[2013가요대전] 전출연자 'You are a miracle'

2013 SBS 가요대전
2013년 12월 29일(Sun) 8:45 PM

[@BeibeiXiaobei]

once upon a time ... when KPOP is not only about viewers, awards, and who is famous TT.TT

[@dianalia6953]

Arlia miracle yes you are right, i miss so much

[@BeibeiXiaobei]

@@dianalia6953 me too :,( I want to go back in the past T.T where there is no competition about who is the most famous

[@raniseptiariani8711]

but it was about KPOP family

[@PianoNewBie690]

@@Loopaliza NOT, but obviously BTS played or rather their fans created an environment where they look at other idols like lesser beings. It didn't help also that BTShit condemned.

[@chimcham6762]

Nawwarah Zain Clearly you knew nothing about Cassies or H.O.T’s fanclubs back in the day...fanwars have been happening since the beginning of Kpop and it’s largely due to how these companies market their groups and Kpop. Kpop is a mixture of Japanese idol system and R&B/ hip hop music. The companies make these idols and package them with a specific image to sell to the fans in hopes of amassing a cult-like following where the fans will fight tooth and nail for their faves. Crazy fandoms and the inevitable fanwars have ALWAYS been an essential part of Kpop and continue to be. Y’all must be new Kpop fans or something 🙄

[@wongbdjzjdnsjdb6945]

This is what you call the golden era of kpop

[@youeclipseall]

wongbdjzjdnsjdb The song is golden. But there are always things behind and people suffering you do not know about.

[@bluemikmik6795]

True

[@khelenadevisukham]

True.

[@aeriwayzenni1308]

AGREE..

[@f.880]

exactly

[@bernspadua7864]

This is the main reason why 2nd gen kpop is the best era, the golden era. The interactions of each group and competition is adorable.

[@cosmicrailway7066]

and early 3rd gen too

[@freeexo9301]

True! I miss this time where music still matters the most.

[@JBieberGDragon-cd9qh]

The time when Jonghyun, Sulli and Go Hara is still there. And EXO is still complete. 2ne1 are still active. Where kpop groups became as one. The kind of collaboration that we can't have in this generation.

[@mejoo6575]

yeah bigbang also are here i can see iu and go hara standing together also i miss all of them i miss f(x) together

[@juvilynvalenzuela1269]

The time when JONGHYUN , SULLI & GOO HARA are still here 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭

[@beautifulkoreaworld5969]

All the legends in kpop in this video GOO HARA SULLI JONGHYUN💔💛😭😭

[@juvilynvalenzuela1269]

@@beautifulkoreaworld5969 😭😭😭

[@changbinsnose5584]

even eunb and rise from ladies code were still alive here.. 😭😭

[@yssaayuma6872]

Jhuvy Valenzuela 😭😭😭

[@user-mk9fy3mt7m]

I wish time stop still and everyone could recover from all the toxic people of this world

[@LiuYi_15]

Those days: KPOP vs world These days: KPOP vs KPOP Those days we weren't a global hit. We weren't popular as much as now. But we were happy. Those days are GOLDEN bcuz of that.

[@anjuleeboralessa6090]

I know what you mean. I talked with a really young fourth gen fan and I had to be super careful with what I said. Things have changed. A lot.

[@theaeych3834]

most of todays kpop generation's fans are having fun starting an arguement even you mean good with your words. they'll always mean ill and hate. 😔

[@fictionlover2064]

Well, back during the 1st generation, fandoms would engage into physical fights on the streets...

[@sarahjyun2044]

Guys pls don t lie 💀💀💀💀 kfans were fighting a real fight because of some petty

[@iekha_triples7718]

Lol... Kpop fans always fighting with each other since 1st gen... I remember Sone, Elf and Cassie biggest fight around 2010 and 2011... You can even find a lot of anti-Yoona page made by Tiffany fans (that just example) ... And remember Exo debut, the hate around their debut were massive. And there also SNSD Black Ocean, thats 2nd gen fans too. Facebook and twitter is war zone for 2nd gen fans back day... These days looks worse just because there are more people who likes kpop...

[@azrinash6370]

I don't care about any records broke or something. I just need this kind of thing, UNITY

[@maythukyaw7610]

Yesss!

[@mejoo6575]

yeah that is the real kpop

[@zeeeeenuh732]

when you are a SHINee fan but yet recognized all the artists here! that’s what we call unity that I can only see ‘til 2nd gen ♥️

[@nandhu9768]

same💎💎💎💎💎 I was searching for Minho too

[@user-jw3kf9cp1w]

2세대 레전드 가수들을 한 곳에서 볼 수 있다는 게 영광스럽고 그립다 때묻지 않은 순수함이 저들만의 분위기 저 때의 노래 다시는 못 볼 거 같아서 아쉽고 이런 세대에서의 노래를 듣고 즐길 수 있었음에 감사함을 또 느끼네

[@tina_salaria]

Golden days of kpop. No toxicity, no hate, no fan wars. Just pure talents, great friendship, and their passionate love for music.

[@netwpullnman1624]

No army

[@mawiifanai1028]

😭😭

[@mainaida2171]

lmao y'all weren't there in this time 💀 they were a lot of fanwars and toxicity

[@MiquiztliDarkl]

@@mainaida2171 But they were not as mediocre as nowadays

[@piggieluv92]

Are you sure ? I heard they had it physically.

