I don’t think anyone will be able to channel the essence of the song like Samantha Pauly does. The song is about a girl who was groomed, r-worded, and abused for YEARS and she channels those emotions PERFECTLY. I think a lot of people forget the song is about a girl who died at 19 after being taken advantage of by men her entire life and not an over-confident woman who got around, but Sam conveys the sadness and heartbreak so well.
@taysmanuscript Жыл бұрын
I agree so much, it sends literal chills down my spine
@sophiatawil930 Жыл бұрын
facts same for me.
@lydiarose1239 ай бұрын
definitely the best one!
@JADELee-w8r9 ай бұрын
Fully agree
@zellachan12659 ай бұрын
I LOVE SAMANTHA PAULY's version, it's the only version that made really bawl my eyes out while the others just made me sad. The way Samantha Pauly portrayed the song with so much emotion and desperation in the end that I feel like I'm watching irl Katherine Howard's life flash before my eyes, plus it was assumed she died at ages around 17-19 which means she never got to even become an adult.
@svnnyelisee86502 жыл бұрын
Where is the talk about Sam Pauly- like omg she hit those high notes like a frickin boss and put in so much emotion
@ChanceApollo2 жыл бұрын
Sam seems to be a favorite of a lot of people from what I can tell. She is absolutely amazing.
@macymeower2 жыл бұрын
almost every comment is abt her lol wdym
@Idontexisthihi0012 жыл бұрын
Literally every comment is about her lol
@ahyescourtney1805 Жыл бұрын
Every comment is about her Wdym
@CatalinaLinal7710 Жыл бұрын
At this point it would be nice if people would give the other K Howards BESIDES Sam a legitimate chance
@RealOceanAmethyst Жыл бұрын
During Samantha Pauly’s version, you can hear someone in the audience crying.
@bluesungshine6 ай бұрын
oops that was me (joke...but i did cry)
@GMR.245 ай бұрын
*coughing
@adianethken97472 жыл бұрын
It's always gonna be Samantha Pauly for me because the emotion she conveys without sacrificing the vocal quality is so powerful and she gets very into the character and it's such a powerful and heartbreaking performance from her.
@cherylblack93492 жыл бұрын
All of these girls are fantastic, but Sam Pauly delivers chills each and every time. Amazing!!
@Khowardishereandthefunsbegunnn21 күн бұрын
Sam and Courtney
@rosemariescott-griffiths9676 Жыл бұрын
No disrespect to all the other wonderful performers but Samantha Pauly’s perfect performance gives me chills each time I view.
@heikemackenzie74034 ай бұрын
Yea legit
@leilaclayton67702 жыл бұрын
Samantha Pauly for life. She channels so much emotion and is how I picture K Howard acting. Edit: tysm for the likes. however, in terms of vocals, I listen to the Aimie Atkinson one because that is the studio recording and my personal preference.
@leilaclayton67702 жыл бұрын
But Collette adds so much emotion too
@wickedsai8 ай бұрын
I truly think Samantha Pauli fully embodies the emotions in this song. I would like to say that Jodi Steele, and Courtney Mack did REALLY amazing as well. The main difference in the performances we think are stellar vs just good are what the performer is putting focus on. Acting or singing?. The others did great on the vocals, in fact no one did bad on vocals in any way, but sometimes the vocals needs to be set aside to get the soul of the song across to its full extent. Samantha Pauli's performance makes you want to cry because she is basically begging for her innocence and her life.
@CarolinaFernandes-i3vАй бұрын
I fully agree, no one sang it best or worst, but most of them were more focused on singing while Sam was more focused on acting and THAT'S what made me cry when I first heard her version
@jocelynnunnez8 ай бұрын
I was listening to this as background noise and when i heard samantha pauly's, i kid you not. I physically recoiled and almost dropped my food. My jaw DROPPED to the earths core because i was NOT expecting that 😦
@Tea-xo9ry2 жыл бұрын
I was blessed with the chance to see Samatha Pauly’s Howard and oh my gosh. The bootleg doesn’t do her justice. The EMOTION SHE PUTS. She’s so talented oh my gosh. I was in shock.
@vanilladrizzlequeen Жыл бұрын
In Samantha’s you can literally hear the fear in her voice- and that’s hard to convey while singing. The way she seems to have a mental breakdown on stage is absolutely amazing and I wish I could see it in person because I’ve actually been very very interested in Katheryn Howard irl so seeing Six would be amazing
@luna2o2638 ай бұрын
Sam Pauly is absolutely the best K Howard. The way she starts physically shaking and hyperventilating just fits so perfectly with the emotions of the character. If I didn't know any better I would have thought that she actually went through the same things as K Howard.
