16 December 2024 | Editorial Discussion | OCMC, Religious Worship Act, TFGBV | Sumit Rewri Sir

[@OnlyIasnothingelse]

docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLScqjJqT0Zaiiq2r9dprQD6U0K59RLOLQfqq0gh-TBKax1vQAw/viewform?usp=sharing Join Current Affairs Plus Course by Sumit Rewri Sir www.pw.live/study/batches/current-affairs-plus-by-sumit-sir-708041/batch-overview?activeSection=Description

[@shikhaparihar4608]

1. Utilitarian perspective: Torturing or killing might seem justified to prevent harm to a larger number of people. 2. Concerns raised: Violates Article 21 of the Indian Constitution (right to life with dignity). 3. Means vs. ends: The means used (torture or killing) are morally not justifiable. 4. Alternative approaches: Lie detector tests could be used to extract information. 5. Conclusion: Torturing is not justifiable; alternative approaches respect human rights and uphold the rule of law.

[@DhirendraKumar675]

Radhe radhe guru ji and to all of my friends ! I think threatening family members is not realistic, ideal , ethical and moral to access information. Reason- 1. Motivated terrorists have not feelings. So , utiliterinean justice possibly not achieved due to time wasting in family threatening process. However, several measures we can take, like 1. Psychological manipulation by family members support 2. Fast-track team can search places visited by terrorist by the help of one of the family member. 3. AI can analyse statement,so , possibility to found right place will increasing. Why should we not threatened family members? Because- Process can impact child psychology and stimulating his/ her towards illegal activities in future,due individual injustice. Thus

[@vivekverma8577]

Sir aap pichle dilemma ka solution bhi discuss kiya kijiye

[@as-dz4rg]

Good afternoon sir ap jiyo hazaron saal ab mujhe editorial me understanding aane lgi hai or main isko relate kr pa raha hun

[@iasmotivation1552]

How can u plz define it ?

[@Jaybhanshorts]

Bro. Hint me

[@-taibur9206]

​@@Jaybhanshorts kuchh din bad tumko pata chalega consistency rakho

[@Subhash__2005___]

आज से मैंने संपादकीय चर्चा का श्रीगणेश किया है। मैंने आज पहला कदम रख दिया। day 1❣️

[@Rakesh-ix2xk]

Nishpaksh sampadakiye karega Best of luck 🎉

[@feeleditzstatus]

5:00 3. Only 1 and 3

[@MG12330]

Thank you so much sir 😊 SC CJI ka bilkul sahi decision h ki mandir masjid religious places ka survey krna sahi nhi h blki ye to 2 dharmo ke bich discrimination paida krti h mera v manna h sir religious survey khin tk sahi ni esme to srf politics involved rhti h politics ka to kam hi vote ke nam pr 2 dharmo ke logo ke bich jhagra karwana. CJI ka sahi faisla h ye I'm agree with CJI decision 🙏🙏

[@Kamleshmeenaofficial_18]

I think sir wife aur children ko torcher nhi karna chahiye bcz unke apne rights hai like right to life or dignity (Article 19,20,21,22) saath hi yah ethically sahi nahi ki Father /Husband ke karan children /wife ko punishment mile iske liye usi ko torcher karne ki jaroorat hai Thank you sir ❣️😊

[@aartiraikwar2462]

One candidate one constituency issue Dobara election karvane ki jagah 2nd candidate jise sabse jyada vote mile use mp bana dena chahiye. Esse dobara election nahi karvana padega, extra expenditure bhi nahi hoga. Esse multiple constitutency par 1 candidate ko jyada labh nahi hoga.

[@krushna9535]

2nd candidate 1st candidate ko hamesha mar dalne ki sochta hoga fir😂😂

[@PradumanPal-de8ue]

0:01 good evening sir and PW team Jay Hind Jay Bharat 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳❤❤❤ 2:08 Sir, in this case, we have to deal with terrorists, but the point is that terrorists commit terror activities, not their families. So the question is, why do we harm or harass their families? If you want to know the truth about where the bomb was planted, we can use medical therapy. There are many technologies and machines that can easily extract the truth from the mind. Forensic science is very advanced, so we can easily do this. If we have an alternative approach, why do we harm their families? As we know, Article 21 guarantees the right to live with dignity, so we can’t abolish individual rights. Also, their families did nothing wrong. Children don’t know what their father does or why he does it, so we can’t punish them. We should take the alternative approach through forensic science to easily extract the truth about bomb planting.” jay hind🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳 5:00 B 2 only 34:17 thank you so much sir and PW team Jay Hind Jay Bharat 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳❤❤❤

[@Pummy-k6u]

146 days completed Consistently ❤❤❤

[@mayankrathi1628]

Keep it up bro

[@i--am--XclusiVe]

Namaskar sir ji 🥀❤

[@bhola8052]

Thank you sir 😊

[@rahatpraveen4782]

Sir u r too good.... thank you sir..... from bottom of heart

[@Upsc.9631ips]

Jai hind ❤❤❤❤ sir

[@VivekSingh-ew9qz]

Lecture completed 💯

[@govindsinghchaudhari3629]

Thanks sir for your efforts it's helpful for.....,..

