18 - The Life of Imam Ali: Ghadir Khumm - Dr. Sayed Ammar Nakshwani - Ramadhan 1435

18 - The Life of Imam Ali (AS): Ghadir Khumm - Dr. Sayed Ammar Nakshwani - Ramadhan 1435 AH in Allentown, PA

[@hr4037]

The truth revolves around ALI. What else can be said

[@aliibnraymond1361]

"I am with the truth and the truth is with Ali(as)"- Nabi Muhammad(saw)

[@jameswohley3332]

“ O Ali you are to me like Harun was to Musa” - Prophet Muhammad(PBUH)

[@davidmollahassani4329]

Oh brother I love you you makes us shia so proud your knowlage your devotion to Islam is one I have not seen or heard a like of it may Allah bless you and the parent that brought up such a man.

[@ahmiduturay9546]

The Imam whose intellect is beyond measure. What sprinkles from others overflows in him

[@berthabaig4520]

Imam ALI was brilliant and anforgettable and this speaker loves him, like me..

[@aliamer6790]

Keep roaring Sayedna 🧿 اللهم صل علي محمد و ال محمد

[@raaziamarzia786]

Allahumma solli alaa Muhammad wa aali Muhammad wa ajil farajahum.

[@MohamadNadi]

May Allah bless sayed ammar nakshawani

[@sabimuhammadyasin8186]

Rasulullah saw did said,” The truth is with Ali, and Ali is the truth.”. This is a very clear chystal sentences regarding the position of Imam Ali bin Abi Tholib. Don’t denied it, have respect of ourself.

[@iamnabilaabbas]

Masha Allah 💐

[@manzoorhussain6523]

Every lecture you listen to Dr, good👍

[@alsiratemustaqeem14]

Ya Ali Ya Ali Ya Ali Ya Ali Ya Ali a.s madad✋🏻

[@ayubnawab4989]

Ya allah madad

[@corpsefoot758]

@@ayubnawab4989 Wasilah is in the Quran itself. You Sunnis even say “AsSalaamu Alaika Ayyuhan Nabiyyu” in your daily prayers, which is a supplication directed toward the Prophet himself and not Allah Intellect is crucial in Islamic studies

[@jameswohley3332]

@@corpsefoot758 you’re correct

[@alihasnenghoghai7893]

Fabulous Contribution!! May Allah keep him salamat...Allahumma solli alaa Muhammad wa aali Muhammad wa ajil farajahum.

[@AqilRahimov]

Thank you my brother.I have been informed about a lot of information after listening to Ammar.Listening to Ammar gives me more knowledge abour Imams(as).

[@ahmedandalous2878]

"There's a difference between being liked and being valued. A lot of people like you. Not many value you. Be valued.👍🏿🤫😗😶😉😎👍🏿"

[@Comandente93]

MashaAllah!!

[@zamaurdhussain4206]

Sermon 53 They leapt upon me as the camels leap upon eace other on their arrival for drinking water , having been let loose after fastening if their four legs till I thought they would either kill me or one another in front of me. I thought over this matter in and out to the extent that it prevented me from sleeping . But I found no way except to fight them or else to reject whatever has been brought by MUHAMMAD ( s) . I found that to face war was easier for me than to face the retribution, and the hardships of this world were easier than hardships of the next world./ Nahjul balagha.

[@NP0451]

Mash'Allah, Thank you for spreading the truth. May Allah bless you Sayedina.

[@safwanabdi693]

Msh allah

[@theupperroom1]

Wow just wow Allahuma sallay aala Muhammad wa aal-e-Muhammad Wa Ajal Farajahum Wa Lan’al Adhom

[@ahmedandalous2878]

*"Subha'n Allah, Alhamdulil'ah, La ila'ha illa' Allah."😲😗😃👍🏿Allahu, Akbar."*

[@user-go5dl1yq4f]

Thanky very match...brather

[@BodmonBullet]

Very well said, smart man

[@aliashah9747]

May Almighty Keep You Safe.

[@kawishnaqvi8211]

MA, very nice..

[@ShaimaElMabsouta]

Let's pretend that "mawla" means "friend". Using that logic for a minute, why did Aisha fight him in the Battel of Camel? Why did Muawiya fight him? And why didn't the Prophet ever explicitly say that anyone else was his friend in such a public announcement? On his way to Mecca, the Prophet made such an important announcement just to say, "Ali is my friend!" Totally illogical. Ya Rab help the Sunni. Alhamdulilah I'm SHIA!

[@mustafaa1458]

haha ... thank God im one the shia of Ali ibn abe talib (peace be upon them and thier families) .. nice one bro

[@ShaimaElMabsouta]

ALHAMDULILAH!!!

[@ShaimaElMabsouta]

+Matin Muhd Nor Maybe you need to re-read what I wrote. What you said makes no sense at all... (Which isn't surprising... Typical Sunni)

[@ShaimaElMabsouta]

+Matin Muhd Nor Yet again, you made zero sense.