@AddieT072 жыл бұрын
Samantha Pauly is a legend
@moonscout37022 жыл бұрын
I like ALL of them, but I think that Samantha Pauly is my favorite. I think she captured K Howard's character very well - the part where she cries at the end is really heartbreaking. I love the emotion she put in it.
@zaktar32002 жыл бұрын
Samantha Pauly always gives me shivers down my spine whenever she sings.
@peridotasadeadbritishmonar79242 жыл бұрын
I love Courtney Stapleton, Jodie, Sam and Alicia's performances. Courtney has a lot of anger in her voice, Jodie sounds so scared and her physical acting is how I imagine Katherine acting at this part of the song, Sam's voice is just filled with desperation and sadness, and Alicia makes the role super youthful.
@wenlucasq36784 ай бұрын
My Top 4: 1. Sam Pauly 2. Jodie Steele 3. Zara Macintosh 4: Collette Guitart
@suticenkedu4 ай бұрын
Me too
@Alicia-ip5gg2 жыл бұрын
Aimie's Howard manages the balance between trauma and immaturity in such a unique way that does make her my favorite. But Zara has such a different take on Howard, presents a more healed yet hurt version of her that was so beautiful to experience as well.
@YOUR_DAILY_SHIPWRECK5 ай бұрын
I KNOWWWWW THATS WHAT I THINK
@carlee45062 жыл бұрын
samantha pauly’s k howard will always be my favorite. i got to see her live on broadway and i had tears in my eyes. her emotion at the end is spot on and her vocals are amazing
@evie2894 Жыл бұрын
0:00 Annabel Marlow 0:55 Aimie Atkinson 1:51 Grace Mouat 2:47 Courtney Stapleton 3:42 Vicki Manser 4:39 Jodie Steele 5:36 Jennifer Caldwell 6:36 Samantha Pauly 7:33 Courtney Mack 8:29 Sophie Isaacs 9:25 Zara MacIntosh 10:20 Collette Guitart 11:15 Hana Stewart 12:12 Alicia Corrales-Connor 13:09 Bryony Duncan 14:05 Natalie Pilkington 15:00 Georgia Carr 15:25 Elizabeth Walker 16:21 Courtney Monsma 17:22 Rebecca Wickes 18:18 Maddison Firth 19:14 Sadie Hurst your welcome 🤷♀️
@rubyrevelation119 Жыл бұрын
thank u sm
@Gaons.hair_ Жыл бұрын
Tyyy
@jacksworld46537 ай бұрын
Thank you
@andiortiz27092 жыл бұрын
SAM ALWAYS AND FOREVER she actually made me cry when i watched it live
@kirstennn_falls Жыл бұрын
All the other girls are amazing but Sam Pauly. She hits those high notes and shows so much emotion and makes me feel the Katherine’s pain and what she felt. She seriously a boss and she’s frickin amazing.
@taysmanuscript Жыл бұрын
Personally for me, it’s Sam Pauly. That little end bit sends literal chills down my spine
@mandygrundy Жыл бұрын
Samantha Pauly for life. She always channels the emotion and belts it out so so good but for the others I was just waiting for that emotion but nobody delivered it as good as Sam Pauly did!!
@Jessica-ch1yi2 жыл бұрын
Samantha Pauly plays her best, the emotion from her just feels so real! But I thought Grace Mouat did awesome portraying her anguish too :) And Jennifer Caldwell and Alicia Corrales-Connor have such beautiful voices. Madison Firth too, would’ve been cool to see her sing it on stage in costume and all
@macy77039 ай бұрын
Jennifer has no emotion whatsoever
@h0lm3sbury2 жыл бұрын
annabel is criminally underrated.
@sixx-jo4is2 жыл бұрын
i’m just now hearing her ending and jesus are those harmonies beautiful
@justcallmethewearethetiger18682 жыл бұрын
Right? Her climax is painful BECAUSE of the lack off difference. I love the sheer HURT in most of the actresses, but hers hits hard because she went numb - Annabel's Howard is more numb and defeated as opposed to hurt or mad.
@thepengua57672 жыл бұрын
Sam, Zara, and Sophie are my favorite. Sam captures the pain and suffering while Sophie’s voice seems more childish, signifying how young K Howard was. Zara has so much emotion and I’m here for it.
