You need to check out the Ross Kemp version

WHY THE STUPID ANNOYING CRAP BACKGROUND MUSIC WHICH TOTALLY PUTS YOU OFF WHAT ID BEING SAID ?????

Lame cop out ending. Season six felt like it was directed and edited by some snobby tryhard film student.

I think Tony knew he was going to get locked up

CARMELA. Expensive life. Kills Tony. 25% for the asbestos was a god deal. To keep the Pax Soprana.

Stanley was trying to tell us about Epstein, Weinstein, Diddy

It's a death scene but who said he was shot? Maybe Tony had a heart attack and the grey jacket 🤌🤌🤌 is just someone unrelated to this event, just there to confuse the viewer

It's a stupid, terrible movie. Btw in the book, he never escapes to the surface.

Il put it this way: the worm suggesting a "quicker way" to the castle by Sarah's departure reminds me of the line from Pilgrim's Progress at the end of that book: "....there was a way to Hell, even from the gates of Heaven..."

My friend who loves music played Barbara Ellen on the first try..

Eugene was a rat 🐀

Kubrick reportedly never included randomness in his props or scenes Runtime 6.30 Suspicious man standing by shop called [A Hint of] Crossing road [STOP CHB Verona Returant] Wonder whether this is an early reference to the 'Pizza Parties' we have heard about? The graffiti is a little hard to make out, but generally if you want to analyse look at the background as well.

Kubrick knew how to attach a legendary soundtrack to the film he makes.

We make a point of watching the Muppets version every year on Xmas eve or Xmas day. I found the DVD on e-bay that doesn't cut out Belle's song (which was cut from many media available because it didn't pass muster with some or other "test audience"). Sim, Scott, Owens, and Finney all have their good points.

I know the right words! Goblin King Goblin King, where ever you might be- Come and take this child of mine far away from me!

Is Robert Patrick the guy with the cap? He had many reasons to kill Tony 😅

The term “surplus population” was a comment about how Britain had to import food because they couldn’t grow enough to feed everyone. Dickens’ used that term because it’s something that politicians of his day were saying.

Who said Tony died?

Ruling out Butchie is a mistake.

It was blatantly obvious Phil's crew had him done in retaliation for Phil, simple as that, they gave Tony the greenlight to kill Phil in the final chilly meeting and then naturally went ahead and whacked Tony in turn to cover up their own betrayal of their own crew member. Cos if they hadnt then questions wouldve been left floating about why Phil was killed. Youd think Tony wouldve considered he was being set up considering the crew asked him to do it cos they didnt want to get their own hands dirty.

some note Stanley wanted the narration like the earlier film.

Lesser known made for TV adaptation with Robert Guillome, John Grin’s Christmas. It’s not very long, has a different take, but deserves a mention.

Alastair Sim version of Scrooge has always been my favorite.

Unpopular opinion: The Alastair Sim version is awful & my least favorite Scrooge. I've seen almost all he adaptations at this point and I will never watch that particular version ever again

Right from the start, I really HATE any musical versions of A Christmas Carol, mostly because I HATE musicals and musical theater. My favorite versions of A Christmas Carol are the dramatic versions, like the one from 1938 starring Reginald Owen and the 1999 movie starring Sir Patrick Stewart.

Why no mention of Patrick Stewart?

Idk, I've never found Alistair Sim believable, especially as the reformed Scrooge. It looked more like he'd gone mad to me. Michael Cain to me was probably one of the weakest Scrooges George C Scott was probably my favourite one

Reginold Owen the best IMO.

Alistair Sim's portrayal is the best that all others are judged upon. There is a colorized version as well with Alistair Sim

Muppet Christmas Carol is my vote!

I totally agree with you. Michael Caine is the best Scrooge and Muppet Christmas Carol is the best version of the tale. I do have a fondness for the 1994 Alan Menken-composed A Christmas Carol, shown annually at Madison Square Garden in NYC until 2003. It has wonderful songs and featured a friend of mine originating the role of Christmas Past. It was filmed in 2004 with Kelsey Grammer and was, to me, rather awful, but is worth watching for the songs. I grew up with Mr. Magoo's Christmas Carol, another one with great songs.

George C Scott and Michael Cain hands down. Also you've got to love Bean Bunny in Muppet Christmas Carol!

1951 version is one of the best ever made.

He’s not dead! The man just took him to a nice farm to live with his dog

Alistair Sim and Albert Finney

The 1970 one is the the best.

George C Scott is my favorite. He has the perfect voice, the perfect temperament.

Jim Carrey's voice-over performance was great

My favorite version is the musical "Scrooge", but I've enjoyed many of the ones you've listed here.

ALISTER SIMS ALL THE WAY!! STILL SCARES THE 😱 💩 OUT OF ME! EACH EVERY CHRISTMAS EVE ! A FAMILY TRADITION

Aside from Alastair Sim, my other favorite Scrooge is Patrick Stewart. However, I'm unsure why you showed him a few times in the beginning but totally left his version of A Christmas Carol out of the rest of the video? I really like his version of the story, as it provides a lot of the backstory to the early parts of Scrooge's life (something that some of the other films don't cover). The supporting cast is also quite good in this one. I recommend that everyone check out that film, if you haven't done so already.

Was with it till he said Muppet Christmas Carol is his favorite adaptation. What a load of rubbish. Thumbs down. If I had to pick my favorite, it would be a tossup between Sim and Scott, with Hicks (1935) a close second/third.

Albert Finney is the greatest Scrooge.

Sim rules!

The 1938 version with Reginald Owen is my favorite!! I watch it every year! My elementary school used to show it to all the grades on the last school day before Christmas vacation! No one plays a scarier Marley than Leo G. Carroll! Seeing the redemption of Owen’s Scrooge is a delight and all that you would expect a repentant Scrooge to be. Well done in my opinion!

George C. Scott is my favorite Scrooge with Patrick Stewart a very close 2nd.

Thank you for your most perfect reviews of a wonderful Christmas Story. My husband's favorite for years is the George C Scott version. It is beautifully filmed and beautifully acted by George and others. We have purchased dvds of Christmas movies rather than going on a hunt each year. Each year we watch: George C Scott, Bill Murray,. Because of your review I will mark some to watch next year.

Michael Caine will always be the best Scrooge for me. Second best, one you didn't mention, probably because he isn't in a "A Christmas Carol" as a movie, is Christopher Plummer as Scrooge in "The Man Who Invented Christmas!

Alister Sim is the best for me!

1938 version is the favorite for my family .