16 Pros Beat the Game WITHOUT Communicating | Pass the World

Today, me and 15 other Terraria content creators will be attempting to defeat the game without communication. Each person will be given 2 hours to play on the same character and world file. But what they don't know is that we have to beat the game by the time the world returns to me.
Thanks to all those who participated! @wexelradley @Charzium @wildlmao @ImCollier @COLTcolossal @daviddevsgames @ColdToasty @BenchTerraria @wyeeett @0klah @CataclysmicArmageddon @bromex_ @Megaswave12 @theterrariayoutuber @MottTerraria
Thank you to Colt Colossal for the sprite of the earth and Wild Lmao for the thumbnail design idea. If you haven't seen them, the idea is heavily inspired by the game dev challenges by @Blackthornprod . Cataclysmic uses the "Cataclysmic's Amalgamation" [texture pack or mod] to make his game look the way it does.
00:00 Throarbin
03:15 Wexel Radley
06:14 Charzium
08:43 Bench
11:40 Wild Lmao
14:21 Cold Toast
16:55 Brome
19:46 Oklah
22:23 DavidDevsGames
24:46 Wyeeett
27:15 I'm Collier
29:56 The Terraria KZbinr
32:29 Cataclysmic
36:02 Megaswave
38:27 ColtColossal
41:24 Mott
43:37 Back to me
________________________________________________
Check Out my Other Channel!
My gaming channel:​ @ThroarbinGaming
________________________________________________
Join my discord!: / discord
Become a channel members today!
________________________________________________
MUSIC I USE
Terraria Original Soundtrack: • Terraria (Full Origina...
Terraria Otherworld Sountrack: • Terraria: Otherworld O...
Calamity Mod Soundtrack: / the-calamity-mod-ost
Mod of Redemption Soundtrack: • Playlist
Core Keeper Soundtrack: • Core Keeper - OST
________________________________________________
TEXTURE PACKS
- Axolotl Pet, New Animations, New Shields, Shadow Armor Revamp, Color Buffs, Colored Emblems, Chinese Moonlord, Tomes retextured, Desk dragon, Better World Icons, Colored Boss Relics, Pylon, Crabby Angler, Dryad Deer, Eevee Fennec, Cyborg, Clockwork Dragon, Kobold Invasion
________________________________________________
#terraria #gaming

[@agentEE233]

Multiple consecutive people failed to kill a mech boss then Megaswave just casually killed all three, what a chad

[@dailthegoat799]

Ikr

[@blakepeters9872]

I mean he had a megashark soooo

[@gstreamgc.9697]

​@@blakepeters9872 its actually impressive tbh.

[@Femboy_Grey]

Bro had his thanos arc

[@user-uq7ml1vw2d]

Bro carried but some just don’t make it after him

[@Xenylard]

> be wexel > join the game knowing you have 2 hours > decide to just f around and kill the dungeon guardian > leave without elaborating

[@wexelradley]

What I want to know is, who unequipped the pet? 🤔

[@SpaceMarineJeff]

@@wexelradley Yo whats up whens the next hardcore co op part?

[@wexelradley]

​@@SpaceMarineJeff 😎👉👉 On it's way...

[@pyroteknikk3127]

​@@SpaceMarineJeffDO NOT RUSH ART

[@HyperDash47]

​@@pyroteknikk3127 bro was just asking damn

[@gryzziarth8288]

I misunderstood this. I thought this was going to be 16 people in a single game beating it without talking to each other in any way.

[@RhodeCasaway]

Same

[@dcper608]

that would be too easy no?

[@gryzziarth8288]

@@dcper608 maybe. Maybe not. It depends on how much experience each player has compared to the other. Also ideally this kind of challenge you wouldn’t be allowed to use signs or emotes to communicate. You just have to rely on what people are doing. Also bosses get scaled to players so considering most of these challenges are in expert-master mode you really need players to know what the other players want to do next. Some are builders, explorers, and fighters. One might try queen bee by accident then she ends up killing everyone who isn’t in the jungle. It could really go sideways which is what I thought would happen in this video but this is also just as chaotic lol

[@thedyingmeme6]

So did i lmao, i was hoping for Absolute Chaos

[@jpbastyr]

this sounds like a good 2nd version of the vid!

[@MrChummington]

Wexel was probably the best part of the video. Bro just walked in and killed the dungeon then left everyone in confusion. Honestly he carried.

[@Azimii]

@@inooxsome people know what true progress is sorry

[@Greatcelestialkaligo]

@@Azimii what they say?

[@Azimii]

@@Greatcelestialkaligo complained about wexel “not making any progress”

[@Greatcelestialkaligo]

@@Azimii true he didn't but he had fun and did soemthing interesting but I'm not mad at him at least he didn't do what that The Terraria KZbinr did and do nothing then did negative progression.

[@LenaSpark412]

@@Azimiiplus the group didn’t know there was a goal

[@legendleopard7125]

I love that the people who read the challenges had no idea that they were not offical and someone before them just put them in

[@Throarbin]

Yeah, when I learned that was a thing it took everything in me to not tell everybody I didn't make the challenges.

[@BenchTerraria]

We love being a little mischievous 😏

[@hajoeijgenraam295]

@@BenchTerraria I honestly think your segment is the best because you actually made some of the most progression, and set up the whole sidequest thing. Of course it made everyone end up wasting time on it instead of making progression which was honestly hilarious knowing what the real challenge was

[@BenchTerraria]

@@hajoeijgenraam295 Throarbin’s such a prankster for not telling us the real goal of the challenge

[@Gabriel-se6tj]

​@@BenchTerrariaimo your challenges made everything so much more enterteining to watch instead of 16 terraria pros shredding through game progression.

