Honestly I could see that final three happening, they’re all decently iconic

i think that my favourite would surprise you

12:00 me when I see my school.

This is really original, also there are tons of good changes

i know someone already pointed this out but 12:00 damn

What if profiley joined tpot with td?

finally i am at peace

racism.

This is good and all but i have a problem with this. In the volcano challenge, firey dies becauze of the fish monster. He would probably die in this timeline as well. So the challenge would be a beuty contest. So firey and FLOWER would win. So flower wouldnt get eliminated here. I think blocky would get eliminated. THEN flower would get eliminated. Tb would place 3rd,firey would be 2nd and td would be 1st.

Hey yall, I made a slight error with Blocky. At one point I said he got himself another win token for being the last one standing during the handstand challenge, but he actually never got a win token for rejoining in this What If. Also I forgot to add the 15 points from that win token to Blocky’s score. Thankfully, this doesn’t change anything in the grand scheme of things.

This does not seem realistic at all

Kinda crazy how this little change made teardrop win the season LOL

Somehow it does kinda feel like Blocky was supposed to stay in the game longer than he did, honestly. I wonder if Eraser being gone would have made Snowball more one of the Jocks, to be honest--basically an alternate, I guess?

I would’ve loved Woody rejoining too bad he didn’t

I've always though about what if these thing were canon, like in the og bfb storyboard rocky survived and the annoucer stayed

I feel like Firey could've still won, since TD didn't have too much of a personality back then, so it's not impossible for Firey to still win over TD, especially on what WebzForevz said on his "What if BFDI was Vote to Save?" Video, with Firey being EXTREMELY Popular, but still definitely could've gotten very far, but what if he did still Win in the Timeline where Leafy picked Woody over Rocky? Well, since that Ferris Wheel Scene never happened since Leafy and Firey never formed a Bond in BFDI 20, Firey wouldn't have any problems with Leafy. But who would take Leafy's Place into Stealing Dream Island instead? It would be Coiny, even with Coiny saying that he had grown closer to Firey than anyone has ever known, He thinks about it for a few seconds, and ultimately rejects his speech and says, "Nice Try, Coiny, But I Will NEVER, EVER, LET YOU INTO DREAM ISLAND" and then tells him that he has moved on from him, and Instead of Firey accepting Coiny into Dream Island, he would reject him, and we would then get this Flashback Sequence to a Backstory of why he hates Coiny so much, and then shuts the Gates on Coiny, and therefore he steals Dream Island, which puts the rest of the Episode's Events into Motion, except that Coiny is in Leafy's Place, and it would make a Lot more sense as well, given on how much Coiny wanted Dream Island, especially when you take his Speech from BFDI 12 into account. No One would be willing to save Coiny in the End when he gets Executed, and before the Credits Roll, Flower's Announcer Crusher would either turn him into a Pancake, or he would crumble into Pieces which would go flying, which therefore, kills him "forever" along with Bubble, Flower, and Woody, and everyone would take Cover when Coiny's Pieces go flying, and they would then celebrate. How would have this affected BFDIA as a result? (This timeline where he wins instead of Teardrop or the Normal Timeline where that Ferris Wheel Scene NEVER Happens, doesn't really matter, I'd be satisfied with either option, but more likely the latter since Teardrop won.)

What if the cherries chose golf ball over rocky?

I personally think that Dora would have joined instead since people would want to see how she'll interact with David.

Well i love robotyyy And also, he didn’t even want to join BEEP, when leafy asked roboty to join, he said “-.. -- -. -“ which transalated to DONT.

Roboty has always been my favorite, so I really hope people start to see that he’s really not that bad, and isn’t just “bland”.. Like a depressed robot? Come on, how could you not feel bad for him..

Idea: What if no one could rejoin (or debut) in BFDI?

Idea: What if no one could rejoin (or debut) in BFDI?

Shouldn’t heather have been 8th with Courtney, and Blaineley 4th? Why was Heather 3rd if she got an average of 7.25?

I’m so happy Roboty is getting the love he deserves

Here’s a fun idea: what if the now bfdi 7 deleted scene was canon, and the squashy grapes got woody and the squishy cherries got blocky?

wanna add a quick note Roboty saying he "saved the day" in tpot 11 could be him finally gaining confidence in himself and having a chance at redemption, hence why he's so desperate to join tpot with the other exitors

This feels very accurate iancers is probably my favorite Bfdi what if creator

Hate this tb is king coiny= stupid unless BFDIA and after BFDIA

I’m not completely sure if Snowball would beat Coiny in the first elimination, but this still feels really realistic so

Tennisball looks cute falling into the tlc in the thumbnail😊

1:03 Snowball would most likely get dogpiled in a vote since viewers see him way meaner Then Coiny

It would’ve been the worst if Coiny stayed. I ABSOLUTELY DETEST COINY!

Thanks for doing my idea