people would let small things slide if the main plot was delivering it isn't so here we are
@Analyze_This54Күн бұрын
I thought the main plot was pretty good. People took issues with side things like the weight of a character.
@Youtube-C.I.A2 күн бұрын
People have different opinions and videos about their opinions. 😮😮 The horror!! Grow up. I mean, im sorry humans are not ants with a hive mind.
@Analyze_This54Күн бұрын
You totally missed the points I made in the video. I’m not saying we all have to be part of a hive mind. I was giving my thoughts on the reception the show received and why I don’t agree with some people’s opinion. This is kind of video is pretty common on KZbin lol.
@jfrancis61912 күн бұрын
Lucasfilm was an admirable private company. Disney is a disgusting corporate monopoly. That’s the difference.
@cobbler885 күн бұрын
I'm fine with the b!tching. What I don't care for is all the crying about how the fans are OWED this and that just because they liked a movie decades ago and bought a bunch of toys. Feel free to criticize he new monkey bars, but you did NOT build the playground.
@יקיטבע5 күн бұрын
When ubisoft was quality
@thiccmcchicken5506 күн бұрын
I might be biased but as someone who’s enjoys the first 2 sequels I can’t help but think that if we had gotten The Duel of fates for Ep9 everything would probably be a lot more peaceful
@kasaibouF297 күн бұрын
Interesting that you have issues with Disney Star Wars, yet you found enjoyment with Ahsoka. Perhaps Mauler's "Star Wars Cannot Grow Up" video isn't all that reliable, and on top of that, him grandstanding about consoomers contradicts what he said in his TFA critique "It's valid to say that you do or do not like something". So much for being consistent with your standards, am I right?
@moisieiev71249 күн бұрын
Fans - reason I left SW
@lucasszaroas10 күн бұрын
Awesome video man!
@decades191212 күн бұрын
I've gotten more into Ramble Radio and really appreciate your viewpoints.
@Analyze_This5412 күн бұрын
Glad you enjoy the podcast!
@decades191212 күн бұрын
My man is back! Huzzah! Good to see you, AT.
@tommyfamolare874014 күн бұрын
It was good I liked it. But I hope instead of having a second season we get a new tales series instead like tales of the sith or tales of the clones
@tommyfamolare874014 күн бұрын
People were complaining abt Ariana greenblat weight not being the same as animation ahsoka… fucking disgusting especially considering the fact that the woman in clone wars looked unhealthily skinny especially padme. And then they were complaining abt the lekku not being perfect when this is the best we can do at this time.
@mreszotnik14 күн бұрын
Also, I think part of the reason you you enjoyed the Star Wars content was that back in the day you were exposed to less negativity. Even vitriolic hatred suffered by George Lucas (for prequels), Ahmed Best, Karen Traviss (for writing novels showing the Jedi in bad light) was something only ardent fans were aware of. But now everyone has their own vision of Star Wars, and when you admit to enjoying a bit of it, you can be sure several killjoys will come up to spoil your fun. I think something like that happened to you with Ahsoka series. Imagine watching the ESB with someone who complains how AT-ATs are stupid camel-like boxy machines, how defeating them with towing cables was unrealistic, how damsel Luke saved in original Star Wars was stolen from him by bad boy Han, how "No, I am your father" reveal destroyed the characters of Luke, Obi-wan and Vader at the same time, and how if you enjoy any of it you are a tasteless hack. This is something especially casual fans are subjected to on a constant basis. Makes you wonder who in the right mind would want to become a part of this fandom.
@mreszotnik14 күн бұрын
I think the reason Lucasfilm should refocus on post-sequel trilogy content is threefold: 1. Just like Clone Wars cartoons elevated the prequel trilogy (e.g. by providing necessary context for Anakin's actions), it is very possible that extra content in the sequel era will elevate the sequels. 2. There are far more fans of the sequel trilogy than people here give it credit for. It's just they do not mingle with people who rag on the sequels. 3. You never want your franchise to actually be directed by passionate but ultimately misguided people - for instance people who would hate on Ahsoka series, without even watching it, because some shadowy influencer told a few lies about it. 4. Sequel trilogy is an easy point of entry for casual fans. As much as grognards would like to deny it, without casual fans this franchise dies.