[@LozMajM]

It's so funny how half the players go "I'm gonna make progress" and 20 seconds later we get "it's obvious I won't be able to make progress"

[@graphospasm5394]

And then he ruins the next guys progress by hiding thier gear so he had to remake it.

[@Greatcelestialkaligo]

@@graphospasm5394 but the chad Cata manages to kill a mech boss

[@barritoothy]

@@Greatcelestialkaligo the dumbass before him who puts his gear on the other side of the world and also leaves him with prehardmode gear to go into hardmode wtf was that guy on

[@jakethereaper2060]

Megaswave casually making more progress then the last 5 people made combined

[@nicodemusvangaalen5156]

literally! I was thinking that, and he did it with EASE.

[@Greatcelestialkaligo]

What are you talking about Cata did a lot and was messed up by the person before him (the most out of anyone didn't mess up the person after him Mega did. Cata easily 1st and Mega a solid 2nd Mega did less than Cata and beasue if him hlep got the megashark to finish the rest of the mech bosses they are chads but do discredit cata, The Terraria KZbin is the one who messed up big time equally to negative progression.

[@Wakwaw796]

if cata actually get the gear. the mech would be beaten

[@PokeRedstone]

It was entirely Cata’s work. Megaswave made forward progress only because Cata set him up by getting it back on track.

[@Megaswave12]

^^^ Cata hard carried my segment, wouldn’t have made any progress without it!

[@sad-o-lantern7825]

I think the biggest time waste was the last 4 players swapping consistently back and forth between hallowed and chlorophyte armor

[@alexanderelderhorst2107]

truuuuue

[@lks19]

jokes on wexel spending 2+ hours doing nothing but trying to cheese dungeon guardian just to flex a pet.

[@funky555]

bro someone litterally gave up looking for the temple and wasted more time than that dungeon guardian@@lks19

[@Scratchy__The_cat]

​@@lks19 ngl, the one who put all of the stuff at the right side of the world kinda messed everything up more than this 2 hour "waste" especially since the sign pointing to that part got destroyed

[@user-lk4ge3ns2g]

@@Scratchy__The_cat i think most damage came from funny "challenges"

[@blakecryer8425]

The fact that Oklah didn't even open the rest of the chests to see that the Night's Edge had already been made

[@LakeDrinker]

Honestly made me seethe💀

[@inoox]

Some people are just really stupid.

[@HashiraObanai]

​@@inoox Fr i hated his whole segment of the video 💀

[@hercules2606hd]

@@HashiraObanai He beat the wall of flesh with a bad build and made some actual progression. Half of the other creators didn't

[@somefries3101]

​​@@hercules2606hd the skeletron prime segments were the ones i hated the most

[@wildlmao]

I set cold toast up so good for a wall of flesh fight and he goes and makes a toast statue with a fake wild lmao signature on it 😭

[@PythonicIe]

he even insults the build you had, and doesn't even fight the wall of flesh 😭

[@cryo7847]

he didnt even read the sign 😭😭

[@r4gn4r0k69]

And then it took till fucking oklah to beat it

[@Dracooles]

@@cryo7847 he did, he changed that sign for brome

[@redrar00]

Average shorts youtuber moment

[@wexelradley]

SEASON 2 WHEN?!?

[@eddible544]

hardcore co(pe)-op content creator my beloved

[@nneykobar_hali]

Hope you contribute to the fun of the project the same. The only thing more enjoyable than your tomfoolery was the most agresively british person i ve heard , but that's just unbeatable.

[@bossrodrihezzz8971]

you needa re do fr

[@bobosaurus331]

Beat Duke Fishron early but only keep the relic/trophy

[@zdelrod829]

I just want the entire gameplay stitched together to make a continuous playthrough. I'd binge that shit.

[@___agos___]

37:01 I love how everyone up to this point struggled so hard to beat skellatron prime and this guy just goes “this fight was kinda boring” and speeds it up 😭😭😭😭

[@Megaswave12]

It was kinda boring to be fair, it’s just Skeletron with slightly more brain power

[@princepidove7089]

@@Megaswave12 LOL

[@Jeekc]

Makes you wonder if those are really pros heh

[@Popcorn_Pillow]

I swear that boss is so easy. I don't get how people thinks it is hard

[@xiqy1959]

@@Megaswave12 The GOAT!

[@BenchTerraria]

Wow that bench guy looks really awesome and I bet he was the first one to submit his segment and that there were no problems with that

[@The_Mad_Potato]

Agreed

[@Throarbin]

Yeah...the first...sure...totally not the one who took the longest

[@CataclysmicArmageddon]

Totally

[@Charzium]

Yeah Its not like he recorded in September and didn’t submit it till march…

[@V0RTEX_000]

You definitely contributed the most to the video and progression

[@bryceio]

Genuinely painful how many times equipment kept getting lost between handoffs ;--;

[@truestrose234]

bro there's no way these guys are pros. The way they misuse the grapple and can't even fight bosses properly. I'm used to be an intermediate player many years ago and I play better than them now.

