CRNAs are unnecessary , unless theyre organising stuff and helping a doctor like a nurse in Cardiology or Pediatrics usually does . Anaesthesiologist should stand up against this wannabe MD nurses .
@rozithplaysАй бұрын
CRNAs do make really good money. However, when she breaks it down CRNAs and anesthesiologists have almost the same length of training. It seems that the 2 to 3 years of experience for ICU RNs comes in before schooling, unlike doing the residency after Medical school, but you add up the 4 years of BSN then the 3 years of field then 3 years of CRNA school.
@AndrewGuyton-fq1jeАй бұрын
How and where does one work during school?
@chrisking6695Ай бұрын
CRNA was invented so hospitals don't have to pay 800k salaries lol
@drew54948Ай бұрын
I’m hoping to match into anesthesia next year … wondering what the most important things are to look for in a program
@passion55542 ай бұрын
Hi Doc. Respectfully, if you are going to include the undergraduate studies of becoming an anesthesiologist. It would be appropriate to include the 4 years required for a Bachelor's of Nursing Science undergraduate degree for CRNAs. If anesthesiologist have 4 yrs undergrad + 4 yrs med school + 4 years anesthesiology residency +/- 1 yr fellowship = 12-13 years of training then a CRNA would be 4 yrs undergrad + 2/3 yrs of ICU experience + 3 yr Doctorate level CRNA degree = 9-10 years of training. I respect the anesthesiologist I work with but we should be transparent and non-biased when educating the public about education levels and not down play the education background of your colleagues. :)
@k.51522 ай бұрын
oh and it's ridiculous that insurance companies have slowly introduced "patient responsibility" and now even if you have insurance you're still paying for like half the visit
@k.51522 ай бұрын
i read that article too and i also thought it was a little weird. I don't think it's very productive to point fingers at doctors with big salaries when we've all agreed the whole system is broken. And the high salaries are not really bringing in new doctors because they have seen what they have to go through to get anything close to that and it's not worth it a lot of the time, especially for general medicine and fields that don't really reach these specialist salaries. and the job looks rough on top of everything else, it would probably be less stressful to be a deep sea welder and nobody goes after them for their salaries.
@MegaBev2 ай бұрын
Hi, I’ve been looking into AA. Is there anyway I can shadow you for 8 hours?
@sinuzb31152 ай бұрын
Best doctors on an airplane are chiropractors… then heating pads be coming in clutch
@beastmodebane59092 ай бұрын
In addition to Anesthesiologists ( hopefully I'll match in 2026- your channel was a HUGE inspiration for me wanting anesthesia) I would say EM
@AmandaSXiMD2 ай бұрын
Thanks for watching!!! Hope you’ll participate in my summer Virtual Preop Call program in 2025 to prepare for rotations and the application cycle.
@beastmodebane59092 ай бұрын
@ I would LOVE too!! Where can I find more information?
@heitosj2 ай бұрын
Really appreciate this video!! Will most certainly help me this season!
@AmandaSXiMD2 ай бұрын
Glad it was helpful! Good luck this season!!
@adegbolaoluwawamiri30272 ай бұрын
Doc, I get your argument, but from an RN point of view that have seen both CRNAs and Anaesthesiologist in the OR, in all honesty, they do exactly the same thing in clinical practice. I think that is why most hospitals are leaning towards the ACT model now, Now, knowledge base is different but in the clinical setting, there is no difference. As much as this may be an uncomfortable truth, it doesn't change the fact that this is what hospitals are beginning to see. I will personally encourage anyone going to med school to choose another specialty. The job outlook for CRNAs in future seems to be better. I doubt if this will be same for anaesthesiologists. My honest thought.
@MDForTheCulture3 ай бұрын
Maybe I shouldn't choose anesthesia as a specialty 😂
@AmandaSXiMD2 ай бұрын
😂 Gotta know what you're getting into! I'm 5 years out from residency and am not planning on leaving the practice of anesthesia so that's a pretty good sign.
@MDForTheCulture2 ай бұрын
@AmandaSXiMD wow five years, i think I've been watching your channel for about four years now.
