2021 Trek Marlin 5 VS Specialized Rockhopper VS Giant Talon 4

[@solitaryrefinement6787]

The BEST hardtail is the one that's actually in stock. 😭

[@Drippy_hoops]

Which is the talon 4

[@shanemontgomery8846]

Solid ! This is exactly the purchasing question I’m trying to answer. Thanks for the vid

[@TalalipopMTB]

No problem!

[@davidcurlee6759]

You do great work! Thanks so much for these.

[@TalalipopMTB]

Thank you!

[@Nachsosa]

I think that the Rockhopper has a better geometry for Trail rides, well that surprise me because i have Talon 2 and i love it. Great videos as always!

[@TalalipopMTB]

Thank you!

[@americanmade422]

I just upgraded from a northrockxc27 to the Rockhopper. I couldn't find a bike during the pandemic so the xc27 was all I could find.

[@HarryPotterFan1772]

YAYAY WE MISSED YOU!! SO HAPPY YOU’RE BACK!!

[@TalalipopMTB]

I LOVE U

[@igi_random5481]

This was my only dilema it was the rockhopper or the marlin 5 but im going to get the rockhopper :D

[@bikerandgamer3113]

Exactly what I needed I was looking for a bike in those prices thx

[@TalalipopMTB]

Welcome!

[@kerbie213]

I really like this guy doing a review.more videos please

[@TalalipopMTB]

Thanks!! I will :)

[@timothy7768]

Welcome back seems like forever since you've made your last video. I love three of the bikes but if I had to choose the trek marlin all the way.

[@TalalipopMTB]

Yeah had a few problems with Trek and wasn't allowed to upload for a while; might talk about that eventually. But thank you!

[@nunesgil-3668]

What could you tell us about the warranty and costumer service between this brands? There's a few bikeshop which offers free tune ups and third would make difference for a beginner rider for example.

[@stevenewart3873]

The Best hardtail is the one that fits you. I'd prefer the specialized rockhopper elite or trek x calibre 7. Thanks

[@maxjames921]

Love this vid! Would also like a Merida big nine/seven vs Cannondale trail comparison

[@KungFuTze]

I'm a larger dude and I want a bike.. unfortunately the steel frames are all cheap so I'm leaning towards the Marlin 5, since it's rated to people up to 300 while the other ones are only listed to somewhere around 250-275. Due to post pandy inventory what I've seen in 2023 is that the Marlin has upgraded to altus drivetrain while the Talon 4 and the specialized are using now microshift the talon4 is now around 570, the marlin 5 is 590 in certain trek stores but retailers have it for 750, while the rockhopper 29 is about 650. USD. There's barely any inventory close by in Denver

[@No_ReGretzkys99]

I know your comment was a year ago but I just bought a brand new specialized rockhopper sport It has a 1x drivetrain, and it's Shimano I really enjoy it I'll change the forks out but other than that it's a great bike❤❤❤

[@KungFuTze]

@@No_ReGretzkys99 I bought the Marlin so far happy with the decision!

[@kamiledytawerpachowski3215]

Up until now we had Trek FX 7.2 that we used mainly on pavement. We are thinking about upgrading to MTB so we can use them on off road trails, gravel and hard packed roads as well as paved city streets. How would you compare Giant Talon 2 to Specialized Rockhopper Sport? They are both $750 with hydraulic breaks. Specialized has 2x9 drivetrain where Giant is 1x9.

[@MAolmos07]

Congrats for the job! Do you know anything about the bike shortages when will more bike will be available

[@jwpoon]

Good day! Thank you for a great work done! I’ve followed all of your videos and loved them. I am about to pull the trigger on Trek within the next 3-4 weeks. But i am lose between Duo Sport 3/4 vs Checkpoint (ALR or SL). Do you think you can do a video on this, please? I would really owe u a big favour!

[@TalalipopMTB]

I may be able to make a video like that eventually, though I mainly focus on mountain bikes on my channel currently. For now though I'll quickly mention that the dual sports are hyrbid bikes that are more about comfort and having versatility, while the checkpoints are gravel bikes with drop handlebars made to go a bit faster on gravel. The dual sport is more of a commuter or fitness style bike while the checkpoint is more built for speed and bike days in my opinion.