[@defenceenthusiast]

I have a solution we can give permission to one representative/nominated for PM of a national party to contest in 2 constituencies and for others it will be one candidate one constituency by this we will have to only conduct by polls for 6 seats maximum

[@AnandKumar-ru4or]

Sir Aaj apse ek shikayat he .mene bahut se place pr apko ye bolte hua suna he ki coaching institutes ko aspirants ko jo jaruri he vohi provide karna chahiye extra chije add kar aisi chije lene ke liye n force Kiya jaye jisse uspe financial burden ke sath extra unnecessary chijo ka burden ho jaye . Sir mera complain he ki me aaj test series ke liye prayagraj centre pr gya tha and sir mujhe abhi keval test series ki jarurat he taki me time management and questions practice kar saku baki Mera study aur revision sahi chal rha and sir apne financial condition ko dekhte huye mene room pr padne ke liye khud ko addict kar liya he jisse ab mujhe library ki jarurat nhi he pr sir apke institute me aisa koi initiative hi nhi he jisme keval test ho usme aur bhi aisi chije he jo uski price bada rhi he .sir apse request he ki aap iss bare me prayagraj centre se bat kare . sir me already apke online foundation course se juda hu.

[@mitalisainiad0442]

Idmp Lelo

[@Nivedita_2.25]

No sir it's not good bcz bht sare tarike h emotional blackmailing k but bachho ko torture Krna is not good Kyunki bacchon ki ismein koi galti nahin hai innocent hai wo

[@thermogram8762]

Sir if secularism Good then Religious secularism Best✅.

[@baldevbhakal101]

Thank you so much sir ji ☺️😊

[@anitchaudhari1722]

EQ-1--B

[@ApjAbdulkalam-m4m]

Thank you sir 😊😊❤❤

[@alokdash2655]

For national interest, tourchure and any things that required.......all that aspects are right only and only for national interest

[@dreams7663]

Dilemma- society vs individualism Means vs end It is not right to harm the family of any person we can't give the someone's punishment to others. According to me - can create an artificial situation where terrorist being shown that his wife is died and his children will be died if he will not disclose the information but in reality his wife and children is safe

[@RohanSahu-ew3pm]

Thank u sir

[@Aurora99a]

Jaise exams mein waiting list hta hai wese hi elections mein b hona chhye..in case of resignation / death or vacancy of a seat of Legislator/ parliamentarian, next one in queue must be given this seat..who is 2nd in succession to the victorious candidate in the already conducted elections..time paisay energy bach jaynge

[@SonamYadav-vs8yd]

Vese torchar nhi krna chahiye tha kyoki wife ke Marne pr to kuch btaya nhitha 😊 sir fir ap btana ki kya krna chahiye hme thanks for editorial discussion sir 🙏🏻 😊😊

[@PrincessJuhi123]

Wife or children ko tourched nhi krni chahiye because it is again human right and mortality.or bhi tarikhe apply kr sakte h location jane ke liye jaise wife or children ke jarya emotionally tarike se pta laga sakte h location ka Thank you sir ♥️♥️♥️

[@Shrirang-c6w]

Technically his wife now informing government about his terrorist intensity proves her guilty as well ?

[@RahmanAli-qx1tt]

good thought😍😍😍

[@RahmanAli-qx1tt]

@@PrincessJuhi123 follow (aniq_143) to

[@LavkushKumar-i9z]

Pranam Sir, As we have seen during torture wife has Killed, That means he doesn’t have emotion and love left for their family so, Torturing child who is innocent has serious legal and ethical concerns as our constitution guarantee right to life with dignity(A21) and can’t compell person to be witness against himself(A20). We can use some other standard method to get information like Psychological and technological Procedure(continues fatigue along with Polygraph test)

[@Mrhemant82]

Movie dekh kar batate hai😅

[@nspireworld]

😅😅😂😂

[@neetuyadav5878]

Nahi sir ye jayaj nahi hai kyuki kabhi kabhi aparadhi ki family ko pta tk nahi hota hai ki unka family of member kis apradh me sanlipt hai or chhote baccho ki to koi galti nahi hai hume koi dusra tareeka apnana chahiye

[@Knok_knock]

1:40 harming his family members or loved once or by just showing him his mission has failed and the leader got arrested these things can actually lead to emotionally weakening him and if his wife is also involved then the investigator must do what they can but instead of really harming her or children they can use morph video and also they can use chemicals like truth serum.

