What If David Was in BFDI From the Start?

I didn't add a proper transition in the last few seconds and now I'm never going to let it go

[@mmmchezburgers8699]

The way this would change the whole story of Bfdi, because flower won’t be the first eliminated she won’t win BFB and that would mean Someone else would have won.

[@princelandrycrusher]

Cool video. ^^ Here's a What If idea what if BFDI had a proper antagonist. Another what if idea is what if there weren't any rejoins and all eliminations were permanent. :)

[@Emporer_flimsy_whale]

So basically if heather was in bfdi instead of tdi tda and tdwt

[@GhostPepperWhopper]

Pen won Dream Island. Now he can put up a big sign saying “Pen Island”, with no spaces and in all caps.

[@Icezil]

yeahh i love *potty launguage* land

[@Dapprtnt]

PENISLAND

[@Algodoo123]

Spoilers

[@Dapprtnt]

My comment

[@CYANMARKER]

How dare you spoil it

[@Tree.0_o]

Idea for next video: what if pin and coiny in BFDIA 2 wouldn't chose teardrop?

[@mario-kart-nick-and-dkr-fan]

Pen winning Dream Island would be very interesting, although I think he'd still get out for cheating in some contests. If he made it to the end, he'd have to have some massive character development. Maybe Leafy convinced him not to cheat and he followed through?

[@3D_PUPPO]

Finally woody isnt literally last place

[@ginbing123]

I have an idea, What if win tokens still existed after the merge?

[@ElloBoi712]

Just to add to why Rocky got eliminated, we can assume he still kicks TB into a fire

[@goodboi7026]

Hear me out for this one: What if Rocky was eliminated instead of Match in BFDI 14?

[@Gartenofgiraffesisback-bq9qn]

BFDI but the first 20 failed debuters are in in and the debut is between the original 20 contestants and the other characters like the ones who failed to join BFDIA but not the original debuters and maybe stapy liy Foldy and loser

[@coinygaming2763]

idea: whit if the grapes chose coiny over tennis ball

[@BFDI64]

Suggestion for a video: what if the contestants bfdi could switch like in bfdia?

[@FishGamingReal]

I've noticed a lot more people making BFDI what ifs now. One thing I tell everyone new is that: In the frisbee contest, if you think all the pairs can successfully complete their catches, just give 4th place 15 points. If a pair can't (like canon with Leafy / Ice cube) deduct 1000 points Also for BFDI 20's eliminated contestant vote, actually do it, as who knows, the eliminated contestants (considering their opinions in this alternate timeline) would vote someone else to be eliminated. (ice cube was already the majority voted before the 300ish reccomended characters bit)

[@Napoleonbonaparterealman]

bfdi what if: what if yellow face was in bfdi during season 1?

[@schabowy1236]

idea for video what if yellow face wasnt in the debut for BFDIA *even tho he wasnt but magicly was*

[@mihailopanic5893]

BFDI but what if Scuashy Grapes choose Coiny instead TennisBall

[@jazenskibrown1780]

What if Blocky and Pen didnt get caught cheating?

[@elizabethko7890]

What if bomby joined BFDI instead of David?

[@Whatywhatgeo]

How do you do these videos? I wanna do a similar one.

[@iancers]

@@Whatywhatgeo I use PowerPoint

[@CoinyTPOT2]

PEN ISLAND?

[@oddballer5950]

Hey I made a What If like this one

[@brightmuntand23]

Can you do what if Four was never multiply by zero?

[@Jivudo]

0:27 wouldnt it be teardrop? she got third in the original one

[@iancers]

Yeah, was she not the third team leader?

[@Jivudo]

@@iancers oh weird i guess i missed that somehow sorry lol

[@iancers]

@@Jivudo it good 👍

[@Straw-x7k]

Yep nice vid

[@radish.6660]

What if Roboty joined instead of David

[@stormgsreal]

If that happened Pencil wouldn't be screwed over by the 2 digit scoreboard in BFDI 18 that's for sure

[@stormgsreal]

As Roboty would most likely win

[@JaeFresh504]

Bomby wasn’t nothing in BFDIA, only BFDI

[@iancers]

@@JaeFresh504 post hiatus yeah I agree, but Bomby didn’t do anything during the first 5 episodes of BFDIA, so I’d assume he behave similarly to how he did during those 5 episodes

[@JaeFresh504]

ALL SPACES NO CAPS

[@memecards11]

Wasn't it NO SPACES ALL CAPS

[@Whatywhatgeo]

p e n i s l a n d Something like this?

[@Pencilbfdi99]

@@memecards11 yes so it’s PENISLAND

[@RenierTroche]

Spoiler blocker