@uimasterroshi17116 күн бұрын
Its not new. You people just did never learn to interact with people. Your world is only online thats why you cant deal with fans what have different oppinions and different viewpoints. A boring excuse that the fanbase is the worst, its not, it just doesnt follow one single bubble and people out of the bubble cant deal with that. Try to talk with real people about star wars... suddenly its complete different story. Online you will always only see the extreme of both sides
@ledinyourwallsАй бұрын
Seeing your other content you seem to be a bit misguided, the entire "woke agenda" thing is pretty much all nonsense. KK isn't some comic book supervillain trying to insert politics into sw, she's just a bad leader. I've heard a few times from some former lucasfilm employees that she really just lets writers do what they want with no control over them, additionally most of the "woke" stuff can easily be attributed to suits and advertising firms attempting to appeal to more people, which usually is a very botched job. Imo culture war content should be completely dismissed as often it just lies to the viewer or purposely misrepresents points all in the name of a pushing a silly "we are always winning" narrative, while personally Sw is at a low point seeing how the Mcu has greatly improved over the past year gives me hope that sw will eventually change as well. I hope you see this and perhaps it'll change your view on this subject as you seem a lot more open minded than most people in this fandom
@Analyze_This54Ай бұрын
I appreciate you checking out the content on the channel and seeing my viewpoints on a few different topics around Star Wars. I don’t hate KK like some, but I really wish they would change the way they did things over there. I definitely think “woke” is overused and it is misused. It’s annoying to see people call things woke automatically because the main character of a show is a woman or a non white person. Theres no denying that stuff is out there. But Lucasfilm does not have a focus on making really good Star Wars content. They care more about what’s happening in real life than in creating stories in a sci-fix universe that gives us a break from reality and can make use feel like a kid again. Until that happens I have zero confidence that I will ever truly love Star Again.
@ledinyourwallsАй бұрын
@@Analyze_This54personally I think things are looking up again, skeleton crew has been great so far and andor is most likely going to be a amazing but who knows with the Mando movie though, it'll probably succeed on the basis it's the first star wars movie in like 8 years but the quality is up in the air still, it probably won't be affected by the rewrites they had to do with BOBF and s3 which is good +it's already had a better production than most of the stuff that's came out. Apparently bob is getting replaced either this year or next year which means we could be potentially seeing KK finally going but who knows given that they still think that because she was somewhat successful financially with the sequels that she should be in charge of Sw
@Analyze_This54Ай бұрын
Skeleton Crew has been amazing. It’s a great story and the overall production quality is excellent. The Mando movie should be hit but the show has lost momentum over time. Season 3 was weak and so much time has passed that I don’t think people care as much as they did before. They badly need to make a movie soon though.
@ledinyourwallsАй бұрын
@@Analyze_This54it's Been long enough imo where people just want to take their families to see Sw again, TFA was literally just a rehash of ANH and it made 2 billion dollars, personally I'm probably going to be seeing it with my family next year as my mom is a fan of Mando
@ledinyourwallsАй бұрын
@@Analyze_This54additionally you see they are making a KOTOR show now? People are already complaining that it's going to be terrible and that it's going to ruin the story despite the fact they were all begging the eu's story's to be adapted
@ledinyourwallsАй бұрын
Let me add some extra context to that stupid for is female comment, it was a crumby tshirt at a nike meant to promote nke air forces. Legitimately nothing to do with SW but it's been twisted because reactionary's need someone to scapegoat and farm for views
@ledinyourwallsАй бұрын
Seeing your other content you seem to be a bit misguided, the entire "woke agenda" thing is pretty much all nonsense. KK isn't some comic book supervillain trying to insert politics into sw, she's just a bad leader. I've heard a few times from some former lucasfilm employees that she really just lets writers do what they want with no control over them, additionally most of the "woke" stuff can easily be attributed to suits and advertising firms attempting to appeal to more people, which usually is a very botched job. Imo culture war content should be completely dismissed as often it just lies to the viewer or purposely misrepresents points all in the name of a pushing a silly "we are always winning" narrative, while personally Sw is at a low point seeing how the Mcu has greatly improved over the past year gives me hope that sw will eventually change as well,
@Analyze_This54Ай бұрын
I can’t stand content creators that just make content to draw viewers. All this rage baiting, drama stirring content has made KZbin toxic. We can’t have fun and in-depth discussions on movies, shows, and games like we used to.
