This was actually fascinating. I thought at first this would be a reiteration of the speculations on the wiki, but this went well beyond. Good job!

Of course, we've have had substantial oxygen production on Earth that could not be explained by photosynthesis which we called dark oxygen as their cause was unknown at the time and now we have identified that nodules of rare metals on the ocean floor acted as batteries when grouoed together such that they electeolyzed the sea water producing oxygen (the hydrogen would of course if unreacted to other elements, rise to the upper atmosphere where the solar wind would blow them out to space). Though we would suspect biologic activity for oxygen in the atmosphere of an exoplanet, it doesn't actually mean that it has to be biotic. However, that planet also seemed to be devoid of surface water so abiotic oxygen production similar to Earth's dark oxygen might be unlikely.

Past affects the Future and the Future affects the past.

Was Cooper Station lifted off from Earth, or was it mainly assembled in space? That sucker is HUGE, so I would tend towards the latter explanation. Also, I would not necessarily write Earth completely off. Given 50+ years of dedicated effort plus added assistance from the space habitats, it seems plausible that something positive could be achieved there. Not necessarily a compete and immediate restoration, *perhaps* largely evacuated, but at least getting the ecosphere pointed in a better direction long-term. We don't get to hear anything at all about what is happening with or to Earth near movie's end, so I'd consider the jury to be out on that one. Mostly a good explanation, but I don't buy into the 'closed loop' idea around time paradoxes. Seems to me that becoming 5th dimensional beings may not necessarily be the end of the road. There are branches of physics that have worked their way up to 20+ dimensions in their efforts to work out the nature of reality. All in all, not bad, though.

1:31 Edmonds planet was red shifted because of the systems proximity to gargantua

Why would you send a “particle physicist” on a solo space mission?

Who wouldn't want to repopulate with Anne Hathaway !

That movie was nothing more than a lecture about global warming, we're so advanced to do all of that but not advanced enough to fix our own planet, how stupid

Human race dies out. Was very clear in the film.

Since nobody knows what happened inside a black hole, anything can happened inside a black hole including time travel.

Live around a black hole? Nope.

Who cares? It was garbage of the first order.

Few things wrong. It takes 7 months to reach edmunds planet after going through the wormhole. Cooper couldn't make that soft of distace with a ranger. The ranger doesn't have hyper sleep or enough resrouces to last 7 months in space.

Why the other humans didnt settle in edmunds planet?

This should’ve been part of the movie. It’s better when there are no loose ends.

How does that planet have oxygen without life?

Resources will not eventually run out. It’s recycling water and oxygen comes from the crops and plants growing. The station has an ecosystem that keeps everything inside, it doesn’t disappear. If you’re going to do speculations on what happens after, you need to be more accurate to the science.

found a few things that are wrong in the video 1) Edmund couldn't die of old age, its been more than 80 years for him, but he has the hyper sleep tech, Romily aged because he choose not to do Hyper Sleep, Edmund had it available, the only way he could have died of old age is that his hyoper sleep tech stopped working 2) the movie never hinted that edmund died in a rock slide, it has a grave the girl made for Him. 3) the said that humans took so much time because their spaceships will be much bigger and hence slower, size doesn't matter that much in space,

This is fantastic. Keep this channel going.

Fantastic

Plot twist, Disney was hiding in the shadows the whole time waiting for their chance to return and ruin everything you onow and love.

I’m understanding more about outer space by watching this video, Fire

This was the most incredible interstellar video I’ve ever seen. I feel like I’m understanding it for the first time for its complexity

Well that explains everything.

Yea. I'll never ever understand time dilation. Ever.

Very accurate explanations! Instantly suscribed to this channel.

Somehow we can jump on city sized space-stations and fly through wormholes across the galaxy to some sand-planet from hell....... but we can't fix this perfectly good planet right here....

Cooper going back in time behind his bookshelf and sending information is a huge paradox. 1 million years from now, a scientist goes inside a black hole, inside a tesseract, and instead of going behind a bookshelf he goes behind a computer of a physicist or a politician or a journalist in the year 2025 and print all the new technologies developed in the last 1 million years that can avoid blight etc etc. Problems solved. 😂 YOU CAN'T GO BACK IN TIME AND SEND INFORMATION, IT'S A HUGE PARADOX.

Maybe the red colour is not exclusively from deserts, but from vegetation as well, which you could expect from a planet that orbits around a star cooler and more red than the sun, such as a K- or M-type star (those also happen to be by far the most common types of stars).

