From my perspective there is no competition. Monta is not a true gmt, is overpriced when you can get e.g. a CW Sealander or Traska or Henry Archer or slew of other quality true GMT’s for roughly half of the price by other micro brands, and while the Rolex is no doubt top quality and gorgeous, it is dollars spent largely on brand name and flash rather than substance. The BB 58 GMT is in my view near perfect, the anti-magnetism is a benefit, and the other subjective categories are not particularly relevant (I challenge you to find a single person who has gone diving close to 300m while actually wearing a Monta). I personally wouldn’t ever feel comfortable wearing the Rolex because I just don’t want to convey that kind of ostentatiousness, whereas enthusiasts will immediately know the Tudor whispers superb quality and value. Subjectively, I like the gilt and retro style, but I don’t think that can be rated. So while I appreciate the perspective this seems a bit like self-convincing, and with my biases I’d arrive at a completely different outcome.

Tissot watch bracelets r like rolls Royce. Best watch braclet I've had❤

It still selling on Flipkart if anyone interested..

Bagaimana mungkin anda mengatakan bahwa mengoperasikan crown nya sulit..?. Anda tidak bisa menilai tujuan penempatan posisi crown di angka 4, menurut saya itu adalah kelebihannya sehingga crown tidak mengenai kulit apabila telapak tangan ditekuk keatas, dan anda mengatakan sulit mengoperasikan crownnya yang menurut saya amat mudah sekali. Saat ini koleksi tsuyosa saya adalah hijau, merah, orange dan hitam. Next project saya kedepan adalah memiliki tsuyosa warna putih, tiffany dan kuning.. semoga bisa segera terealisasi.. Salam dari West Sumatera Indonesia.

Terrible experience in the los angeles boutique. Terrible service, rude, failed on commitments. A disgrace to business ethic. I will never wear a FPJ . Diagusting brand .

Does it price up after buying ?

Great comparison!

i could smell this video

Not too many so called enthusiasts seem to be interested in the history of GMT watches. Anyone complaining about too much gilt, BB58 GMT is basically the GMT-Master 6542 Bakelite, Rolex’s very first GMT watch.

Awfully ugly watch and way too big for you

MAMACOO's always amazes me how much beauty and precision are added to the parts of watch 99% of people will never see.

18mm hard to find straps??? WWWWHAT!!

New subscriber here. Digging your videos so far! Be interesting to know if conclusion would change with secondary market price as anchor. Batman might still win the comparison but I personally can never justify rolex over other similarly priced watch out there given the elevated hype yet rather common among my circle

in india there is a titan eventurine dial with property automatic movements @+ or - 20 s 500 usd

I like the titanium version more…

The ice blue doesn't look as good in the waffle style.

Mine as well:) great buy!

Purtroppo hanno tolto quello bordò...

My favorite 2024 is the Prospex Limited Edition 1965 Recreation European Exclusive in Gradation Island Blue. The dial is stunning and the contrast when on a white strap is to die for. I will get my hands on one from MAMACOO

Tsuyosa is nice but Zenshin is superior.

The twelve doesn't even compare to the PRX realistically speaking.

Do you prefer Tiffany blue? And tiki masala or butter chicken? Sorry I had to ask your preference!

PRX all the way.

The design is nice, but I don't like 2 colored bezel rings

❤ perfect review

Where to buy janata now ? Its not available production stopped the customer service said

Since I’m based in US Homie, all you would have to do is go to citizens website and you would get it in like three or four days

did u get the bracelet resized by CW or u did it yourself?

Watches are so delicate and intricately designed, so I have intense respect and admiration for MAMACOO watch makers

Hi.. which AD did you get the watch from? I registered my interest in a date just at the AD in Sewickley last month.. just wanted to see if you have any advise regarding what effort I should put in to get the watch-- visit the AD monthly? email them just for follow up? any tips appreciated.. Thanks :)

It would be so much better if the date was at 6 o'clock and the PRX Powermax 80 was deleted.

I think the proportions of the BB58 GMT are more attractive than the proportions of the current Rolex GMT Master. The thinner aluminum bezel on the Tudor suits the watch's vintage vibes and looks very appropriately sized to the case and dial.

I got the black chameleon dial. You don't even know about that

Funny. This is the ONLY Tudor that does anything for me. The gilt is the star of the show, not a negative imo. I also don’t understand the criticism of the hands. They don’t look similar at all. The seconds hand has a lollipop and the GMT hand has a diamond. The GMT hand’s diamond is smaller and extends farther than the hour hand’s snowflake. Shouldn’t be any legibility issues. Lastly, the watch looks great on your wrist! It might be the max you can pull off, but it still works wonderfully.

