3 ай бұрын
7 ай бұрын
Пікірлер
@Raicri 13 күн бұрын
I wonder if we will have something like that but with moneyball?
@shaq1784 15 күн бұрын
i hope this doesnt end up becoming a paid service...
@freeburn9 16 күн бұрын
How do you make the chart bigger? When i do an upload the graph is much smaller compared to yours and only shows 9 players while yours is like 16
@FMDataLab 15 күн бұрын
@@freeburn9 Which chart are you referring to? It may just be that recorded on a larger resolution monitor and zoomed out in my browser?
@freeburn9 15 күн бұрын
@@FMDataLab thats probably it. zoomed out more. Thanks for clarifying
@FalseNine.9 17 күн бұрын
Hi mate, I am starting a new save and want to ask you when to add in the scouting details and put the top divisions for scouting players, because I will start in the Serie C, should I put lower leagues instead of the top divisions? Thanks
@FMDataLab 17 күн бұрын
@FalseNine.9 Yeah. I'd usually go for leagues with reputation around your own. Players in top leagues tend come at a premium.
@imeverywhere629 18 күн бұрын
Would you believe me, if I said I did this, ranking my team's, my reserve's and U19's best and second best 11, two times each season? I'm currently running a Youth Academy Challenge, so playing time is extremely important for my youth players' development. I've been doing this process of finding the best combination for each squad (not algebraically, just eye balling it as precise as I can) for 11 in game years. I can't believe this tool, it's gonna save me literal dozens of hours of playing time. Thank you so much.
@taktischeseinhorn8094 19 күн бұрын
This is great work. Really nice expansion of the tool! I wonder about a few functionalities: 1. Sometimes you have to field a player for various reasons (promise, important unhappy player, ...). Would it make sense to add an option that a certain player has to a) be on the pitch b) be on the pitch in a specific position c) be on the pitch with a specific role, while the rest of the squad is then calculated around that restriction? 2. Does this consider footedness? I can see that it recommend a right foot for my left back, which he is natural at but I need my wing backs to cross the ball so they should be strong with the outside foot. I'd also prefer to habe my IF have the strong foot on the inside of the pitch. So maybe does it make sense to either include footedness or (maybe easier) do the reverse to 1. and disallow a player from playing in a specific position. 3. To not have to re-export the file would it be possible to just mark a player as inelligible at all? Could be that he is out for a week with a minor injury. Again, great work!
@FMDataLab 18 күн бұрын
Hey! 1. That's something I could possibly add in the future, good idea 2. Not currently, but that's a fair point, it is a little tricky though, I will look into it. I will need to handle inverted wide roles in this implementation too. 3. Yes, that could be possible, however, it's possible from the time of the first export to another, players' attributes may have changed. In the interim, what you can do, is manually remove the `<tr` element in the HTML file that contains that player, the `tr` will end with `</tr>`
@FalseNine.9 19 күн бұрын
Question mate. I am starting a save in Serie C. I was thinking to add in the scouting edit, instead of the top leagues 1st divisions, to add top leagues but 2nd or 3rd divisions to find players to match my team's division. That would work in moneyball and finding players?
@FalseNine.9 20 күн бұрын
Top work mate. I will make sure to shout - out you in my live streams and videos. I am already using it in my saves and I am starting a new moneyball save on Twitch and one reason is this work. Great work.
@garibaldi1368 21 күн бұрын
Great video and the explanation, stay healthy bro
@gamefan8552 23 күн бұрын
Interesting, the one missing piece of this calculation is the hidden attributes, they seem to play a bigger role than what they seem to. All this can point toward a great player, but let's say they have a high proness to injury, or hate big matches, then things will most likely not go as we wish even if all the attributes are there. From SI manual it also state for example three attributes which are universally important for all positions: decisions, anticipation and positioning. Not sure how that would affect your role ratings though.
@cl8931 24 күн бұрын
Amazing work 👏
@marimar1093 24 күн бұрын
This is insane work, congratulations. I do wonder if adding some kind of artificial score adjustment to different roles could be useful to bring them all kind of on to the same scale. Like maybe all role scores get x 20 / 'max score for role'. Not sure if that would help comparisons a bit or not.
@FMDataLab 24 күн бұрын
@marimar1093 Definitely, I think the discovery of these differences from working on this feature does highlight a potential issue with the Role score weightings. I might play around with the weightings at some point to try and get all max role scores to get in or around the same max score.
@Matute_Xeneize12 24 күн бұрын
Does this work also for console?
@FMDataLab 24 күн бұрын
@Matute_Xeneize12 Unfortunately not, the FM console versions don't have the export feature that Desktop FM versions do.
@gamefan8552 24 күн бұрын
Hi looks interesting, to help automate making a lot of comparisons and making a great tactic based on what we have, however do I need to create an account to use the tool ? Can I use it without creating an account ? Also does this work for FM console ? I think they share same data and roles as PC version. Sadly another caveat is that this tool only works for PC version of FM, console players are left out, the views are not allowed to be imported there, guess they use different data then, but not sure.
