1978 Romanillos, 1973 Fleta, 2018 Scharbatke, Imai | The Weekly Guitar Meeting #20 - Siccas Guitars

[@marceloligalupi7238]

Ignacio Fleta y sus maravillosas tapas de cedro, maestro de luthiers, sus guitarras lo tienen todo, graves increíbles, agudos mágicos, Fleta por siempre!!

[@151dgold13Tx]

what a delight of sounds, wonderful

[@thesharpwatcher]

The Scharbatke is my preference. Very nice workmanship, excellently combined with its simplicity. The sound is sublime. Warm and detailed, with all tones from high to low coming out harmoniously.

[@сергейсолоницкий-м9ь]

Ignacio Fleta's guitar, in my opinion, outshines all other instruments. What a timbre , tone , and sustain !! And on the treble (the first three strings ) , as the guitarist said , the timbre is , of course, magnificent .

[@eguit1]

Fleta forewer👏👏👏

[@RobertoMartinez-kv5tp]

👍

[@locngo]

Wow....just WOW

[@IvaldoGTR]

muito obrigado Sergio Tordini valeuuuu

[@JoshChristiane]

I'd take the Fleta. It seems to have the most depth and resonance, something very old world Spanish about it.

[@SiccasGuitars]

I agree. It had more depth and resonance in comparison to the other guitars.

[@r.j.1456]

Yes, it was no contest really.

[@JamieCruz-g1f]

I second the motion. FLETA hands down!

[@ramongalipolo7256]

Excelent video... Beautiful guitars... I love the sound of all of them... Thank you...! Greetings...!!!

[@DavidSmith-sy2bp]

I do desire the Fleta . Alas my beer budget would not allow me to acquire such a gem . Thanks for the presentation:)

[@DavidSmith-sy2bp]

@Konstantin Ridaya i don’t drink alcohol….. I also don’t have $100,000.00 spare for self indulgence, though no judgment on people that can afford a Fleta .

[@NorbertLen]

Romanillos ❤❤❤❤

[@seanc5861]

All of these guitars sound better than my Yamaha C40.

[@RobertoMartinez-kv5tp]

Puntuación: Scharbatke 10 Imai 10 Romanillos 100 Fleta 100 El "sonido moderno" al que hace referencia el conductor, conlleva a que las guitarras tienen más volumen, son más gritonas. Pero pierden ese sonido maderal tan propio de una guitarra, y que le da a la música esos colores y ese sabor dulce agradable y fino. Jamas cambiaría una Fleta, Romanillos, Hauser, etc., por una guitarra con "sonido moderno"

[@IvaldoGTR]

sem sombra de duvidas viu , as 3 guitarras são fantásticas, cada uma com um característica bem pessoal, o Romanillos um timbre brilhoso, o Rolando um som consistente e forte, já o Fleta parece que tem uma personalidade sonora forte, um timbre forte vigoroso um grave muito bonito e médios encorpados, parabéns pela apresentação, sempre é um prazer ouvir as vozes dessas belas guitarras.

[@tribestribes2555]

Well, there is no problem to take a standpoint wich guitar is the very best, anyway for me. It fell on the Fleta of course. A brand I,v erlier in my days played at several occasions but never have the oppertunity to own. I,m 74 by now and realize that I will never own one, but thats life. Other guitars are of course very fine but no one can stand against a Fleta.

[@r.j.1456]

Totally agree, the Fleta was in a whole other league.

[@GeorgeAnastasiou]

Romanillos all day long

[@e4d578]

Romanillos for the win.

[@anthonyegan59]

It's good that you play , the same piece on each guitar.. A good guitar , has to have its Own pop, and project it's harmony.

[@JoseOchoa-dw9vk]

The Romanillos is amazing. ❤🎉😊 The Imai is also great. Not sure if I heard something inside the guitar bouncing around when rotated. 😮

[@jeffhildreth9244]

The IMAI appears to have a spruce top, or Port Orford Cedar.