[@tasneemsalyani7517]

Shaima El Mabsouta how can we even pretend for a second? We can pretend when the content is about friendship,but here the prophet talks about authority! He asks his people first," do i have greater authority over you?" Then he says "so for whomsoever i am his master then Ali is his master! One more thing, for the argument's sake, lets say the word maula means friend. Why will everyone come and congratulate Ali after that? For friendship??

[@moinkarnib6669]

salam brother, i would just like to ask if it is possible if i can download this video since copyright requires permission from the uploader. the same goes the other 1435 ramadan videos. thank you.

[@aliashah9747]

I Pray A Lot For You.Stay Safe.🙏🤲🌟🌟

[@johnarin8155]

Ya Ali ☝🏿☝🏿☝🏿☝🏿☝🏿

[@cafertasdemir7952]

Gadir Hum is the day Allah-u teala pointed İmam Ali â s after Hz Muhammed s â v for as â imam for muslims.

[@dr.mobarakali255]

Jazakum Allahu Khairan Katheeran. "...Wa Aliyun Maula." Ali Ibn Abu Talib AS was the only legitimate and Rightful Successor as designated by the Messenger of Allah himself SAS. Some of the most meritorious, indisputably prominent and distinguished characteristics and status of Ali AS over and above ALL the other Sahabas can be highlighted as follows: 1. Ali AS was brought up in the household of the Prophet SAS from the tender age of 10 when the Prophet SAS was then 30 years old, 10 years before Revelation and never worshipped idols, unlike the rest of the Sahabas. 2. Dawatul Ashira - 609 when Ali AS was the first male at 23 years old who openly declared acceptance of Islam directly to Prophet SAS, while the other paternal blood relatives declined. Refer to 26:214. The Prophet SAS then referred to him as "Akhi", "Wasi" and "Khalifa". 3. Lailat Mabit - 622 when Ali AS readily and happily risked his life for the Prophet SAS by agreeing to sleep in his SAS's bed for the Hijrah, at the assasination plot to kill the Prophet SAS by the tribesmen. Refer to 2:207. 4. On the Hijrah from Makkah to Madinah, the Prophet SAS left Ali AS in charge of executing the Amana by returning the valuable possessions of some Makkans kept with the Prophet SAS back to the people as a Sacred Trust. 5. The Prophet SAS then gave Ali AS another Sacred Trust to take the three Fatimas - Fatima Zahara AS, his own mother Fatima and Fatima, daughter of Hamza safely to join the Prophet SAS in Madinah and single-handedly valiantly fought off attackers on the journey. 6. A few months upon arrival in Madinah, the Prophet SAS ordered the Muhajireen to each choose an Ansar as his brother to cement brotherhood, but he SAS did not request Ali AS to do so. Neither did the Prophet SAS himself do likewise. Instead, he SAS held Ali AS's hand and declared him as his SAS brother to affirm their special and unique relationship in this world and the Hereafter. Refer to 59:9. 7. Marriage to Fatima AS - 624 when Ali AS was choosen to marry the daughter of the Prophet SAS, while Abu Bakr and Umar RA were refused. Ali AS was the paternal cousin of the Prophet SAS, son-in-law and closest confidante and their house was the only door left open to Masjid Nabawi when all others were ordered closed. 8. Battle of Badr - 624 when Ali AS put down more of the enemies than any other from among the 313 ill equipped Muslims against some 1,000 strong and better equipped enemies of Makkah. 9. Battle of Khaibar - 629 when Ali AS brought an astounding victory to the Prophet SAS. After Abu Bakr and Umar RA failed to do so before him on two separate attempts, the Prophet SAS made an amazing statement: "Tomorrow Allah will send a man who loves Allah and His Prophet and Allah and His Prophet love him too. He will deliver Khaibar to me." 10. Battle of Hunain - 630 when the army of 12,000 fled the arrows in the valley by the Hawazin and Thaqif of 24,000 strong against the Prophet SAS, while only 8 distinguished Companions remained with the Prophet SAS, not including neither Abu Bakr, Umar nor Uthman RA. Ali AS brought final victory to him SAS at Hunain. 11. Ghazwat Tabuk - 630 when the Prophet SAS left Ali AS in charge of Madinah and likened him to himself SAS as Aron was to Moses AS as Nabi and Successor. Refer to 13:7. 12. Ghadeer Khumm - 632 on the 18th of Zul Hijjah after the Farewell Hajj, when the Prophet SAS explicitly and publicly declared Ali AS his SAS's Successor and those present openly congratulated him, including Abu Bakr and Umar RA. 13. Mubahala - 632 when the Prophet SAS entered into Divine Curse with the Christians of Najran to prove the Truth. The Prophet SAS took along with himself only Ali, Fatima, Hasan and Husain AS as his family to confront the Christians. Refer 3:61. 14. Kisa - 632 when the Prophet SAS took only Ali, Fatima, Hasan and Husain AS under his cloak at the Revelation of Ayat Tathir, 33:33, as the only members of Ahlul Bait. He excluded others even though it happened in the house of Umm Salama RA who expressly requested to be included. 15. This highlights the superiority of Ali AS over all the other Sahabas, when the Prophet SAS declared: "I am the City of Knowledge and Ali is the Gate." 16. Consider why the Prophet SAS, at his death bed, when he SAS ordered everyone, including Abu Bakr and Umar RA who refused to join Usama bin Zaid's Army against the Romans but particularly insisted that only Ali Ibn Abu Talib AS alone should remain with him SAS in Madinah.

