One of the weaker efforts, along with Jabreezy

really interesting that this fooled them. out of all the performances.

That was such wonderful misdirection. Love it

Holy shit. It was too obvious to even realize. Why didn't I see that the first time.

Well that was easy

This is so stupidly obvious.

Damn, sometimes the editing of this show throws me off because it doesn't stay focused on a performance shot, but taking everyone's advice and watching it again, I do see now how he loaded the cookie, that was damn clever because it was so natural our brains don't think about it.

i was focusing so much on everything that i was not supposed to focus on, after watching it a second time it was so unrealistically obvious, and i got no clue how the hell i didn't notice, but DAMN was that a great act nonetheless, brought humor into it as well, loved it

I watched this trick about a dozen times when I first met my now step daughters and until their recent teenage years, they had me perform it every time their friends would come over several times a year. I can’t solely credit the trick to my family loving me but it sure helped

Everyone has a plan until they get a milk and cookie. - Mike Tyson

This trick is so stupidly simple on the second viewing. XD They were fooled because they were overthinking it.

I know how it's done and all but I'm still sold, what a fantastic performance. Teller fumbled the bag by not also spitting the milk back into the cup, it would've made the cookie reveal far funnier but still a great gag all around. really, really well done.

Teller looked like he noticed the load. I would bet my money on it actually.

He fooled them? Didnt he just hold the cookie and milk in his mouth and spit it out again? If thats magic, then everyone smuggling drugs must be a magician

All the people on the comments going how could you miss it but you also forget that you are watching a recording of what's going on and you're not in the moment.

I may not be able to string the whole act together, but I saw how he loaded the cookie. I cant help but feel like Im missing something. Beside the cookie load, the milk didnt return in the same amount that he put in his mouth. So am I missing something? It seemed like Penn knew the trick with the nail and the milk didn't really seem like a trick, so was it really the cookie that fooled him? Or was it something else? And if it was the cookie, I think it was because Penn might have been focused on Teller when Chris Rose snuck the second cookie in. Can someone confirm or deny something I've said?

Haha loved the Fooled U (FU!) trophy!

how did noone see the load lmao

That was a good trick, but all of the elements were so easy to see if you were looking, I don’t know how Penn and Teller missed them. It kinda feels like the results were predetermined.

A perfect example of how a magician does something unnatural while making it look like something totally natural.

I would be always sceptical eating anything from a magician’s props, even if it’s edible. Who owns how long it was lying there

I never noticed where the cookie came from until someone said about the cookie load and now I know. Damn. I've watched the video countless times and didn't notice it before. Very sneaky.

I often enjoys these clips, but this one is my favourite so far :)

I've probably seen this clip a dozen or more times, and I never saw the cookie load until now. Amazing!

I just noticed, but in a later season, Teller gives Penn a very concerned look after he asked if he could take a deck of cards from a magician during the act, and not during the bust phase. Penn was very upset at himself for doing, and called himself out for cheating before exonerating himself by proclaiming the magician fooled them anyway. Well, well, well, tell me if Teller didn't just pick up that cookie and take it right there in violation of the show's rules. He effectively took a guess at how the trick was done by taking the prop; and they keep themselves to only one guess. Again, this is a case, where this was a fooler anyway; but it goes to show that he has done the same thing himself.

I didn't notice it the first time, but it's actually stupidly simple lol

is anyone else here on a 3 hour penn and teller fooler marathon?

It was so simple and obvious, they looked it over and couldn't figure it out. It's maybe the most brilliant trick on this show

Oh i realized when he put it. That was so smooth but i think teller noticed

It worked because no one expected that 👍🏻

I really like how you loaded that. Super simple but so natural that it goes completely unnoticed!

While Teller is standing beside him, you can watch his eyes looking him up and down watching every little movement. That alone is fascinating to watch.

Chris Rose is funny plus he's a great magician..

Yea if he’d just kept it in his mouth it might have gotten cracked or it at least would have gotten soaked when he drank the milk

Yes the cookie was easy but the nail!

Allison Hannigan hosted this?

Teller completely watched him slip it in.. He left Penn to guess

Has que la gente se ría y carga un elefante.

I’m just trying to figure out when the nail went in the nose

The way he says yes! After teller goes for the cookie, he knew he fooled teller.

The way he did it was so obvious, that’s why they didn’t see it. Cause why would he make it so obvious

How did they not get it?! I saw it straight away, it was too obvious

I was expecting Teller to know the trick and follow you by spitting out the milk. It was a pretty big surprise to me when he didn't and an even bigger surprise when you produced the cookie! Great performance.

Yeh. YOU JUST LOST. Great misdirection 😂😂😂

The trick was hidden in plain sight. Clever. Risky, but clever.

Wow.... I the average man figure out the trick watching one time

So easy to spot when you watch it back

Chris, this was the first trick from FU I ever saw and it led me to becoming a regular watcher of the show. Congrats on such a great routine, just A+ stuff.

I fully understand by seeing the video only one time about how he did it but I don't know why Pen and Teller acted like they don't understand how he did that. This trick was a child's play

i think there were a few misdirections on purpose to distract Teller and they worked really well. nice