[@nicolasnovoaartigas4488]

"It's like the tone which is smiling all the time" That's a nice description, Julian, it speaks very clearly to me at least. Congratulations for the good work! About the Romanillos, I always thought they sound much warmer than the Hausers, even if partially inspired by them. What do you think?

[@polochdesteufels8554]

Will haben!

[@joepworther2284]

FLETA !!!

[@carlostringhi7822]

Fleta is wonderful. Romanillos desappears.

[@IvaldoGTR]

Boa noite sou apreciador a apaixonado por guitarras classic, e musico, posso saber o nome desta peça a qual você sempre executa quando nos mata de inveja testando estas belas e preciosas guitarras? por favor

[@sergioguitars]

Ständchen de Franz Schubert/Mertz

[@HotZTrain]

This subject is subjective. My vote would be the American luthier, Jose Oribe.

[@fernandogoes7218]

Oh man. What amazing the romanillos. This is magical. Note: the sustain isnt longer?

[@budlarainey5123]

Are all the guitars strung with the same string’s? Why don’t you tell us weather the neck is a ‘c’ or ‘d’ profile, and what the nut and 12th fret widths are ?

[@johnmyers466]

Sure wish you would say the prices.

[@Ovell]

Interesting presentation as allways, i wondering if i'n Siccas are mexican models?

[@tasosdiaforetico7377]

4.07 the piece Is Schubert?

[@atharehk40]

😍😍

[@NamAnhNguyen-uq2mo]

4:57 what is the name of this beautiful piece? Please!!

[@SiccasGuitars]

Homenaje a la guitarra by E.S. de la Maza

[@peterpenrose4215]

Stanchen by Schubert

[@ramongalipolo7256]

Folks... what do you think about the sound of mahogany solid top guitars...? I like this kind of sound... and you...? Greetings...!!!

[@ramongalipolo7256]

I saw it... excelent...!!! I was waiting he plays the guitar... and suddenly... the video finished...😥

[@carpicabeckers6029]

To me the winner is the Imai. Followed by the Fleta, the Romanillos and finally the Scharbatke. If I could, I would even not put the Scharbatke in here...too much tone quality difference between this guitars. The Fleta is incredible, but I feel that the boomy basses somehow covers the beautiful trebles, making it a guitar you have to know really well to play it good.

[@djsebastian1]

I played an Imai when I was in Germany in 1983. It was a fantastic instrument but a little out of my price range at the time.

[@johnlay3040]

Romanillos is amazing, it doesn't seem to have louder G# on this one. Scharbatke is of the same level as Romanillos. Imai is not as loud as the other two. I don't agree that it sounds more like Kohno. Fleta, one of the Godfathers of Luthiery, is different from Romanillos, which is my first choice. My second choice is Scharbatke, 3rd Fleta and 4th Imai.

[@janvierc6924]

are they for sale? if so , how much does they cost ?

[@laucha490]

This gentleman has the strange ability of making any instrument sound awful

[@sebastianmansilla8166]

Bien dicho!

[@sebthi7890]

"Rolls Royce" der Gitarre... ich hoffe die Schmuckstücke haben nicht den gleiche desaströsen Preisverfall, wie die englischen Luxuslimousinen

[@phuchoangng93]

What is the song that you play please

[@SiccasGuitars]

Ständchen by F. Schubert & Fly me to the moon by Frank Sinatra.

[@phuchoangng93]

@@SiccasGuitars thank you ☺️

[@emp29]

What song did you play @4:05?

[@niceguitar6144]

Good video. Neither of the guitars stood out to me; despite the big names. If i had to have one, it would be Scherbatke.

[@mariusb5150]

Huh ... no 4, 2, 3, 1.

[@soundknight]

Ha! NO. Old, classy, under powered, decades old engineering... That's a Torres not a romanillos. 😉