[2020/Bass Battle] Avi VS Tim VS Geoff (Low Notes Only) Eb2 - C0 REACTION

[@nathanielgilliland9939]

Tim Foust: Hits a C0 Paul David Kennamer: "So, you finally reached the bottom of the 0 octave. Welcome to the club. Be sure to say hi to Tim Storms and Roger Menees as soon as you see them; right now, I think they're in the negative octave room." Tim Foust: "The... negative octave room?"

[@kirioes]

What about JD Sumner

[@nathanielgilliland9939]

@@kirioes J.D. never hit a C0, mostly because he never used vocal fry. He is, however, the only person to ever sing a G0 in chest voice.

[@prayaanevano5481]

Only elephants can hear them

[@gremcs]

I feel like they'd get a kick out of hearing PDK's vocal range. His chest-fry is nuts.

[@jonahhicks747]

Wait where

[@Marcell0Bass]

Been waiting for this one guys

[@KingFamilyReacts]

I watched one of your videos last night. Great job

[@Marcell0Bass]

King Family Reacts I saw that ❤️ I would recommend my Male singers low notes video (the second version is better)

[@Marcell0Bass]

King Family Reacts kzbin.info/www/bejne/n5-uhnSwib10j8k here really think you’d enjoy watching this it has Avi,Tim,Geoff and many more

[@reubenthomas7907]

Your 10 year old hit an F1( first F note on a grand piano) with the same technique the three basses, used on some of their low notes. Cool.

[@eligbnsu71]

Timestamp??

[@reubenthomas7907]

@@eligbnsu71 22:18 onwards he slides down to around an F1.

[@wALkEr-gd9ff]

A Growl, yeah!!!!!

[@emojijoyio]

I can go lower then him he hits a f1 I hit a c#1 the 5th lowest note on the piano

[@hunter133official]

I think that’s growl, and I might get D1 growls soon.

[@williamroop451]

The C0 note by Tim during Your Man live actually blew the sound system, that's why the video cut short... There is a better recording of this song by them that actually catches the note that your son couldn't hear... kzbin.info/www/bejne/b53TfIyAa8dpa6c I would watch the whole song - it REALLY showcases the entertainment of the group as well as Tim's freakish range. Be prepared for the 1:45 to 2:20 mark as well as his finish. When you get ready for Christmas songs, just before Halloween I suggest you react to Pentatonix Making Christmas - it REALLY needs to be done before Halloween or maybe even ON Halloween.

[@andeiqi]

Why does the dads beard look like a headsetmicrophone?😂

[@sprigmom1]

😄it does! Looks good, though.🙂

[@rachaelromine6024]

The Pentatonix video you asked about is "Love Again", one of their original songs (not a cover). I'm surprised y'all haven't seen it yet but they do have quite an extensive catalog! Definitely add it to your list of "to do reactions"!

[@jdj3bro]

My favorite PTX song👍🏾

[@hustonnagy3332]

Fyi, C0 is an octave below C1. It is also off the end of the piano, and the lowest note on a piano is A0

[@MichelleB-yy8ge]

You'll have to go back and watch again just to get the names of all the songs so you can react to the ones you haven't done yet. 😉

[@bobbythandon6939]

Amazing, agree with you

[@smallfamily2604]

I personally felt that Geoff was the best of the 3. He had the lowest chest voice and the best control of the three. That's not to take away from the other two, more like a 1a vs a 1b and 1c. I may be splitting hairs here, but I just like Geoff's low notes a little bit better. When it came to the live performances, I liked his by FAR better than the other two. I could actually HEAR his live performances. Tim's I could hear almost as well but they seemed more airy. I could barely hear Avi's live notes. Anyway, great reaction and I look forward to watching many more! *I absolutely love how you involve your kids with many of your reactions. They're the most unbias opinions of them all!*

[@michaelsoper3610]

In live performance videos, the difference in quality is often more a measure of the recording equipment than of the singer. Especially, as is usually the case, in videos shot by fans. Each of these men are stellar bass singers with tremendous access to their higher registers. Ironically, in different interviews, I believe each has suggested focus on expanding one's high range as the best way for aspiring bass singers to improve low notes. There is some magical transitive property nobody seems to really understand.

[@redux1012]

That kid hit an F1 at the end wtf 😂😂😂

[@lorganiste8953]

yeah, it's growl, pretty awesome

[@mcmerry2846]

Pure growl...