[@strawr7198]

@@truestrose234its just clickbait for the title im p sure theyre just terraria content creators bc the terraria guy spent 2 hours literally doing nothing

[@SpiderJAAM]

Can we talk about how if Megaswave hadn't speedran all those mecs and the Plantera arena, it would've took even longer to beat Plantera? 🤣

[@CataclysmicArmageddon]

Megawave went chad mode on the mechs, Granted that megashark likely had a play in it

[@ThomasSchwietert]

@@CataclysmicArmageddonyea but anyone could have gotten it

[@noakeyharding9437]

@@ThomasSchwietert yeah but anyone could have destroy these mecha with it

[@kiruara]

cata and mega are the real chads in this video both made great progress tbf

[@Romdara21]

megaswave was so underrated for just casually killing all 3 mech bosses and making an plantera arena while all the other players could barely beat one mech

[@jimbobstinkums]

Then the guy next to him said "the last guy doesn't have chlorophyte armour yet?" lmao This was such a good dumb video

[@Flamme-Sanabi]

What do you mean, underrated? Seemingly every 4th comment points out their boss rush.

[@Romdara21]

@@Flamme-Sanabiits because hes not very known in the youtube comunity

[@Megaswave12]

@@Romdara21I appreciate the kind words! I haven’t uploaded in a long time which probably contributes to me being unknown, but I do plan on getting back into it!

[@barritoothy]

@@Megaswave12 the man the myth the legend

[@markobou3340]

the best part is that everyone has 2 hours and master mode speedrun wr is 1h 25mins

[@platypus96175]

It took me and my 2 friends 40 hours to beat golem on our first master mode run. we never beat moon lord

[@alexanderelderhorst2107]

@@platypus96175 Hah while I reached hardmode once before I'd never played into it before trying Mastermode and even though I played a long time (built cool houses in biomes like a pirate shipand halowed castle) I did a 100% achievement run and made the Zenith. Solo. It's hard but not that hard, how can people not beat moonlord? Did I use a minecart and the hallowed armour dodge (before the patch) to beat daytime empress?... maybe. But that was besides the point. I ended with vortex beater and it took a good few tries to beat it. I also am doing calamity and stars above mod mastermode deathmode now. And just beat the mech bosses although I haven't played in months. Got no time now, need to make time... after Palworld.

[@dabasil]

​@@alexanderelderhorst2107 after several years you might wanna go back and rethink of the comment you made and finally cringe on it

[@brianjjames1]

@@dabasilbruh who’s gonna revisit a specific terraria video just to look at a random comment they made years ago 😂

[@dabasil]

@@brianjjames1 you have no idea people will just comment on this post after several years

[@daviddevsgames]

the golf course was 100% worth my time to make

[@Throarbin]

yeah...mhm

[@CataclysmicArmageddon]

Press X to doubt

[@BenchTerraria]

I bet it was fun tho

[@COLTcolossal]

I didnt have time to play it :(

[@Charzium]

I’d rate it if I actually got to do it…. Why didn’t you time travel?

[@themilkguy9572]

so many people were just like “man ive been trying to progress the game for 30 minutes and its not getting anywhere. well i guess ill just mess around for the rest of the 2 hours"

[@KCzz15]

Really annoyed me, def avoiding any YTer who does that.

[@minimeg]

Mott looked for the temple for TWENTY minutes before wasting 1h40 on a banner room... Like at the very least the others gave up on a fight or from lack of time but that was just lazy and sealed the run's fate

[@ryd9686]

@@KCzz15 damn u sound super annoying to

[@LordMarshyMan]

Those people made this so painful to watch, what was worse was people who hid armour and other progression though

[@KainYusanagi]

@@minimeg To be fair, they didn't know what the challenge was. It didn't make it any easier to watch, though.

[@Ryan50Ryan]

33:12 Cataclysmic: "That sign can't stop me because I can't read."

[@CataclysmicArmageddon]

If I could understand what you said, I'd likely be very offended

[@Luctor]

​@@CataclysmicArmageddon I have to admit your were the funniest

[@CataclysmicArmageddon]

@@Luctor 🫡

[@CuCuKM]

@@CataclysmicArmageddon subscribed to you and only you cuz of how fun you were in this

[@CataclysmicArmageddon]

@@CuCuKM It was a pleasure to entertain everyone with my segment

[@anon9469]

Can you imagine this, but with building channels? Episode 1: setting up for the challenges ahead! Episode 2-14: construction. Episode 15: oh god I have two hours to beat everything after the Eye, but also, my base is BEAUTIFUL.

[@MrMIGON]

😂😂 i can imagine that

[@MrMIGON]

*fails to defeat eye of cthulhu. *Returns to building.

[@Felinaxo]

If they were to do another version of this in the future I really, REALLY hope they invite more of the builders from the community and sprinkle them across different parts of the video

[@nneykobar_hali]

Oh yes.

[@bobosaurus331]

Or everyone tries different build themes

[@elijahlarson1582]

I appreciate how the first three walked so Bench could run. Definitely reflects how Terraria feels: you either accomplish nothing or beat 5 bosses in 2 hours

[@connortg5]

man this was a rollercoaster, from the people f'ing around to the people just trying their best TO THE ABSOLUTE MADMEN that hard carried everyone else, i honestly couldn't tell whether you guys were gonna pull this off or not... well, until mott gave up searching for the jungle temple and wasted his 2 hours, then i knew y'all were doomed, but hey you got close

[@ilovekids-kx1bq]

yeah throarbin spent like 5 min finding it and he gave up after only 20 min, if he had just searched more he could have found it. Beat golem and maybe lunatic cultist. In the beginning everybody was goofing off and i was like "Eh they just began theyll start defeating the bosses" But as they got closer to the end of the run i was getting more disappointed

[@theterrarianmudkip]

quote of the video: pain agony disgrace double quarter pounder with cheese

[@wyeeett]

this is my contribution and I bear it with pride

[@gebdemedici]

​@@wyeeett I ADORED your part of the video lmao. You're hilarious.