[@mariaelialyngio5756]

ADMIT IT YOU ARE A FAN OF ONE OR TWO OR MORE GROUPS HERE BUT YOU RECOGNIZED ALL OF THEM 😅 THE POWER OF THE GOLDEN ERA

[@katarinacvetkovic4463]

All groups in the stage and all solos are perfect for me that time was precious and I cant ever forget how it feels being therw with them and love them. My heart stay there in happy times and when nothing was ruined like its now. I regret that any bad this happend at all. 2014 changed everything.

[@katarinacvetkovic4463]

@@chan607 right

[@lastscenebychen4344]

They'll have a hit song and we hype all that time, such a golden moment

[@ramisarayhan2178]

You can say many things like BTS broke that record, Blackpink created this and Twice made that and its true they are great but.... This is what they missed and this is what true kpop is, not infacted with american chart awards...........

[@ayalahmidi4885]

True 🙏

[@baekyoong489]

Agree..yes we are proud of american chart/ award..but this video is what we called home of kpop, they all like family

[@cryingmichi7768]

True. I am someone who started to listen to kpop since that era and stopped somehow. But it is also something i cannot deny, new gen kpop made me come back and remember how things back then was so much better

[@ayajeighnn20]

Up!

[@arieanne3507]

BTS had actually already debuted here. They were at this award show. They participated in the other idol performance

[@myraromasanta]

the golden days of kpop.. when they can create such a beautiful and meaningful song together without fandoms trashing other groups because they think their group: 1. is having less screentime or lines 2. is better artists 3. should be in the middle 4. should be most mentioned in the comment section 5. is the only reason they watched this 😢 miss the old days.

[@confusedmulfand5100]

Myra Romasanta ikr!!! I am miss too

[@ann13141]

so true

[@thueri9036]

True😢

[@hamarodaoud9430]

Myra Romasanta Words 👏👏

[@youeclipseall]

There is always these things. But back then the translation is not so good and advanced that’s why you do not know about.

[@strbrrymochii]

The time when Kpop isn't as toxic as it is now. Ah the old times.

[@josephjoestar9110]

Lol

[@ayrfawkes6039]

Yes

[@bubu-tg4gp]

RIGHT

[@bubu-tg4gp]

live유시아 but still same...

[@angiejackson4424]

I agree

[@sailormoons2]

exo were rookies but already so big in 2013 that they put them in the front with all the 2nd gen groups ICONIC

[@maythukyaw7610]

The power EXO holds and so proud of them^^

[@maiavitale8458]

EXO were just rookies yet they were standing in the same position with the already established older groups

[@Rattenfanger614]

Well if we consider that EXO gave the beginning at the 3rd gen you could say that "debuted" as 2nd gen and from Rookie were up to the big ones of the Golden Era of Hallyu.

[@user-qt3sm9uw4s]

진짜 이때 가요계가 너무 좋았다. 이때 활동한 그룹들이 소녀시대, 엑소, 카라, 샤이니, 에프엑스, 시크릿, 인피니트, 비스트, 비원에이포, 포미닛, 투피엠, 에이핑크, 걸스데이, 미쓰에이, 씨스타....지금은 중견이 되거나 전설을 찍은 후덜덜한 라인업들. 지금은 이 그룹들을 어떻게 한 자리에 부른 거지 라는 말이 저절로 나올 정도.... 아이돌 뿐만 아니라 아아유 케이윌 같은 솔로 가수들도 있었고. 요즘은 이별노래+사재기가 대놓고 창궐하고 있는데다 한 그룹이 독주하고 있어서 음악프로가 너무 심심함.

[@ailee_mylife]

+솔로 에일리♡

[@__-ui9ft]

빅스...블락비...

[@user-rj2yu8ld3b]

슈퍼주니어 ♡

[@young6756]

+ cnblue❤️

[@user-ty1uf5zl1z]

아이유💓

[@preetidas9418]

The new kpop stans only know how to make everything toxic. This is the era they all missed

[@firstinttv8232]

TRUE.... they're only know about 'i feel blabla style in her/him' or like 'i feel this group looks like blabla' TOO MUCH DISAGREMENTT

[@khelenadevisukham]

True

[@lisaaprilia9747]

Trueee

[@user-fq5xd2nc2h]

Im also really miss this era, the truely of kpop without all the drama

[@katarinacvetkovic4463]

@J Perm Official Fan Account we know how music feels like free and did with passion and with talents. For me kpop was better when little people know them and when it wasn't big in America or west. People need to appreciate music and let that lead them. Not this poor quality things.. I never said I don't like new kpop just feel like something need to change and be better. Only sad things I heard this year even when Bts are the best Black Pink made views and so on so on. Kpop are falling apart don't you see... Kpop need new beginning. I will stop seeing news of kpop stars and will listen old kpop.. That's way better then this...

[@christina-leigh2833]

The fact that most kpop fans these days weren’t around when this legendary moment in time was created, is actually so sad they will never understand how brilliant it used to be when artist could actually hangout without being hated on and a time where fame, fortune, awards, gender, and fan wars didn’t matter. A beautiful moment where idols could just hangout and do what they loved most making music😩 it’s hard to see that nowadays😒😒 it’s sad that idols these days can’t even do their job without being frowned upon by even one person. It breaks my heart too that new fans don’t even acknowledge idols of this generation all they care about is who’s great now even though there are many awesome groups now, we should always be greatful for those who paved the way including those of the 1st and 2nd gen as well

[@shinaejzhang7891]

uwu 😭💚

[@rockinpinkcadillac]

I was around but just didn’t listen to it back then sadly 😔 Back in 2013 I would have been 14 years old. I started listening to it when I was 18.