@ledinyourwallsАй бұрын
@@Analyze_This54exactly the amount of KK kicked my dog or "skeleton crew is failing!!!! KK crying!!!!" Videos I've seen has been insane I couldn't imagine watching such slop
@Analyze_This5429 күн бұрын
That's why I can't be 100% on the side of the fans. There are a lot of them that are just flat out ignorant. They give nothing a chance and they just thrive off of hating the franchise. Sure, it's in a rough state, but you can't have logical conversations or debates with these people.
@ledinyourwalls29 күн бұрын
@@Analyze_This54 especially those that watch culture war content, a while back I got in a argument with a guy that legitimately thought that one Disney Michael Jackson movie was becoming cannon because of the reference to it in the first episode of skeleton crew and instead of actually listening just started insulting me lmao
@ledinyourwallsАй бұрын
Ive literally seen a guy shit on everything that comes out while being a zack snyder fan lmao, high standers my ass
@chuckkosajr690Ай бұрын
I miss these games a ton(the main line entries). I wish I had a way to still play them. I would love to see remasters of the originals and for them to finally give us the fourth installment to finish up baker’s story and for the fact that you know they were heading to the battle of the bulge when legget ask’s baker “do you like snow” and poof the series was gone
@Analyze_This54Ай бұрын
I want them to come back and make one more game! Finish it off with the Battle of the Bulge. I miss having games like this where you just simply play through the missions, but get to enjoy a great story and a great group of characters. I’d also love to see more shooters like this where you can command squads of soldiers under your command.
@Emerald_BlasphemerАй бұрын
I feel like a lot of the modern Star Wars fandom have kind of forgotten where Star Wars came from. Honestly, I think it would do a lot of the more jaded Star Wars fans good if they sat down and rewatched the original trilogy again with the same standards they have for every other Star Wars property and see if they come away from it with the same level of reverence that they had when they went in. Because I wouldn't be surprised if they didn't. There is a good amount to criticise about the OT. A lot of people might come to the realisation that they just don't like Star Wars as much as they thought they did. They might find that they have just as much to criticise about the OT as they do every other Star Wars property. I think it would be a very interesting experiment if nothing else.
@SubtleReignАй бұрын
If u really tried to defend disney starwars shut the hell up cuz ur observational skills are very lacking that u could tell this was all going to happen when u saw how the star wars rebel show and first movie they made.
@Analyze_This54Ай бұрын
It'd be great if the end of your comment made more sense so I can give a proper reply. You must have been more worried about being an aggressive internet tough guy in the first part of your comment telling me to shut up lol.
@SubtleReignАй бұрын
@Analyze_This54 i fixed it just two words saw how not say the no more, im not being an internet tough guy im being the guy to tell u to shit up if u dont know what the fuck u are talking about if u can make or see the connections to why shit is bad
@SubtleReignАй бұрын
@Analyze_This54 but im general it the same has how if u could see how tv became shittier and shitter after cartoon network switch from 2007-8 was the clear sign of how shit was going to go. Disney later did the same thing got rid of amazing toon disney jetix and replaced it with shitty trash male version of terrible acting and scripted shows from regular disney channel. This was 2008-9 for disney. Nickelodeon same thing but but this one took the longest to become trash but it did happened around a year or 2 after disney and now we have the shit like sanja and craig and other shows that i dont remember the names or didnt dont last. There are so many examples to that show the transition persiod from good television to woke trash that is nothimg but pandering or just falling in to the greed hole and fills it with the easy way to make money play on peoples nostalgia and bring in the group of people that feel the most segregated in society so we can play on the abults behavoirs and thought they have for woke things not race but the lgbt stuff while exposing the children of the people to it so then they can later forcibly calm down and conform the parents or not by having them deal with the morale dilemma of. Am i a shitty bad person or parent cuz of how i treat my kids because they are gay now or tranny, or non binary or etc..., ik this is a bad written somewhat rant but is completely true cuz there is no science based evidence that humans can be nonbinary or chang genders. And sure is not by how they feel and behave and if u think thats true that is what a woke person would believe. Just in case, woke do not mean u are soicial aware of segregated, injustice, and blah blah blah. Todays use of the woke have been twisted soo much that liberals from the 90s are not the same as leftist of todays world thats while the leftiest from the early 2000s and 90s and 80s have became ore joined the republican side more.