[@orcajesus6621]

2/3's of the KZbinrs: "ill leave progression to someone else"

[@Manticore4828]

There is "I'll do it later" energy in it...

[@ledonkly8817]

Literally bystander effect

[@nuclearcatpotatoe3714]

Metaphor for climate change 😔

[@angtem7163]

0:07 "2 hours to do whatever i want in it" 0:20 says he doesn't tell them the challenge was to beat the game Honestly, you cant blame the 2/3 of the youtubers, they were literally doing what they think the video was, doing whatever they want 😂

[@tellyg47]

3/3 of the KZbinrs doing whatever they want because they weren’t told to do progression 👍

[@CataclysmicArmageddon]

Ma! MAAAAA! LOOK IT'S ME! I'm in a Throarbin video again! Thanks for letting me join in on this little adventure, It was a lot of fun.

[@Aaron-gx3ft]

You were definitely my favourite, I liked your humour will be subscribing

[@CataclysmicArmageddon]

@@Aaron-gx3ft Huzzah! Welcome to the Cataclysmic chaos

[@skyss0fly]

Definitely had a few funny puns. I subbed 😂

[@thejkgamer4283]

@@CataclysmicArmageddon loved the energy and watched your infurnum run and loved every minute you my good friend earned a sub

[@CataclysmicArmageddon]

@thejkgamer4283 This pleases me greatly to hear that I'm doing things right, Thank you 🫡

[@wwzombieslayr]

I kept laughing at cataclysmic tbh, the fast talking for one, and the obvious rage, that’s my kind of content creator

[@CataclysmicArmageddon]

Twas a pleasure to entertain

[@florantlover5554]

New sub for you!​@@CataclysmicArmageddon

[@CataclysmicArmageddon]

@@florantlover5554 Huzzah! Thank you

[@Saplo101]

@@CataclysmicArmageddonyour section of the video was great man! Texture pack is also really cool :D

[@nneykobar_hali]

And acent. And half politenes. Thats so enjoyable. (I apologise for acent remark , but thick british or british like acents always make the things spoken 20 times more enjoyable for me.) + I just love rage with decency. No over the top swearing , just pure rage.

[@thatguy4609]

The terraria youtuber wasting his entire time and moving every useful item to the right definitely contributed to the challenge

[@mostlyus3l3ss]

Hey man dont be toxic

[@imlosingit.]

hes not wrong at all, the terraria youtuber basically sold the ENTIRE challenge other than benches tomfoolery ​@mostlyus3l3ss

[@mostlyus3l3ss]

@@imlosingit. i never said he aint wrong i just find it dissapointing that people are genuinely getting mad about a challenge. I am sure thorabin never meant anyone to take it so seriously. Its just fun and games and all of the people featured are nice people and in my opinion dont deserve hate over a challenge

[@imlosingit.]

@mostlyus3l3ss im not saying hes mad or that hes hating on the guy, all he did was state what he did wrong, and quite frankly, hes correct

[@noakeyharding9437]

@@imlosingit. i dont get why it was "wrong" doing that though, isnt like they had any objectif, we know they werent tell what was the goal of the chalenge, they where unaware they were suposed to beat the game and make progress, so isnt like he did something against the goal on purpose, he have no way to know he wasnt suposed to do that, that's why a lot of them just fooling around and spend time on doing the "side quest" and make one for the next guy, they didnt know they were suposed to make progress at all. if they had an obecjtive and he intentional trow it by wasting his time and the time of the one after him, then i would agree it was wrong, but as i said, in his perspective he didnt have any objective neither the other guy...

[@ethantemple8068]

Cataclysmic has more energy at any moment than I feel in a week total.

[@CataclysmicArmageddon]

[@MadManMicruhwayve]

@@CataclysmicArmageddon brooooo I loved your section in this vid 💯it was absolutly hilarious

[@CataclysmicArmageddon]

@@MadManMicruhwayve 🫡 Thank you, Glad you liked it

[@CataclysmicArmageddon]

@@MadManMicruhwayve Glad you enjoyed the show

[@hajoeijgenraam295]

Haven't finished the video yet but i have a strong hunch that bench fucked up any chance of beating the challenge by distracting everyone with side objectives. And sure enough that's what happened. Some people spent their whole 2 hours on side objectives, and the precedent was set so they kept making new ones

[@Dappersworth]

throar even called it happening lmao

[@dragonmaster3207]

You were told to do whatever you want so they did, they never were told to beat the game.

[@EbonMaster]

11:25 This right here. This is where the rest of the run was doomed to never be completed. This single set of actions was the most powerful sabotage I've seen in a long time.

[@Kermit_E_Frog]

Megaswave is like 40% of the reason alone the challenge got as close as it did

[@druidplayz2313]

Hey uhh why did he have the megashark ya know a realy good ranger weapon thats kinda hard to get that caried him

[@Kermit_E_Frog]

​@@druidplayz2313 Hey uh idk if you'd only read like 40% of my comment but I did say he's like 40% of the reason they got close not 100

[@spellsman4]

@@druidplayz2313 oh yeah from that guy who couldn't read a simple sign and wasted an hour

[@sauskaucheaha1244]

Bench was another 40%(he killed EoW and skeletron)

[@Popcorn_Pillow]

@@druidplayz2313 is it really that hard to get?