@AmandaSXiMD2 ай бұрын
Thanks for being such a loyal and committed subscriber! Feel free to reach out with questions!
@seabee30973 ай бұрын
I loved this rant! Its 2024 and I think the pandemic years will become scrutinized much more as time goes on. You handled the topic perfectly for all the ages past present and future. Well done. I clicked on the video because I wanted to hear directly from you about the types of procedures you participated in that were related to COVID. If I could watch a video from 1347 of a doctor describing their experience in the operating room(or on the streets lets face it) with bubonic plague I would definitely be watching every grisly detail.
@iCanonKiD3 ай бұрын
Thank you for this video! Would you choose anesthesia again if were back in medical school? Or, is there another specialty more fitting in your eyes? I'm struggling to decide between a surgical specialty and anesthesia.
@AmandaSXiMD3 ай бұрын
Thanks for watching and commenting! I definitely would choose anesthesia again [thanks for another idea for a quick video in the future]. For most surgical specialties, I think that it'll be really important for you to ask yourself whether you could see yourself doing any other specialty because surgical fields are grueling in a different way from all other specialties. You have to really identify as a surgeon to get through the training and the challenges beyond training. But if that's what you love, then that's that. Good luck!
@SofiaCaeiro933 ай бұрын
Don't know if yours viewers would know this, but In Europe each Anesthesiologist is assigned to just 1 room, but there's also anesthesia nurses, which prepare the patient, assist with the drug preparion and administration, and 1intern/resident in teaching Hospitals. The nurses cannot work be responsible for an operating room and although they asssist the anethesiologist they can't administer drugs or change ventilation parameters of their own volition. They cant also perform any invasive procedures like regional anesthesia, intubation arterial lines etc. These are reserved to the physian only.
@نورالامة10003 ай бұрын
Well that sucks as studies shows that midlevels are indeed able to administer anesthesia safely
@AmandaSXiMD3 ай бұрын
This is a really helpful perspective for me [and my viewers!]. I'm always curious how anesthesia is practiced in other countries.
@marinal27053 ай бұрын
Love how comprehensive this is! Kind of surreal-I found your channel 3 years ago when I was just applying to med school, thinking about anesthesia CCM and now this time next year hopefully I'll be in the process of interviewing for anesthesia. Thanks for everything, Dr. Xi!
@AmandaSXiMD3 ай бұрын
Thank you for watching and following along! Let me know if more questions come up as you prepare your application - the specialty has gotten so much more competitive these last few years so it's important to have a strong application and strategy for when you apply. Also I hope you'll be able to join my summer "Virtual Preop Program" calls next summer! Good luck!
@marinal27053 ай бұрын
@@AmandaSXiMD Will definitely tune in on that next summer! Would love to know your advice on anesthesia program signaling
@AmandaSXiMD2 ай бұрын
I go into detail on signaling and everything related to the application process in my blog entry here: blog.amandaxi.com/2024/09/16/advice-for-applying-to-anesthesiology-for-match-2025/
@yunzhu48153 ай бұрын
my friend moved out from Standford system 3 years ago just because the intense situiation back then. 150K cut down on her income but her mental health has been much better and she actually can have time at least one day fully being around her little kids! you guys are amazing
@AmandaSXiMD3 ай бұрын
Thanks for watching and commenting! Each system certainly has it's pros/cons and depending on staffing, can really have a real impact on job satisfaction and burnout. I'm glad your friend found a practice with a better fit -- you only have one life and I think it's so important to prioritize the things that matter (i.e., life outside of the hospital!).
@drew549483 ай бұрын
The pager was a paid actor 😂
@AmandaSXiMD3 ай бұрын
Haha true story. 😂
@rtzy46363 ай бұрын
After completing medical school, what specific training or residency programs should I pursue to become an anesthesiologist? Are there any subspecialties or additional certifications within anesthesiology that are beneficial to consider?
