it’s honestly a genius choice to change brokenstars design from the more conventional “horror/evil” design to a more sort of soulless look, with a face that looks permanent and painted on. Really hits home how he was predetermined to run shadowclan into the ground as punishment to yellowfang for breaking the code, and how he was never really his own cat.
@bvnnyskvllz8 ай бұрын
i think my fave change from tha og to this version is how brokenstar frowns instead of smiles. it feels more eerie somehow , like he doesn't Really enjoy doing this and he's tired of everything but with starclan's bullshittery he's compelled to keep going anyway , any kind of morals be damned , because of he doesn't then who's going to 'punish' yellowfang for something so utterly beyond her control ? or maybe i'm reading too far in2 that KWEHJDGXKSWHS it's just a rlly cool pmv
@YellowFangIsBetter3 ай бұрын
I honestly love this. It's so good in such a disturbing and dark way, especially the beginning, and portrays Brokenstar so well
@jaimejones-q1u5 ай бұрын
The subtle adding of more blood each time you see broken stars face is very nice. All the subtle touches are what brings it it’s true glory
The original PMV is arguably one of my favorite bits of warriors content and this remake just blew me away. It held up the unnerving aspect while not going overboard, and really played into the sadder, more upsetting lyrics and tone. A detail i love is how after Brokenstar is blinded, Yellowfang's face disappears, showing that although he can't see her, he knows she's there, whether that be a comfort, or a curse. You will literally never cease to be one of my biggest inspirations.
@apxllo873411 ай бұрын
hey thank you so much! this comment is awesome I’m super glad you like it that much :D really means a lot to me
@Mumble7857 ай бұрын
dude.... did Not expect that just a starry sky being Black instead of dark blue would hit so hard omg this is just FULL of really nice subtle touches like that, i friggin LOVE this 😍
@ghostscouts11 ай бұрын
Your like one of the best and most noble OG warrior cats creator, I hope you can appreciate yourself as much as I do! Your art is so beautiful and you have helped me get comfortable drawing what I want again! I felt trapped by my art for a very long time and felt I couldn’t draw the things I wanted, seeing you grow and your art make so many people happy helped me find freedom in it again. I hope this doesn’t make you uncomfortable as I tend to be a bit bad at this! Please take care of yourself and do what makes you happy!
@milli596811 ай бұрын
This hits harder when it's raining intensely outside
@pyrook40747 ай бұрын
I’ve never seen the original beforehand but this is now my favorite Brokenstar video. Everything about it is so perfect, the unsettlingly uneasy yet somehow ethereal atmosphere, the simple yet wonderfully succinct designs, how disturbing this framing manages to be WITHOUT intense gore. It feels like a breath of fresh air where almost all other Brokenstar content really stresses the brutality and violence behind the storyline, this frames it as more an existential tragedy instead. Fitting considering Brokenstar’s birth was a purposeful curse bestowed upon the Clans, and he was doomed to be evil from the beginning due to forces beyond their control. Stunningly beautiful work!
@explodingdragonstudios2 ай бұрын
I wonder what would've happened if Brokenstar got a different life alongside Yellowfang. After all, their circumstances aren't far from Leafpool and her kits except she had squirrelflight to help and so Yellowfang turned to the only one she knew. Lizardstripe. Just a downright shame. lovely work anyway.
@s6datab6 ай бұрын
This just shows how messed up Brokentail really is… I showed my friends this and they literally said, ‘how tf are these books for kids??”
@mooneatsworms11 ай бұрын
OMG I REMEMBER SEEING THIS WHEN IT FIRST CAME OUT,,, tyis is literally the coolest
@sappletoast11 ай бұрын
this is just absolutely a beautiful work of art ..
@lukasdr0wned8 ай бұрын
Ive watched the og about a million times. This blows it out of the park, your art is just wonderful
@umborium11 ай бұрын
This is one of the best pmv's I've ever seen!
@veronica36629 ай бұрын
God, this is awesome. It's almost midnight for me rn and holyshit, this sent chills down my spine, I actually felt kinda uncomfortable. You nailed it, great job
@NalannieArt11 ай бұрын
This is genuinely amazing!!
@mapleshadeapologist5 ай бұрын
I don’t care what anyone else says, Brokenstar was the most messed up part of the series. Literally sending out CHILD SOLDIERS AGAINST THEIR WILL. Imagine how it would be if that were in the REAL world and people forced toddlers into the army? Fucked up shit.
@siqxyre847311 ай бұрын
LWTSGOOOO
@Bee846711 ай бұрын
Awesome!
@gonersonpaws8 ай бұрын
HELL YEAHHH NEW SUB GREAT JOH ON THIS DUDE ps:i just found ur channel and im in love omgimgomgkngomg
@ЪуЪ-т3я11 ай бұрын
Why there are so few likes...
@men_r_paul10 ай бұрын
Is there a reason for two broken'stars? I haven't read that far into the books
@apxllo873410 ай бұрын
there is only one brokenstar in this video
@BeanKally10 ай бұрын
I believe the cat you’re mistaking for a second brokenstar is actually yellowfang unless you’re talking about a different cat
@men_r_paul9 ай бұрын
Oh- Then why is brokenstar so uncanny for a cat? (I'm sorry if this is a stupid question)
@apxllo87349 ай бұрын
@@men_r_paul for fun
@ANALBONES11 ай бұрын
OH MY GOD I REMEMBER SEEING THE ORIGINAL AND I LOVED IT!! this is so cool omfg