by his CO for the Victoria Cross (VC) after his single-handed exploits in capturing/liberating the Dutch town of Zwolle, which was subsequently turned down by other senior officers (Not including FM Montgomery) & subsequently recommended the DCM (Distinguished Conduct Medal) instead, that is one tier lower than either the Victoria or George Crosses that have equal topmost standing in order of rank of British & Commonwealth medals & insignias for supreme valour or supreme meritorious service. No official reasons were ever forthcoming for denying Major the VC or downgrading his medal application to the DCM, which is still the second highest award for extreme valour available to all all ranks in the British & Commonwealth Armed Forces then! It was well known that Major regarded Montgomery & his senior commanders with almost contempt, branding Montgomery as an incompetent amongst other detracting things! Equally, it was also known that the Field Marshal would brook no dissent or opposition towards any of his well formulated plans or deeply held views on anything & he was also known for being able to harbour grudges & being vindictive at times in such situations, hence you could quite easily see that someone wanted to avoid a confrontation or clash of personalities or opinions or both! Incidentally, nearly a decade later when Major reenlisted into the Canadian Army to fight in the Korean War - 1950-53, he was awarded another DCM (DCM & Bar) for similar courageous acts there then too!! He subsequently also earned the reputation & the sobriquet amongst his legion of admirers as, “Le Rambo Quebecois! - the Quebec Rambo” For his legendary valorous deeds throughout his military career!
@dpullen17
@dpullen17 11 ай бұрын
In the question and answer section, there is a question if spiritualism is a rejection of technology. A number of books including discussions with HG Wells and others viewed spiritualism and the spirit world as possible as the atom, or electons. New sciences were being developed and expanded constantly so as we could suddenly prove how light waves worked, could we not also prove that spirits actually existed. So I've viewed the burst of belief in spiritualism in the late 1800s and into the war years as not a rejection of technology but looked at as a possible technology that could be properly evaluated and tested.
@LeftCoastStephen
@LeftCoastStephen 11 ай бұрын
1:22:00 Perfectly said. As bad as the Allied armies were, we won, and many times critical events were led by Canadians.
@Splodge542
@Splodge542 Жыл бұрын
We have certainly not forgotten the Canadians. Nor have we forgotten my grandfather's regiment The Royal Ulster Rifles. We just love you guys as we love our own.
@raze5346
@raze5346 Жыл бұрын
UBI will fix nothing
@fredsaenger6476
@fredsaenger6476 Жыл бұрын
Fuck that , I already pay for too many losers!
@NOTBOBROBERTS
@NOTBOBROBERTS Жыл бұрын
Most of the Canadian History, and in particular our military history, I have learned since graduating from University in 1990.
@MBrunet796
@MBrunet796 Жыл бұрын
UBI is a good idea but we also have to deal with the Mental Health issues that propagate through poverty. We have to address the $B in cuts that have taken place over the last 15 years. It was a time that saw the release of unprepared institutionalized patients. Healing from poverty should encompass the whole of the person.
@clarkbowler157
@clarkbowler157 11 ай бұрын
Don't you think that eliminating poverty would contribute to solving mental issues associated with poverty?
@MBrunet796
@MBrunet796 11 ай бұрын
I am not sure what you mean by solving them. Mental Health issues are not solved they are treated in such a way that it allows an individual to better deal with the problems and bring some healing. Also a quick note that not everyone seeks treatment, you can't force someone to get help. UBI is a major attempt to address challenges brought on by homelessness and poverty. The cuts I was talking about saw the release of mental health patients that were not ready for society. Through those years society has felt the shift to a population that saw depression and anxiety of various forms take a front seat of most of our lives. It has become a learned behavior in response to dealing with people who have an illness of this sort. I have personally travelled from one end of this country to the other several times examining the level of poverty and the one city that stood out was Vancouver; in which a transient arriving in Vancouver was automatically given a cheque hours after arriving which made sure he or she was off the street. This in itself is a prime example of the benefits of UBI.@@clarkbowler157
@tomgreen8628
@tomgreen8628 Жыл бұрын
It's only useful to control the citizens. If you can't support yourself in this country, you need welfare. The majority of people are very capable of thriving
@dm95422
@dm95422 Жыл бұрын
The reason UBI will NEVER happen in Canada is that it takes away the ability of politicians to pander to groups. Politicians HATE universality because it eliminates their ability to indulge their favourite group of the day. And no one loves pandering more than the selfie-obsessed empty suit that currently holds the top post.
@MBrunet796
@MBrunet796 11 ай бұрын
Lets try to focus on the issue.
@tompogson9755
@tompogson9755 Жыл бұрын
Spoiler alert, it does. kzbin.info/aero/PL79EeOg8kw88SOdLseAX0CMNxKI9Ng8WO
@JD-ir8cb
@JD-ir8cb Жыл бұрын
spoiler... it doesnt
@normagraham149
@normagraham149 Жыл бұрын
Cannot wait for this website to become available. 😊
@dermotrooney9584
@dermotrooney9584 Жыл бұрын
Just worked out I've more books by Terry than any other historian - and I'm not even Canadian! 🇨🇦
@dermotrooney9584
@dermotrooney9584 Жыл бұрын
Go Terry!
@f8bethere
@f8bethere Жыл бұрын
Is there a data base of these prisoners, in particular the Ukrainians sent to northern Ontario, more specifically Chapleau?