[@theabsoluteking8764]

I’m a 2nd Gen fan since 12’, because of BIGBANG. But I can’t forget 2NE1, Girls Generation, EXO, Infinite, SHINEE, Epik High, Super Junior, Many of the 2nd Generation Groups. Who cares about international awards, who cares about Daesangs, views. Music was all we cared back then, and family. The Golden Era will never be topped.

[@maryannenelson4355]

While fans are good, they can also be scary. Some of them create the toxicity in kpop today. They get angry when idols hang together, complain about this and that. Like I said, some.

[@zanramp]

So true all people care about is who is more popular and degrade and hate those who has less fandom. People nowadays are so toxic.

[@user-mu3zq5wn3o]

진짜 저때가 개인적으로 가요계 레전드라 생각해서 그리워진다.... 지금보면 에이핑크랑 엑소가 저때는 1~2년차 신인이어서 레전드 선배님들과 함께했었지만 지금은 어느새 두그룹이 레전드 대선배가 되어버렸고ㅠㅠ 예전에는 중소형 기획사 그룹들이 가요계 접수하고 그랬는데 요즘에는 대형아니면 저시절부터 활동한 그룹들 아니면 이름 모르는게 대다수... 그리고 가끔 보러올때마다 이제는 볼수없는 얼굴들이 보여서 되게 울컥해지네... 그곳에는 아프지말고 웃으면서 행복하게 다들 지내시길

[@user-if1fh1vd8o]

세계적으로는 지금이 k-pop전성기라지만 한국인에게는 이때가 가장 전성기 아니였을지 ㅜ ㅜ .. 그립다

[@itsthiaaa414]

The golden era of kpop.. Gosh how I wish I could turn back the time.. Second generation of kpop was always the best! Less fanwar and more friendship

[@shogunsista]

Its Thiaaa I agree with you. It's a healthy competition. 🙂

[@ann13141]

Its Thiaaa i totally agree.

[@arianataes8420]

Its Thiaaa i agree but the fanwars were much worse back then

[@EyqaNsj]

I agree with u.. until now. My music file still filled it with 2nd generation song..

[@boydrewl]

loonatheworld not as bad as it is now. It 2013 fanwars were not as bad..

[@andd2456]

REAL KPOP about QUALITY not POPULARITY ALL LEGEND TOGETHER FRIENDSHIP GOLDEN ERA OF KPOP 😢😢

[@aininsofiyabtmdnasir1282]

AS 27 i agree with you.I miss the golden era of kpop.Nowadays kpop is all abouat popularity and top in charts.Fanwars between fandom when their idols cannot get the win.Definetely this era cannot compete that golden era🤘

[@hafsamoarmy4ever924]

Ikr

[@mariaanneguevarra6818]

Real legend

[@hafsamoarmy4ever924]

I really miss that kpop without aby fan wars.....😢 I want that time back

[@mohash21]

2:32.... Dude that part with Ailee and Taeyang was so magical 😍❤️.... Jonghyubs's high note RIP... And the legend Tiger JK 🙏... And the fan screams on G-Dragon damn, he was the biggest soloist at the time and owned 2013 👑... Miss the 2nd and early 3rd gen Kpop 😔

[@asyrafdimyati2529]

The fact that Exo were just rookies singing with their seniors shows how popular they were back then.

[@user-ks5kc1co9m]

와 진짜 한명도 모르는 가수가없네.. 이분들이 있기에 지금에 k-pop이 있다고 생각합니다. 지금 이 순간에도 볼수없는사람들도 있어서 한편으론 찡하네요 그땐 이렇게 될줄 몰랐는데..

[@user-M1_nji09]

인정요ㅠㅠ😢😢😢

[@user-by7bl4ek8g]

그립다 정말..여기서 3명은 하늘의 천사가 되버리고 이젠 다시 못보는 그룹이 있다는게 너무 마음 아프다. 고마워요 제 학창시절을 행복하게 해줘서

[@user-ml6nl1gk9o]

카메라에 잘 안잡혔지먼 뒤에 레이디스 코드 멤버들도 있네요..불과 약 7년만에 5명의 천사들이 떠났네요....

[@user-gy5mj4pv8c]

제가잘몰라서 그러는데 누구인지알수있나요?

[@user-ml6nl1gk9o]

아미 레이디스 코드 은비 리세양과 샤이니 종현군 에프엑스 설리양 카라 구하라양 각각 멤버들은 안잡혔지만 다른 그룹들 사이 사이에 같은 그룹 멤버들이 잡힌 거 보면 아마 저 자리에 잏지 않을까요...

[@user-gy5mj4pv8c]

감사합니다

[@user-fd1hr3xn3v]

아 진짜 너무 슬퍼요 이노래들으니깐 또 눈물나네요..

[@user-wr7ql7cg6s]

한명한명 나오는데 계속 소름돋는다.. 이젠 이렇게 또 모이긴 힘든 조합이라 더 대박인듯..

[@springdelight3889]

Fans today will not understand how beautiful this era was.