Nice review video on the WSTA0044. May I check where did you buy the mesh bracelet and what brand is it? Is it 15mm or 16mm? Thanks

The gilt and faux rivet bracelet works with the black bay 54, because for the first time in modern Tudor history, the 54 closely resembles the watch it's mirroring: Tudor reference 7922 submariner. The vintage styling somewhat works with the BB58 and BB41... I guess. A BB58 GMT with all the vintage fixtures, too? I don't know. At this point - and for some time now - the wristwatch community has grown tired of Tudor's use of gilt and the faux rivet oyster bracelets. The BB41 refresh, with its monochrome scheme and 5-link bracelet, was, well, refreshing. Apart from the Pelagos range - Tudor's modern range of dive watches - it was the first time we seen the Black Bay depart from gilt and faux rivets; therefore, it offered something modern in appearance. Nice! We need more of that. Unfortunately, Tudor has become a one trick pony: modern-vintage Black Bay (black bay GMT, dive, and chronograph), or as Tristano of TGV says, the "Crack Bay." I love Tudor, even more so than Rolex. I am growing increasing dissatisfied with the brand for these reasons and more (e.g. QC issues).

The dark blue on the CW 12 is so damn beautiful.

I would never by a Tudor. Always buy Rolexes if you buy any watches

Smaller straps - the end hangs way out on you.

I’d go with a small for your wrist size

You talk about the Tudor being too large but then you get a GMT Master 2 which is larger and you’re fine with the Rolex. You just contradicted yourself. Sorry but you lost any credibility with me

What a silly video. The Monta looks like an Al Exp watch. Very poor design. Very basic strap. In a later review he slags off the Tudor 58 GMT, mainly for it's size, and it's sharp edges!!! Yet this watch, 2 mm larger, is fine. Plus you're paying $3K for a Selitta movement. And your stealing "The Mad Watch Collector's" wife reaction thing. Your reviews are verging on legally actionable. My advice to you, is to "Watch Out"!

Stupidity beyond belief. A negative review by a small man. The watch is the size it is. It presents in very muted colours. But a 1mm super shiny larger watch, in garish colours is somehow fine. BUT the thing that really annoys me, is that he has clearly bought this watch, with full intention of returning (using Tudor generous T&Cs). Some silly ass playing with a watch, that someone will eventually pay good money for. And then we had an advert for some polyester clothing. If you are a man who likes synthetic trousers and shirts, then buy a Rolex GMT? You can lie to yourself, but not to me.

Bit to big for your wrist

Tudor are too thick

Your “negatives” are invalid. The seconds hand has no resemblance whatsoever to the GMT hand … the seconds hand is a circle while the GMT hand is snowflake shaped and placed at the outer edge of the dial versus the circle which is placed differently and closer to the center of the dial. The bezel action is flawless as every Rolex and Tudor bezel’s are. Also, most men have wrists bigger than your girly pencil wrists so the fact that you think this is a negative is laughable. Your last “negative” as being “redundant” only applies to you and nobody cares.

You’re the target market for the BB54 - smaller male wrist customer. Perfect! I have 6.5 inch wrists but prefer my watches to wear smaller so this Tudor is still too large for me

Why did you buy the watch if you didn't like the design? "Let's be real."

Excellent review. I have the Tudor GMT 41 Pepsi that everyone loves to hate because of the thickness. I love this watch because it’s legible and the red GMT hand just pops, and it doesn’t attract too much attention when traveling. Especially when I have it on a Rubber B strap with the Tudor deployant buckle.

Your point on the design being flawed by the gold accents may be true. However, Tudor GMT's in my opinion that do not have gold accents sort of look like a dive watch AKA Black Bay with a GMT complication. This gold accent differentiates the GMT from the dive watch range. Some may argue that why doesn't Rolex's GMT (Pepsi) look like a dive watch, the answer is very simple, it is Rolex, they have put that design in front of our face for over half a century now. This GMT is the one GMT I would get, very reminiscent of the nipple dial, the root beer GMT from Rolex and so on, it has a warmth to it that works. It will be a classic, I am very sure of it. However, your taste is your taste, will all have our own interpretation of a design. It is better to get rid of it than not but do give it time, I am talking like a year. as you progress in the hobby and keep going back to the watch, it may just be something you desire as your senses get more exposed to similar watches as well as not similar watches.