[@Ralseio]

Bruh, Wexel litteraly joined, said f it I'ma kill the dungeon guardian, left and didn't elaborate. CHAD

[@RamesGamesLC]

You, Cataclysmic and Megaswave were definitely the MVP's. This was so scuffed xD

[@JetZV]

If Bench had simply *not* made that challenge board, you probably would've been set. Wild would've had more armor to work with, Toast wouldn't waste time with the summoner build, David wouldn't have had to spend time making a golf course, Wyeeett and Collier wouldn't waste their time on a boss they couldn't beat, and TTY would've actually been able to do something.

[@ThesePinkTeeth]

Every single one was optional. They didn’t HAVE to do it.

[@vicio19995]

​@@ThesePinkTeeth we are all gamers here, OPTIONAL Challenge means MANDATORY CHALLENGE

[@zel6010]

@@ThesePinkTeeth The problem is they didn't know it was optional

[@tellyg47]

@@zel6010it literally said bonus challenge…

[@wisemage0]

I do find it really funny that nobody bothered to say "fuck it" to the bonus challenges and just not do them.

[@VioletAeonSnowfield]

It's wild to me that they all took the challenges as gospel. Not to mention how hilarious it is that Wild set things up specifically for Toast to kill the Wall and he made it his priority to kill Deerclops instead.

[@arinpendragon4344]

Also, I love how Cataclysmic is just freaking out about getting stuck in a wall while fighting the Wall of Flesh. 😂

[@CataclysmicArmageddon]

It had 900HP left...It was very frustrating to be cock blocked by a stupid wall

[@arinpendragon4344]

@CataclysmicArmageddon You put up a valiant fight, Cata! Better than I did this morning when I tried to fight Skeletron. 🤣

[@vandieyahya1024]

Okay so the Dungeon Guardian kill idea from Wexel was legendary lol. He had a well spent time there killing such a boss stronger than Moon Lord in term of stats, in pre hardmode. Pffft

[@Manticore4828]

Smile was on my face every time any youtuber has been noticed this

[@venessafugi6768]

Cataclysmic was absolutely my favorite part of this whole video because of how angry they were the whole time, I loved listening to the rant that was his section lol

[@CataclysmicArmageddon]

After the recording was made, I'd taken a look at the others videos that were avaliable and noticed some of the time wasting going on (Hense the golfing rant) Plus I had to talk fast to get it all into the short time I was allocated so it just felt right to do it fast and mildly angry since I knew I was in for a lot of work to help catch up, my whole playthrough was dedicated to making the next players time better which us why I got the armor from QS and the Megashark/Crystal bullets, So glad Megawave put all the effort to good use!

[@personperson9380]

@@CataclysmicArmageddon He wasn't insulting you it sounded like he enjoyed your playing!

[@CataclysmicArmageddon]

@personperson9380 hmm? I wasn't insulted at all, Is that how that reply sounded? Wasn't ment to be at all

[@Flamme-Sanabi]

Love how Cataclysmic and Megawave locked in as opposed to most before them.

[@stevendobrzynski1655]

“Pros” is very generous for this batch, great video though!

[@Acylenn]

terraria can be one hell of a trip sometimes. that was what? 3 separate players who got hard stuck on the wall in the random build swap to summoner? only for the wall to go down first try through the ancient art of "lmao hellwing bow" i must have north of 1000 hours in that game and it still amazes me how much you can set yourself up for success or failure with just loadout choices.

[@twustermydude]

legit the only real prep check for wof is shoes, streets and something that shoots bats from hell

[@clydedavis3623]

Wexel totally should have min/maxed his time and started dungeon guardian in the last 5 minutes.

[@thunder0997]

i like the fact that in the video he says it is 14 pros, but in the title says 16, and in the description says 15

[@Throarbin]

Well 15 people other than me, I said 14 because...last second changes...16 is the real number

[@thunder0997]

@@Throarbin never let them know your next move

[@abinashworlds860]

Honestly Throarbin is one guy who can make me watch paint dry and I will still enjoy it.

[@Throarbin]

Guess I got an idea for a future video

[@raindrop_animationz2739]

cant wait for 16 terraria pros watch paint dry without communicating

[@COLTcolossal]

Best idea

[@Charzium]

@@raindrop_animationz2739we were already planning that. How did you know?

[@Etranck]

2:27 Man really skipped past the waldo painting, the rarest painting in the game.

[@dailthegoat799]

I thought I was the only one 😭

[@V0RTEX_000]

I didn't even see that

[@DylBro101]

Not that rare ngl. Seen it like, 6 times throughout a couple hardcore runs I've been doing recently. That might be because I'm seeing a lot of underground houses but it's definitely not that rare. it's spawn got increased in a more recent update.

[@derfloh4245]

@@DylBro101 "Waldo is much rarer than the other paintings that can be found in Underground Cabins. For any given painting in an Underground Cabin, there is a 32.5% chance for it to be a 2×3 painting, and out of all the 2×3 paintings, there is only a 0.49% chance for it to be Waldo. Combining these two percentages, there is only about a 0.16% chance for a painting to be Waldo." From the Terraria.wiki.gg site, post update

[@Jeff-.-X]

Nice to see Colt Toast cares for summoners saying he could care less

[@ColdToasty]

Lmao

[@tschudaun]

Those mini challenges really staggered the progression. At first it was the no pants which ruined the set bonus and makes fighting really annoying, and then the swap to summoner that made the others also believe they had to keep that class resulted in 10-15 minutes of video that can just be skipped because nothing happened.