[@bootupjeansoh7959]

When KPOP is still about unity in music. When B1A4 is still blessing us their vocals. When Beast is still Beast. When EXO was still OT12 (will always be) When SNSD was still OT9 When SHINee still have Jonghyun in their side When BIGBANG still wanted to promote in Korea When ZE-A is still promoting When INFINITE still have Hoya as their main dancer When f(x) still have Sulli When KARA still have Hara When 2NE1 isn't disbanded When MissA is still promoting When 4minute isn't disbanded yet .... a lot of things happened. I am so happy i am part of this journey. ❤️🥺 (Sorry if i forgot someone)

[@erlindawardani4038]

note ze:a only hiatus not disband

[@todayslucy]

When Girls day, sistar still promote

[@xantialogrono4666]

The best era

[@nurkhalida8290]

When CNBLUE still have their guitarist

[@notbythemoon4957]

crying this comment hurts so bad

[@quenparantar5670]

03:43 JONGHYUN, THOSE HIGH NOTES :( IMISSYOUSOMUCH. REST IN PEACE

[@deediaries4338]

Quennie Parantar Zz

[@Jessica-et2lv]

also jonghyun being in the thumbnail :'(

[@quenparantar5670]

Jessica stop :( cant take it anymore :(

[@aiurlevi]

fuck....... my feels

[@othach8555]

Dont worry... He will have another life... I didn't believe in something like reincarnation but when I saw the blue moon, I believed it is real...

[@shrijitahalder]

K-pop then: About Passion for Music and Unity and love for each other K-pop now- About Views,Daesangs and Fanwars

[@topkpopzaekhyun4742]

watching in 2020 and missing : BigBang,2ne1,GuHara,Sulli,Jonghyun,"Kris,Luhan & Tao" Old times💔😭

[@user-ro1wj7kd9t]

뭐야 다들 해체 안하고 모여있는 거 보니까 왜 반갑지,, 일방적 친밀감 뭐야 이거ㅠㅜ😭 되게 오랜만에 만난 친구 같네,, 이때로 돌아가고 싶다 ㅜㅜ

[@user-tu4rr1un3f]

Jonghyun did that high note at the climax Im soooo proud of SHINee

[@atashaash6929]

Jonghyun😭

[@ratihsiskasari7007]

Kpop more popular worldwide now but gen 2 still the golden era of kpop for me Because their Friendship, peace and unity

[@dalllaliii6494]

For the new generation 3-4 fans, I present to you, the best song of all time, you are a miracle. Your idol song cannot beat this and this moment is more precious than your idol's achievement. And the fact is that the legendary kpop kings and queens come from here, your idols exist because all of them. (note; this time also dont have any articles about dating rumours as a big news of the day, LOL)

[@santitorres2108]

Who still watch in 2019?

[@elenaparkdenilapark2707]

Meeee

[@13.ervandaregita20]

Meeeeee

[@elvasyap8747]

Me :")

[@lhyneabarro1108]

Just wandering, of all company: JYP, YG, and SM... I always see JYP around of all kpop group.. although YG’s group are popular worldwide and SM’s group are also popular individually.. I see SM but sometimes only unlike JYP (all around)

[@someone1685]

Rosario Torres SF13 meeee

[@xiuminxiuminkokobop3868]

This was honestly so beautiful, some of the biggest legends performed including BIGBANG, SUJU, SNSD, 2NE1, EXO, BEG, BAP, SHINEE, IU, KWILL, APINK, MISSA, KARA, BLOCKB, BEAST, CNBLUE, 4MINUTE, Ailee and more. I cant believe I hadnt watched this before, I feel so nostalgic, this was genuinely the golden age of kpop❤️

[@tasmimfarhana5714]

You forgot 2PM 😭😢😢😦

[@raihananur5398]

you missed INFINITE

[@ladygee4659]

Teentop too

[@mokona3424]

Ladies code

[@andd2456]

ALL OF LEGEND THERE REAL KPOP about QUALITY not POPULARITY....

[@kangtaanchilhyun1262]

3:41 onew and key looking proud at Jonghyun and taemin. I miss you and love you always Jjong.

[@chaemin734]

가슴아프고 찡하다 정말 이때감성 너무그립다.. 빅뱅 소녀시대 제국의아이들 샤이니 인피니트 엪엑스 등등.. 진짜 너무 그립다 다시 가요계의 시간을 돌릴수있다면 이때즈음으로 돌아가서 아무생각없이 즐기고싶어

[@karlacisneros2385]

The feeling you feel after watching this is what kpop is supposed to feel like. Facts dear new stans it’s not about popularity or looks it’s about appreciation and love and family.

[@SelenaLaVonne]

I don't even care abt kpop idols looks or how popular as long as they make me feel some type way and i know their personality well even if behind tv or anything then i will keep em in my heart forever just like Jonghyun💔...

[@windsl280]

This is what i want to say❤️

[@shootmeisawholemood7516]

The new groups can be as popular as you want. They can win thousands of awards, break through American charts, overshadow all... but they’ll never- NEVER- be as great as this generation of kpop. I don’t care what you say.

[@shootmeisawholemood7516]

Sanjana Shagolsem back when the Second Generation was popular, kpop wasn’t a “thing” I’m America. I’m not saying that new groups are worthless, I’m just saying that this generation is better. The strongest groups and bonds were formed in this time, even if most did split up eventually.

