As he is not an artist , he is not able to assess the value of artworks. So better for him to not speak.

very good one!! harald is a legend

Those who are interested in art, enough to bother seeing or hearing what critics have to say, need to be attracted to it all. Without that 'hook' the audience slips away. One hook that nearly everyone goes for is 'perceived value equals real value'. So, no wonder that so much press is devoted to that tiny fraction of art superstars. When there is so much confusion about how to see or interpret art, it is easy to see why they go for the hackneyed proxy perceived value line. However, art that is easily perceived as fascinating (therefore valuable) can be openly and enthusiastically criticized because there is something there ... there. There is no need to argue about how to place value and attention on it.

Elena says AH and UM every two seconds. Can’t they hire someone who’s able to speak properly?

Please someone tells the panelist moderator to stop saying YEA, YEA while galleries are talking

Jail

Who has the most power in the art world; Galleries? Collectors? Artist? Money?.....

stunning candor. eye opening dilemna

didn't age well i guess

Wonderful discussion!

you people are out of your league

Very interesting. Thanking Allan for encyclopedic knowledge and experience.

interesting discussion. regarding reading... hand-wringing about nobody reading has been around for many decades.

Of course, the smartest artists would have what it takes to put together a team of advisors to run a country (if they were interested in an all-access project). This would actually improve certain things and not just change them. All weapons would disappear. The Defense Forces would be renamed the Refinement Forces. I'm a damn dreamer, you bet!

One thing has to be admitted: The girls try their best not to say anything. New artists, that's a joke, they're babies that are now being shaped for the market. The last generation of artists that had something to say was the generation that started in the 90s (their gallerists were the same generation). What they had in mind was never eloquently integrated into the economy. By this I mean that politics could be equipped with the paradigms of critical art. Art should not follow politics, art should do politics.

Why is the audio always so bad on these videos?!! This is really frustrating! I want to hear this!!

It’s tooooo focused on using Artists and their hard work to make massive profits for themselves

Very nice summary of some of the history of western museums and galleries. If the white cube is no longer relevant, what is the alternative? If critics and curators are irrelevant and art doesn't sell and is not a good investment, why continue to do art? I often think about art made in the Renaissance and Baroque periods where a lot of art was commissioned by wealthy (religious) patrons. Now art is produced solely from the ideas of the artist without being filtered through the wants and needs of the patron. So where are we now?

What about the Artists who have made their careers without Gallery representation? I, for example, sell directly from my studio. What then?

theres no sound

Anyone listening to this conversation is doing themselves a huge favor because whether you work for a museum or are just interested in art, everything Allan Schwartzman talks about is accurate.

Le son n'est pas bon

Wooow

How does an art advisor fire a client? between them and the galleries, the egos are so ridiculous. Thats why as an artist, I would never use them. I'm not your employee, I hire you or we are engage in a business partnership. the artist don't need you. You need the artists.

I think someone with a (gasp!) Sotheby’s or Christie’s degree would have been a better panelist than someone like Lisa Schiff 8:08 who is headed to prison. How embarrassing, and did they forget that the moderator is with Sothebys Institute of Art? 😂

it cant impossible art has to be above digital multidimensional if you like . between metaphysics & CERN Ying yang making one 1

it cant imposible 🙅 🙅 art has to be above digital multidimensional if you like . between metaphysis & CERN