@AmandaSXiMD3 ай бұрын
Thanks for watching and commenting! In order to practice anesthesiology in the U.S., you must complete a residency in anesthesiology. The type of program is dependent on what your career goals are. There are tons of subspecialties in anesthesia - I practice critical care (that's a subspecialty), but there's also cardiac, pediatric, acute/chronic pain, obstetrics, and even palliative care. Certifications aren't as important in the training process but may become more important during practice.
@minamelka8603 ай бұрын
.can you please go over again with ...your "strength vs weakness" ???
@AmandaSXiMD3 ай бұрын
I'm sorry, I'm not sure I understand your question? You should certainly be prepared for a question where you can articulate the strengths and weaknesses that you'll be bringing to the program!
@minamelka8603 ай бұрын
we really appreciate for your sharing....great tips...
@AmandaSXiMD3 ай бұрын
Thanks for watching and commenting!
@SamplesDan3 ай бұрын
Love the honesty here. Could you make a video of what supervising CRNA’s looks like? What are things that you are needed for vs they can do themselves?
@AmandaSXiMD3 ай бұрын
Great idea! I added it to my list of KZbin video ideas to cover!
@thritysomethinghuman3 ай бұрын
I did feel my interviews were informal, and as an IMG who really hopes she matches this cycle, i do not have many questions for the program, as i am willing to accept mostly anything haha thank you for sharing your thoughts!! <3
@AmandaSXiMD3 ай бұрын
While your overall objective is to match into whatever program you can, from the program's side, we gauge someone's interest/seriousness of ranking our program highly by questions that get asked. That's why it's so important to find something to ask about! Good luck to you this cycle!
@DishantRakholia3 ай бұрын
Hi Amanda This is an extremely helpful video. Are you available for any mock interviews? As getting a feedback from someone experienced like you will make a lot of difference.
@AmandaSXiMD3 ай бұрын
Hi there! I'm sorry I'm not available for mock interviews this season. Maybe in the future my schedule or goals will allow me to offer this service. Just remember that all feedback can be useful and most individuals have gone through some sort of interview process so they can help coach you! Good luck this cycle!
@sfdeer52193 ай бұрын
This is really helpful! Ty!
@AmandaSXiMD3 ай бұрын
Thanks for watching and good luck this season!
@jakepaucarpura82983 ай бұрын
I’m currently stuck between MD vs PA school. I have wanted to be a doctor since I started high school and lost the vision for it during COVID. I finally realized I want to continue in the medical field but feel like I’m too old to go for Med school. I am currently 22 years old. I just keep getting told that Med school is going to be horrible and that I won’t like it. Idk what to choose at this point. I don’t want to regret not going to Med school if I do choose the PA route. Any advice ? I honestly just want to talk to someone who is experienced in the fields.
@AmandaSXiMD3 ай бұрын
Hi there! You're definitely not too old for medical school - the average age of matriculation is 24! If you're really committed to medical school then don't let others dissuade you; you just have to really love it to get through the training. A number of individuals I know went the PA/AA (anesthesia assist) route because of personal or financial reasons, but then went back to medical school - so that's an option, but it's a longer road. I will say that my colleagues that had PA/AA experience prior to medical school come with a really different perspective that adds a lot of value to our team! Good luck!
@ChillTry263 ай бұрын
Not to sound harsh or anything….but, I whole heartedly agree with all your points. Having experienced both sides of giving and receiving feedback, it’s often hard to grasp the full context, especially when it’s written. Also, sorry for the intense opener lol Great video!
@SludgeMan903 ай бұрын
Hi Amanda. I am about to graduate and I am struggling with what path to go on form here as a result of suffering with a lot of chronic health issues. Do you think anesthesia is a more overwhelming and physically demanding residency as compared to other residencies ? I do enjoy the physiology quite a lot and I like the OR, but perhaps it is not a great fit if you tend to get off days when your function can be somewhat reduced.