@MossIsCool3142 жыл бұрын
I have to say, Sam Pauly is probably my favorite K Howard
@lilyengelsgjerd5860 Жыл бұрын
Sam is my personal favorite, but Collette and Jodie are super good too. The absolute anger and anguish that they each display gets me every time. Plus, the little details like Sam flinching when the other queens are reaching towards her in the choreography, and Jodie looking around in fear and trying to find a way out while the other queens are slowly approaching from all directions. This song is about a young girl being sexually exploited and assaulted all her life, and these three are who really sell that to me. But everyone is really good, it’s really impressive to be able to sing this song and all of them nailed it in their own way!
@matthewpargeter-villarreal35385 ай бұрын
I’m sorry, but Samantha Pauly OWNS this role. There is no contest IMHO
@zalua2 жыл бұрын
samantha really makes me feel her anger and pain. she’s incredible.
@addisontang4738 Жыл бұрын
Sam Pauly no doubt about it. her full performance from start to finish goes from being a badass queen to realisation that she never got the love she wanted. it's heartbreaking but i do love all the other k howards💜
@GingerPrincessVlogs Жыл бұрын
Jodie, Sam, and Zara were the best for me. The second EVER and ENOUGH need to sound dang near hysterical. Too many "sing" it instead of shreak it. Sam gives me chills every time. I just wanna hug and comfort her. Zara adding the panic look during "play time's over" was amazing!
@niamhlashmet2 жыл бұрын
I hadn’t heard Jodie’s version before, but I really love it! The riff is perfect, the emotion is spot on, and she really feels like a young girl going through trauma.
@Southern_QUEERies2 жыл бұрын
I love Zara's scream at the end. Idk there is something that is so horrifying about it.
@LucyAdroitАй бұрын
Caught me off guard there
@daniellevin95752 жыл бұрын
My favorite K Howard climax is K Howard singing the climax.
@kpop_liner2 жыл бұрын
No its K Howard who did best climax
@ambereddie85842 жыл бұрын
@@kpop_liner no it’s obvious that K Howard did it the best 🙄
@D3arD8ughter2 жыл бұрын
@@ambereddie8584 No you swine it was K Howard 🙄
@smileyriley75142 жыл бұрын
omg how could you not see K Howard was the best???
@Skibidi-sigma4 Жыл бұрын
Guys, guys, stop arguing. We all know it’s K Howard!!
@cynder6596 Жыл бұрын
My list. 1. Samantha Pauly 2. Jodie Steele 3. Collette Guitart 4. Georgia carr 5. Grace Mouat Honorable mentions: Hana Stewart, Zara MacIntosh, Courtney Stapleton If there are any you feel i should i add to this list ill re-listen and give my argument (or change the list if i agree).
@SashaLanek4 ай бұрын
Sophie Issacs actually looks like a child. This kinda adds to the role in my opinion. Proabs my favorite Howard.
@mintots_285 ай бұрын
Samantha Pauly 💕
@Hollyvlogs2 жыл бұрын
I saw Zara as alt Howard and I was a emotional wreck! she's so talented.
@peepz14032 жыл бұрын
I love Vicki and Jodies the most. I copied Vicki’s riff for a theatre contest and won 2nd.(btw I’m a dude and did her riff lol).
@lilyu3u2242 жыл бұрын
Congratsss!! ✨
@michaelinthebathroom7560 Жыл бұрын
Jodie and Sam, definitely! I will never forget the first time my best friend's mom heard the end of her version. She was so shocked when she heard the breakdown.
@ACL-iu2qf2 жыл бұрын
Jodie’s little riff literally gives me life!
@ailbhesboo28 күн бұрын
I love Samantha pauly and I’ve seen her live. She is definitely my favorite, but watching Courtney Stapleton put a chill down my spine. Definitely one of my favorites behind Samantha
@OnlineCorvus_5 ай бұрын
they're all good.
@LilMizRandom09 Жыл бұрын
I first heard this song with Samantha Pauly and it makes me cry every time, but everyone does this song so well and I'm really excited to go see it in 2 months time! I can't wait to see what kind of climax to this song I'm going to get to see!
@batty.b19 күн бұрын
It feels like everyone else was still treating it like a song, but Sam was genuinely going through it if that makes sense. It stopped being about putting on a good show and became a true hysterical cry of anguish
@gianlucamalave63062 жыл бұрын
Collete is really, really, really good at riffing. I just love her so much
@AmaturebАй бұрын
Honestly I can’t pick and compare these incredible performers, but I’m gonna mention Annabel Marlow because I think she’s pretty underrated, especially considering she was the first person to perform as K Howard
@SimsAllAroundАй бұрын
Really cool that Toby got their sister to be apart of their first performance
@AmaturebАй бұрын
@@SimsAllAround Wait they’re siblings? I did wonder if they were related - that’s awesome.