The difficulties🎨 of ART 🎶 Markets investors in art 🖼 are created by the economical mentality of markets & the accumulation of wealth by financial & industrial means, humans in modern society are customized to believe that money is power, and more money you have more power you have, The reality is otherwise, money economy are only means of keeping the machine running your body "if you like" the mind functions otherwise money🙈🙉🙊 cannot give you knowledge only ways to manipulated others by economical📱🚬📡 means. The economical means function as a Childs game, denial rewards , you denial the child a toy he wants it more you ban someone from Facebook, twitter, he gets enraged, these gives Facebook power as long you complain and bothers you, ignored and the punishment has no effect on your psyche. The riddle of masters and slaves is simply that fact chilliest children mentality versus the grandpa that hold the inheritance. how his own family hopes to dispose of him as he is getting too 👨‍🦳 old and the family is getting younger 💎💲 younger. These facts apply to everyone moistly dew since 1776/1913 American civilization which most humans exist since 1776 🗽 under that so called civilization. 2023 Has changed the facts reality realms perhaps every 200 years changes happen automatically and these looks are the coming changes from 1776/ to 2023. There is no wall street 💲💎philosophy money 👩‍🦽👩‍🦯 or Empires that can oppose the facts of reality and now we are witnessing the stubborn 1776/ 1913/ facing its own 70 🕎✝ AD, the unavoidable fate of the humane process men is born reaches adulthood and at some point disappears same happens to everything on our own universe🌌🌎 the sun will go at some point as the Washington DC👩‍🦽 wall street 👩‍🦯 realm. Out of chaos comes order🧬 and it is the unavoidable facts of reality those that believe otherwise get their own unavoidable 🕎 70✝ AD without delay.🗽👽🛸

The difficulties🎨 of ART 🎶 Markets investors in art 🖼 are created by the economical mentality of markets & the accumulation of wealth by financial & industrial means, humans in modern society are customized to believe that money is power, and more money you have more power you have, The reality is otherwise, money economy are only means of keeping the machine running your body "if you like" the mind functions otherwise money🙈🙉🙊 cannot give you knowledge only ways to manipulated others by economical📱🚬📡 means. The economical means function as a Childs game, denial rewards , you denial the child a toy he wants it more you ban someone from Facebook, twitter, he gets enraged, these gives Facebook power as long you complain and bothers you, ignored and the punishment has no effect on your psyche. The riddle of masters and slaves is simply that fact chilliest children mentality versus the grandpa that hold the inheritance. how his own family hopes to dispose of him as he is getting too 👨‍🦳 old and the family is getting younger 💎💲 younger. These facts apply to everyone moistly dew since 1776/1913 American civilization which most humans exist since 1776 🗽 under that so called civilization. 2023 Has changed the facts reality realms perhaps every 200 years changes happen automatically and these looks are the coming changes from 1776/ to 2023. There is no wall street 💲💎philosophy money 👩‍🦽👩‍🦯 or Empires that can oppose the facts of reality and now we are witnessing the stubborn 1776/ 1913/ facing its own 70 🕎✝ AD, the unavoidable fate of the humane process men is born reaches adulthood and at some point disappears same happens to everything on our own universe🌌🌎 the sun will go at some point as the Washington DC👩‍🦽 wall street 👩‍🦯 realm. Out of chaos comes order🧬 and it is the unavoidable facts of reality those that believe otherwise get their own unavoidable 🕎 70✝ AD without delay.🗽👽🛸

Gracias a todos ..se necesita muchos Simposium cómo esté para abrir información a los artistas y galerías.. gracias a todos

This lady is quite aggressive, but I suppose being a journalist for the art world does that to you

Such an awesome talk

I love arts

This dude is such an arrogant dufus.

so is kenny schacter.

No

Off course it's a good thing, why else would they do it.

good talk

They shouldn't work together, ever.

Matt's persona is unbearable. The type that detracts so many from entering a gallery.

Yes, an art gallery can be considered an institution. Institutions are generally defined as established organizations or systems with a particular purpose, and art galleries certainly fit that definition. Art galleries typically have a specific mission, whether it be to showcase a particular type of art, support emerging artists, or educate the public about art. Moreover, art galleries often have a physical location, a staff of employees, and a set of rules and procedures for how they operate. They may also have a board of directors or trustees who oversee their activities and ensure that they are fulfilling their mission. All of these elements are characteristic of institutions, and thus art galleries can be considered as such.

Thank you for all videos from Symposium 2022! This channel is a wealth of knowledge

Like artists care

Excellent industry destruction

Sexy

Great talk, they shared alot of good information.

This man is unconventional obviously but he has so much knowledge and is so kind and approachable. He is real and generous with his knowledge… so what if he’s unconventional he is approachable and not a snob unlike so many people in the “Art World”

Love this guy what a genuine and real person…what a character he’s so personable and very likeable .

This is a great talk!