[@grantburgess1422]

Exactly why growl notes dont impress me. Anyone can do it

[@redux1012]

@@grantburgess1422 anyone can growl, but almost nobody can do it as good as Tim so that’s why he impresses people with his, plus he’s the one who popularized it so it’s kind of his thing

[@grantburgess1422]

@@redux1012 I remember doing it before I even knew it was a thing😂 everyone can do it like Tim you just gotta cut the air out of it. If a 7 year old can do it before puberty then it's not impressive if a full grown man can do it too.

[@thegoodberrygaming9578]

Heads up, a B0 is higher than a C0 by 7 keys. The lowest note on a full 88 key pan is an A0, so Tim was hitting lower than a piano.

[@tishatittle1010]

I think your guys son was almost in the floor a few times with the bass, hahahaha. Even though all three have what they're good at bass wise, both Geoff & Avi have credited Tim with teaching them a thing or two. Avi said he helped him even lower and Geoff said he helped get lower with his growl notes. And, yes Tim has vibrated more than a few cameras with his bass. But all 3 are great. And, yes Tim blew out that speaker.

[@tishatittle1010]

Yaaay first highlighted comment, thanks guys. ;)

[@yaimiana]

Tim just helped him with the growl technique. Which was foreign to Avi as a classically trained singer.

[@tishatittle1010]

@@yaimiana I was going by what they themselves have said.

[@hustonnagy3332]

Wait, when did avi say that? Is there a video clip somewhere?

[@westonwilliams6116]

@@yaimiana And Geoff really doesn’t growl a whole lot. He’s a lot more known for his subharmonics.

[@davejtuckgamingandmusic]

The lowest note possible that was hit by a human was a G0 by the legend JD SUMNER

[@davidharman8263]

This was great. Dennis, maybe some figures may help here. A0 is the lowest on the 'grand piano', (27.5 Hz). Almost clicking in the human voice. B0 is approx 30.9 Hz. Again almost clicking. Your normal speaking voice (at 40 - 45 Db, normal loudness at 1 metre (sorry about the spelling, but i'm in the UK) is 500 - 550Hz. The 'A' an orchestra tunes to is an A4, 440 Hz.

[@Meanslicer43]

God. Home free can put some thick emotion in a single voice. nothing against the other two groups as i love both of em. But i think that Home free will always be my number 1

[@efes_art2136]

Hey, I think links does not work in the comment section. So the video for the underrated Bass Singers is called: "Ultimate Bass Battle of Underrated Singers" and it is by BadamB B. He makes the best bass battle and vocal range videos. You really should check out his content! I am sure that you will enjoy!

[@badamb401]

I so appreciate your support bro! Thank you so much!!!

[@acedestiny2433]

OMG now you have to watch the Tenor battle for Christina!

[@jonathanpenyak700]

Heck yeah!

[@TheRealSchmom]

C0 is definitely lower than B0😂 But some people can go much lower. The world record is a G#-7 I guess😂 And I'm not sure but I think Kaleb's note at the end is a G1🤷‍♂️ but that's just my feeling

[@boogs6932]

Thats the note tim storms hit right?

[@TheRealSchmom]

@@boogs6932 Yep

[@GamingPigeon812]

Very close, Tim storms has a 10 octave range, G5-G-5. That’s what I find whenever I look it up at least. I’ve heard -7 as well tho so no clue.

[@iforgor3594]

Kalebs growl sounded like a E1 to me and it goes up and down and he maybe hits around a C1 at The end but idk

[@t-bonetheactiongamer79]

As Geoff put it Tim is the master of the growl.

[@faresbenchikha6620]

they're a family support them

[@scarymarysunshine9155]

That last Tim clip was when he broke the speakers.

[@mityakiselev]

"Geoff's lowest subharmonic" oh no no no these editors lack critical information

[@ryans4472]

As if Kaleb can just hit an F#1 like that 🤣 good job buddy!

[@tonemargrethejohansen5528]

Amazing singers all 3 of them, they should co-lab, and make music.. Greetings from fan in Norway.😉♥️

[@codelyokofan1092]

19:19 When you have been trying to sing those low notes along with them for some time😂

[@miamidolphinsfan]

this was so cool, but they are all amazing no one better than another !! Just love their talent, all of them !

[@danielmadsen3407]

Oh man I cannot wait for this one!!!

[@KingFamilyReacts]

Please watch it until the end. Kaleb does something awesome at the end

[@danielmadsen3407]

@@KingFamilyReacts haha that was pretty awesome! That mite of been a G1 or lower Lol we need to compare that to "FIRE" haha

[@eka8520]

I like how your son said that C#0 was the lowest note and then the C0 popped up, but theres still almost 7 octaves more after C0 and your wife also said B0 was lower than C0 but its not and your sons Growl is Crazy

[@erictheirishbass6704]

Omg I am excited for this!!

