That Jodie steele riff?? Hello??

Samantha pauly easily to me but Jodie was pretty good too

Samantha Pauly. But you did forget Hannah Lowther.

It's just a shame that none of the live performances was used in the album. You can debate as much as you like who did it the most justice, but I think it can be agreed that the studio recording takes away a lot of the emotion.

I love aimee Atkinsons version as she was the og in the first studies recording but Sam pauly is gonna always be my top favorite

It feels like everyone else was still treating it like a song, but Sam was genuinely going through it if that makes sense. It stopped being about putting on a good show and became a true hysterical cry of anguish

The way that she isn't even in the video and people are still talking about Sam Pauly 🙄🙄🙄. At least it seems like her fans have calmed down slightly. I remember when they were going under other actresses' videos and calling them slurs

ok Samantha did amazing but are we just gonna sleep on Jodie Steele. she has so much emotion and you can her her voice quivering and getting quiet and louder.

WHERES THE JAINA AND LEESA TALK??? 13:35

THE OG SAM PAULY!

I love Samantha pauly and I’ve seen her live. She is definitely my favorite, but watching Courtney Stapleton put a chill down my spine. Definitely one of my favorites behind Samantha

A lot say Sam, while she did eat but Grace and Aimie is for me <3

No contest... Samantha in the lead followed by Zara

Samantha Paul’s was the best in my opinion

Honestly I can’t pick and compare these incredible performers, but I’m gonna mention Annabel Marlow because I think she’s pretty underrated, especially considering she was the first person to perform as K Howard

Samantha Pauly foreveeeeer ❤🙌✨

*silently waiting for part 3 for hannah lowther.*

Samantha Pauly was always be the best

Why is no one talking about bryony? Her singing was amazing!

Sam pauly is always gonna be the best one for me, but dammn jodie steele ate with that.

sam is amazing but you guys are sleeping on courtney monsma shes actually amazing

I need Lou Henry

The original student cast instrumental kinda slaps

sam pauly is def the best

Roxanne 💯

sam pauly my girl😭💕

the way you didnt add samantha pauly is criminal

Samm pauly sin dudas, ella literalmente es K. Howard

I’m gonna be honest, Sam Pauly was obnoxious. How did you like it??

I think samatha Pauly did it the best

Sam Pauly every time for me. To the point where I think she's ruined it for anyone who comes after! Her acting here is spot on, you can see her confidence draining away and her anger and desperation growing with each chorus, by the end she is physically recoiling from the many hands reaching out to her. That final line is cried not sung and it tears at my heart every time.

Vicki did a really different take 4:30 😮😮

AHH, I LOVE SHANNEN 7:25

Wasn’t expecting Rachael’s riff on fairest of the fair but I can’t complain it was fire

My Top 4: 1. Sam Pauly 2. Jodie Steele 3. Zara Macintosh 4: Collette Guitart

16:56 OMG, COURTNEY’S OF THE FAIR, ❤❤❤ prob the best of the fair I heard yet

rox is just incredible i wish she got more howie shows :(

Sophie Issacs actually looks like a child. This kinda adds to the role in my opinion. Proabs my favorite Howard.

Samatha Paul is the best!

SOPHIA ISAACS MUST BE THE BEST REPRESENTATION ON KATHERYN HOWARD SHE MUST BE LIKE 17 YRS OLD WHEN SOPHIA ISAACS SUNG THAT

Samantha Pauly is by far my favorite Catherine Howard! Her voice is phenomenal, and she sings and acts the hell out of this song. Everytime I hear her do it, I get goosebumps, and by the time she hits that final note, she always has me in tears. No other version of this song has been able to accomplish either of those things.

9:31 I’m sorry but like Zara is so good and all the comments are talking about same like I get she’s good but I wanna see a different comment than Sam and I really think this one is in my top 3

JODIES VOICE SENT SHIVERS DOWN MY WHOLE BODY

You forgot Sophie Issacs

SAMANTHA Pauley was the best because she owned it. ALOT OF These are trying to imitate her and that's fine but it wasn't enough to convince. I WILL SAY Bryony Duncan was a convincing 2nd.

I had a number of people in my head throughout the vid but by the end I had forgotten most of them. There were some good really exceptional singers, and no this doesn't doesn't include Sam of USA but I'm prettg sure the one right after hed was included. As normal acting, Sam was on point but in my honest opinion, as a musical she let the emotion interfere with the song too much. But I wouldn't blame her, probably her director who asked her to do it that way. But then there was this one girl who did the perfect blend and still let her voice crack without going off beat or ruining the song. I loved them

I’m sorry, but Samantha Pauly OWNS this role. There is no contest IMHO

they're all good.

Honestly Annabel Marlow is pretty good. You can hear the pain in her voice.

Samantha Pauly 💕