@SubtleReignАй бұрын
@Analyze_This54 oh and it sucks that the early 2000s and 90s cartoon had alot of diversity and representation. People act like they didnt. Or how people say their wasnt enough or any strong female protagonist or characters back then in anything but thats only due to the women characters back then actually lool8ng hot and not being ugly as fuck and arrogant as female characters are today
@tommyfamolare874014 күн бұрын
@@SubtleReigndude wtf are u even talking abt. I agree u can’t change ur gender but wtf does this have to do with Star Wars. This just seems like u have some other issues u have and need to work through
@alexfraser8352Ай бұрын
Disney will never diminish my love for what George Lucas created.
@LordLawwritesforfansАй бұрын
Disney / Lucasfilm are you listening? I have the stories and a plan for next twenty years of success. Let me pitch please. Have Hope fans!
@TheCambotАй бұрын
I find it ironic you keep saying “go look at this or that lore”. Yet it seems like you have never actually browsed any of these stories You sound like someone who just scrolled wikipedia. Especially on the vague reasoning (also really Dark Empire? that’s a notoriously bad in the EU)
@Analyze_This54Ай бұрын
So you want me to make a video that’s 10 hours long talking about every single piece of Star Wars media ever created? Sure, I haven’t read everything thing but I have read some stuff and I’ve made it a point to at least do some research into things I haven’t checked out yet. Have you read and watched every piece of content ever created in Star Wars?
@TheCambotАй бұрын
@ have I browse every single Star Wars media? No but I have browsed the majority of the EU. From games, tv shows, comics, novels & etc. But if I discuss them I won’t be super vague about them. I love the EU? But I’m not begging for them to be made for some movie or tv show. Because it 9.9/10 it won’t happen, and I already got those stories.
@Analyze_This54Ай бұрын
Talking about them was not the point of my video lol. I think it would be a great idea to bring some of those stories to life by making some movies or shows about them. At least generate some new ideas from that stuff. I’d rather talk about the last point you made rather than sit here and have a measuring contest on who knows the most about the EU lol.
@TheCambotАй бұрын
@ I didn’t mean to have a Star Wars EU knowledge measure contest. I’m just saying it comes off vague wookiepedia browsing. And you just threw them out vaguely. Besides the EU is constantly used in the new canon shit. Like almost everything has something from the EU in it. If you know anything of the EU. You would know the EU constantly has things used. Why make them movies or shows. When every Star Wars film has been crap after ROTJ. And the only good Star Wars shows are TCW & clone wars 2003? Why would you want more bad movies or tv shows?
@Analyze_This54Ай бұрын
I would argue that there’s a ton of stuff out there that they haven’t used. Sure, they took some things from the Thrawn trilogy and put it into Ahsoka. But there’s a lot of different stories that haven’t been used. I’m curious, what would you like to see them make in the future for movies and shows?
@DanielFincannonАй бұрын
The only Star Wars show i haven't liked is The Acolyte. And EA's Battlefront II is my favorite video game of all time!
@ltokes66Ай бұрын
She’s not fighting against racist fans, she fighting for trans BS and queer crap. There is no place for this crap in kids movies. I hope she finally gets fired so we don’t have to watch crap like the Acolyte. Garbage in = Garbage out.
@MARSHALL_SLAYERАй бұрын
I wanna keep loving this franchise but so many crappy shows and movies have been made and continue to get pushed and I just lost all hope in the Force dude 😔 I been a fan ever since I was 5 when my parents got us the Phantom Menace on vhs and then would rent us the og trilogy and I was enamored on the get go. Watching the sequels and the tv shows that came after it make me feel like the last good Star Wars was Rogue One or Revenge of the Sith. I just wanna keep loving this franchise but it’s body is already decomposed and Mickey is still trying to sell us a fresh horse
@airoe_games8743Ай бұрын
They do it because people like you will make videos to point it out and create more drama around it. Stop caring, stop supporting.
@Master_OrdolАй бұрын
🎯
@briantate8176Ай бұрын
When your more worried about being politically correct than doing a good job it's time to go.
@nicklengyel356Ай бұрын
Kathleen Kennedy needs to go
@-Grovesy-Ай бұрын
One thing that bothered me most is Finn's love interest. They met briefly. People thought Anakin and Padme were cringy when that exists.