[@KingFamilyReacts]

Please watch it until the end. Kaleb does something awesome at the end

[@erictheirishbass6704]

By the look of the tumbnail you guys thought they weren't human anymore

[@KingFamilyReacts]

@@erictheirishbass6704 Pretty much

[@TheRealSchmom]

Waiting for this so long 🔥

[@jeannefiddler7376]

Hope you have the part of Tim from HF blowing the bass while singing in a concert.

[@robertoaldanondo6943]

I've been waiting for this for so long! This is gonna be epic

[@jonathanmerritt9321]

okay so c0 is notttt the lowest possible, and to hit some of the chest notes you have to clear your throat, and when you do that there's a moment of the note in the back of your throat, then just hold it then Boom

[@daynanoneya3068]

I hate seeing reactors do the bass battle videos, just because it ruins the 'wow' bass moments in a lot of videos, in my opinion. You lose that "oh my gosh, did you hear that note!?" moment when you're watching a video for the first time. Y'all did a great reaction tho.

[@sprigmom1]

I still get excited about them!

[@radar1510]

Did that kid just hit an F1 in growl lol. DUDE from a vocal music major that's insane bro lol

[@KingFamilyReacts]

Haha.....he was 10 then also.

[@radar1510]

@@KingFamilyReacts well tell him to keep it up. He may be a singer in the making 😉😉

[@KingFamilyReacts]

@@radar1510 Hope so 😁😁😁

[@gavindoucet4820]

Note: tim storms holds the world record for a vocal range of 10 octaves. His lowest note is G-7

[@hrized6816]

Proof?

[@gavindoucet4820]

@@hrized6816In an interview on August 12, 2012 with Storms, he was asked how they measured his lowest note. He said, "They use a frequency analyzer, or vibration tester, as some engineers call it."

[@iseeyou8773]

@@gavindoucet4820 I thought his lowest was the A0 in their song sold

[@gavindoucet4820]

@@iseeyou8773 That's Tim Foust, not Tim Storms. Foust's lowest note was a debatable A0 in Sold (only debatable bc it may have been an A1 with an extra rumble to it by Adam Rupp/Adam may have been doing throat bass)

[@maitruong7143]

#timstorms

[@mikeakers1209]

By the thumbnail and the looks on each face from left to right dad- what the heck? Son- how low do they go?? Mom- what did I just hear?? Son on the end- I can do that.

[@KingFamilyReacts]

LOL.....that's about right 🤣

[@fearghasdan5576]

5:48 Is that a man or a foghorn?!

[@Aaronwkoa]

both an Alien and Foghorn…

[@wisdomplaysbtd6144]

It’s crazy to think about how out of all 5 of those people, the person that can go the highest and the lowest is Geoff

[@melaninikolova8495]

Love the reaction.... All three guys are amazing but AVI is my top #1 overall !!!!

[@lindasegraves6207]

Tim taught Avi how to reach some of the lowest notes. I also read Tim taught Jeff low notes. Avi sang with Home Free on Ring of Fire.

[@niranjanrajesh1058]

@@lindasegraves6207 what nonsense. Avi is ghe best true bass out of all of them

[@nataliespiker4656]

I have Tim as my favorite. From what I read he has helped Geoff and avi get better with their lower notes. They all do sound good tho

[@jonathanmerritt9321]

and what the uh son did that's called a subharmonic note.

[@DerryleeTheBoysAreWee]

The rin of fire guys Avi Kaplan And Tim Foust were acctally together if u didn't know🔥Brothers of bass

[@tatupistola]

10:30 what name of the music? My english is not good

[@bobogus7559]

The best B0 I’ve ever heard comes from the end of Tim Storms’s “Lonesome Road.”

[@iforgor3594]

At 22:20 he hits a E1 growl and maybe some lower i just tested a E1 on a piano because it sounded like 1 i think he maybe went down a bit lower at The end of The note be C1 or around there😅 i dont have perfect pitch so idk lmao

[@jonathanpenyak700]

Yo I’m so excited

[@bentleyotieno705]

Hi King family. React to deeper voices, Ken Turner, J. D. Sumner Paul David Kennemer and Of course the deepest voice in history , Mr. TIM STORMS

[@Luredreier]

I hope that you guys will listen to the full version of these videos.

[@tmfyi8048]

I can't find that version of white Christmas cover by geoff with the puppet

[@ekill1395]

The octaves on a piano start at c, so the lowest c on a piano is a c1. The two keys below it are a b0 and an a0.