[@jwpoon]

@@TalalipopMTB Thank you bro. Looking forward to your next video. 👌

[@willsimz144]

Do you like your Trek 5 , looking at one myself

[@gabyperalta8223]

Wow very informative so cool

[@TalalipopMTB]

Thank you!

[@idamexmex4206]

Trek store in Twin Falls ID has every bike in stock

[@mabor1999]

I m planning to buy giant talon 3 is it good for competitive riders and competition bte enjoy your videos 💖✨🚲

[@sovietpigeon1346]

I was going to get the giant marlin 4 anyway. It's the cheapest Altrough all of theese bikes are a lot more expensive in ft(hungarian currency) was planning on a nucleus vr 27.5 but it's out if m budget. Marlin is way overpriced too for me, and the rockhopper is out of stuck. 1 question tough, can you put 120mm forks in the talon 4? Medium size

[@TalalipopMTB]

Depends on the fork. If it has a straight steer tube then yes. It will alter the geometry of the bike a little bit, but should be fine.

[@leandroteurer2365]

You should have done the talon 3 it’s closer to the price range

[@walterjiani9229]

Could you pls let me know which would be the best for moderate trail & commuter bike? Thanks

[@Siblove7]

I cant seem to find any basic bike size guides for a xc setup, just ordered a Talon 3 29er size Large frame (following the company guidelines for height) but it turned out HUGE, have about 1 inch space between topbar and crutch while standing on ground. Any recommendations for what I should consider for simple beginner bike fit?

[@jfrtbikgkdhjbeep9974]

medium frame ... i have the S/M frame fits

[@azeemurrehman7731]

Plz make a in-person comparison video between Trek Marlin 7 & Dual sport 4.. which one is best value for Money..? Love from India🇮🇳 Also make video comparison between Trek and Scott bikes Plz.. Thank you in advance🙂

[@takumifujiwara3223]

There are test drive videos

[@Jaysondk]

I want the Marlin 6 but they are out of stock :(((

[@christiandorrejo1652]

Marlin 6

[@DavidMontreal]

What do you think about vitus?

[@rube3k969]

Vitus Nucleus in Grey for me.

[@jensongroff]

I got a roscoe 7 for $550 back in 2019 right before the pandemic.

[@TalalipopMTB]

Nice!!

[@solitaryrefinement6787]

Killer deal right there.

[@ronr.53400]

roscoe? 😳 damnnn

[@jfrtbikgkdhjbeep9974]

same price range for the 2021 Talon 4

[@nathansbikeapedia6204]

Great Videos. How is the Talon 4 and Rockhopper the same in pounds and have an $80 difference in dollars? (2:03)

[@jfrtbikgkdhjbeep9974]

thats probably retail mark up by the bike store ... i chose the talon 4

[@sxm_qa2120]

So which one is good for mountain and road

[@robertsanchez5187]

What would be a good option for gravel trails?

[@TalalipopMTB]

They’ll all be good for that in my opinion, but since travel trails are typically not as bumpy and technical as mountain trails, you could probably go with the marlin to get the cross country geometry that’ll be better for speed

[@eugenio4073]

orbea mx50 is the best

[@nikhilsood3333]

your amazon link is not working for me

[@TalalipopMTB]

Oh oops! Just fixed that

[@nekojcovek8466]

But what about talon 3?

[@victorjimenez9597]

Do you know when Ontario gets stock on the marlin 5? I've been wanting it for months now

[@TalalipopMTB]

Unfortunately I don’t :(

[@victorjimenez9597]

@@TalalipopMTB ok

[@TheCommonSenseProfessor]

Giant always seems like the better deal in these comparisons.

[@xibnjamn]

third

[@willemerson8527]

Would the rockhopper be a good commuter

[@jfrtbikgkdhjbeep9974]

yes, all 3 are really good for commuters

[@subzeroseven]

First!

[@thstudio007]

Big achievement lol 🤣