[@jonaviepulido3492]

@@shootmeisawholemood7516 I think you need to grow up a little hun, it's just music. Music is supposed to be enjoyed, to inspire people, not to create fanwars or start hate. The way you worded your opinion, you sounded envious, jealous and even angry about the current generation's achievements, things not even the biggest k-acts from early to late 2000s were able to get. I want to remind you that no generation is better than the other. Each has to write their own story. Clearly, this is what BTS thought when they wrote and recorded Baepsae. Older generation feeling superior to the younger ones, it is sad because you are limiting these artists on the K-pop bubble and not let them move forward because they aren't the generation you like or the group/artist you prefer. I wouldn't say the older generation is not legendary as you try to make them seem but really, I like how the new generation of k-pop break away from the formula that they kept recycling since BoA and HOT's breakout. And FYI, a lot of third generation groups are close af. Because I'm an ARMY, I'm proud to say that BTS' bond is beyond being members of the same group and label, they are brothers and friends. RM and Suga lived together for eight years, as OT7, they've been living in one roof for seven to six years, and in fact, their early years, they all sleep in one room. They can tell each other apart just by their breathing and smell. They fight a lot but love each other a million folds, something that they reflected through their music. Born Singer, 2! 3!, Sea and Begin, among their other songs exist for a reason.

[@erintse5]

Mai Mai honestly not to start hate but i think the 2nd and 3rd generation Kpop groups are better. As a long follower of the kpop trend probably since 2012/2013 this generation of kpop groups are irreplaceable. And fyi, groups like bts and twice are regarded as 4th generation groups.

[@jonaviepulido3492]

@@erintse5 BTS is considered 3rd generation groups by some sources. Music is subjective so we can never truly point out which generation is better, for me, they are, for you, the other but does it really matter? I've been following K-pop and Asian pop for that matter since 2008 because I used to be a big fan of groups like Fahrenheit and S. H. E. (Taiwan), Twins (Hong Kong), Arashi, KAT-TUN, NewS, Hey! Say! JUMP! (Japan), U-Kiss and TVXQ (SK), at first, I was attracted with the uniqueness of the idol industry in each country, I like knowing the history of everything and eventually, listened to their music, btw, most of the people I used to follow, I primarily found them through dramas and films except for U-Kiss and TVXQ which I found through Pops in Seoul, but honestly, I never got interested in knowing the meaning of their songs in a deeper sense despite having English translations, and among the singers I know in K-pop, the best vocals belong to Kim Jaejoong and BoA, 2nd gen music are bop and danceable but I don't listen to music because of its vibe or beat, I truly LISTEN to music when it moves me, when its message matters to me. I am just sorry that those earlier groups cannot provide me that sense of belongingness in their music nor do they were able to build a connection with me, they made want to dance and all that but they were not able to let me look at the world in different perspectives. However, BTS provided me all those things in the most special way. I am not saying they are better than everyone in the industry but I will never get tired of sharing how their music touched my life. Would you believe that the first time I listened to their debut album, 2Cool 4Skool, I cried so hard? No matter what genre BTS use in their music, their message is beyond those aesthetic surface, their lyrics expresses my inner thoughts and woes, things I could never say aloud. There is a high chance you'll wonder if what I feel for BTS and their music is real or I'm just promoting them, but so you know, I found BTS at my darkest times, I was about to leave my first job, I worried about my future, my family's finances and almost forgot my self-worth, almost losing my identity, I was losing my battle with depression... BTS came into my life and made me realize so many things about me. Just by listening to Path, I was bawling because it was literally my life in some ways. BTS is helping me find myself again, giving me hope that one day, I can learn to truly love myself.

[@shootmeisawholemood7516]

Mai Mai honestly, when I’m talking about the strongest bonds I would choose SHINee. I don’t know if you know this because Armys tend to only think BTS is the best so they don’t look at any other groups. I’m not trying to start a fan war, I’m simply stating that this generation is better. How would I be bringing down the new generation? My opinion obviously doesn’t matter anyways. Out of the thousands of people that enjoy kpop I’ll say that more than 3/4 are Armys. In the great scheme of things, my opinion is nothing and it’s just the petty “kpop” fans like you that feel the need to fight. Honestly, as I was saying before, there is no bond stronger than SHINee. They’ve known each other for 13+ years and additionally, they’ve cared for each other for so long that it hurts my heart. When they won their first Daesang they cried so hard they could barely form sentences the thank their fans. They’re so humble, and you can tell they have a beautiful brotherhood. They’ve been through more than you can imagine concerning the lack of any promotion from SM and the hard work they’ve underwent. Even after the death of Jonghyun, they continue to honor him and keep him in their hearts.

[@DR-gp2jj]

wow!! IU, Big Bang, Shinee- the 2nd gen idols still standing tough with the 4th gen idols.

[@kimchoco789]

작곡가 작사가 아이돌 가수부터 모르는 사람이 한 명도 없다..말이 되냐ㅠ 지금은 분위기가 많이 달라진 것 같아서 아쉽다

[@sheng2435]

New K-Pop fans this is what you've missed!

[@ferielfifi1297]

tbh

[@nouraalmeqbaali8114]

I’m so sad that I only knew about Kpop at the middle of 2017 😭😭😭😭😭

[@nnyliala1968]

I agree

[@silvia-907]

@@nouraalmeqbaali8114 I feel you. Kpop fan since 2018... :/

[@user-ct9lk4ek6r]

와 이게 바로 레전드다 진짜 레전드중 개레전드 개레전드 탑급이 다모이기 쉽지않은데 와 저때가 가요계 리즈

[@melisatan8438]

This song is the most memorable song. where all the best groups and soloists come together as one. the person who collected them should really receive recognition for this outstanding performance 👏👏

[@user-je8xf2zi3o]

3:33 너무 이쁘다 우리 5이니..