@AmandaSXiMD3 ай бұрын
Hi there! I think that all residencies can be overwhelming in ways. The hours are almost always longer than when you're an attending. You're also facing a lot of new scenarios and medical conditions and social challenges while navigating your role as a resident. I think that the upfront transition into anesthesia is very jarring since we are not taught what anesthesiologists have to learn in medical school so there is a lot of muscle memory and immediate triaging that is cognitively taxing. I'd also say that there are also a lot of subspecialty rotations in anesthesia that may require more cognitive load or physical movement [e.g. big bleeding cases like traumas, liver transplants, big open aortic cases, cardiac cases, etc]. In most medical residencies, it is not procedural heavy so while rounds often require long periods of time standing, you're not moving patients, pushing beds, twisting yourself into weird positions to get extra access or to do an intubation in a suboptimal condition. I'd say that having "off" days in anesthesia is tough because your patients are counting on you to be "on" as much as you can. This may mean calling out sick more often to ensure patient safety if your illness prevents you from thinking clearly, acting quickly on your feet, etc. I hope this helps! Amanda
@mytube7853 ай бұрын
Not knowing exactly where is matched is just nuts 😂😂. Is it the decision from the Dean’s Office or from NRMP? Why do they want to do that?
@AmandaSXiMD3 ай бұрын
Great question! Prior to having the Match, medical students would have to interview at places then decide on offers (you have to sign a binding contract or you lose your offer!) before they even know if they were going to get an interview at another place which may have been a better fit. It wasn't fair to all the candidates to be able to find programs that are a good fit for them so the match was put into place. The Match algorithm actually favors the student's list, so while it's stressful to go through the process, I'm glad students have an opportunity to learn about programs and prioritize places that would work best for them!
@mytube7853 ай бұрын
@@AmandaSXiMD When does the applicant sign the contract? Is it when the applicant’s final ROL is submitted?
@AmandaSXiMD3 ай бұрын
Applicants attest to an agreement when they enter the NRMP; after the match, the student then signs a contract with the residency program.
@mytube7853 ай бұрын
@@AmandaSXiMD thanks. From NRMP site: Applicants must sign the NRMP "Match Participation Agreement" (contract) during the Match registration process when they register for the residency match; essentially, you sign it electronically as part of the initial registration steps to participate in the match. This contract is binding with NRMP. Then after match or onboarding, the applicant signs a contract with the program.
@MalikaU-d3y4 ай бұрын
Thank you ❤❤❤
@jonathanchukwuemeka99964 ай бұрын
If you were to advise people going into your specialty, what advice would you give?
@AmandaSXiMD4 ай бұрын
What a great question! Depends on the stage that you’re at but let me think about it 🤔 thanks for inspiration for a future video!
@traceh234 ай бұрын
Good to see you posting content again. Keep up the good work!
@БогданБережной-ж2н4 ай бұрын
Good luck from Ukraine!
@dominickeck80164 ай бұрын
So happy to see you posted!
@solosforthesavior5 ай бұрын
Another study with me would be pretty cool
@stephenduff68775 ай бұрын
Critical care is already such a broad field. Do you think you're spreading yourself thin trying to do two specialties. I work in a country with general ICUs so perhaps less relevant to you
@AmandaSXiMD3 ай бұрын
Great question! In many countries, anesthesia and critical care are actually a single residency - the U.S. is a bit different in that regard. Since a lot of the concepts we learn in anesthesia are applicable to critical care and vice versa, I'd actually say that I think that doing both makes me better in the OR and in the ICU.
@stephenduff68775 ай бұрын
Nice video. I work in Ireland and relate to many of your points. I would add that patients and their families often expect perfection and dont understand the risks so that perfection pressure is a major negative vs critiical care, wards. We have porters who help with the heavy lifting. Worth considering for your hospital.
@AmandaSXiMD3 ай бұрын
Wow that would be incredible to have more help dedicated to patient transport to keep both staff and patients safe! I think it's generally challenging in the U.S. to be adequately staffed since there are so many financial pressures and challenges hospital systems are facing.
