Пікірлер
@Frank13662
@Frank13662 3 күн бұрын
Amazing 😮❤
@user-nw6ve2rq1m
@user-nw6ve2rq1m 5 күн бұрын
❤️
@hjosugh
@hjosugh 7 күн бұрын
So, didn't he ever discuss acts 1 and next?
@Nancenotes
@Nancenotes 7 күн бұрын
Alas. He did not. A series of unfortunate events disrupted his plans and way led on to way. Should I go back and do it now?
@JulianaCinque
@JulianaCinque 8 күн бұрын
I really enjoyed this analysis!
@seltonk5136
@seltonk5136 9 күн бұрын
Leonard Part 6 was better
@piyushyaani
@piyushyaani 12 күн бұрын
It was an amazing lecture ❤
@bigbeefscorcho
@bigbeefscorcho 13 күн бұрын
I’m like a decade late but thanks for this, sums it up nicely
@sathyakarunarathna102
@sathyakarunarathna102 14 күн бұрын
Love your voice buddy
@Braininthemorgue
@Braininthemorgue 16 күн бұрын
I love your reading, you're so enthusiastic!
@vasae9481
@vasae9481 20 күн бұрын
I've watched almost your whole series on the Iliad and it's been a great companion to my reading, thank you for putting this together! Your love of the story really shows and your students are lucky to have you!
@Nancenotes
@Nancenotes 19 күн бұрын
Thank you! You are very kind. I’m currently doing a read through with commentary on The Odyssey on Patreon (which will someday translate to video notes over here, I hope) if you’re interested. Enjoy your continued study of literature!
@larry480
@larry480 22 күн бұрын
First if all, I love all your summaries. Thank you for them. Second, I think a commoner marrying a duke would be seen by Shakespeare's audience as a positive development.
@malcolmwilliamsmuwoola9238
@malcolmwilliamsmuwoola9238 23 күн бұрын
this is amazing. indepth analysis and it shows the inter relations between the plays. im preparing for an exam and this has helped more than i could have imagined
@Nancenotes
@Nancenotes 22 күн бұрын
@@malcolmwilliamsmuwoola9238 Glad I could help!
@fatemehansari5958
@fatemehansari5958 24 күн бұрын
🙏🏻🌸
@fatemehansari5958
@fatemehansari5958 24 күн бұрын
🙏🏻🌸
@fatemehansari5958
@fatemehansari5958 24 күн бұрын
🙏🏻🌸
@fatemehansari5958
@fatemehansari5958 24 күн бұрын
🙏🏻🌸
@fatemehansari5958
@fatemehansari5958 24 күн бұрын
Thank you for explaining the subject so clearly 🙏🏻🌸
@fatemehansari5958
@fatemehansari5958 24 күн бұрын
Thank you for explaining the subject so clearly 🙏🏻🌸
@mosaicowlstudios
@mosaicowlstudios 26 күн бұрын
I am PISSED that modern cynicism is called such, when it should be called timonism. What a smear on the wisdom of Classical Cynicism.
@christopherwalker5351
@christopherwalker5351 26 күн бұрын
I love your synopsis and analysis.
@davidwilson8432
@davidwilson8432 28 күн бұрын
i feel like it's a sort of pointing out that something usually presented/perceived in a certain way is apparently something else entirely by its nature. like in "the boys" tv series, when we have a perception that heroes "help and protect people," "the boys" "deconstruct" that idea, and presents/shows a different, new perspective: "heroes are not good people, because heroes are people, too, and people are not always good." deconstructive criticism (simply) points out what, how, and why the idea of "heroes are good people" are not necessarily right, as presented in "the boys." (feels like the text needs to be presenting something in a new perspective, so we can deconstruct it; otherwise, we'd be making things up) there becomes a contradiction between "heroes are good" and "heroes are not good," and because of that, both negate each other, and thus "there is no meaning." this happens because the deconstructionists believe that whatevere the author or text intends to utter, it will not be understood by the reader (seems like kinda fitting into all the orientations of author, text, and reader, but at the same time, not really, too), so we might as well create a new meaning (that's often the opposite of what's in the text) as we ourselves believe. i don't know if i get it right, tho. feels like it's tricky to understand for the sake of being tricky..