[@rqserenity526]

Those good times when; KARA, 2NE1, 4Minute haven’t disband, Sulli is still with f(x), L.Joe still with Teen Top, ZE:A, After School, Miss A was active, Hoya still with Infinite Jessica sooyoung seohyun tiffany still with Girl's Generation Luhan kris tao still with exo And Jonghyun still alive 😭 How things have changed now.

[@keziafrederikam7989]

Miss Jonghyun

[@amaliee.r.3203]

EunB and RiSe were alive at that time too

[@Jessica-et2lv]

Also snsd is complete :( It was a really good time back then

[@rqserenity526]

Jessica ah you're right, i miss that moment :')

[@heikogebel5908]

Ladies' Code with 5 members 😍

[@Letpeaceprevail]

Jonghyun is one of the greatest artist in Korea even outside the world.....his voice is unique and hard to learn...may he rest in peace.

[@user-mv2nh7jd3e]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/gGjSgZyNr9h6js0

[@sofisofia5948]

Rip him

[@andreaminaya3502]

Jonghyun 😪😭💔💘

[@khonbenolotha9618]

Best of all thank you

[@reignaeleyna9495]

And his jokes are awesome. Rip

[@CrazyShawolAline]

I want go back to this era 😢

[@n.5438]

My eyes for IU BABY with her voice amazing 😭🥺💗💗💗.

[@user-ur1lk3pn8v]

진짜 이때는 자기 아이돌을 떠나서 진짜 그해에 누구든지 들으면 알 수 있는 아이돌 나와서그냥 가요대전을 기다리고 즐겼는 데 지금은 그냥 솔직히 자기 아이돌만 봄... 진짜 이때 가수들 보고 싶다... 여기 아이돌들이 kpop 알려준 분 들었는 데ㅜㅜ

[@jadechoii]

어떻게 한 팀도 빠짐없이 모아놨냐 이거 기획한 사람은 두고두고 칭찬 받아야한다👍모든 팀이 영원할 줄 알았는데 하나 둘 해체해가면서 내 추억도 사라지는 기분이었는데 이렇게라도 기억 할 수 있어서 너무 다행이다. 다들 아프지말고 잘 지냈으면 좋겠다 소중한 추억들은 잘 간직할게.

[@keilaargueta1570]

Always remembered RiSe, EunB, Jonghyun, Sulli and Hara♡ THE BEST ERA, 2ND GEN.

[@jenniekimistheaceofkpop4638]

GD and Taeyang with their strong presence 💖

[@user-fh3xr2xd9x]

평생 다시 볼 수 없는 얼굴도 있고 평생 함께 무대에 설 일이 없는 사람들도 있고...속상하다

[@123violin9]

샤이니 한때 정말 좋아했었는데 정말... 가슴이 찢어진다...

[@ye__seul]

+엑소나간 둘기놈들

[@user-hj5fu8wx3t]

저기 반이상 그룹해체하거나 탈퇴한그룹 보이네 범죄자들도 4명정도 보이고

[@ymju123]

@@ye__seul 걔넨 안봐도 돼요

[@user-nx9ng1qt6h]

진리야 사랑해 너무 보고 싶다

[@user-ru1xd6gc5w]

6년이 지난 지금 보니 참 많은게 변했네요,,, ㅠ 많은 그룹들이 해체하고, 많은 가수들이 탈퇴를 하였고, 6년전 우리가 봤을때 정말 멋지고 빛나는 존재들을 이제는 저때만큼 자주 보지 못한다는게 슬프네요😭

[@MiquiztliDarkl]

Those joining kpop after 2017 will never understand how awesome these eras were and how joyful was to watch perform every single artist/group

[@zidanef.480]

Hopefully SBS created a friendship project like this again

[@bluniverse7833]

They did for KCON they all sang bigbang's version of sunset glow

[@anifaha.7141]

I'm so Thankful that EXO is part of this legendary collaboration. No doubt, why DARA said that exo her last Idol. 💚

[@mansininixo1441]

Luhan, Tao and Kris were there too😐

[@rifqyalbari5614]

This is why Exo said in two generations

[@lelou6563]

Can we just go back to year 2013? When everyone was so pure and alive and living their dreams?

[@ruthadutwumwaaboateng2501]

Stewie Griffin same

[@bujeebujeee7908]

yes. there is my jessica too ㅠㅠ

[@ruthadutwumwaaboateng2501]

Bujee bujeee you sure I didn't see our queen Jessica

[@bujeebujeee7908]

Ruth adutwumwaa Boateng i mean not in this video but in 2013

[@marziaabigaelpalma6597]

If we could just go back to that time.

[@megha8336]

This is what I miss in this generation of kpop . This what the real kpop, the golden era of kpop. Missing those good old days a lot . Idols interactions, collaboration everything. I was really lucky to be a part of this golden era from 2012 onwards . Kpop has changed a lot. I could still feel the Korean vibe through those songs. Now days kpop are like who is famous, who break the record and more KZbin views. This something we can’t see again in coming generation . They are the real legends of the kpop. Really missing those good old days of kpop.

[@reshmi5333]

Same here...started being a kopper.2012 onwards.. the best era

[@ellie_7428]

3:33 본방으로 보면서 종현이가 태민이한테 장난치는 거 보고 웃고 태민이 미소 너무 예뻐서 웃었는데 시간이 이렇게 지났네

[@namshai3979]

i miss this era LEGENDS😍😍😍 best era in Kpop. when all groups are friends. until now they are friends... EXO, BEAST, BIGBANG, BEAST, SHINEE, SUJU, INFINITE, TEENTOP, BAP, SNSD, 2NE1, APINK,KARA,4minute, MISS A, F(x), IU, and MOOORREEEEE. i love them all..... i got stuck in this beautiful era..