@ariaownsyouАй бұрын
Ahsoka, Sabine* and Jyn are all proof Disney can write good female protagonists, they just need to be writing them for purposes besides having a female protagonist. (*Sabine in Rebels and Ahsoka in CW season 7)
@zombiespock4512Ай бұрын
The gayest ever? Seriously, dude? Then you say you're OK with gay characters. Stupid or crappy would have been more honest of you.
@Analyze_This54Ай бұрын
I'm not calling it that in an insulting way. That's what the director and actors in the Acolyte said it was during interviews. That was their goal with the show.
@tinynuggins1029Ай бұрын
Why not just focus on... Star Wars when writing Star Wars? 95% of the people that watch Star Wars agree that racism and sexism are bad. We just dont want to be patronized and have lessons about these subjects ham fistedly crammed down our throats like were all these broken, sexist, racist people that a few woke episodes of Star Wars will fix. The Star Wars movies originally were in essence a story of good vs evil. George Lucas used every other theme or subtext very subtlety. He didnt make Leia a badass to make her into a girlboss that fights the patriarchy just as hard as she fights the Empire. No, he made her a badass strong woman because thats what the character called for so thats what she was. Disney can and had made some pretty good Star Wars shows. They know how. I cant understand why they still insist on trying to indoctrinate us with things most of us already agree with instead of just writing good shows with good plot and character development. Notice that in the good shows nobody complains about any of the female or minority characters....because we dont care! If they're good characters we dont care what color or sex they are! Yet somehow Disney still blames it on the narrow-minded viewers when they make a bad show nobody likes.
@perangoriginal9052Ай бұрын
Not star wars, but i feel like the owl house did this pretty well
@arsena1147Ай бұрын
Amen
@En_Saban_NurАй бұрын
Your argument still doesn’t stand, every time a person of color, a female, anything to do with the alphabet squad, your team says the writing is bad, it’s just as bad as Saying woke, you’re not believable, you just come off as another bigot.
@Analyze_This54Ай бұрын
And the problem with your side is that they think everyone is racist and bigoted. If you truly listened to my points and checked out the rest of my channel then you would see I am not what you claim I am. But people throw around “names” when they don’t agree with someone. I’m not on the team that constantly complains about shows that feature the people you mentioned above. I agree that people like that exist. But I’m not one of them. It’s clear when you look at my channel.
@user-em5fr6zv3uАй бұрын
I was born in 1997 and from my point of view star wars is only growing they sure make mistakes but that is what People said about 1 2 and 3 but for me the story isnt even complete wittout 1 2 and 3 when you grow older you eccept the star wars that you get there is a new generation and at least we can talk about new star wars projects and at least star wars still goed on and about the acolyte i did really like the serie i dint care there were gay People or Black People its star wars i really hope we get to see more acolyte i really do
@bogdantirea6085Ай бұрын
I GUESS THIER ORDERS ARE TO DESTROY STAR WARS
@ChristopherGreen-wf8qcАй бұрын
They don't exist.
@Gideon0297Ай бұрын
KK has failed the franchise. Just make great stories, not politically agenda driven drivel.
@Coffeeman-yq6xuАй бұрын
Star Wars is dead. End of story.
@SpencerStanford-e9bАй бұрын
But it wasn’t a problem until Kathleen Kennedy got involved
@LocoLuke0Ай бұрын
you wanna know how you deal with racist/sexist fans. you make a movie so damn good that they don’t give a fukc who they’re watching
@malcolmhardwick4258Ай бұрын
Disney woke shit killed Star Wars.
@mothepro1515Ай бұрын
Agreed
@OmhikmatАй бұрын
With Timothy Zahn's six Thrawn novels set in the Kennedy Canon, I was hopeful that Kennedy and Company were going to do more with the Chiss Ascendancy. That's a part of the Star Wars galaxy that is open to explore with little to no lore to get in the way of creativity. I would love more adventures with Aralani and others. The Chiss are all people of color too!
@crprodvidsАй бұрын
They act like Lando and Leia and Padme never existed lol
@danielfarnell3076Ай бұрын
we're all trash humans
@limarien6405Ай бұрын
As a queer person I really appreciate the way you put this. Representation is good, but do it right
@Analyze_This54Ай бұрын
Thank you. I’m glad I was able to convey my thoughts in a proper way.
@Basilsik808Ай бұрын
I have a question for you. Do you get offended if lgbtq isn’t represented in fictional content. Like, say, if there was a book to movie adaptation and in the og book there were no lgbtq characters. If the movie did NOT add any, would you still be upset?