[@joeswanson7634]

You should do some reaction ms to . Tim storm who has not only the largest vocal range in the world of 10 octaves (dimash has 7 for comparison ) he also has the world's deepest voice being able to hit the lowest note in the world on record he goes so low that sone people /most people can't hear his lowest note especially without headphones

[@doubletime6573]

The 10 year old son in you video done a growl note I'm note sure what not he hit but very impressive.

[@child_of_gaia1836]

The lowest note Tim can go to 0-A Growl Note. And he can reach A5 High tenner.

[@mattc8637]

22:18

[@KingFamilyReacts]

IKR!!!

[@mattc8637]

@@KingFamilyReacts I didn’t see a time stamp anywhere lol 😂

[@Robin-ij6ks]

the little kid was like: ._. the whole video

[@stanbannmusic8334]

Loved the reaction. A0 is the lowest note on the piano (which Tim Foust repeatedly crushes in "Sold"). Notation-wise the first part is the pitch (in this case A) and the number is the octave C to C on the keyboard lowest to highest (the lowest C being C1). For reference middle C is C4. Since there are notes on the piano below the lowest C that's where the 0 octave enters (C0 would be the first C below the piano). Octaves below that are negative numbers. Bottom line is these guys are singing well below the bass clef and some are in ranges that are hard for whales to hear. As was mentioned below Tim Storms has the world record of a G-7 (0.189 Hz). For reference when orchestras tune they use the A below middle C which is at 440Hz. Definitely become acquainted with Tim Storms and JD Sumner for some unearthly sub bass singers!! While all here are talented my allegiance goes to Tim Foust for a full 5 octave range. I respect Geoff's range but he often seems a bit emotionally flat (for lack of a better term). Both Tim and Avi bring character and emotional inflection to their singing. If I had to listen to one of these three on their own for a prolonged time, not that the others aren't extraordinary, my vote is Tim Foust.

[@cslapler007]

@ 3:55 @ 12:39 gotta do What Child is This, Chris Rupp feat Home Free for Christmas This one is one of my all time favorites and I think needs more visibility b/c there isn't nearly the views there should be. Also, I don't agree with all of the descriptors, especially some of the lower chest vs/ growls. The subharmonics are mostly correct though I think.

[@kennethrogers7128]

The last clip of that video you were watching Tim actually busted the subwoofer!!

[@GMac0550]

The last one Tim broke the sound system

[@soundwavethesavage8250]

Tim storm another bass singer can go from a GO-B4

[@xXNunduXx]

Soundwave TheSavage he can actually go several octaves lower, G0 is just his lowest note he’s sung in an actual song.

[@samuelcurtis7470]

Tim's lowest note is a G#-7

[@aqhan]

I struggled with G1, somehow not my note, then it was good until Tim hit D1. I found my limit, because I thought my throat will turn inside out. Mind you, I've been only training singing bass at home for about a month, so I feel pretty good about even going that low.

[@Arg478]

Quite crazy that Tim's lowest note is B0 when I, 14, am quite comfortably singing C0 with my bad singing technique. I combine growl notes with chest fry to get C0 and occasionally B -1.

[@wisdomplaysbtd6144]

I wish I had bass training, because I have a very low voice, on a low day, my normal speaking voice is C1

[@cslapler007]

Sounds like Caleb used a "growl" or "fire-breathing" technique, notes varied a bit but he settled down on an F1! There toward the end it sounded a little more sub-harmonic, but I dont' think it was due to the airiness. He actually is doing an impressive job with it, but there's a lot I don't know about the technique so take it for what it's worth. To my understanding, the 3 bassists in this video pull it off so well for numerous reasons, some of which being: 1. they have deeper resonance and consistent intonation (locking into a particular note) 2. they have technique and stamina to minimize the airy overtones and "pushing" for the sound (only with practice) 3. they have mics with good frequency response and filters and EQ that cuts out the higher register stuff and boosts the low. Basically the growl technique doesn't sound good if it isn't done in a microphone and doctored up a bit.

[@Shaggyboring]

Is so good

[@amylynn5141]

Do You Hear What I Hear is known as a Christmas song.. but it is technically not... :) Adam Rupp (beatboxer) arranged HF's version and it is by far my favorite!

[@ferziovelazquez5254]

Thank you for readme😂

[@atari4953]

Well... Lowest note on piano is A0. And lowest note in every octave is C. So C0 is much lower that A0. The row looks like C0-D0-E0-F0-G0-A0-B0-C1- and repeat

[@crymsonyt5686]

The b0 is not lower than the c0 btw. It starts at b then a-g-f-e-d-c and c is the lowest and b is the highest note if it’s in the same octave.