[@nouraalmeqbaali8114]

shai Nam I wish I was there during this era 😭😭😭😭

[@ditimeto9775]

The best era...

[@nadrahrahim9894]

Me too...i miss them...

[@joekolateb9774]

Me too...an I am not leaving... 😊

[@oriananurrahmawati2780]

GIRLS DAY 😭😭 I MISS THEM

[@user-xm5dj1ss9m]

여기 있는 모든 가수들은 가요계에 한 획을 그은 사람들임

[@milkywayexo]

나는 저때 좋아. 이 노래도 울컥하고 좋아. 고마워, 모든 아이돌 가수들. 노래해주고 무대 서줘서. 덕분에 위로 받고 행복해. 다 소중한 존재야

[@mariasailo3079]

They are the one who paved the way.....

[@Karina-rk5cp]

It's 2019 and here's how much it has changed since then: - Jonghyun (of Shinee) passed away - Beast is changed to Highlight - Luhan left EXO - Kara, 4minute, missA, 2ne1, BAP disbanded - Taeyang got married - Tiffany and Seohyun left SMent - Jonghyun (of CNBLUE) involved in a huge scandal This just shows how many unpredictable things happen in only 5 years. I miss the good old era. You're welcome to add more!

[@evangelica9396]

Since that damn burning sun incident, i have been doing old kpop songs marathon. it was definitely the golden era :""""

[@evangelica9396]

Oups, don't forget hoya who left infinite :"

[@itsanna3rih]

KPOP Gossips JONGHYUN ( of CN BLUE ) isn’t in a scandal he is the bastard!!!! I am just disgusted every time i see his face .....

[@evafadilla1510]

don't forget kaeun who joining produce48 and sunmi left JYP

[@aaydef7881]

F(x) with no comeback HAHAAH

[@blue_night_-]

당연히 계속 볼 수 있을거라 생각했는데 시간이 지나보니 그렇지 않았기에 마냥 웃으면서 볼 수는 없지만 그럼에도 정말 소중했던 기억들, 모든 추억들

[@JAclever-pw6nd]

No song can beat this song, now matter how the newer generation sing together or the new songs achieve heights still this is still untouchable, the fact that this is when the K-hiphop and K-pop doesn't have that wall. I stan Kpop in 2015 and I'm familiar with all the K-hiphop artists who participated here even the soloist. I don't stan them all but I knew all of them.

[@syafiqaharina]

2nd gen is the golden generation of kpop✨the best generation ever!

[@user-ok2ws2et8d]

진짜 저때가 우리나라 레전드 KPOP 가수들임...

[@jcucumbera8066]

@구글글 저사람들이 있었으니까 지금가수들이 세계적으로 유명해진거지..소녀시대나 빅뱅이 진작에 해외로 가는 문을 안열어줬음 지금방탄이나 트와이스가 세계로 나갈 수 있었겠나요 애초에 케이팝이라는 장르를 만드신 분들이죠

[@EuniceYore]

김가은 인정~~

[@user-ot3kw8ug4m]

김가은 인정 ... 저때가 진짜 쌉레전드 KPOP 가수들이다

[@user-xg2yx4vi8k]

글쎄.. 그냥 2,3세대 아이돌 같은데.. 레전드라 부르기엔....

[@zi-zone]

@yu r 이런애들이 멜론차트 사재기 음원 들으면서 좋다고 빨아줄듯..ㅋㅋ 에휴~^^ㅋㅋㅋ

[@mang0allergy]

정말 이 시절이 너무 그립다. 아이돌 덕질 세대가 느낄 수 있는 그 특유의 분위기..?가 제일 만연했던 시절같아. 97년도 H.O.T 시대 지나고, 2012-3년 이때 아이돌 덕질 포텐 터졌다고 생각함.. 내 학창시절 생각나서 정말 아련하다

[@Kaye_Gaming1028]

When you almost know the groups and soloists here. 😭 I'm proud to that I got to see the Golden Era of KPOP.

[@vinnysolagraciamesah9354]

People nowdays have to know, every group and person in this video are people who lead korean vawe into world, thats why kpop can go international because of their talent. The golden era of kpop, no fan war. And its not just about viewers, awards or who is the famous one. It is just about how talented they are:) Being kpop fan nowdays seems to noisy…

[@wlsthd5]

와 심장에 소름돋는다 .....모르는사람 한명도 없고 그룹마다 색깔도 다다른다 노래가 하나가 된다..

[@ppp5773]

이젠 볼수 없는 조합이다...ㅠㅠ 이때까진 맨날 연말이 기다려졌는데..

[@ynnelkim5318]

The moment I saw Shinee and Junghyun singing his part, I cried. He looks so happy ang carefree, I can't believe he's gone now.

[@gaktaugakpunyanama9712]

Anyone watching this video in 2024? I really miss the moment second generation idol 🥹🥹🥹

[@johnnyflor]

3:44 JONGHYUN WE WILL MISS YOU... #Jonghyun #Shawols

[@serirasyidah2390]

John Lemuel Flor jonghyun is miracle :')

[@sonesooyoung2896]

John Lemuel Flor me to 💔

[@parkjenni7738]

YES WE WILL MISS HIM

[@johnnyflor]

HE IS OUR MIRACLE ANGEL!