@FMDataLab 24 күн бұрын
@gamefan8552 You can use the role scores tool now without signing up, www.fmdatalab.com/upload But to use the tactic feature, you will need to sign up as tactics are linked to user accounts. You won't be able to use with FM Console, however, as you can't export data from console like you can with the desktop version.
@milobedini4917 25 күн бұрын
Incredible work sir
@timofej650 25 күн бұрын
goat
@zacmoat7290 27 күн бұрын
This is absolutely unreal, I play with complete attribute masking and rely primarily on scouts and the limited data analysis currently in FM. This is about to change my life.
@axelabalo9732 29 күн бұрын
Very good video! Check, do you happen to have a video or will you make some with the key statistics for each position? Thank you very much in advance! Greetings from Argentina 🇦🇷
@otterinari2390 Ай бұрын
Hey man, this tool actually made me come back to the game. But one thing is, i did everything you did for role scores, but my scores are in red. For eg, the max score i get is 1.21 for a dm and .44 for an inside forward. No matter how many times i print the squad or player search with the appropriate filter or views, i get it everytime
@FMDataLab Ай бұрын
Hey, glad to hear that FMDataLab has pulled you back into FM, but sorry to hear about the issues you're having with the Role Scores Tool. - Do you have attribute masking enabled? If so, that may be the reason as the players in your exported HTML file from FM may only have a number of attribute values, where the rest may be just displayed as `-`. - Does your exported HTML file have all the correct attribute values for each player? (If you do have attribute masking enabled, you may see some attribute values as `-`.) - Do you get any error windows on FMDataLab, or any x or warning icons on the table?
@otterinari2390 Ай бұрын
@@FMDataLab Wow thanks for the reply man. No I was using mustermann skin and so the attributes didn't get displayed. So I changed to default and it worked. I took York City from vanarama to the championship with just a million spent using your tool 🤙
@FMDataLab Ай бұрын
@otterinari2390 Ahh, that would make sense. Glad you got sorted and thanks for letting me know the solution, much appreciated! Love to hear a success story using FMDataLab! Keep up the good work and hope FMDataLab can continue to help with your success!
@Raven81_ Ай бұрын
Absolute legende! This is a game changer for me as i tend to stuggle to find players who actually upgrades my team! Cheers! Keep up the good work!
@johnpaularnado7124 Ай бұрын
Does it work for FM23 Mate?
@FMDataLab Ай бұрын
@johnpaularnado7124 it does indeed! There are FM23 views in the zip file. There are however a few stats missing from FM23 that are in FM24.
@julius-the-space-explorer Ай бұрын
Love FM Data Lab! It is so handy and looks absolutely gorgeous as well! FYI: the term most often used for players who can play with both feet is 'ambipedal'.
@TokurErdem Ай бұрын
I expected a career using this
@Sgeeeeeee Ай бұрын
Wow, this is a game changer, great work 🔥
@franciscorecabarren3294 Ай бұрын
Sorry, when I put the filters, it doesn't give me data on speed, mental or physical. What causes me to get data 0 - 0 - 0 when I export it. Could you help me?
@franciscorecabarren3294 Ай бұрын
Sorry, when I put the filters, it doesn't give me data on speed, mental or physical. What causes me to get data 0 - 0 - 0 when I export it. Could you help me?
@r3creat903 Ай бұрын
Up same issue
@DrHydroxide Ай бұрын
28:43 The word you're looking for is "ambidexterity"
@FMDataLab Ай бұрын
@DrHydroxide Thanks, you're probably correct, I just thought at the time that, that term applied to hands only, but a quick Google search tells me that it can be used for feet too. There's also "ambipedal".
@colouredIncognito Ай бұрын
Moneyball isnt data recruitment
@e_xtazzy Ай бұрын
This is cheating😂 but awesome work in the community
@iwonamalanowska6485 Ай бұрын
Scam
@sherifddin-9612 Ай бұрын
Hey, using the FM23 views and it's displaying the attributes instead of the stats. Can I get any help?
@FMDataLab Ай бұрын
@sherifddin-9612 It sounds like you've imported the role score views e.g. "fmdatalab_player_search_view" instead of the Moneyball views e.g. "fmdatalab_moneyball_player_search_view" (note the _moneyball in the .fmf filename) The moneyball views will be in the "Moneyball" directory within the extracted zip file. Or just download the specific Moneyball views from www.fmdatalab.com/tutorials/moneyball#Downloading_Moneyball_Views
@jonathangoliath91 Ай бұрын
This is what the ingame data manipulation and visualisation should be. More data points for informed decisions. A suggested function is ability to accumulate and label stats from year to year.
@II-wt2le 2 ай бұрын
How are people this smart man, unreal
@Marcel_KAAAA 2 ай бұрын
nice, but as always the proof of concept is missing.