[@moldorm30]

"WITHOUT COMMUNICATING" Everyone leaves signs for each other and everything..

[@boptodatop]

Not like they told them how to continue with progression 💀

[@twustermydude]

@@boptodatop a few of them did sometimes say "it's up to you to beat xyz boss," i thought it'd be cute to leave it to statues and things other than the written word but that didn't sit right with me lmao not like they uh. managed to progress much with or without the signs so i guess it's fine

[@nicestpancake]

​@@twustermydudetbf, I would argue that the real lack of communication happened w/ the unnecessary challenges lolol

[@bromex_]

that was so fun to do thank you Throarbin! :)

[@penguin_king2759]

Loved the music you used

[@aabrakadabraa_]

goat

[@blegh277]

chippy house was class

[@AdrianRaydamur-op1lj]

Megaswave such a professional, log in, lock in, get and done, very nice impact on vid

[@lemint1195]

- Wexel: Kill Dungeon Guardian. Leave 🗿. - Charzium: Call Throarbin and Wexel bad because they haven't defeat the EoC while he wasting his time find the boomstick for some reason when he can just kill the boss with Hermes boots and Star Fury or a Musket. - Bench: Make a challenge board that waste everyone time. - Wild Lmao: Can't progress much thanks to Bench. - Cold Toast: Can't progress much also thanks to Bench. - Brome: He tried to kill WoF with bad setup thanks to Bench make Wild Lmao make summoner to help Cold Toast but didn't end well. - Oklah: Beat WoF with bad setup but better than Wild Lmao's summoner setup he make for Cold Toast thanks to Bench. - DavidDevsGames: Spend most of his time just to make a golf minigame thanks to Bench. - Wyeeett: He changed the dungeon guardian pet.... - Collier: Spend most of his time try to defeat the Skeletron Prime when he don't have to but thanks to Bench anyway. Make a cooler base than Oklah. - The Terraria KZbinr: play the golf game and setup a prank. - Cataclysmic: Make better gears. - Megaswave: Progress the game with better gears. - ColtColossal: Outsmart Megaswave's prank and kill Plantera. - Mott: Notthing to say for him.

[@phanthehuy4996]

At his point, we can say that Bench is absolute legend of this challenge

[@Charzium]

Btw I got the boomstick and beat the Eoc in only 20 minutes. I said at the end of my part that I only played for 40 mins total because of some game problems. It wasn’t that I wasted time it was that I didn’t have much time

[@CataclysmicArmageddon]

I mean...This comment is pretty accurate but don't forget Bench may of made the signs but also made a ton of progress before hand 😅

[@Fierce0Deity0Link]

me after reading that "hm, what did Mott do already?" *click at random point in his segment* Mott mid-sentence: "banner room" me: "oh right".

[@AlexanderBC42]

@@Fierce0Deity0Link he 'searched' for like 5 minutes on end and farmed corruption "for a really long time" ...he got me so annoyed. BRO THE TIMER IS ON THE SCREEN WTF HE TALKING ABOUT

[@bacondudz1966]

i feel like this should be done again but there are 16 people all at once with no tools of communication. It would be funny for a boss to spawn and most of the others wont be prepared.

[@nullkyanite1889]

"No Communication" proceeds to communicate and waste 4 hours on golf

[@nodrance]

We need a reaction video of everyone getting mad at the person after them

[@CataclysmicArmageddon]

Heh, A hilarious plan

[@wyeeett]

I love this idea because collier went out of his way to get me and we have (totally real) beef now

[@jamjamtheredpanda1302]

Honestly, having all these different creators film and edit their own portions of the video, is incredible. Makes it very interesting. Not only is it great story telling, also a good bit of advertising for them xD

[@plaguedoct0r]

You guys did communicate. You made signs for each other.

[@starplatinum329]

Watching this video made me feel a lot better about my skill at the game

[@jamesraposa942]

seeing a "Pro player" put an accesory into their full inventory and then trash a herb... kinda just hurt me

[@Throarbin]

who needs herbs when you have accessories you can sell for MONEY

[@twustermydude]

my hoarding tendencies mean i stuff extra accessories into my other two loadouts when i'm short on space and i just explode when i see people dicking around with five dirt and vines sitting in their bag for hours on end

[@Semirotta]

Funny that so many of these "professionals" do not understand to place extra accessories to the cosmetic slot next to the accessory slot so it wont take space in inventory :D

[@lightninghuff]

Normie Player: "Hey [Streamer], you can put extra accessories in vanity to swap." Patchnote Andy: "They removed that feature." Terraria Historian: "Ackshually they added it back because it was controversial." Overwhelmed Streamer: Stop telling me I can use vanity slots because chat said it doesn't work anymore!