[@ellentorrence8688]

no doubt about Ghadir

[@ahmedandalous2878]

"Many people, otherwise considered, 'sane', are reporting hearing 'voices' in their head." 😲🙄🤯 "If you're not careful, the newspapers will have you hating the people who are being oppressed, and loving the people who are doing the oppressing." - Malcolm X 🤔👍🏿"

[@sabimuhammadyasin8186]

Salam. Brothers & sisters, try to reflect, and take note. Rasulullah saw never leaved things that is uncharged. For example, Attap bin Uzir at the age of 20 yrs was in charged of Mecca when Rasulullah saw go to Taif for the war of Hunain. During the war of Tabuk, Ali bin Abi Thalib was in charged of Medina. So, when Rasulullah saw will leaved this world, do you think Rasulullah saw didn’t appoint someone to take care the religion of Islam that he had brought and struggling for 23 yrs??? It is absurd. Gadir khumm is a clearly prove that Allah saw ask Rasulullah saw to deliver the important message about his successor. Why denied?? Why go against the the message that Allah swt ask Rasulullah saw to deliver. If others said Rasulullah saw never appointed his successor, then answer to Allah swt in the judgement day. I will leaved it to you to decide and do the research the truth and only the truth. I will not give anyone to take the honour and merit of Ali bin Abi Thalib. Salute you ya Imam Ali. Credit also go to brother syed Ammar for his beautifully lecture. Hv a blessed day bro.

[@arshiqsyed7961]

Uk guys we fights a lot but the answer is in one line “Of whomever I was master, Ali (A.S) is his master.” Simple stop fighting and people will learn by time inshallah all my Muslim brothers and sisters will realize

[@jayd1877]

please can someone tell me the books he mentioned, i only understood al kafi.

[@1587hope]

If you google 4 book Of Shia Hadith you will find them

[@enayatmazaryar8720]

The man challenges our Sunni brothers worldwide. We the followers of Imam Ali pbuh after rasulallah pbuh, want a reply!

[@dirtyinfidel7704]

yes sahih muslim says i left my ahlu bait but is there a hadith that specifically says ali ra is the first caliph because there should be

[@imanfathi6034]

+dirty infidel.There isn't a hadith stating that Ali(as) is khalifa after me but mauwla has many meanings and it just won't make sense to stop a 100,000 people just to say that Ali is a friend and also since the prophet emphasizes about his ahlul baiyt,did his ahlul baiyt get the honour and respect that they deserved? No they were all harassed and killed.its not a laughing manner that our sunni brothers call the ahlul baiyt ra and the killers also ra.

[@yahyasarani9346]

WHEN WILL YOU STOP INCITING!!!. It is history 1400 yrs ago. What you want to achieve. You cannot change anything. Dont you believe qadr of ALLAH ???

[@j.3628]

According to your logic you should accept if something bad happens because it is qadr? That's like saying people worshipping nabi Isa a.s. is qadr?

[@yahyasarani9346]

@@j.3628 You hve been talking for 1400 yrs yet you cannot change anything. What is done cannot be undone. ALLAH SWT has better plan than what you hve in mind. Will you now accept the history as QADR OF ALLAH.??

[@aliwesker]

ok Honestly except KAFi i didnt know the other books, i have not read KAFI either, can someone please post the names of the books. thank you. also link if available.

[@mustafaa1458]

hey dude i could help you... which kind of book you ? suuni_shia from a shia point of view ? a book about the prophet mohammed (peace be upon him and his family)? just name the type and ill comment the pdf here in comments

[@mustafaa1458]

and you want it in arabic or english?

[@alzahraasayedati7986]

18 - The Life of Imam Ali: Ghadir Khumm - Dr. Sayed Ammar Nakshwani - Ramadhan 1435

[@aliabid6521]

Source / reference please??

[@rathernot6660]

Muhammad saw said if there was a prophet to come after me it would be Umar RA

[@tvhead2463]

He never said that u r just making things

[@corpsefoot758]

According to what, some Sunni book? And you think this is authentic? A former polytheist would become a prophet of Allah?

[@arshiqsyed7961]

Not to sound rude or arrogant bro the research u did isn’t one bit true just please go do research properly than than take your time and knowledge it out

[@waleeha7407]

the word "if" shows the nonsense in your statement here.

[@sharps8726]

What i do not understand is that you say the Quran with Ali (AS) is in chronological order however you state verses in the order in which they are originally in. Can someone with knowledge please clarify this for me?