@SahilKumar-jk5mo
@SahilKumar-jk5mo 29 күн бұрын
I also know how to read the poem you only resd the poem 😂😂
@Nancenotes
@Nancenotes 29 күн бұрын
@@SahilKumar-jk5mo I have notes over it in another video. I’m honestly not sure why this video gets as much traffic as it does.
@_S3W_
@_S3W_ Ай бұрын
Just some notes for myself: 0:26 Roger feeds of Dimmesdale’s soul - he himself is a symbolism - of the Black Man - Puritan image of the devil. 1:07 - A lot of comparisons between Roger and the Black Man. How does Roger mirrors the image of the Black Man. 1. Deformity: He is deformed - his shoulder and the black man moves around with a black cloak and cloven hooves. The Black Man wanders through the woods for souls while Roger did so to search for herbs. 2. His wise and a learned man - he always carries around books everywhere he goes which reminds the readers about the books the black man carries for his souls. 3. He tries to destroy a soul - Dimmesdale’s soul. He tries his very best in destroying Dimmesdale and the connection between the two clearly symbolizes how similar Roger is to the black man.
@saurabhkashyap1335
@saurabhkashyap1335 Ай бұрын
Deconstruction needs Deconstruction
@MiaOrtega1111
@MiaOrtega1111 Ай бұрын
Amazing! Thank you!
@ralphjenkins1507
@ralphjenkins1507 Ай бұрын
❤ the Tempest
@playz2090
@playz2090 Ай бұрын
I can’t be the only guy here right
@playz2090
@playz2090 Ай бұрын
This video is so old
@playz2090
@playz2090 Ай бұрын
Wow
@Autumn-Rain1122
@Autumn-Rain1122 Ай бұрын
Limbus Company!!!
@dellh86
@dellh86 Ай бұрын
I am reading all Shakespeare plays and this is my favorite so far(I have read 8 plays now). I didn't read the mocking of the mechanicals play as mean but I can see how it could be read that way. To me, it brought to mind the idea of "So bad that it's good" movies. That is what I took the line about imagining the actors good to mean. Maybe what makes there play good isn't pretending that the actors know what they are doing but instead the changing of criteria for art critique in the audience from expecting a somber Greek tradgedy to watching something like The Room. Tommy Wiseau was asked in an interview what he thought about audiences and critics considering his movie the worst of all time and he asked how it could be the worst movie after if people regularly watch it and laugh, being obviously entertained, the whole time. So I saw it as a situation where the only people not having fun in this scene would be pretentious audience members who expected a 'serious performance' from these goofballs, and maybe the epilogue to Shakespeare's play is a nod to the idea that maybe people will find Midsummer night's dream to be a bad play like the mechanicals play. Gives me very Beatles "what would you think if I sang out of tune" vibes. And then maybe, perhaps grasping here,he is creating parallels between the choas of loving people and of loving art.
@Nancenotes
@Nancenotes Ай бұрын
Oh, hai Mark! (Also, the Beatles once acted out the rude mechanical’s play! You can find it fairly easily here on KZbin.)
@naly202
@naly202 Ай бұрын
If I were Claudius, I'd be offended by Hamlet's behaviour during the court play, even if I wasn't guilty. His shouting and prancing about made the play unwatchable. So, I'd wanna leave too. Hamlet's proof isn't so solid after all. If Claudius himself didn't confess to the murder in his prayer, we as the audience could still have reasons to believe he was being framed.
@naly202
@naly202 Ай бұрын
Damn! I was listening to your video while driving and got really worried over some error sounds. Thought there was smth wrong with my car (seat belt, door open, etc). Turns out it was your printer making all those sounds!
@Nancenotes
@Nancenotes Ай бұрын
Ha! That’s hilarious! Sorry!
@janey2345
@janey2345 Ай бұрын
On my understanding and based on the video, deconstruction is not really meaningless like don't have any interpretation at all it is just different from the usual it conveyss.
