Thanks much!

I think you should have put the mic's mounts more at rear because the capsules are too much in front, close to the end of the disc... But interesting vidéo

The felt one had the most coherent center image to my ears, which is the most important function of the disk IMO. I would have liked to hear them panned 100% left and right too. I would put a single speaker playing pink noise in the middle and then use a correlation analyzer to see which does the best

I'm building four tubes presently and watched your video. I am relieved your approach is almost identical to mine. I will proceed. Thumbs up

I liked the corkboard best, sounded the cleanest to me compared to the cardboard that has more reverb to it. But I don't see why you would use the JDisk in a studio with a single player. You could also mic the guitar with two mics and pan it. Probably more useful for a group where you would want the stereo effect.

Thank you, I'm gonna use this.

How would I hang heavier panels

4:47 7:04

Does this help with sound coming from the outside room? I’m trying to quiet noise from my landlords side of the house 😂

So it’s better not to stack them and put each in their own corner? Also is it better than super chunks?

Are they useful for recording guitar home studio recording?

Вы молодцы ребят!

Never heard of these but I can see why they make a difference. You might try denting the cardboard or adding some cloth strings in different patterns for texture.

Jordan is so coool!

would work better if you cut rock wool in circles and filled tube, could have just siliconed lids on top and bottom, the wood in the middle doesn't help much probably makes it more vulnerable to the lids shifting. No need to cut holes in tube.

is there a reason you dont build them from floor to roof?

So the half of paper on insulation will block the preesure (the bass frequencies) to go thru?? wau .. amazing

They look nice but in audio things don't work by the looks. Do you have any numbers on how low they absorb and how much ?

Can't hear any difference with or without 😅

10:47 - lolol

Is there a acoustic reason for using 1.5" holes spaced 8" apart? Can I just make random 2" holes around the tube, or is there a point when there are too many holes?

For small rooms, 4" thick wall panels should always be the minimum. Using 2" thick panels and a 2" air gap is more mounting work than it's worth. A 4" flush panel works better than a 2" panel with a 2" air gap. If you only have a 1" or 2" thick wall panel to work with... fine air gap it, otherwise get a 4" wall panel and forget about air gapping.

Down the rabbit hole we go

what is the most effective way to tame a ~30 Hz node ?

Well done my man

What was your budget per trap?

We’re no more in 2016. But “Organized” is my word for 2022

How do you feel about your traps 5 years later? Your design I would’ve thought would catch on as it was more involved than the typical diy version using just the rolled up insulation and clothes. Any thoughts on how they’re doing or if you’ve moved on from these? Thanks!

I need to be able to do this without drilling into wall and damaging it in a apartment. Any suggestions?

I’m wondering why you wouldn’t go one step further and simply fill the tube with rock wool?

Thanks for making this video.

Loved this, Simple 👌🏾

Could this be done with 12" PVC pipes instead instead of the concrete form?

What size screw and anchors are you using?

Hi, how do you know how high to hang it? Like how far up from the ground? Thanks!

Thanks guy and Rob McElhenney

Wouldn't that tube cover reflect the wave than absorb?

Nice video guys! Have you made measurements and know in what frequency range it works?

For proper A/B'ing, you should switch immediately between sources, all the best mix and mastering engineers do this when evaluating subtle moves. We have terrible sound memory for the tiny differences between sounds, so listening to one, then 30 seconds later, listening to another is far from the best way to analyze two similar sounds. With these time links, you can quickly jump to different sounds, like strumming with no disk right to strumming with cardboard disk. I think you'll be surprised in what you hear. I prefer no disk at all - larger image, and it sounds more "natural" meaning it doesn't sound like the sound was "messed with" which is a sense I get with any of the disks. I don't have the aural sophistication to pick out exactly what the messed with sound is, but I've learned to trust my ears. When something sounds unnatural, I don't use it. 4:47 Strumming, no disk. 5:45 Strumming, disk w/ foam. 6:24 Strumming, disk w/ cork. 7:04 Strumming, disk w/ felt. 7:44 Strumming, disk w/ cardboard. 5:04 Picking, no disk. 5:59 Picking, disk w/ foam. 6:39 Picking, disk w/ cork. 7:19 Picking, disk w/ felt. 8:00 Picking, disk w/ cardboard.

Were you in a comedy?

are u from the walking dead

Means nothing if not measured.....

you can use a router with a top bearing flush trim bit to cut the wood to the shape of the tube. It follows the contour of the tube and only cuts the wood outside of the tube. The tube will act as a template.

Have you tested how much attenuation you get in the sub 100Hz range in dB? I've heard great things about tube traps being able to absorb low frequency energy without taking up the space and weight of a diaphragmatic absorber, but considering the amount of absorptive material in your finished product, it doesn't seem like it would absorb a lot of low frequency at all.

Nice job. Thanks for sharing.

One of the Best Ideas of SoundProofing is "SoundProof Curtains" That Stops Outside Noise by 80% (25 Db) Tested. Check Here: livesoundproof.com/best-soundproof-curtains/

One of the Best Ideas of SoundProofing is "SoundProof Curtains" That Stops Outside Noise by 80% (25 Db) Tested. Check Here: livesoundproof.com/best-soundproof-curtains/

You can measure the circumference before you mark the 4 inches and adjust accordingly. If the circumference was 27 inches, for example, you would need to figure out a number that will work evenly all the way around.

Skip video when u drill n put that panel at the bracket...its waste my time..i want see it..argh🥺

Thousands of lifetime projects with Woodprix plans.