[@Alimehdimalpara]

Quran with Maula ali(a.s) was in chronological order in accordance to its befall. And the one we all have is that which was collected by sahaba's and writer's according to their respective collection and its not in choronological order.If you want to know more about it there's lecture of ammar nakhsawani on quran .

[@dirtyinfidel7704]

the hadith says i remind you to the duties of the members of my house hold. Ive been looking but haven't found a hadith saying Muhammad pbuh raised Ali ra hand and announced him to be the (first) caliph

[@habeebaga]

Sahib muslim brother. Type khumm, as Ammar said and U'll get what u want.

[@MM-ps2xy]

Dear friend. before searching think about this event.was it possible prophet mohammad died without declaring anybody as his successor? And leaved people without any wills?

[@corpsefoot758]

So you think that by “Man Kunto Mawla”, the Prophet gathered 100,000 traveling Muslims over two days in the hot desert, just to remind them all that Ali is his buddy? Are you using your intellect, brother

[@yourmomshouse8993]

Stay in your faith brother we don’t need you to believe what we Shias believe. Leave it to us we are crazy we beat our chests and we cut our heads and we cry we are completely crazy. Stay Sunni and stay happy brother. Let us miserable Shia deal with our misery. We are sick, we have a different Quran and we worship the dead. Leave us alone. Go back to your peaceful religion.

[@syedhrwasti1210]

Salam un Alaikum Ghadeer The Pillar of Islam on the True Path. Brother’s who rejected this are Orphans till date.

[@sabimuhammadyasin8186]

Salam. Ghadir Khumm is very clearly that Allah swt appointed Ali bin Abi Tholib the successor; deliver by prophet Rasulullah saw. Not friend as they claim ...... Think wisely bro, Rasulullah saw call all people who returning from haj and gather at Ghadir Khummz, about more then 50,000 people gathered, and maked pulpit , and delivered the important message, only to said whoever I am his friend, Ali is also his friend, It is absurd bro. The truth is Rasulullah saw successor. I do not know wheee they put their head, wise up .............

[@arshiqsyed7961]

If umar and abu bakar were the chosen ones why did our rasool (AS) not marry bibi Fatima (as) to them! The only chosen man was imam ali (as)! Everyhting is in the details we just gotta find it! And btw it also states in your sunni books that abu bakar and Omar approach rasool (as) for bibi Fatima (as)

[@ellentorrence8688]

stay strong #shia

[@seletarroots3258]

On the point of not clarifying a successor, of not clarifying political authority or how to hold it accountable, how to exercise it and how to transfer it once some time limit or term has come to an end: is it not possible this was left out on purpose? That the religion of Islam, which is what Mohammed was tasked with bringing to mankind, a mankind exhorted to take up the challenge of the Khilafa and to uphold the Balance (Mizan) and not transgress it as clarified in the Koran, is a religion for individual humans. It is not a political system, fixed and immutable. And that by not appointing a successor and getting into that part of human social dynamics other than to exhort people to follow the principles and the lofty goals mentioned in said Koran, to let them both influence and shape you as a human being in your understanding of yourself and your place and role in the world around you, Mohammed avoids ossifying, setting in stone, the society that adopts his teachings. Instead they get to ask the questions about a political and social system and it´s shaping as best fit their day and age, their geography and their ethnic and cultural identity and knowledge/understanding of the world. Above is notwithstanding the fact that both Mohammed and the Koran are quite adamant there is to be nobody after Mohammed. No successor. I am surprised both Sunni and Shia can´t seem to grasp this or wrestle with it effectively. Instead they entrench themselves on each side of the topic, thereby dooming themselves to repeating their forefathers failures.

[@Tronmalik]

Peace. I wish to (as quickly as possible) share some ayat that I found very compelling in the discussion of wilayat and why it would not be left out on purpose. Perhaps we can use the Quran to explain almost everything about Islam long before resorting to hadith. “Verily it is honorable, in a Book hidden. Touch it not save the purified ones, sent down by the Lord of the Worlds” 56:79… who are the purified ones? “Who is he that can intercede with Him except with His permission?” 2:255 “They will have no power of intercession, except for someone who has an agreement with the most merciful” 19:87 “And mention when Abraham was tried by His Lord with commands and he fulfilled them. Allah said “Indeed, I will make you a leader (imam) for the people.’ Abraham said ‘and of my descendants?’ Allah said, ‘My covenant does not extend to the unjust’” 2:124 “He it is who brought the book down to you. Part of it consists of verses firm and categorical in meaning, these being the foundation of the book and part of others allegorical and meaning those in whose Hearts is a perversion and deviance follow only the metaphorical verses in order to create confusion and disorder while claiming to be interpreting those verses. Their interpretation is known however only to God and those firmly rooted in knowledge” 3:7 “Their prophet said to them, “God has appointed Saul to be your king.” They said, “How can he have authority over us, when we are more worthy of authority than he, and he was not given plenty of wealth?” He said, “God has chosen him over you, and has increased him in knowledge and stature.” God bestows His sovereignty upon whomever He wills. God is Embracing and Knowing.” 2:247 He who had knowledge from the Book said, “I will bring it to you before your glance returns to you.” And when he saw it settled before him, he said, “This is from the grace of my Lord, to test me, whether I am grateful or ungrateful. He who is grateful, his gratitude is to his own credit; but he who is ungrateful-my Lord is Independent and Generous.” 27:40 From only a few verses that discuss leadership we can see a trend that there is a criterion that is held in the scope of the covenant. Also we can see that there is a class of mysterious people who can intercede to God on behalf of others. It is true that there are no more prophets after Muhammad (a.s.) but we can see that there are intercessors. God reveals in the Quran that prophets chose their successors and each successor was tested and verified against this criterion (knowledge, purification and steadfastness in Allahs tests). So if the Quran reveals successorship, intercession and a standard for leadership to carry on the covenant, it is unlikely that it wouldn’t apply to the final messenger with the final covenant that would be the highest standard on the day of account. He else shall be in charge of the covenant other than those who have intercession and knowledge of the Book? I hope this little bit is as much use to you as it has been for me in your journey. Peace be upon you.

