Thanks so much. Actually I didn't know this piece until quite recently. Those 10ths in the accompaniment with that repeated melody are Romantic! so forward thinking and a million miles from Bach. The arpeggi in the background were actually a serendipitous accident and I'm sure. some will quite rightly raise an eyebrow or two. Thanks again, Orzomondo for your articulate review.

Thanks so, so, so much, Karl. - I saw Ridley Scott's Napoleon a while back and was mesmerised by this played on the piano. I'm familiar with some Rameau but didn't know this at all and thought it might be by the composer for the film!! Anyway I found it so mesmerising I couldn't follow the dialog and has been singing in my ears ever since. Thanks again.

@@grahamcaldecott Confession: Sometimes, I have to synthesize a piece - even if I don't upload it - simply to exorcise the ear-worm! After so many repeated auditions, I can't bear to hear it again for at least two years!

Grazie ancora per la tua generosa recensione. Per trovare questa foto ci è voluto quasi lo stesso tempo che per realizzare questo arrangiamento!

Thanks, ShyHunter. That bass line makes me almost want to rock.

Thanks so much!!

Ancora grazie mille.

Thanks you!

😊

Lol, the first baroque etude.

Everyone has an issue with this piece. The E flat book 1 was the made to do piece for me and at the time I hated it as well. Anyway, very glad I've changed your mind! Andreas.

Indeed.

Thanks so, so much!

Grazie mille!!!

Good one to start with.

Thanks so much. Ah, yes, it sounds a tad dry at the beginning, I will try the -60db next time..

Thank you!

Muchas gracias

..Это! Так как же это произошло?... как атомы начали разговаривать друг с другом, чтобы могла возникнуть жизнь и произвести Баха...

@@grahamcaldecott они этого не знают - про атомы они когда-то слышали - то ли в детсаду, то ли в школе - им похеррр - они НИЧЕГО не знаюттт! Колбаса и политика - этааа всёёё!!!! ЭТААА - они знаюттт!!! Даже кушалии!!

...........

Grazie mille. Trovare una buona foto richiede ore e trovare quella che ritengo appropriata può richiedere settimane: Nadia Eeckhout ha prodotto qui un ritratto eccezionale.

@@grahamcaldecott è un capolavoro.

Thank you!!

Thanks a lot!

Thank you.

Thanks Andreas, this one could be done a million different ways and like Giacometti never feel that I'll ever get absolutely right.

Thanks yet again. I'm so gratified to hear this as it was one of the most difficult arrangements to do mainly of course because of the low registers. I'm not sure the first and second movs will be doable so will put off for the foreseeable. Anyway, thanks again.

Thanks a mill!

Thanks so much, Geopholus. I didn't know that about Schikele and I guess it could work, and yes Bach anticipated Steve Reich et al in this piece.

Thanks so, so, so much.

Like a lot of people I have my doubts and insecurities but this comment inspires me to continue.

Vielen dank.

Vielen Dank

Danke, ich fühle mich völlig geschmeichelt!!!

Thanks so much!!!

Grazie mille!!!!!

Thanks you.

Thanks a ton.

Thanks so much.

XXXXXX

Thanks so, so much. Best, Graham

Спасибо сто раз

Thanks so much

Thanks again

Thanks so much!

Thanks so much.The lower registers were so difficult to translate into something that duets and sings. Anyway I'm happy with the way it turned out especially the latter two thirds. Don't think I have the resources to tackle first movement, maybe in ten years :)

THANK YOU!

THANKS A MILL!!!

You're welcome

Thanks mega tons, Karl. It really, really was a challenging piece and I'm so gratified by your comments.

Thanks so much.

That's a lovely poetic description.

@@grahamcaldecott Thankyou From A corner of Tokyo 🎑🎴

@@shin-i-chikozima ` You're welcome from a corner of London

@@grahamcaldecott London New York Paris and Tokyo are the impeccable City of the various soul See you again Good luck ⭐🌟⭐🌟⭐🌟⭐🌟⭐🌟⭐⭐⭐⭐🌟⭐

Спасибо