[@ilovekids-kx1bq]

theyre streamers, idk why he added professional

[@Drekromancer]

@@lightninghuffThat actually explains why they'd miss it, thanks

[@cullenlatham2366]

I have 2 feuding parts of my brain right now. The goal focused one is mad at the unofficial bonus challenges that waste time, the dungeon guardian kill i can kinda excuse for being so early, and the general combination of trolling and lack of organization or general blindness on remaking the same equipment over and over again while ignoring valid options that were there. The content enjoying part of my brain on the other hand only hates the fact that the premise of the challenge defined by a goal was left hidden, and enjoyed the various trolling that came from people not expecting an overall time limit. In the end, it is an expectations vs reality issue. There was plenty of "communication" between people (signs, mostly), except where it mattered most: goal. The challenges were a great way to spice up each segment, but was often confused as "required" considering that all but 2 or so people focused on it, and most of the goals took up the entirety of their playtime to complete. If you do it again, you need to decide between putting an overall time limit or telling the players the goal. There is a case to be made that many goofed off for the express reason of letting the world last longer and get more chaotic or decorated as it went, and/or would have played differently and spent time more wisely if they knew the "win condition" of the cooperative challenge was based off a time limit instead of simply whether or not moon lord was eventually beaten after enough players.

[@Iistener]

Big agree. My expectations before watching were akin to seeing Hollow Knight pro players (like what Fireb0rn does on his channel) smurf and make do with what they're given by passing the world. Instead, it was just 1-5 pros carrying with the other "pros" making little progress or help or even back pedaling progress. I understand that there was no communication allowed and or it's for fun as there weren't any specifications for the challenge but it still was a frustrating watch given the expectations I had.

[@dillity]

Great idea, lost me when Oklah was just complaining about everything.

[@jedibob4346]

Oklah was the worst part about this video. He was so egotistical

[@nosouprice6309]

They're friends and he's joking

[@wadimek116]

He defeated the boss through, half of the players didn't

[@brobro9743]

Agreed. Can't expect anyone to watch someone so annoying and cynical

[@foxescouch9602]

The guy that hid everything on the right was a massive L.

[@CataclysmicArmageddon]

YEP!

[@noakeyharding9437]

i mean you are a massiv L too, but since you are a nobody no one gona hate you for it :x (exept me !) PS: well sadly i dont even hate you i just wana point out how stupid it is to write this kind of thing by doing the same but, well since its stupid i dont feel good by doing it :x.

[@ayothemayoman2840]

How? The sign literally said it was all on the right side. Just that Cata didn’t bother to use his brain there 🤣

[@CataclysmicArmageddon]

@@ayothemayoman2840 The sign wasn't named for me so obviously I wouldn't listen to it

[@ayothemayoman2840]

@@CataclysmicArmageddon didn’t mean to come out rude just was pointing out that in that moment you read the sign but didn’t think much of it. I wouldn’t say any of yall are an L it was entertaining af to watch 🤣

[@gnar539]

I am amazed that you even got to moon lord considering it took like three people to beat the eye

[@Etranck]

Sad MrJFL wasn’t able to make it to the video, saw he had a sign set up for him. Hope he’s doing well.

[@Throarbin]

Yeah, it was sad he had to back out

[@Charzium]

This “Charzium” guy seems interesting I think I should check him out

[@AstrumGalaxeus]

For real

[@CataclysmicArmageddon]

Absolutely

[@sharrzeor7478]

"No communication" - everyone leaving signs for each other 🤔

[@klauserji]

megaswave making more progress than the previous 3-4 before him combined

[@Scorchlette]

I'd love to see this again at some point. The sheer amount of gremlin energy is delightful. Maybe a modded version with either more time or more people?

[@ravenman4228]

Poor cold toast, doesn't even have enough skill to enjoy an actually fun class in Terraria

[@ColdToasty]

tehe

[@Jaymez2012]

Basically a challenge of whether or not one guy can turn what will inevitably become a regurgitated piece of poop that's been consumed and excreted 15 times over into gold by the end of a "run". People confusing Bench's completely made up objectives as "requirements" to them for the game file definitely screwed things over the most in addition to the general trolling happening from player to player. Kind of goes to show how most people tend to find being unhelpful in the short-term more fun than being helpful in the long-term, but when so many people are choosing to be unhelpful in the short-term, it creates a 'death by a thousand cuts' domino effect, lol. Nice vid.

[@jozajab6849]

This is the most fun Terraria video I’ve seen in a while! It’s a super cool concept and I hope you make more like this in the future! If there was just one thing I could add to this video, I wish you would have done a segment at the end where you explored the world and fully reacted to the things that everyone had built. It would just be a cool and fun way to cap off the video.

[@modamine6396]

Well... that was an incredible video if i've ever seen one. Great fricking work throarbin !! Can't wait to see you totally do the same with calamity and the video releasing a year after instead of 7 months (it would be awesome if it actually happens tho). Wish you the best of days.

[@Theknightman-wg1dz]

I got so infuriated by a lot of these guys just going in circles and doing nothing for so long, but that was probably bound to happen

[@sef3120]

great video!! What an awesome collaboration. Some of the commenters are taking this wayy too serious. well done to everyone involved in the challenge, so cool to see everyone's editing styles + diff energy. I just got into terraria so this was a great way to find out whose channels i should check out!

[@kidsunewuzhere7017]

wexel took all its time to kill the dungeon guardian only for cata to not use the pet

[@CataclysmicArmageddon]

My pets are just better that's all 😆

[@kidsunewuzhere7017]

@@CataclysmicArmageddon they do look cool af

[@Rain-nm1ee]

@@CataclysmicArmageddonI am curious tbh, is it like a texture pack or something? I’ve played terraria like 5 times total lol

[@CataclysmicArmageddon]

@@Rain-nm1ee Mod, A vanity mod

[@Rain-nm1ee]

@@CataclysmicArmageddon thanks for the reply! Loved watching you play

[@k.daydreams_]

Why is this Cataclysmic guy talking so fast, does he have an nuclear power plant running in his body

[@ImMimicute]

He only had two hours so he had to talk fast 😂

[@CataclysmicArmageddon]

2 hours with a ton of work done into a 2 and a half minute video limit...I had to talk as fast as possible to make it all fit and even than I had to boost in entire video (Vocals include) but 8% speed up just to make the time....But yeah, I am powered by some form of Nuclear energy.