[@seletarroots3258]

@@Tronmalik Thank you for your post! From the Shia perspective(s) there are surely many verses in the Quran that support their side of the argument, where Muhammed did appoint a successor and indeed this was Ali and his progeny. Now I understand from your verses here that you wish to address the more general topic of God appointing successors or leaders or assigning such authority onto people. The verses from the Quran that you have listed here do mention those kinds of topics. But even there, none of them are conclusive to the matter of political succession of Mohammed. Or of political succession in general. In fact, the verses very clearly connect God´s decision and the outcome of that decision. There is no lack of clarity or delay in the decision. It just is so and it is so because God says so, to put it bluntly. In the case of Muhammed and I do understand what you are saying in the light of the preceeding verses you quoted, you make the case that it must be that God then also appointed some successor with intercessionary powers, not Prophetic but intercessionary nonetheless, after Muhammed. He did do so before ergo, it must be so now. The closest the Shia perspective gets to supporting this particular claim is the verses from Surah Maidah about God having perfected the religion this day. But again, even then and very much in light of your own quoted verses where this appointment is crystal clear and understood by all and is a direct command by God rather than a whisper or private revelation to whatever Prophet or person in question who then has to convey the message to those around him, we are back to the lack of clarity. Was there indeed a successor appointed to the Prophet, was this understood by his contemporaries and was this appointment political or spiritual in nature and what does such appointment look like when the next transfer point comes as one dies or is incapacitated and the next takes over. You can see even among the Shia (which is why I wrote "perspectives" in the beginning) they are not in agreement. The Ismailis say Ismail ibn Jaafar takes over as the oldest and first born, but since he dies before his father, his younger brother Musa takes the torch according to the Ithna Ashari. Which of course begs the question of really? According to what order or command is this the case? Is it then yet another one of those whispers or private revelations that only the initated (and in this case they are intercessors rather than prophets) are privy to and through which we then learn what is the case? The revelations of the Quran were always quoted verbatim by Muhammed to those present who heard and listened and then wrote it down on whatever was available. If something was unclear they would ask Muhammed and he would do his best to explain. This is something all scholarship is in agreement on and is also the main reason why Sunnah and Hadith play such an important role as one of the verses of the Quran you quoted illustrate. The Quran alone is not always a clear recitation for Mankind. But here, in this case of political and/or spiritual succession of the Prophet, the matter was never clarified. And mind you, this goes just as much for the Sunni side of this matter by the way. They appointed Abu Bakr how? On what basis? And how was Omar then appointed? And after him, Osman? All different ways, all done not by public vote or grounding in revelation or clear Prophetic command/example or anything of that nature but by the very same privy council approach, some kind of exclusive group that claims special knowledge or special ability to see the truth (or hear the whispers of it) and make the best decisions. Neither the Sunni nor the Shia perspective on this is conclusive or final or well founded. The day they both understand this, embrace the doubt and uncertainty and emerge as aware beings into the darkness they both are fumbling around in under the pretense/delusion of certainty and clarity, that day they will begin to see the light of the principles and goals engendered in the Quran. Light that will guide them through the darkness. Never removing it, but guiding them as is truly the case that we all are mired in darkness and doubt and uncertainty. That type of certainty or removal of doubt does not truly exist for Man, only the guiding light through uncertainty and darkness. There is no removing of darkness and uncertainty and doubt in this life, there is but hope that we can find a guiding light through it. By recognizing this and embracing it can we truly begin to be the deserving human beings that are appointed to the Khilafa of Man and to begin to fulfill the command of upholding the Balance (Mizan). Thank you for reading.