@matanwiesner3640
@matanwiesner3640 Ай бұрын
Any advice how you deal with the play as a non native spaker? Other plays - I can read a translation and source together and understand but when it come to word game of this play - I lost
@matanwiesner3640
@matanwiesner3640 Ай бұрын
0:00 langugage in the ply 2:33 Notes 0:00 langugage in the play 2:33 comedy doesn’t end as a comedy Plot: - 3:55 Act 1: King of Navarre and his people sign on not talking to women, Costard sent to armando to be punished, -6:14 Act 2: princess come, they only stay in court , each princees know one lord.Taking about sopme old doubt. -8:06 Act 3: Costard is free, Berowne ❤ Rosaline -8:42 Act 4 : some letter replacement , we discover Berowne breaks his outh --10:00 focus on Act 4 scense 3: people reads sonnets, hides, watch others and then blame others for break the outh , finally Berowne is caught due his letter, they decided to “get the girls”(his words) -12:49 Act 5: Plan to perform a play -- 13:34 A5S2: Mens get women present, ask them to wear them but ladies replace present and come with veil , someone told about someone pregment, and some told about a dead father 20:40 Death in play 21:00 the end song 21:30 find a performance
@Nancenotes
@Nancenotes Ай бұрын
Thank you!
@RoRo-we4ev
@RoRo-we4ev Ай бұрын
you strike to me as such a likeable person, i sincerely hope you're having a great life from across the world :*
@jordanobrien3099
@jordanobrien3099 Ай бұрын
An important ethical component is missing from this discussion. AI does not generate from nothing. Instead, it remixes from existing sources. In effect, it is a plagiarism machine. It obfuscates sources, removes attribution, and prevents recognition to those doing the real intellectual work that AI pulls from.
@uncatila
@uncatila Ай бұрын
No man is now an island near Shakespear's white'd tomb please get a grip on history or you'll never get a clue Say what became of Southell? who was hunted for his pen Might we supose that Jesuit was Shakespeard secret friend? Could he have been the Turtle? when his head graced Traitors gate I know I might be streatching things but the hour is getting late it could have cause some trouble if the Bard was hosting priests Topcliff was a mastermind at causing Doves to flee
@naly202
@naly202 2 ай бұрын
I wonder if JK was inspired by Richard III when she wrote about the ghosts encouraging Harry Potter before his battle with Voldemort.
@Nancenotes
@Nancenotes 2 ай бұрын
Good thought! I’d never made that connection.
@FatimahAdamo
@FatimahAdamo 2 ай бұрын
Thank you This is so clear and easy to understand
@marypalmer2373
@marypalmer2373 2 ай бұрын
6(
@ethancobley9525
@ethancobley9525 2 ай бұрын
i love the way you describe the play, it gives a lot of clarity. The idea that the true conflict is within prospero is something i definitely overlooked, thus is such a good way of explaining the plays meaning. it also relates better to the idea that prosper is seen as shakespeare speaking through him as he’s coming to the end of his playwright career as i imagine this would have caused him conflict
@reedr7142
@reedr7142 2 ай бұрын
I learned that it was pronounced “JAY-kweez”
@donnarichardson7214
@donnarichardson7214 2 ай бұрын
24:40 Out-and-out the worst moment of caterwauling on KZbin.
@Nancenotes
@Nancenotes 2 ай бұрын
Just call me Celine.
@melis7643
@melis7643 2 ай бұрын
this really helped a lot, thank you teacher 😊
@Frank13662
@Frank13662 2 ай бұрын
are you going to do a video like this for the Odyssey and the Aeneid?
@Nancenotes
@Nancenotes 2 ай бұрын
Someday. For now, I’m putting up audio notes over the Odyssey as a perk for Patreon subscribers.
@tomservo75
@tomservo75 2 ай бұрын
I watched this play for the first time last week. I think my biggest issue (again it was only the first viewing) was the complexity and how many characters there are with so many different motives I couldn't really keep track of the plot. It doesn't help that the production I was watching was just awful. It was the RSC performance from about 5 years ago and it was done in a very artsy, over-the-top way, and, oh shall we say... poor casting choices. This was not the right production to be introduced to the play with. I'm going to try and watch the 1980s BBC production tonight, something that's played more straightforward and maybe I'll have better luck. But again it was confusing because there were so many characters mostly with small roles.
@Nancenotes
@Nancenotes 2 ай бұрын
Was that the weird Mad Max style one? I didn’t see it, but saw the promo pictures.
@pakizakq2663
@pakizakq2663 2 ай бұрын
Came to watch the explanation for my exam and end up watching this guy singing wracking ball 😂