[@tekatektwitch609]

The guy named “The Terraria KZbinr” admits he’s bad at the game, proves it, edits like a blender pulping jumpcuts, then throws away 10+ hours in the smoothest brain way possible. What a showman

[@theterrariayoutuber]

I try

[@ddd-op5wy]

​@@theterrariayoutuberNah bro not your fault. Ignore the smooth brains. Your challenge was the worst one because it makes the game unplayable, and you did leave a sign for the stuff on the right.

[@ahbsed]

This was great! Definitely discuss logistics with everyone so you can get it edited and polished sooner. I like the idea of completing the game the fastest and getting the best build; and/or, implementing ideas from previous terraria content while also implementing the ‘pass it on’ element.

[@cheesymcnuggets]

Clicked on this video because I'm a game developer who recognised the blackthornprod challenge format, nice to see it used successfully in other youtube communities :)

[@Blaikser]

This project was genuinely so wholesome and fun and the specific interactions this challenge brings between the content creators is so uniquely fun to me

[@topazish]

love the fact that "OSOGOF tunnel" has become an actual term

[@COLTcolossal]

i originally metioned waffletime but i had to cut it for time.

[@Busshhu]

what does it mean? I've never heard that term before

[@topazish]

@@Busshhu it's short for OH SHIT OH GOD OH FUCK tunnel. when plantera enters phase 2 and you lose the advantage, you jump down it to keep distance between you and her.

[@Busshhu]

@@topazish amazing- I shall be incorporating this into my vocab from now on

[@jajnuharium]

Great video! Love to see the amount of small creators in the collab!

[@RoyalGamingMastersRGM]

This is a really good idea. Helps advertise some lesser known creators and helps (and maybe hinders) team building. On top of that, pretty entertaining!

[@gamergamer7515]

bro, the house changed more times than the players

[@COLTcolossal]

Oh my goodness golly THE COLTcolossal is in this video?!?!?!?! INSTA SUB.

[@CataclysmicArmageddon]

OMG is that COLT! Top Terraria keyframing KZbinr of mega editing skillz!!!

[@COLTcolossal]

Heeheehee

[@Charzium]

No way it’s the guy who spends too much time editing! (But makes masterpieces because of it)

[@wyeeett]

I'm so glad my favorite youtuber made the cut

[@BenchTerraria]

The council was thinking of canning your part but decided it was necessary for continuity

[@mochatoastsalt]

So cool! I love big collaborative projects like these

[@jakob6437]

Amazing video! Haven't played terraria in years & I happily watched through the entire video. One of the best youtube videos I've seen in a while!

[@TheDan37]

I think terraria pros is a bit of an overstatement, love the vid and dudes involved tho (no Hate)

[@CataclysmicArmageddon]

Hmmm, Not sure if I need to fake being offended here

[@Potato_Tomato-od2lz]

Pro means profession and they have monetized channels so technically they are pros

[@TheDan37]

They are all pros in a unique way

[@TypicalLuffy]

professional goobers

[@gyrozeppeli7296]

​@@CataclysmicArmageddon You are the exception

[@elijhalafond]

throarbin really doing the most progression, then theres wexley and The Terraria KZbinr😂

[@jomanji1732]

This was such a wonderfully entertaining video. All your guys’ work on this 7 month project did not go to waste - I thoroughly enjoyed it. One of the best YT videos I’ve seen in awhile.

[@Hosteyo4]

very cool concept and well made video keep it up man!

[@neptune7042]

whats wild is that wexel literally wasted his time killing the dungeon guardian and STILL bench was 100% responsible for this run failing, he didnt just waste his time, he wasted a good hour of EVERYONE's time with the challenge board

[@Kveldred]

Don't know any of these people, don't know how I got here... still pretty amusing in the end, though 👌 makes me wanna try this game ...but Jesus, some of these segments are way higher quality than others; Cold Toast almost put me to sleep lol. Wexel, Bench, Cataclysmic, Megaswave pretty cool dudes seems like tho 👌

[@noodlesgaming846]

Incredibly good video concept and execution, would love to see more like this.

[@nottakenaway]

Very funny and fun! Honestly I am chuffed that many of the players sabotaged each other against the hidden goal. I was rooting for the villains, for the faffing about, for the monuments and designing.

[@aphextwink_]

This is by far the best concept for a video ive seen in ages. The idea for the sidequests from bench was so good

[@dankpingu4056]

He screwed over the entire run lmao

[@aphextwink_]

@@dankpingu4056 but it was entertaining! Having all these people who've beaten the game so many times have to engage in different and funny ways is a great idea for a challenge like this

[@dankpingu4056]

@@aphextwink_ Yeah definitely; the vid wouldnt have been nearly as food without it

[@isaacbush6864]

I approve of this. Despite the fact you couldn’t beat Moon Lord, you all gave it your best shot. -a Terraria enthusiast

[@OmegaChip]

This is a really brilliant idea, nice one!

[@tommytapia6466]

Great video. I never got into terraria as much as I wanted but this video was still super entertaining to watch. Makes me wanna start watching more terraria content