Ai generated garbage.

Such good writing and insight to fill out Tolkien’s outline of history. Well done.

One very tiny tiny observation - and this is not a criticism, but a few times you've gone from first person to 'eye of God', referring to Melkor as a separate person. Very easy to do. Just thought you might want to know if you read this

Phenomenal work

That was Pretty much ( AWESOME )

Lol left-tenant not loo-tenant 😊

This is fantastic! Adds magic to my day. I can't thank you enough. Can't resist adding, it's a shame Tolkien maligns spiders so much. They do so much good and save many lives. Without them, all life on earth would cease. Ungolient in contrast is more black hole than spider. I'm glad how in the game shadow of war, they made Shelob on the side of good, giving Talion visions to help him fight against Sauron. But Tolkien's novels doesn't help their cause at all. On an entirely different note, I wonder what would've happened if Sauron gave Morgoth a ring of power? Someone elsewhere suggested that Celebrimbor was a better craftsman than Feanor because the rings were much more powerful than the simirals. One thing that you could say Sauron was though - he was loyal.

wow this is friggin awesome!

Damn this is amazing!

I poured my heart into this piece about Melkor's life, and I'm very happy how it turned out - my best work yet I think. Anyway, thanks for watching guys!

So happy I’m here first for this banger

I like to think Tolkien wrote himself into the story.

Wow fantastic video. Glad I just found your channel. Loved the video, deff checking out the others. Subbed. Keep up your quality work. It shows.

This is pretty gay

Does the Witch-king resemble the one from Mar-a-Lago?

Great job It sounds like Daniel Davis narrating he did Darth Plagues

Not sure how I feel about this story besides the great telling of it.

If it don't fit in a short, don't put it in a short.

"And Morgoth came"... I must've missed it...

It's good, too bad they can't create videos like this yet. Still some of the pictures help give an idea of Tolkens writings.

I've been trying to figure out the Witch King's name so I can use it as a game nickname because he always seemed like the most badass character to me

So many words, so little to say. AI obviously. 🙄 He was a black Numenorean, meaning that he was a descendant of those that were originally corrupted to Morgoth worship before Numenor was destroyed. They indulged in black magick, dark ritual and spell work: evil people and brought up their children the same way.

Crazy effort. Well done!

Feanor calling Fingolfin a pale imitation, oh how wrong he turned out to be.

They mention the pits carved out of the earth by Morgoth’s mace, but not the trench made in the ground by Fingolfin dragging his enormous balls into battle.

Tolkien never wrote about this = its like Disney RoP , fake

I imagine it was easy for Sauron to convince the 9 men to take the rings. I'm sure that regardless of whatever rationale and arguments he made them, the allure of the 9 rings, enhanced by the presence of the 1, would quickly win over the hearts of the Nazgul, even if they were wary at first.

Beautiful as always 🌹

Very good. Taste of more off it. Where's the rest??

The narration is drowned out by the music. We need some editing here

is this ai generated?

LOVE the video. Thank you again! Another gem. This is an observation, not a criticism: the video seems to take place after the Dead fulfilled their oath to Isildur's heir. That should've meant they were then able to rest in peace? If they've fulfilled the oath, then that's not how it's supposed to work. There's a strict code of honour at play here, as far as i know. It's up to both sides to honour their agreement. Maybe you should've set the video before Aragorn called on them to keep their promise? Also, everyone pronounces Sam Gamgee's name as Gamgee as in 'gee whiz'. But wouldn't it be Gamgee as in 'go' or 'gate'? It simply sounds more country yokel than 'Gamgee-whiz' in my opinion. It's based on the dialect of the English countryside. I have been known to be wrong

I think Tom would actually be tulkas in tolkiens mythos. A valar curious but not interfering overmuch in the third age and Nessa being Goldberry He would not be Illuvatar in the mythos as Tom has boundaries spoken of in the council of elrond

Cool vid

Love the imagery, thank you!

Yeah, I’ve been at work listening to this so when I go home, I’m going to listen to it to deal with my headset on while I’m in the dark

It is. I can’t think of any other place so macabre. Very nice. 👍. As usual, Numanorean creates a master piece. Hey everyone, tell all your friends to subscribe and for them to get their friends to do the same. This artist and master story teller puts his soul into his stories. A true purist.

I don’t think Peter Jackson did this justice.

Is the Paths of the Dead the most haunting place in Middle-Earth?

this... was absolutely captivating... felt like I was part of the story. Incredible work! Thank you so much! ❤

your videos are absolutely incredible... I feel like a child listening to a fairytale, taking in every word and every beautiful image. thank you so much and please dont stop making them ❤

Hey Numenorean, I updated all my songs to include your channel. I wish the best for you always. Be safe and keep up the incredible work!

One thing i loved about the Rings of Power is the idea of the dwarves singing to the rock to find the best place to mine. It made the dwarves part of the music of Eru Illuvitar in a most beautiful way, like the elves and their songs.

Who's the guy reading this his voice is so beautiful and incredible and why is there no one commented on it yet what is going on out there?? Does anyone know this guy's voice

Hmm interesting...written by AI supposedly?

Tom Bombadil is my favourite person in Tolkien. So wise and important to all who met him, who knew him

Couldn't get through it, lose the background music, it just doesn't fit I'm afraid

Gotta be the dumbest title ever in lotr channels. Any information you have about this fictional character is coming from a story that's already been told. So how the fuck are you providing an "untold story".

The Souls of The Damned.

Got to ask, what do you mean by 'period' in the title? Shouldn't it be 'full stop'? Tolkien was a British, not a US writer, i thought