[@achmatjohnstone2135]

Truth does not revolve around one person Saidna Ali was a giant apriceless treasure who will certainly not be in agreement with what you are saying

[@justsaying8]

The problem is when u discuss with a Sunni he will need hadeths from bukhari and Muslim they don't accept anything from our books 😒

[@sikandershah3909]

let them when we die they will find out then its called ignorance they act that there books are like the quran smh

[@yourmomshouse8993]

Even when you prove to them in their books they still don’t get it. I’m glad they don’t get it honestly. I like us Shia to be small but tight in our beliefs and our manners are like shining stars.

[@zamaurdhussain4206]

786, It is reported, by Ibn Jarir, ' on the authority of Qubaysah ibn Dhu'ayb that he Said:' Kaab,said: " Had this verse been revealed on other than this Community, they would have taken the day of its revelation as a feast in which they meet,!, Then' Umar Said: O kaab, which Verse you mean!, He replied: " This day have I perfected your religion for you. " Umar Said: I Know the day and place in which it was revealed.. that was on Friday, on Arafat Day, and both of them are CELEBRATED by, us as a feast, thanks to Allah. / " To believe that the verse " This day have I perfected your religion for you" ,,was revealed on Arafat Day, , Is Contradictory with the verse of proclamation ( ayat al balaaagh): " O MESSENGER! MAKE KNOWN THAT HATH BEEN REVEALED UNTO THEE FROM THY LORD " ."" WHICH COMMANDS- THE MESSENGER (S) TO DELIVER A SIGNIFICANT MATTER "WITH-OUT WHICH THE MESSAGE IS INCOMPLETE. " THIS VERSE WAS RECORDED BETWEEN A PLACE CALLED "MAKKAH AND MEDINA AFTER THE LAST HAJJ( HAJJAT AL WADA ).- ' THIS EVENT ", THAT WAS REPORTED BY MORE THAN A HUNDRED TWENTY THOUSAND COMPANIONS, AND THREE HUNDRED AND SIXTY OF AHL AL SUNNAH 'ULA'A'MAH'./- , al hafiz abu nu'aym in his book Nu'zul al Qur'an., al imam al wahidi in his book asbaabb al nuuzuul page 150/ Al imam abu ishaq al Thalabi in his al Tafsir al Kabir ,,al Hakim al Hasakani in is book Shawahid al tanzilli' qawaa 'id al tafdil ,volume. I,page 187,/ Jalal al din al Suyuti in his book al Durr al manthur fi al tafsir bi al ma'thur, volume III,PAGE 117./ al Fakhr al Razi in his al tafsir al KABIR , volume. XII PAGE 50,/ MUHAMMAD RASHID RIDA in Tafsir al manar ,Vol. II,PAGE, 86; 'VOLUME. VI, P.463 ABU ASAKIR al Shaafii in TA'RIKH DIMASHQ, VOL.II PAGE '86', - ALShawkani in Fath al Qadir, Volume II,P.60 ,-/ IBN Talhah al shaafi in al - MATALIB, Sa'ul, vol.I p.44, - Ibn Sabbagh Al Maliki in al Fusul al Muhimmah,page25./ al Qunduzi al Hanafi in Yanabi'al mawaddah,page 120./- al shahrustani in al Milal wa al nihal ,Volume I page,. 163.' Ibn Jarir al Tabari in ketab al Wilayah. Badr al Din al Hanafi in Umdat al qari fi Sharh al BUKHARI. VOLUME,.VIII P.584./ Abd al WAHHAB AL BUKHARI IN TAFSIR AL QURAN. -, AL , ALUSI IN RUH MA 'ANI , VOL. II P.384,/ , IBN SA'ID AL SIJJISTANI , IN KITAAB AL WILAYAH . AL, HAMWINI IN FARA'ID AL SIMTAYN , VOL.I P.185- AL SAYYID SIDDIQ HASAN KGAN IN FATH AL BAYAANFI MASQASID AL QUR'AN,.VOLUME III,P.63.).

[@muhammaddawood9995]

possible sahaba and tabi fought ali as and al bait tel me you shia help ale bait no for sure when imam hassan sulah with mavia no one with him except few 5 ten people and when imam hussain as will go for fight and shia write letters to imam but than what they did tel me i personaly agree to some sahaba fought with ale bait but same thing done by shia to

[@corpsefoot758]

No true Shi’a would attack Husayn The only real Shi’a died alongside him at Karbala, including Hurr a former commander of Yazid’s forces You must save yourself from being fed Caliphate propaganda before it’s too late. Abu Bakr created this false Caliphate system through Saqifa, then he himself changed the rules from Saqifa to succession in order to appoint Umar, then the hypocrite Muawiya took over while cursing Ali and attacking him in battle, before finally passing the Caliphate down to his drunkard son Yazid who murdered Husayn, the blessed grandson of our Prophet. The Caliphate is therefore a man-made invention. It was neither created nor protected by Allah, unless you believe that Allah Himself would wage wars against Ali ibn Abi Talib and murder Husayn

[@user-mf9jm9wl7f]

Does he has a tattoo on his hand?