I think they explain that Edmund's planet orbits a star that orbits Gargantua from afar. If it has an oxygen atmosphere, shouldn't it have a lot of plant life ? Or was it naturally occuring oxygen that was in the atmosphere from its formation ? Edmunds wouldn't die from old age. After sending the "good planet" message, he would have gone for a long nap like Mann. Maybe with a wake up date but calculated so he would be able to guide humanity whenever they make it to his planet. He probably died during his nap as his pod was crushed by rocks. I wonder how much of his data was lost and Brand has to rediscover everything. On the matter of the future of settlement, they never establish how many stations like Cooper Station are in the Solar system. We don't know how many people were able to make it off planet. Even with free gravity, building the stations would have taken ressources on a dying planet. We don't know how many stations there are, how many people on each station but given that they don't seem to be saving space on Cooper, they must have groundfloor to spare, hence probably many stations. There aren't any indication of the political system. NASA could have morphed into government and basically ruled through the supreme power of the gravity equation and the organisation of the evacuation of the Earth. A Sapiocracy like Foundation part space program, part university that rules society (like the Foundation on early Terminus). Which also raises the question how they revealed themselves ot the world who thought they has been disbanded decades ago : "By the way guys, we're still here. We have that magic equation, and now we can do anything we want". But if they shared the gravity formula in open source, different political factions may control one or several O'Neil cylinders. I know it's a utopian future but there is still a finite amout of ressources with which to build in the Solar sytem, leading to inetvitable tensions. Even there aren't any tensions with ressources, there are always tensions on political differences. Now Edmund's planet is probably large enough to house the plan B baby colony and all the populations of the O'Neil cylinders. When the colony ships arrives (I don't know if the gravity powered O'neil cylinders would do well in the wormhole), how would they organise the settlements ? Especially without central authority. Would they bunch up into a big city or every station gets a spot on a ressource ? That's the problem with a frontier, in the end it's still humanity. Then again, I don't know how much Cooper tells them about "Them" being future humans. The knowledge that Humanity will transcend and become fifth dimensional saving itself and going beyond material needs may lead to a spiritual awakening and the will to unite to make that future in harmony. Maybe the tech and virtual infinite energy of free gravity leads to societies that don't compete and just thrive, leaving each other space of cohabitating but without confrontations. Maybe the tensions start when it is time to start exploring the stars and expand, the competition of explorers. Or maybe conflict disappears and we ascend through peace and openness.

Dumbest amazing movie of all time. Instead of fixing Earth or finding thousands of solutions to the current problems, they decide to abandon earth for a mars like basically dead rust plannet close to a supermassive black hole. Cool visuals. Cool concepts. Dumb overall plot.

Just like the johnny b goode paradox in bttf

So the space tootsie roll can talk to them

The youtube algorithm has been recommending these banger videos from small accounts and it has not disappointed me

So they are half way through the movie on the planet. Almost half way through it actually.

I did not understand a word of what is said!!!!

You need a spit screen for your mic

Amazing soundtrack, shame about the film...

*_''BUT WHEN IS NOW??!!''_* -Dark Helmet, Spaceball

Let’s say you put 50,000 people a month on spaceships to leave Earth forever. It would take a little over 3,000 years to remove everyone from the planet. Let’s think of a better plan. 🌏 🚀

Wow. What a fantastic video and execution of it.

This movie is just a big paradox. Doesn't make sense.

Instead of creating space stations, why not use the ginormous energy created from understanding gravity to create stations on earth? Humans could reclaim areas of earth creating the same secure environment, eventually exterminating the fungus

I be like "nope" and colonising the asteroid belt with O'Neill habitats instead.

Yes! I understood all that! No, I'm lying.😟

She will have deccatuplets?

That was excellent commentary. Thank you for your explanation of Edmonds Planet. I took issue with the ending (time dilation and relativity). Dr. Brand tells Cooper that time is relative and can stretch and squeeze, but it can't run backwards. He also says that gravity is the only thing that can move across dimensions, like time. For example, Cooper and his crew spend about 3 hours and 17 minutes on Miller's planet, but 23 years, 4 months, and 8 days pass for Romily. Cooper is left in space for approximately 51 years due to the extreme time dilation near the black hole Gargantua, meaning that while he experiences only a short time, decades pass on Earth. Now, how many years would it take Cooper to find out the brand on Edmonds Planet? 80 years or more? Now if Doctor Brand goes into some sort of cryo sleep. All Cooper has to do is awaken her when he gets there. Murphy on a bedside did comment I believe. Doctor Brand was settling in for the long nap, which probably means a cryo sleep.

Still find it bizarre that most authors think humans will remain biologically human and live on the surface of worlds once we start to spread out across the galaxy.

The Teserac and 5th dimentional beings made the story outrageous.

The politics about plan B being applied and then humanity coming to this planet, It’s crazy. Who leads the planet?