I don't speak french but WOW, I'm gaining SO MUCH out of this tutorial. I'd love to know about Pauls 'cello - make, age etc.

Now Mr.Greensmith is a great cellist and also a teacher. Thank you for posting this video. How adorable he was at age 20!

Fantastic teacher

Un génie définitif

I never get tired of watching this video thanks so much for posting this

3:17 人差し指ではなく中指

Tortelier was a complete master of the Violoncello, that is for sure.

Beautiful

Pure and absolute live!!

Does anyone know if there is an upload of the Brahms FMaj or Bach Tortelier masterclass here on KZbin? I’ve looked but 🤷🏼‍♂️

His ability to describe in Metaphor seems to be on a par with his playing - I absolutely love how he talks. Thank you so much for uploading, so much to learn from these.

I wonder why she bothered to turn up if she’s going to be so narky and ego bruised about it. It’s a masterclass, he’s the master (student of Hekking, no less!) she isn’t. The young woman is lucky to have had the opportunity. He’s stone cold dead now. Too bad for the rest of us.

Well, after all, it is a masterclass.

An inspired player and equally inspired teacher.

5:15 the look on Tortelier‘s face when the pianist missed like one note, I died 😂

3.00- the commentary about being too mean with the bow. "Be generous, shownus all of your bow". 👏 wow. What a difference in sound and feeling!! Brava!

This is great

人としての格が違いすぎる

05:00 the most careful and beautiful harmonics i've ever heard in dvorak's concerto

これ見たかったっす。

ラストにシンディローパー居なかったか？

これ絶対弾けるようになりたい！

You understand ? I love the way he would say that after an explanation .

Starts at 2:20

4:22 that stare 🥰

I just don’t want to hear the voice in the end. Why can’t we just hear what tortelier was teaching😂😂

1:25 E(イー)minor sonata だからイ短調って翻訳ミスしてるの草

compliments from the master. Wow

the student didnt play even one tone ;-)

He said it good.

Music is on sheet music Plus ...44.00!

Sounds extremely difficult!

I remember him from a Cello Congress in Maryland,,back in 88. Truly one of the best cellists and teachers of the century.

-praise opens student (Measured, specific, genuine) -humor, even ridicule can make a point

-context by composer (Brahms, Beethoven, Mozart... etc) -craft arguments/Reason; suggestions/taste -choose ^ vs. reject -instinctual; analytical; sentimental (?) -thinking: “let’s figure it out together”

I can't believe that M. Tortelier played this apparently very difficult passage with the other two cellists while conducting in 3 with his head and didn't miss a nuance!!

You really have to be a great cellist to do this piece justice....

Rostropovich has bad taste

My true inspiration and hero. Incredible teacher and master!

Thanks Mr.Greenberg! This video saw almost 30,000people!

I am Rodney Greenberg. I directed and produced 4 Tortelier Masterclasses at the Royal Northern College of Music in Manchester in 1985 and previously a series of six at the BBC TV studios in 1973. Nice to see them still going strong on KZbin.

Young Clive is really good but nothing to be compared to his playing now.

What piece are they playing? What is it called

ドボルザークの思いと日本人の叙情的な感性の表情が重なり、奇跡のように表現されているように思いました。 涙が溢れて止まりませんでした。 トゥルトゥリエ先生も仰っていた通り。 ありがとう。

Oh my gosh; I can't believe that's Clive Greensmith!!!

I love how the pianists intro is so short.

Very interesting masterclass, IMHO (I'm not a cellist). And (contrary to what +Michael Martin says) IMO he's right about her vibrato. Strange that apparently none of her previous teachers had corrected her... I've watched a masterclass by Janos Starker in which he had to teach the right position of her disciple's left hand so that she could achieve a correct vibrato. And she wasn't a beginner either...

8:10 Problem? Trolltelier

Wonderful!!

8:12 先生「この感覚感じなきゃだめだよ。ちゃんと感じてる？」 先生「感じてますか？」 あき子「…」 ピアニスト「彼女わからないわ」 先生「sentir（感じること）、言ってる意味分る？」 先生「あぁ、たぶんこの単語の意味分らないね。」 先生「（この場面に対する）あなたがどう感じるか見つけて。」 先生「音楽はすべての事に共通している」