[@yupyes6831]

Amjad Hadwan alhadwani yes

[@ayubnawab4989]

Yes brother he has . . . .and talking about islam and after sahaba

[@jayd1877]

Yes he has a tattoo but attack the message not the messenger. Put forward your argument instead of snide comments.

[@jayd1877]

How many people who dress and look like pious Muslims are the exact opposite in their nature. This is why you are easily deceived.

[@corpsefoot758]

@@ayubnawab4989 Some Shia scholars argue that since tattoos are beneath the skin, they do not invalidate Wudhu; as long as no holy names are written on them to be brought into the bathroom for using your toilet etc., these scholars find tattoos permissible This is worlds apart from many Sunni scholars, who oftentimes find themselves in support of the Taliban etc.

[@ruslaniphone9770]

Zy

[@T-19-]

Ghadir Khumm Linguistically: Mawla has many meanings like sayyid, helper, someone you love and aid. Mawla comes from the word Al walayah, not Al wilayah (Al waliyy) which means leadership. They’re 2 different words. The proof that the word Mawla doesn’t mean khilafa from the Qur’an - Allah mentions an ayah with the word mawla, mentioning Allah, the believers and the angels: ‎فَاِنَّ اللّٰهَ هُوَ مَوۡلٰٮهُ وَجِبۡرِيۡلُ وَصَالِحُ الۡمُ ‎ؤۡمِنِيۡنَ ۚ وَالۡمَلٰٓـئِكَةُ بَعۡدَ ذٰلِكَ ظَهِيۡرٌ‏ then Allah is his supporter, and Jibra’īl (Gabriel) and righteous believers, and after all that, angels are his helpers. (66:4) According to Shi’a logic; Allah is using the word mawla (مَوۡلٰٮهُ) in this ayah, Allah is a khalifa over the prophet and THEN the angel Jibreel is also khalifa, and then the believers are also khalifas according to Shi’a argument which makes no sense. Therefore, it doesn’t mean leadership. Context of Ghadir Khumm: There was a disagreement over ghaneema (spoils of war) amount between Ali and buraydah ibn husayb, Buraydah disliked Ali for that and complained to the prophet, so the prophet backed Ali and reminded the people about Ali because he knew that later on people will make Takfeer on him and rebel against him I.E the Khawaarij. At ghadir khumm, the Muslims were returning back to their homes and heading towards medina and the surrounding areas after Hajj. There was only a few hundreds or maybe thousands of Muslims. If Ali becoming khalifa was so important, the prophet would of announced it in front of all the people at Hajj ,The Farewell Sermon ( خطبة الوداع, Khuṭbatu l-Widāʿ ), where there was around 100,000 Muslims from all over the world like Yemen, Iraq, Sham etc. Ali refuses khilafa a year after Ghadir Khumm event (Bukhari) and 24 years after (nahjul balagha): The author of the book Nahj al-Balagha - a reliable source for the Shia, reports that Ali RadiaAllahu Anhu refused to be the Caliph after the martyrdom of Uthman when people gathered around him requesting him to assume the caliphate and besought them to accept their leadership. “Leave me alone; go in search of somebody else….If you leave me alone I shall be just like you as an ordinary citizen of the Islamic State…As a matter of fact I like to guide you and advise you more than I would wish to rule over you.” Source: Nahjul Balagha p 136, see also pg 366-367 and pg 322. See pg 263 the Nahjul Balagha published by Islamic Seminary Publication Translated by Askari Jafri.(Sermon 95.) Hadith in Sahih Bukhari: Narrated 'Abdullah bin 'Abbas:

'Ali bin Abu Talib came out of the house of the Prophet during his fatal ailment. The people asked ('Ali), "O Abu Hasan! How is the health of Allah's Apostle this morning?" 'Ali said, "This morning he is better, with the grace of Allah." Al-'Abbas held Ali by the hand and said, "Don't you see him (about to die)? By Allah, within three days you will be the slave of the stick (i.e., under the command of another ruler). By Allah, I think that Allah's Apostle will die from his present ailment, for I know the signs of death on the faces of the offspring of 'Abdul Muttalib. So let us go to Allah's Apostle to ask him who will take over the Caliphate. If the authority is given to us, we will know it, and if it is given to somebody else we will request him to recommend us to him. " 'Ali said, "By Allah! If we ask Allah's Apostle for the rulership and he refuses, then the people will never give it to us. Besides, I will never ask Allah's Apostle for it." (See Hadith No 728, Vol 5) Source: Sahih Bukhari 6266 THEREFORE, Ali himself didn’t know he was even supposed to be KHALIFA but SHI’A say he was.

[@Jameso0071]

If you listened to the lecture you would realise there was no iraq during ghadir, iraq was formed 7 years later, and yemen had just accepted islam, they wouldn’t do hajj on their first day of becoming muslim.

[@tvhead2463]

U maybe listen 1 minute that’s why u are saying. Go first do read history or books of Islam. Because if u listen the whole lecture u will not question the imam Ali as the successor of prophet....