[@krings5114]

This is sure the memorable era ever😢😢 shinee jonghyun, missA , snsd , exo and other artist in one video.

[@user-xq6fi4qz9g]

이시절 그리운 사람들 많을거다... 나도 저때가 그리움

[@JENIN1912]

저땐 어려서 더 꼬박 챙겨본 것도 있지만 스토리 있는 무대, 컨텐츠도 많았고 서로 어울리는 무대가 많아서 더 재밌었는데 지금은 화려한 무대뿐인 것 같아서 몇몇 가수들 무대만 보고 다른데 틀거나 아얘 안보게 됨..

[@user-mo2yu6iv7l]

정말 아무것도 안변할 거 같은데 너무 많은 것들이 변했다. 딱 하루만이라도 저 때로 돌아가고 싶다 크리스마스가 진짜 크리스마스 같고 연말이 정말 연말 같았었는데 참

[@esharamchurn6513]

3:47 JONGHYUN SLAY

[@alexajuliaisip1434]

😢

[@laroussimarwa5768]

Esha Ramchurn ❤❤❤❤

[@VIOLET-bs3gm]

He rests at peace now 😢😢

[@kateson22]

😢😢😢😢😢

[@restiindraswari4215]

😭😭

[@seyochoi588]

missing this era of kpop. when everything is enjoyable.

[@milkywayexo]

2013년은 정말 라인업들이 끝내줬구나, 내 학창시절. 그립다, 다 행복만 하세요.

[@sunithabhasker3397]

Taemin looks soooo happy with his hyung jonghyun I really worry for him 😭😢

[@ann13141]

sunitha bhasker im more worried with all shinee members. how are they going to keep going on despite the hurt inside them.

[@sunithabhasker3397]

ANN QIU yeah I know. I'm worried about all of them. But I am specifically worried about Taemin because he's the youngest one. 😔

[@EyqaNsj]

sunitha bhasker im worried too

[@chantaljacee2394]

Taemin can get thru this, he has remaining 3 hyungs at his back. And Taemin is strong guy. All SHINee bros can get through this. (to be honest... I myself is having a hard time coping up with the reality that we can't anymore see Jonghyun. Hurting like hell. His great voice, his wits, his caring side, his tough and fighter side, his physical presence~ damn.... heartbreaking). #PrayingForThem

[@restiindraswari4215]

Worry?? Why. Taemin can smile. But me, still crying for Jonghyun.. i think nobody love Jonghyun.. Jonghyun deserve more love

[@user-br4fn3xd2r]

이때랑 지금 시상식 보니 세대 체인지를 확실히 했구나... 생각해보면 그렇게 오래된것도 아닌데

[@emeenoraineeralino3068]

Legendary era!!!! wala pang toxic fans di kagaya ngayon :"

[@FlowerL_1485]

2:32 ailee & tae 💗💗💗 exo rookies with legendary groups wow 3rd gen exo 2nd gen BIGBANG My lovely groups coz of insane vocals & performance Still listening to those groups 2nd gn gold days ❤❤❤ MISSING pure talents

[@user-iu8pj6ci1y]

진짜 눈물 나올 거 같다... 이게 언제적이야 우리 때 아이돌들 가수들 다 모여있어 ㅜㅜㅜㅜ해체도 안 하고 전체 다 모여있어 ㅜㅜ

[@wonhuishua9999]

The Era where idols can interact with each other without minding their fans 😭

[@Me-zf2uh]

I miss this.. miss they interaction..

[@wonhuishua9999]

Me나 I hope kpop will turn back to this :

[@jakedellomas5058]

I wish we can still have this kind of era. When kpop is about Music, artistry and friendship.

[@user-lt5rl8kf8d]

요즘 이때가 너무 그리워서 자꾸 보러오게 된다 초등학생 때 12월, 1월만 되면 크리스마스와 새해의 그 설레는 분위기 즐기면서 늘 연말 무대를 기다렸는데 언제부턴가 그런 설렘도 사라지고 나는 벌써 고2네 작년에 티비 돌리다가 가요대전 잠깐 봤는데 어느새 아이돌들도 세대교차가 됐더라 예전이 너무 그립다

[@jaedeeh7323]

This song symbolizes the Golden Era of KPop, seriously. I was amazed at how they were able to gather the best of the best to sing this amazing song... reminds me of how I first started listening to KPop almost 10 years ago. Watching it now brings me a lot of nostalgic and (definitely) bittersweet feelings.

[@S.doan2002]

2013 was a wonderful time for kpop when.. EXO was ot12 B2ST still had hyunsung Jessica was still with SNSD ZE:A was active Sulli was with F(X) KARA haven't disbanded After School was around TeenTop performed often 2NE1 was still together MISSA had their leader Jia and when 4MINUTE was a group how things have changed...

[@lationhard8039]

soitssarah leader Jia?😕

[@ayses4668]

soitssarah Miss A never had a leader

[@PrincessNabilah]

and still use BEAST as their group name right now in 2017 their group rename as HIGHLIGHT... -_-

[@xxxnicky130]

soitssarah so true wherever I heard 2013 all in my head was the best year of kpop

[@angeltorela7709]

soitssarah Ladies code was OT5...

[@user-sc5ro8vl5z]

노래 할때 가장 빛이나는 우리 종현이

[@azlynsulyadi2104]

im an army and i can't deny 1st and 2nd gen interactions are the best