@tophat2115
@tophat2115 Жыл бұрын
Presentation begins at 12:12
@MEYanZav
@MEYanZav Жыл бұрын
Thank you. Holy shit that intro was long
@christianmorin1437
@christianmorin1437 Жыл бұрын
bon coeur bon bras regiment de maisonneuve forever
@dermotanthonydavidkyne1019
@dermotanthonydavidkyne1019 Жыл бұрын
I do not believe that the "people" who are leaving comments sub this video really exist. Or, if they are "real," they have been recruited to leave this effusive and contrived commentary These videos are nothing more than Masonic/zionist propaganda. The degree of "historical" "accuracy" expressed within the context of these videos is exceedingly biased. One may as well watch reruns of the "Hogan's Heroes" television program that aired in the 1960's ad 1970's. The statements uttered by this moron are false, fraudulent and utterly without foundation.
@dianneblondepinkerton9140
@dianneblondepinkerton9140 Жыл бұрын
absolutely fabulous; the knowledge that Ted has & imparts so effortlessly is to be commended ; much appreciated thank you
@thomasmoore9673
@thomasmoore9673 Жыл бұрын
Wonderful presentation! I'll be passing this along to a number of Twitter friends in the RCN encouraging them to present to all personnel of the RCN. Your energy an passion for this subject comes through in spades!
@dermotanthonydavidkyne1019
@dermotanthonydavidkyne1019 Жыл бұрын
"kanada," "kanada," "kanada," "Kanada." This video is nothing more than an excuse to use and deploy the terms "kanada." and "kanadian" as often as possible. This channel is nothing more than federalist propaganda. Discuss the "brave" and "courageous" "kanadian" "soldiers" who raped and murdered the wives and daughters of the Boer bush rangers. Who fought the English take over of the Cape Colony between 1899 - 1902. The wives and children of the Boer Freedom Fighters met the "brave" and "courageous" "kanadian" soldiers" with tea and coffee. And then they were then told to leave their homestead. The buildigs were then burnt dow. The cattle were either stolen or killed. And their well was filled or dynamited. An "history" to be proud of. Particularly morons such as the pseudo "academic" pseudo "intellectual" masonic imbecile in the image supra.
@ToddSauve
@ToddSauve Жыл бұрын
Maybe someone at the Laurier Centre can explain something for me. In "Stopping the Panzers: The Untold Story of D Day" Dr. Marc Milner of the University of New Brunswick states unequivocally that General George Patton was _not_ the most feared of Allied generals by the Germans prior to D Day. Can someone square up Terry Copp's statement that Patton _was_ the most feared by the Germans with Dr. Marc Milner's statement that Patton was merely a mostly _unknown quantity_ to them, and that Patton's large reputation has been read backwards into the historical account prior to the Normandy campaign by post-WW2 American historians? 🤔🤷‍♂ Moreover, I have _never_ heard anyone other than Terry Copp state that Rommel thought the Allies would land at the Pas de Calais. Virtually every other historian has stated, in the last 25 years anyway, that Rommel thought the Allies would land in Normandy. Here I am only 20 minutes into this presentation and I am finding contradictions between Terry Copp's account of D Day and everyone else's that I know of. 🤔🤨 Alas, another seemingly unresolvable statement from Mr. Copp is that General Montgomery knew little of the plan to invade Normandy on D Day and was just a cheerleader, yet Montgomery was the general who drew up the invasion plans! This is getting to be quite unhappy and I'm only at the 34 minute mark. I am not trying to be unduly critical of Mr. Copp's account, and I am not a professional historian, but the discrepancies are really there! 🤨 I believe Mr. Copp's criticisms of Colonel Stacey and his account of the Canadian army on D Day and throughout the rest of the campaign until victory in May 1945 are quite valid. From what I understand of Colonel Stacey, he never once even set foot on mainland Europe during WW2 and relied exclusively on regimental reports and the such to fashion what he wrote of the Canadian army. This is unacceptably bad and his book should, IMHO, be withdrawn from publication and only serve as an example of how _not_ to write about this campaign.
@wtfbuddy1
@wtfbuddy1 Жыл бұрын
Very nice presentation of our RCN history, thank you for sharing. Cheers
@normagraham149
@normagraham149 Жыл бұрын
David O’Keefe is brilliant. Love this presentation.
@bubba_oats
@bubba_oats Жыл бұрын
I found my grandpas journal for WW2. He was a tail gunner in a bomber and was credited with 2 shoot downs for the battle of britain and 1 on DDAY
@cefrg
@cefrg 2 жыл бұрын
So honest, informative, and yes, illuminating. Floored by the level of understanding on all subjects mentioned.
@bongiubon
@bongiubon 2 жыл бұрын
skill issue
@fxdci
@fxdci 2 жыл бұрын
Excellent presentation! Its really good to hear from our Canadian brothers-in-arms about SWW. I don't think most Americans or possibly other Commonwealth members have any idea on the contributions of these brave men.
@regolith1350
@regolith1350 2 жыл бұрын
Talk begins at 8:19
@momc1134
@momc1134 2 жыл бұрын
Wow, I am impressed with this video. Very well done and very interesting to learn more about an event in World War 2 that people from my home town participated in. It really brought the event to life for me and deepened my appreciation for remembrance day ceremonies. It also brings to light how people who lived in the geographic area of the events still are so affected by the events of the war.
@hughbeastodonnell3733
@hughbeastodonnell3733 2 жыл бұрын
Great presentation by Terry, even if the sound cut out at times. Did the Montreal Irish join up in any great numbers for the Second World War ?
@hughbeastodonnell3733
@hughbeastodonnell3733 2 жыл бұрын
The sound sure cut on poor Terry a lot during the presentation.
@scottbelanger9571
@scottbelanger9571 2 жыл бұрын
My Uncle Russell Desjardins died at Welberg Nov 2 along with 4 of his crew in a tank across from the Eklingburg Farm, wonderful job Robert thank you for your work. Thank you to you all for this video.