@SimsAllAroundАй бұрын
@@Amatureb Yep 😁
@adamiel_warning11 ай бұрын
Jodie Steele, Samantha Pauly y Zara MacIntosh are my favorites for 'cause I feel the emotions better than with the others, that part is not necessary to be perfectly singed, is necessary to put the biggest emotions in it, even if that sacrifice the perfect sing, because the point is that she emotional broken and the emotions are the climax for over everything
@coyotix Жыл бұрын
The musical: Dont compare yourself to other people, this spreads misinformation and is a counterproductive way to learn. The fan base: Who sang the r@pe song best?
@kingkingwong39243 ай бұрын
LOL IKR
@juejue2_474 ай бұрын
JODIES VOICE SENT SHIVERS DOWN MY WHOLE BODY
@Decaying_r0seАй бұрын
Why is no one talking about bryony? Her singing was amazing!
@serenitythesiren50315 ай бұрын
Honestly Annabel Marlow is pretty good. You can hear the pain in her voice.
@Lennykins31208 ай бұрын
Sam just gives me chills with her emotion.
@narcissamalfoy886 Жыл бұрын
I love Sam's but i feel like we should give each K Howard love since there all good
@colinj17262 жыл бұрын
Omg, Maddison, HIT THAT RIFF. Holy COW, she's incredible. (Btw, my personal favorite Howards are Jodie and Sam; Jodie just does something to me and Sam could sing a song about farting and I would cry.)
@trassaya4 ай бұрын
Samantha Pauly is by far my favorite Catherine Howard! Her voice is phenomenal, and she sings and acts the hell out of this song. Everytime I hear her do it, I get goosebumps, and by the time she hits that final note, she always has me in tears. No other version of this song has been able to accomplish either of those things.
@aquaticanimations97892 жыл бұрын
They all portray her so good
@weknowtheend_2 жыл бұрын
Courtney S, Sam, Sophie, Collette, Alicia and Bryony are my faves!! Great video!
@CelesteStClair Жыл бұрын
Jodie Steele and Samantha Pauly have my favourite versions of this track by FAR
@parkerp49242 жыл бұрын
courtney monsma is criminally underrated..
@laurahenderson4528 Жыл бұрын
she is the best katherine howard i have ever seen!! not only in person but in all of these compilations!! she never struggles with the vocals and she PERFORMS such a strong yet quiet intensity !! she feels it, you don’t feel like she’s acting you can see her feeling it!! anyway i could go on for hours about how court is the best k howard
@ImThatBoleynGirlAndImUpNextSeeАй бұрын
HER OF THE FAIR IS THE BEST 😭
@pinkgoesgoodwithgreenАй бұрын
FINALLY SOMEONE SAID IT
@ashp4613 Жыл бұрын
To me no one can beat Samantha Pauly
@nigela.sepnio23394 ай бұрын
SOPHIA ISAACS MUST BE THE BEST REPRESENTATION ON KATHERYN HOWARD SHE MUST BE LIKE 17 YRS OLD WHEN SOPHIA ISAACS SUNG THAT
@ImThatBoleynGirlAndImUpNextSee4 ай бұрын
16:56 OMG, COURTNEY’S OF THE FAIR, ❤❤❤ prob the best of the fair I heard yet
@catskilsha8 ай бұрын
All of them are amazing but my favorites are Sam, Jodie, Sophie, Aimie and Alicia (and Hannah Lowther but she wasn't in this since her debut was only just over a month ago)
@spiderwickian Жыл бұрын
its got to be sam pauly or courtney mack for me! the pure emotion and trembles they have are just sensational!
@3xclusivelyShaniah2 жыл бұрын
I love Vicki and how she does the notes but I love ever k Howard they all make that character sound different
@egorrum8637 Жыл бұрын
Saw Courtney Monsmas version live and it was amazing, incredible talent 🙌
@Vladlovesbobo5 ай бұрын
I need nats full aywd
@helloitsme532 Жыл бұрын
Lol watching Sam Pauly's, which is absolutly amazing btw, andrea is rly getting into it.
@JoaquinSoza-e8x16 күн бұрын
I love aimee Atkinsons version as she was the og in the first studies recording but Sam pauly is gonna always be my top favorite
@justxxsunset2 жыл бұрын
i’ve never heard collete’s version before and omgggg i’m in love with her voice 😍😍😍✨✨✨
@jacobrostron1864 Жыл бұрын
Sam pauly just slays it like she is a cricking beast and can sing that song like a boss ❤
@Whynot_770 Жыл бұрын
All the girls were amazing but I think we can all agree that Sam Pauly is the best Howard ever
@kitwatson2537 Жыл бұрын
Toby marlow had a great choice for the broadway cast
@sandramahermurphy5 ай бұрын
I don’t think everyone agrees
@noypoll8 ай бұрын
Sam Pauly is the best in my opinion. she really brings emotion into the song, you can actually feel her journey and her realization.