[@sprigmom1]

Loved it!

[@lurecyyy]

Btw a C0 is almost an octave lower than a B0 cuz a C1 comes before a B0.

[@adamszczesny3848]

Tim Tim Tim! I don't think I need to write or speak anymore :)

[@evanbowen4221]

C0 is lower than the B actually the lower the number the lower the note the lowest note ever sung was a G#-7

[@johngeo5816]

Avi is like a decade younger than tim and geoff He can still go lower

[@jakewalker271]

😂 definitely not

[@kyandenton]

Nope avi stops around E1 while Geoff and Tim have 0 octave notes. As well as the fact that they use more techniques than Avi (subharmonic and chest fry).

[@ginoreitabagan5935]

And I've never heard Avi use subharmonics.

[@johngeo5816]

@@kyandenton i dont mean he can go lower by he can hit lower notes right now i mean that he can potentially reach those notes because he is still very young compared to them

[@coryhoover83]

You gotta listen to the video 22 times tim Foust went subwoofer

[@AntonioSantos-xn6fo]

IF YOU LIKE BASS, REACT TO TOMI P!!

[@larchezockt1841]

Goosebumps at 10:22

[@Mitch-zy7dj]

the b0 is higher than the c0, the lower b would be a b-1

[@ericsites2233]

Personally a Geoff fan

[@secretarts]

If you do not hear C0 your headphones did not have the ability to reproduce the note. There was an opera singer in 1980 that did officially sing a A0 but it is not word just a sound you feel more than hear.

[@_Nickiii_]

I couldn't help but notice the kid in the middle copying dad the whole time lol. Definitely dads kiddo lol

[@scotthritz6641]

Sorry guys your sound in the reaction is messed up. Did you change your equipment or adjustments?? Very distorted. Good reaction otherwise. Thanks!!

[@RosheenQuynh]

SO IT WASN'T JUST ME

[@scotthritz6641]

Nope. Something has changed the sound of their recordings that we hear. Quality has dropped drastically. Come on KFR fix it up!!!!

[@scotthritz6641]

Male scale for bass goes from highest B1,A1,G1, F1,E1,D1,C1,B0,A0 being the lowest.

[@kn3236]

The B0 is not lower than C0, C0 is like several semitones lower, and Geoff's lowest chest is D1, and his lowest note is B0 aswell, And the loweset note ever recorded is a G#-7, it's in the NEGATIVE Octave, it's basically an entire piano lower than the original piano

[@DerryleeTheBoysAreWee]

*actually*

[@calebgauthier1280]

Lowest I've gone is E1 subharmonic

[@maryshelton69]

Your boys are adorable..

[@jhn4915]

React a basso profundo

[@joefran2513]

Why do i get the impression someone is gonna sleep on the couch?

[@charlottevan_8]

The problem I have with these bass battles is that it seems to be so much about only how low you can go, and not the actual quality of those low notes. Yes, Tim and Geoff can growl very very low, but there's a lot of distortion when you do that. And sometimes it feels like those low, low notes are just for showing off. Avi's low notes are, I think, more purposeful, clearer (with a few exceptions when he had to do growls), and demonstrate the operatic training he had as a Basso Profundo, where he was taught how to achieve very low notes with timbre, depth and volume.

[@Coldiplier50]

I don’t think the link works because it keeps saying error or something. But I love the video I think Tim is my favorite I think it’s interesting to hear how low these singers can go

[@johnsonsaxyman321]

Love the AEW shirt!

[@richardgrace4500]

The best singer out of all of them is still Tim though mainly because of his range because he has a 5+octave range which is literally unheard of

[@bryanpearson2208]

Tim Storms Genius book lowest vocal ON RECORD

[@mcmerry2846]

React to opera bass and oktavist...pure chest notes with power

[@weslennon3425]

Wait, a violin in an acapella group, not allowed, no instruments!

[@bobbythandon6939]

If you want to hear the low notes in song, you should react VIDEO LONESOME ROAD by TIM STROM

[@kn3236]

That's a growl note, their easy but they hurt and they are hard to control and maintain cause they require alot of breath, but Geoff's lowest Subharmonic Note is actually B0 btw, and his lowest chest is D1, which makes it way lower than tim's.......just saying

[@theflyingstallion5218]

his mustache looks like a mic piece😂😂😂

[@N9TheNoob]

give them some propper headphones, it looks like they are not even hearing the notes