[@huss6291]

First of all ur completely incorrect if u knew anything about more Classical Arabic u would know that some words have different meaning depending on the context. So no maula can mean friend, helper, leader, guardian. Please don’t spread false information. Second mashallah real smart using bakhari a book that isn’t a hujja on shia to prove ur opinion to the shia 🤦‍♂️.

[@lulupingpong]

Very eloquent speaker; impressed by his ability to use emotion. - The Prophet SAW (God forbid) missed the chance to announce succession on 9th zulhijjah, where he SAW addressed all the pilgrims and the deen completion verse was revealed?! - the Prophet SAW announced the 'succession' infront of a handful of people at a pond side on 18 zulhijjah ?! - if Ali RA was truly understood to be a successor, it was obligatory on him to take this right even by force because it was divinely ordained according to your belief. All the above does not add up. Tough pill to swallow... Yeah we know. But kudos to the speaker's spirit.

[@hsiuhuang7886]

Dear Brother, Following are clarifications to your comments:- - The Prophet SAW did not take chances about when to announce succession ! He could only say what God ordained to be revealed at the time He sent down the divine message of guidance for transmission to the Ummah. - The divinely ordained succession was announced, in accordance with the Divine instruction, at Ghadir Khumm in front of many thousands of the Haj pilgrims of the Ummah. As mentioned, the people ahead were called back and the ones behind were awaited before the sermon was delivered. - Imam Ali (A.S.) could not take it by force because firstly, he did not have enough supporters in Medina willing to take up arms and secondly because he did not want to cause a civil war at that critical time. - As you know, Allah (Glory and Praise be to Him), sends down divine guidance to human beings but, as is very clear in many ayats of the Holy Quran, many people, throughout history have refused to accept His Guidance (and suffered accordingly due to the evil of their own lack of faith and obedience - just as you can see that the Muslim Ummah is suffering today !). There is no tough pill to swallow because all matters will be settled by the Allmighty One on the Day of Judgement and, even before that Day His servant Imam Mohammad Al Mahdi (A.S.) will remove oppression and bring justice to the world just as it is today full of oppression and injustice (being the 12th Divinely ordained Imam after the Prophet (SAW).. With Salaams and pray, InshAllah, that you seek and discover the truth by the Grace and Guidance of the AllMighty One

[@corpsefoot758]

If Imam Ali “should have taken up arms” instead of waiting for more followers, why did our Prophet not “take up arms” instead of retreating from Mecca to Medina?

[@HussainFahmy]

Delving into the past grievances will not change the present not the future. It will only breed hate and disunity. Muslims should focus on uniting as one Ummah under the fundamental Islamic values and learn to tolerate minor differences in belief and avoid the unpardonable sin 'shirk'.

[@a_gen]

Salam, High above all is Allah, the King, the Truth! Be not in haste with the Qur'an before its revelation to thee is completed, but say, "O my Lord! advance me in knowledge." Quran 20:114 Knowledge, city, and who's the gate.... Ali is with the truth and the truth is with Ali. And I agree with you brother, let's all stop this and unite our ummah!! Let's stop all this and obey our prophet! Let's hold tight to those weighty precious things, THE QURAN and my AHLUL BAYT * No more shirk! Agreed!

[@syedwaqaraliabedi3051]

+Hussain Fahmy حسين فحمي‎ I agree we shouldn't fight on it but things should be explained.

[@sardaralirazanaqvi8541]

brother Salam Aliykum there is no bad that shia sunni.sunni also recite Quran and worship Allah and shia Also same. but if there is two types of water if one water is normal water and one water is came from heaven's from river of kawsar. so which one you drink? kawsar cause water from heaven's is pure water and greater in taste. so as shia followers of Ahlbait a.s belongs from jafri school of thought (teachings of Ahlbait a.s) that teachings of Ahlbait a.s is greater then other companions.

[@HussainFahmy]

*WaAlaikum Salaams* - _And lo! this your religion is one religion and I am your Lord, so keep your duty unto Me. (The Noble Quran __22:52__) But they (mankind) have broken their religion among them into sects, each sect rejoicing in its tenets. (The Noble Quran __22:53__) So leave them in their error till a time. (The Noble Quran __22:54__)_

[@syedwaqaraliabedi3051]

Hussain Fahmy حسين فحمي Bro shia is short for Shi`atul Ali a.s meaning partisans of Ali a.s. In islam there is no problem in making a party of a person that will never go against islam. Shia is not a sect it is a party. "And most surely Abraham was among the Shi’a of him (i.e., Noah)”(Qur’an 37:83) Shia has many meanings - follower,same kind etc. They imply that you follow a particular person. Mohammed s.a.w himself said that the true shias of Ali were Salman,Abu dhar,Miqdad,Ammar bin yasir (peace be upon them). And other hadith were mohammed s.a.w said no matter if the entire universe walks on one side and ali a.s the other. We should follow Ali a.s. Ofcourse All the people who claim to be shia might not be true shias of ali only allah knows who are and who arent. We are all sinners,we must try to improve ourselves by learning more about islam.