@bredrin4146 2 ай бұрын
what I'm doing with your tool( btw thank you very much), is finding young players who are cheap and performing well, I'm talking from 17-19 years old, buying them, loaning them out, then selling them after a couple of seasons for profit, kinda red bull leipzig, let's see how it goes, thank you again
@sparky-FM 2 ай бұрын
loving this.....such a valuable resource. Can see this becoming essential to my FM experience.
@bahadirtuncay192 2 ай бұрын
I've recently started a moneyball save and this is exactly the tool I was searching for to help me on my endeavour. This is simply completely amazing !!!
@kckcy 2 ай бұрын
Playing fm is already like smoking crack, now imagine playing fm with moneyball tool. Bye my social life
@NotesfromtheBenchRWDP 2 ай бұрын
Unbelievable Stuff
@Goldbridge7 2 ай бұрын
This is insane, very impressive will use
@ethanhough3322 2 ай бұрын
goldbridge alt acc??
@matsbuer9996 2 ай бұрын
How would you go about adjusting the stat weights for a Target Forward that you would play floated crosses to so he would score most his goals by heading in crosses and from corners?
@FMDataLab 2 ай бұрын
For this specific style of play, the key attributes to prioritise when adjusting role weights would be; - "Heading", ensuring you have a player adept at converting crosses and corners with precision. - "Finishing" is equally essential, guaranteeing the player can capitalise on the opportunities created for them. - "Jumping Reach" is another crucial attribute, allowing the player to rise above defenders, especially taller centre-backs, to contest and win aerial challenges. - "Off The Ball" and "Positioning" will enable your player to consistently make intelligent runs and position themselves optimally to meet incoming crosses. - "Strength" could also be advantageous, ensuring the player can hold their own physically and not be easily outmuscled in the penalty area. - "Bravery", could also factor a little, as this reflects the player’s willingness to challenge for aerial duels in potentially dangerous situations where others with lower "Bravery" may hesitate.
@matsbuer9996 2 ай бұрын
@@FMDataLab thank you for the respons. I think i wrote my question badly. What i meant was how would you weight those stats with numbers? Sorry, english is not my first language. Again, thank you for the respons 😊
@justjames1348 2 ай бұрын
I actually can't believe this. youre insane man. love it
@THEmajnik 2 ай бұрын
How do I make the list of players smaller? I have over 40 000 players in "players in range" section and I wonder how do I cut it down so that I can upload it into the Data Lab?
@FMDataLab 2 ай бұрын
@THEmajnik Age, Position, World Reputation & Update the interest level in Transfer/Loan (i.e., Interested/Very Interested/Extremely Interested)
@14thStreetSmash 2 ай бұрын
this is insane, love this!
@pxp3475 2 ай бұрын
Assistance with Filtering Multiple Players in FM24 and Moneyball Tool. While working on a FM save, I came across a challenge while using the Moneyball tool. After exporting the player role score data [I filtered for players with a Sweeper Keeper rating of 13+ and exported the results], which gave me around 150 players. However, I am facing difficulties in refining my selection further using the FM 'Player search' and the Moneyball tool. I want to analyze only the above 150 players stats using Moneyball tool, but in Football Manager's Player Search, I found that there is no option to filter out multiple names or use a "one-off" filter under the "Name" or "Unique ID" set. The system only allows filtering for one result per condition. The same applies when using the Moneyball tool - I am unable to filter or search for multiple names at once. Is there a way to achieve this within Football Manager or with the Moneyball tool? I would appreciate any suggestions or workarounds that you could provide to help me in this scenario. Thank you for your time and the incredible work you do! You inspired me to deep dive into sports analytics and the way I play our beloved game FOOTBALL MANAGER!
@tomkmb4120 2 ай бұрын
Got any idea of a good way to filter out players in much lower leagues? Is the easiest way to specify each league you want to include - or maybe just to exclude the ones you dont...though both could be quite lengthy
@FMDataLab 2 ай бұрын
Yeah, a bit of a tricky one. You can filter on World Reputation to filter out low reputation players, but you might have some relatively unknown players with a low World Reputation that play in top leagues that would get excluded by filtering on a minimum of X World Reputation.
@tomkmb4120 2 ай бұрын
hey mate - been doing an attributeless save with Mustermann skin recently and thought I'd give this tool a go. What's the difference between the main Moneyball views and the alternates in the pack? There's no Readme or anything. Tried to see if I could message on X but I'm not verified, so thought I'd just comment here instead.
@FMDataLab 2 ай бұрын
@tomkmb4120 The alternate views are just for when you have an issue with the default views, they were generated by another user who had issues with the moneyball views, they're the same columns, just helps when users may have any issues with the default moneyball views. Details here www.fmdatalab.com/tutorials/moneyball#I_am_getting_an_error,_how_can_I_resolve and in my recent video. I'll need to add a README file, thanks for reminding me.
@tomkmb4120 2 ай бұрын
@@FMDataLab Ah thanks for the clarification.
@gdhmunited6157 2 ай бұрын
Wish there was app to use like this for phone for Xbox fm24
@neo5818 2 ай бұрын
This is so awesome