@stephenduff68775 ай бұрын
Great video. I think the difficulty is integrating this into a family routine. How would you manage an early start with a partner who is up later? What time do you go to bed? How do you still have a social life with such early mornings
@AmandaSXiMD3 ай бұрын
Thanks for watching! My former partner had to be at work later so we did opt for a bigger place to live in so that I could get ready and not disturb him as much. He used to work extra shifts and come back later than my bedtime so he'd end up getting ready for bed when I was already sleep. I usually try to go to bed around 8-9p [actually physically be in bed!] in order to make this routine sustainable. If I know that I want to go to an event later that evening, then I'll plan to "sleep in" a bit and skip a workout or getting other tasks done.
@stephenduff68773 ай бұрын
@@AmandaSXiMD thanks for the reply!
@kylecole25045 ай бұрын
Do critical care anesthesiologists work in cardiac ICUs? Thank you!
@AmandaSXiMD5 ай бұрын
Yes! Typically in a cardiac surgery (e.g. after open heart surgery, mechanical support devices, etc) based ICU rather than a cardiology-based ICU (e.g. heart attacks, support before cardiac surgery, arrhythmias).
@NewNurseGuidebook6 ай бұрын
Thank you for the great content Dr. Amanda!
@M-ih3ly6 ай бұрын
Thank you
@gustavorodriguez39537 ай бұрын
MS-2 here. What made you choose anesthesiology residency over internal medicine residency when it comes to the critical care route? Awesome videos!
@AmandaSXiMD7 ай бұрын
Thanks for watching!! This is such a good question - I think it’s so important when you shadow and go into rotations asking yourself if you see yourself doing what the attendings in that specialty are doing. I personally did not enjoy the clinic setting so internal medicine + pulmonology/critical care would have been a challenging training process for me. I’m more interested in the hospital setting rather than outpatient- I feel more at home in the hospital. So ask yourself which settings you’d like to practice in!
@AlanZablocki7 ай бұрын
The care-team model, especially if it is 4:1, is a self inflicted wound by anesthesiologists, for economic gain. I have been in a practice like that ( I left ), in which the anesthesiologists never did their own cases & were relegated to signing the chart. They, largely, were worthless and added no value most of the time. They functioned, not as a physician, but a PA- the CRNA became the go-to person. In addition, billing in a 4:1 model is often fraudulent, as it is impossible in a busy practice to meet all 7 requirements for billing under medical direction. In a different practice that had both anesthesiologists & CRNAs in equal numbers, I did all the cardiac, thoracic & vascular cases myself. My time was much better spent doing that rather than going from room to room watching a CRNA insert an LMA & sign the chart!
@AmandaSXiMD7 ай бұрын
If I cannot do a vascular case solo at my institution then I would take myself out of clinical anesthesia practice. This is the standard I set for myself.
@doctorposting7 ай бұрын
Could you do an updated vid for 2025? If anything has changed?
@AmandaSXiMD7 ай бұрын
Planning on a new video soon! Most of the information on this blog entry are applicable to Match 2025: blog.amandaxi.com/2023/07/31/advice-for-applying-to-anesthesiology-for-match-2024-and-beyond/
@Hadrian_S8 ай бұрын
I like to view it as a military structure. Physicians will be the generals. Newer docs will be Brigadier generals and they gain stars with experience. CRNAs are the Lieutenant Colonels and Colonels. AAs will be the Captains and Majors. Nurses and RTs are 2nd and 1st Lieutenants. CNAs are the Corporals and Sargeant’s. EVS, Linen, Dietary are the Privates. We all need each other and while some jobs require less training than others, the hospital would fall apart without each and every employee.
@Kay_20168 ай бұрын
Thanks for the video. I'm a respiratory therapist intern this video was helpful. What type of physians usually are in the team in the same time? My team usually have 4 physians and one consultant. But I don't really know their specialities yet as I have just started my intrrn year
@truesharma448 ай бұрын
i like the video would you say theres high financial potential in critical care anesthesiology
@rodneyh19479 ай бұрын
A lot of MDs becoming youtubers nowadays, it is a trend. They all complaining about the same things you complaining about. The burnout is due to greed. Same with nurses, the hospitals intentionally understaff so they can make more money. Doctors are just high paid slaves.