[@NimishaParekh-yn5kf]

there are varied dilemmas: individual interest vs nations interest utilitarianism vs human values harming free will vs security of nation suggestions: the idea of prisoners dilemma if this is sole terrorist to be held caught in name of others group members mechanisms like lie detecting or others

[@AryanRajput-y3u]

परिवार को पीटने के बजाय आराम से जानकारी प्राप्त की जा सकती है क्योंकि बच्चे छोटे है इसलिए झूठ नहीं बोलेंगे फिर भी न बताने पर उनको offers दिये जा सकते हैं या फिर किसी mindreader का सहारा लिया जा सकता है ई think that's right😊😊😊😊

[@Agrafunnyfamily]

Sir in this situation I will try to influence child in such a way that they ask location from their dad. I I’ll try Gandhi satyagrah sarvodaya and EI

[@anukritipandey10]

Only 2

[@ShipraSKY]

1:42 nhi...it will impact their mental health and so on issue with upbringing.

[@VishaThapa-messi]

Good point. Even the child will develop hatred towards society and walk on the same path as the father.

[@ShipraSKY]

@VishaThapa-messi killing a innocent to save another innocents is same crime with different name....

[@SUCCESSHOLIC450]

Good morning sir सिर्फ toucher करने से बच्चों को कुछ भी नही होगा इसलिए इन बच्चों को उसके पिता (टेरेरिस्ट) के सामने थोड़ा बहुत toucher करने के बाद वो पता ही देगा की बॉम कहा कहा पर लगी है फिर ज्यादा मासूम लोगो की जान बचाई जा शक्ति है फिर उन बच्चो को भी सही राह दिखाई जा सकती है

[@shayarkigali1588]

MCQ Ans (b) 2

[@anitchaudhari1722]

Ethics dialema-----Sir, jab wife ko marne se nhi btaya to bachcho ko problem me dekhker bhi nhi btayga isliy child tourcher sahi nhi hai . koi other upay jaise uske pass available equipment ke through pta lga sakte hai for example hipnotiese karke

[@M_K_S95]

I think Only 2 but kal iska answer zrur dena sir🙏🙏

[@bhola8052]

Good morning sir

[@sandeeplodhi590]

Dalema Unethical hai but Kabi Kabi sisution easi hoti hai ki na chahte hua bhi Krna padta hai.

[@HARSHAMISHRA-w2m]

Good afternoon sir 🙏

[@-Empathy77]

Ethics is above all!! To harass kids is totally unacceptable & unethical if he is so stubborn that he will not reveal anything then what’s the need to harass kids

[@dreams7663]

Q2021- b

[@abhayjha2390]

Pranam sir ji

[@kumaranuj4917]

Daily Editorial discussion short notes ki pdf kaha milti h koi bta skta h Plz reply

[@rasmiranjandas8013]

2&3

[@radhikabajaj2592]

I think it is not the mistake of wife or children and they should not be tourched and killed as it is against human right as well as morality. also we dont know whether the family was knowing abt this or not. Instead we should use lie dictator machines and other means to get answers. thankyou

[@ChaudharyVipul-pq2ox]

Brilliant answer di 👍

[@SAURABHCHANDRAMISHRA]

as we all know ye sahi to nahi ki ham bachcho ko torture kare but again investigator ke paas bhi shayad koi aur option bacha nhi hoga agar ham yaha emotional honge to shayad bomb se bahuto ki jaan chali jaaye but ye bhi hai ki pata nahi itne torture ke baad bhi bachcho ke ye terrorist bataye yaa nahi ye bhi ek question hai. conclusion sometimes we will have to try all option for the life of numbers of citizens

[@NehaKumawat-o3y]

Bachho ko torture nhi Krna chahiye, but bachho ko bol skte h ki wo apne father ko bole ki hamme bahot torture kra gya wo acting kre torture kre jaane ki

[@BituKumar-fb5yi]

🙏

[@nitinlodhi2272]

Usi person ko tochar krenge bs Na ki uske bacchon ko kyoki (100 अपराधी छूट जाए पर एक निर्दोष को सजा नहीं होनी चाहिए भारतीय परंपरा न्याय के अनुसार ) fake torcher kar sakte hai bhale hi Us person se related sari jankari nikalege kb kaha gya kisse mila etc. aor uski link wagera pta krenge aor investigation ko aage badhaenge

[@Rohitbamniya05]

Q = 2&3 ONLY

[@rajnandani-tf4ld]

Option 2

[@rubitiwari9233]

According to utilitarism theory it is correct.

