2.5 (Pt. 1/4) - Max Weber: Bureaucracy, Types of Authority (UPSC Pub Ad by Ashish)

[@Gucci_matters]

Thank you thank you thank you so much Ashish Sir 🙏🙏🙏best lecture and notes

[@kk-op8qr]

Very Good Explanation.. Please continue the good work

[@kundanlal9119]

Provide us pdf please ...how to get pdf of all your lecture ...

[@saurabhkumar-ld1zi]

parampara , pratishtha , anushashan - traditional authority

[@s-l-m.]

You are explaining very nicely, million magic gratitude from the bottom of my heart !!!!

[@Adr-zw3nr]

Kautilya administration ki video hh kya

[@avnishrajput5758]

Great lecture sir ,please continue it.

[@qazi95]

Was waiting for this. Thank you Asish Sir

[@dose.of.happiness]

So can all govt officials who are "appointed " be called bureaucrats? For instance : clerc , section officer, sweeper, mali(when govt advertises for a vacancy of this post), since all these are appointed positions... can we call all of them bureaucrats? Kindly answer

[@UPSCPublicAdministration]

Hello Udita, this question would take us back to the first lecture: What do you consider to fall within the definition of 'administration'. Because, roughly translated, b'crats are administrators. So whether you take Integral view or Managerial view, would define your b'crats. Acc to integral view, clerks and sweepers are administrators too, since they have a role to play in the entire functioning. However, in modern times, generally speaking we call b'crats as those people who have a direct responsibility of administration. These would be the people who actually pass on the files, put their signatures on those files, etc. This has more to do with the importance attached to the word "b'cracy" after Weber gave his thesis. Because Weber explicitly mentioned what b'cracy should look like and how it should behave, I do not think clerks and other such appointments would qualify. Again, this is subjective and changes with perspective. I may think one way, some other scholar or thinker would convince you that sweepers are administrators too.

[@surabhikumari1693]

I m not able to download the PDF, through the app.can u help me in download of module slides

[@UPSCPublicAdministration]

These notes are not downloadable, only readable. I'm really sorry for any inconvenience caused. I used to provide PPTs earlier (before launching the app), but now everything is available on the app.

[@deepanshutiwari9439]

Sir in which Book I can get details like u have discussed here.Even the book by PRASAD AND PRASAD does not provide so many details.Please tell me about the references used by u... Thanx for the wonderful lecture

[@UPSCPublicAdministration]

Thank you Deepanshu for appreciation. I do not have any fixed reference for my notes. While I was studying the subject, I studied it from varied sources to make concepts clearer for myself. Now while preparing the notes, I knew what I had to put in the slides. In any case, for your ease, below are some links for a blog written by a Pub Ad topper (Lohit Matani), which will give you a deep insight on how to prepare the subject and what the approach should be. Also, it has module-wise and chapter-wise breakup of reference books: 1) Pub Ad Paper 1 strategy: lohitmatani.wordpress.com/2014/06/23/strategy-for-public-administration-paper-1-2/ 2) Pub Ad Paper 2 strategy: lohitmatani.wordpress.com/2014/06/24/strategy-for-public-administration-paper-2/ 3) Hidden Syllabus in Pub Ad: lohitmatani.wordpress.com/2014/07/08/hidden-syllabus-of-public-administration-for-cse/

[@deepanshutiwari9439]

Thank you Sir

[@ajaykumar-rf7bc]

Deepanshu Tiwari This matter in completely given as usual in ignou book ok ba

[@Sachin-qr7kl]

M Laxmikanth

[@shreeshachalawadi4846]

Sir.... Your explanation is good but can you please explain slowly....

[@gulabgulab2800]

listen at 0.75x

[@davidpaul4058]

Speed can be slow in u tube....😉

[@HawreKoyi1]

OMG, this accent !! blow up my head ...

[@shahirahali8628]

then get lost dumbass

[@Loh_purush]

I feel bit difficult to read Mohit Bhattacharya .. so do I stick to his book or I can switch to another one

[@UPSCPublicAdministration]

Mohit Bhattacharya's "New Horizons" is like "Bhagwad Gita" of Pub Ad. And as like Gita, it is very complex to understand, it is laced with heavy words and complex statements. But, the information contained in it is priceless. If you are able to understand what the author is trying to convey, it will stay with you forever. BUT, this book should be read only when you have some insight about the topic already. My suggestion would be to clear all the basic concepts about a topic. And then have a glance what M.B. has to say about the same topic. Surely with time, you will find the book to be of immense use.

[@Loh_purush]

Ok thank you sir.. I will stick to M.B only..

[@shrikrishnamanepatil4926]

Sir please give rest of the module. Your teaching is really great. I attended 2 coachings but none of them even close to you.

[@awadhutborkar2978]

Sir..ur lectures are so comphrensive and informative.. But...It's not analytical I hope u will consider this suggestions...Thanks

[@yashrajscreations7087]

Sir how to download ppt slides , plz let me know.

[@UPSCPublicAdministration]

Download link is in the description of every video (except Max Weber; Weber's ppt will be made available when all the 4 parts of it have been uploaded; it will be in the description of the video whenever that comes out)

[@girjeshsingh5080]

R ur videos available in hindi also..?

[@pankajsingh7762]

great work Ashish sir... you are the Savior of aspirants like me

[@surabhikumari1693]

U have a very fine distinction Power bw thinkers

[@rajammapandu169]

sir many many thanks you ,your reaching really good

[@UPSCPublicAdministration]

Thank you for your appreciation. Means a lot. :)

[@Gucci_matters]

Thank you sir...it is very helpful

[@nikhilwankhade4817]

good job sir

[@shahidashafeeq3003]

Sir plzz give lecture on rensis likert

[@harinderdhillon3386]

thank you so much Sir

[@prittj]

Thank younsir

[@UPSCPublicAdministration]

Thank you! :)

[@manasdascec]

difference between MPs and bureaucrats

[@UPSCPublicAdministration]

** MPs are "Members of Parliament". THESE ARE THE POLITICIANS. In India, people elect their politicians. (In some other other countries, politicians might even be appointed). ** B'crats, on the other hand, are NOT politicians. These are never elected, but appointed (they clear exams, face interviews, etc.). A bureaucrat is anyone whose primary work is administration at whatever level. These are the people who sit at desks and move paper around, who follow procedures and make decisions according to the procedures. They can be in business or in government service (IAS, IPS, etc. are examples of b'crats). ** Basically, work of a politician (MPs, ministers, etc.) is to form an overall policy - the broad outline. And finer details inside that broad policy are filled by b'crats. I hope this clears your doubt. :)

[@dose.of.happiness]

UPSC Public Administration can a clerc be called as a bureaucrat? Aur a govt hospital nurse, or a officer boy of govt organisation...

[@ameyakhadse8795]

thank u sir

[@rohitsingh-rb2cz]

You explain very fast kindly go slow