Can't ask for a better teacher, I'm so glad to have found you

Here from the future

Best ear training vdo on earth

Thank you sir

Hey, saw your udemy courses. That are awesome and very helpfull for beginners and intermediate levels.. Thank You... Love ❤️From INDIA

Best use of insomnia Ive made for a while! Your approach is awesome!

Confusing when in key of E but at point 16:`9 and 16:24 the tonic (E) sounds very different to the other tonic and then at point 16:30 it's back to how it originally sounds!! I guess a few accuracy issues need to be ironed out although grateful for bringing this to us as very helpful.

D6: 20/30 16/20 13/20

I think this guy discovered a new torture technique

so of all you know is the minor scale when you first start out, and it has a feeling... could it cause depression, clinically, if a person hears or plays too much minor... you feel it resonating in your chest if its on guitar or other and or coming from speakers..... Play major scale, do depressed people cheer up? or do depressed people not want to hear major scale because it opposes their narrative... who the fuck knows...

hello Im from the future

Your courses have been so illuminating for me, thank you! THIS WAS SO LOVELY! I would love to hear more!

thanks for the series, helped me an absolute ton!

Thank you so very much, Max. Your instructions are the best I've found and you have helped me enormously with your tutorials. Much obliged.

Overall, this series is awesome - thank you for putting it together! One thing - where do I find the samples you used? I assume they are in downloadable sample libraries?

Thank you 🙏

i just got highs and though of the exact same idea for a channel, keep it up bro you gonna go big with this quality

47:35 do you have a list of the drones on Spotify you could share with us. Been practicing the drums and stretching neck and shoulder muscles whilst listening in on your melodies, and the drones , I think will help me mentally whilst out walking the dogs too :) Oh, your saying about the tempura now. Once I bought a Raagini in Leicester England at the wise advise of Pete kimber, AKA sonic , E.A.R electrical audio research of the band spacemen 3. Cheers for the lesson :)

I can't make the head and tail of this video. But it is a good presentation.

The Immersive Ear Training series is helping me so much !! I feel I am becoming so much better at understanding notes and intervals. Thank you so much for these videos!

13:46

Wtf is this. If you want to get good at playing by ear then just practise Listening to songs and finding the chords

Thx so much for this I do it while I crochet lol

2:58

D1: 17/30

11min24: 21/30, 23/30, 22/30

Maybe I did too much interval training in the past but when I hear say b3 for example, I count down in the scale "b3 - 2 - 1" or a b6 I will count up "b6-b7-1." This happens quite quickly like in the time in takes for you to reveal the answer so it works here. However with a real song I struggle a lot, is this perhaps because I'm not focusing on the FEELING as much as relying on that quick method of figuring the interval? Or is this an ok way and I will just get faster to the point it doesn't really matter and the feeling will take precedent? I hope that makes sense. THANKS for all you do it's been amazing. Can't wait for the app.

I'm sorry, but I'd like to understand. Why are the degrees arranged by fourth/fifth? What does it do? Sciencomancy? It would be more convenient and logical to arrange them in order, as they are numbered -1 2 3 4 5 6 7, and how they're arranged on the keyboard.

ive doing this consiously with songs, findind the 1 and picking an instrument and trying to figure the interval, and sing it. also i've been using the drones and for now i just walk through 1,2,3...,till 1 again, and then back, really trying to feel it in my head vibrate as i sing. and sometimes i do pick it up, like they sound really different. at first when i saw the video i didn't get why 1 sounded more like 5 than to 2 which is closer, to be honest they all sounded..like random notes. but now i get it, and if i make a mistake is usually mistaking 1 for 5 and 6 for 3 or for 2. like they really have a similar feeling to them, which is difficult to explain but it's amazing to be moving forward. thanks. it's slow, but i hope i'll eventually feel them all

A progress report: I started listening to this video when it first came out in mid-September, approximately two months ago. The first time I played it, I could only hear the 1, 2, and 7 scale degrees. Since then I have played it for about 10 minutes a day (starting at a randomly chosen spot in the video), for 5 or 6 days out of each week. As of this week, I find that I can identify all seven scale degrees over 90% of the time. Also, I am 65 years old. Takeaways: (1) you don't need to be young or musically talented for your brain to learn to recognize scale degrees (I am neither). (2) It's a marathon, not a sprint. Think months, not weeks or days. (3) Consistency is important. Don't do it once a week, or five times in one day then stop for two weeks. Think of it like weight training.

Well, I'm still in the middle of it, but I had to stop to thank you! This seems to be the key, because I like music but didn't know why exactly. There are some answers in this video. And btw thanks for putting your face in the middle of the circle, very accurate 😂

You have a very very strong channel that I'm glad I stumbled upon!! I'm an 👂 training "junkie" because for me music @ it's base is an aural art!! So I welcome the instructions and commend you on your channel!!!🙏🙏🙏

Love your videos....want more of these😅

Im floored by this approach. Take my money with thé app!

is it real person or ai? XD

Thanks for making this video. It helps me alot.

6/8 isn't always divided into triplets, nor is 4/4 always felt and 4 beats; sometimes it's 2 down beats and 2 up beats. I think there's a range of bpms people normally feel comfortable tapping their foot to. If 4/4 is played too slow, one can't help but count every beat. If 6/8 is too slow, one can't help but count it more like 2 measures of 3/4. The real magic of 6/8 is that the 1 and 4 beats are normally slow enough that one MUST count them, but the 2, 3, 5, and 6 beats are normally too quick for most people to think of them as anything other than up beats. 6/8 also has more ability to swap between different rhythms, which some songs I like use to great effect. This ability is also what makes 5/8, 7/8 and other prime numerator time signatures so fun. A favorite song of mine is in 7/8 time, but each measure alternates between "ONE two three four FIVE six seven" and ONE two three FOUR five six seven".

NOPE! 🤷‍♀️

Wintersun - Way of the fire 3:03 - 4:04 sends shivers down the spine. Anything from Wintersun really. That music will be explored in future centuries.

Honestly? The 4/4 time is kinda a lot higher-energy, even though technically the 6/8 sounds faster. Kinda like the difference between having to pedal on a bike vs just coasting, you’re putting more energy into it for the former. And then there’s 3/4 time, which is more like taking a bus ride home, and you’re just unwinding from riding your bike

"Only the thing is the thing"

i saw this a few weeks ago, and it made sense to me. I've never tried writing anything in a time signature other than 4/4 since the other videos i watched were didnt really make sense to me, so when i saw this video, i told myself that i had to try it out, and i actually accomplished it, im so proud i was able to pull it off! if it wasn't for this video, i wouldn't have made the song. thank you, Max! 💜

Hey Max! Just made it through all 92 videos and wanted to thank you for making this all available, it has helped me tremendously starting out. Is there a continuation in this series? If so where is it? Something I would be happy to pay for.

56:53

Wait, is the clarinet track the same in all examples?

i have a question is it okay to identify note from what it resolves to or what’s it’s next to for example in the major scale i can hear 7 because i know it’s next to 1? or is it just about getting more fine tuned

Can't wait for the app, do you know if you will release it soon? Thanks for your amazing lessons and ear training videos! You're the best! 💪

Really good video, thanks Max!

I have a song in 15 that confuses drummers still.. i will show them this and hopefully, they can extrapolate a functional part.