[@aarush584]

Good afternoon sir

[@Harsh-pe8vu]

❤❤❤❤

[@UpasanaSaini-z9k]

Nice ❤

[@SrishtiTiwari]

I think that option d is correct

[@rohitsingla3369]

According to me, It should not happen because of the following ethical issues Ends vs Means Rights vs Right to Do Sanctity of life Against the principles of Islam, Sikhism, Bible, Romans Ethics Lack of Societal Ethics Utilitarianism vs Individual Rights I thing Officers can follow others options by considering the implications of this action

[@AkhilJamwal-m6b]

No sir its against the fr ....of population end dosen5 justify means

[@harshrathore9407]

HW Q1.D

[@010monithasai9]

2 and 3

[@chhavisingh9540]

😊

[@rajuprasadverma951]

B option is right sir

[@NiramJamriya]

Nahi sir unko ase torcher nahi karna chahiye unka kiya dosh he sir

[@KhushiKumari-eq4qq]

D1

[@innuyadav3012]

2 only

[@preetyprasad6906]

Eq1 a

[@kumaranuj5115]

🙏👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍

[@BableshKumari-k8l]

life le lena wife and bcho ki is not ethical.will try other possible ways to detect location of bomb ,but life of each single individual is important.

[@Passion-for-UPSC]

Where shoul I post my daily answer. Plz provide the platform link

[@raviroji6273]

Batana hota to bata deta wife k Marne s phale Mera side s usi touture karo agar bata de do thik nahi Mere pt. Dhirendra Shastri ko lekar jao maann ki baat padh lega😂 Ya koi aur way pata karna padega 😂😂😂

[@funnyweedsS]

Mast bola re ye 😁🤣 apne yaha bahut baba hai 😂

[@preetyprasad6906]

The agency should not do that they killed the terrorist wife and they tourchered their children which was not ethical and humanitarian basis and it does not mean tha we right to do the same thing which the terrorist did .There was no fault of his children and wife .

[@nilima4187]

Pdf kaha milaga ?

[@funnyweedsS]

Ek rasta Dhirendra Shastri mann ki baat jann lenge😂

[@harshrathore9407]

😂😂 y shi h😂

[@bishalyadav148]

Sir for nation security tourcher can be done as it the most important for us as a civil servant for the security of our country

[@EBKME_NISHANT]

1 only

[@anilsaini8860]

Agr utilitarian aproch se to shi h sir but Humantarin or mordern time k hisaab se aske aor bhi option hmre smne jesa narko tast

[@prabhatyadav6569]

Please Sir app bhi dilemma ka solution btaya kijiye 1 ya 2 min

[@Nivedita_2.25]

We can't use the utilitarian approach here

[@arpitmishramishra4488]

Ek aisa apradh jise kitna human nuksan iske alawa Kai dask tk iske prabah hota h jais 26/11 us apradhk ko rokne ki leye sab kuch jayaj h ....sayad 3 ko mar ki 300 ki jaan bachi ja sake.....aise time pr emotional chejo si dur rhna cahye

[@ABHISHEKYADAV-pj4sz]

Sir mai capf ac ke liye prepare kar raha hu aapki new initiative current affairs ki paid classse capf ka current affairs kavar ho jayega

[@dollykumari6646]

No sir

[@arbazshekh267]

Gurudev BPSC ke bare me app kya kahte hai jo 13 tarikh ko hua

[@vijetam7057]

Ans 1. D

[@MoumitaDas-hh8eo]

Kisi v bacche ko torcher karna sehi nahi ha but es case me bohot logo ki life jury hai to us terrorist ko fake news deke(jaisa upnar bola he) information nikal na hoga taki kisi ki v luksan na ho sake

[@Subhamjaisworld]

Terrorist not resembling actual terrorists

[@pawanpandit3043]

Nahi

[@jyotirajput4920]

Obviously Bachho ko torture karna unethical hai how can we punish them when they don't know about the consequence or they don't have the knowledge yet

[@MukulKasyap-e3j]

sir 2 constituency me winner k bad jiska sbse jada no, hoga vo jeet jayega,

[@devdasbhadarva7751]

I think deep fack technology ka use karke esa video batao jisme uske bacho ko torcher kiya ja raha ho

[@KDBhardwajEasytounderstand]

Sir hum terrorist k bachoo ka btakar ki unke father ne ye galat kaam kiya hai aur unko bolene ki aap humara issme help.krr dijiye jisse hum us nuksan ko rok ske

[@warriors01]

No

[@akritigupta7094]

Isme bachho ki kya galti hai

[@IpsThakur-o6e]

Sir terrorist ke bajeh se uske family ke fundamental right violet ho rahe he