@imthebossmermaid3648 Жыл бұрын
Sam Pauly killed it but Zara also encapsulates the horror and sadness of the situation as well. I think both are my top faves.
@ra1ndr4gon2 жыл бұрын
I like Amie’s and Sam’s the most
@Anniebellpotter Жыл бұрын
I know we’re all sitting here in appreciating Sam and I’m totally on the sam hype as she does incredible but can we also take a minute to appreciate how great Grace does!? Like chills
@다시마무청 Жыл бұрын
I watched Becca Wickes as Howard live a few days ago and she was just amazing
@ashleyj97 Жыл бұрын
Everyone - "sam pauly is amazing" Courtney Mack - 👁👄👁
@k_kace Жыл бұрын
aimie will always be my favourite k howie, but the emotion her, sam and grace, (well all of them really) put into it really portrayas how heartbreaking and sad the song and her life really was, howard always won the competition for me
@becauseyesandisaidso3474 Жыл бұрын
Sam is the goat! She shows so much emotion then everyone else!
@popgirl123xxx2 жыл бұрын
First time hearing zara I was so impressed with the acting as well🤩
@MechakoshiАй бұрын
The original student cast instrumental kinda slaps
@mckenzie81962 жыл бұрын
All I wanna do is listen to six the musical
@anica80428 ай бұрын
Sam Pauly really capture my heart. It feels like she's telling me to love myself other than looking for a man to love me.
@Daniiii_playsdatrumpet Жыл бұрын
Aimie Courtney s. Vicki M. Jodie S. Samatha p. sophie I (she sounded young like the accurate Kathrine H) Zara Collette Alicia C-C Georgia C are my favs
@ItsRickLopez2 жыл бұрын
I love the Heather Chandlers! Maddison Firth and Jodie Steele!
@st4r6028 ай бұрын
6:36 - sam pauly !
@aisnadi8511 Жыл бұрын
Zara, Jodie, Collete and Sam are my faves Zara's growls at the end and she was the only one I think who screamed instead of gasping at the end (gave me chills) Jodie's acting on her side is legit from happy go Lucky to heart broken is so cool and vocals from Collete goosebumps and Sams acting and singing is breathtaking literally
@0LaTanya6 ай бұрын
My personal ratings... Keep in mind this is just my opinion and its not based off of voice but on how much emotion they put into the verse. They all have beautiful voices! Annabel Marlow: 00:00 2/5 I personally don't feel it Aimie Atkinson: 00:55 Grace Mouat: 01:51 Courtney Stapleton: 02:47 Vicki Manser: 03:43 Jodie Steele: 04:39 Jennifer Caldwell: 05:36 Samantha Pauly: 06:37 Courtney Mack: 07:34 Sophie Isaacs: 08:30 Zara MacIntosh: 09:26 Collette Guitart: 10:20 Hana Stewart: 11:16 Alicia Corrales-Connor: 12:12 Bryony Duncan: 13:09 Natalie Pilkington: 14:04 Georgia Carr: 15:00 Elizabeth Walker: 15:26 Courtney Monsma: 16:21 Rebecca Wickes: 17:22 Maddison Firth: 18:18 Sadie Hurst: 19:14
@Posyopues2007Ай бұрын
You only ranked one tho
@ChantawnEnglish Жыл бұрын
Samantha Paula by far was the best. She embodied Katherine Howard! I loved it!
@JordanArrasmith2 жыл бұрын
It’s Sam and Jodie Steele for me
@Angel8L46 Жыл бұрын
Sam Pauly will always been at the top for me but damn Jodie's runs and riffs were so clean I love both their voices so much
@xxelectricrosexx73292 жыл бұрын
Alicia, Bryony, Natalie, Courtney Monsma, and Hana are my favorites!
@ji1072 Жыл бұрын
Samantha Pauly...hands down !
@jodhenvelarde2440 Жыл бұрын
si Samantha Paul
@jodhenvelarde2440 Жыл бұрын
si Samantha Pauly
@TheJstsofTheJsimps29 күн бұрын
A lot say Sam, while she did eat but Grace and Aimie is for me
@janationaltreasure Жыл бұрын
I just recently watched it live and the K Howard in that performance was Aline Mayagoitia, and I think she gave an emotionally similar performance to Sam Pauly. Sam had me almost crying because of my own history of being a victim of SA, but Aline also had me emotional Honorable mention to Aimie Atkinson bc I love her