2024 BMW X5 VS Porsche Cayenne VS Range Rover Sport || Which Luxury SUV Is Best?

[@pepito060666]

For me X5 I had three of them great excellent, no issues super powerful car.

[@petermacgregor2004]

I sold my Range Rover Sport SDV8 and purchased a Porsche Cayenne GTS Coupe 2023. I opted for the 18 Way seats so the comfort level is on a par with the Rangie. I've had the Cayenne since the beginning of March this year and so far haven't had to take it back to the dealer. The Range Rover was back 3 times in the first 6 months of ownership.

[@lbentley516]

NIce. I am considering the same three SUVS, coming from a '21 S580 wanting a little downsize since my car has been giving me some minor issues I feel like its in the cards to make a move. Having a hard time from car to SUV (knowing noting will be as good as my S class. I am super biased to MB and the 3 S classes I have owned) So I'm getting a crap ton of time on youtube narrowing down my choices. So you are still very happy with the Cayenne GTS Coupe, correct?

[@petermacgregor2004]

Fair to say it keeps getting better.@@lbentley516

[@jcdentonunatco]

how are you liking the Cayenne? in particular how does the driving dynamics compare and the sound system?

[@PeterMacGrergor]

@@jcdentonunatco it is a great drive. Corners like it is on rails. Press the red button and it goes like a scaled cat. The sound system is brilliant. The sport exhaust system sounds amazing. Hard to beat a V8.

[@kentwang6408]

I have a 2016 Cayenne for for 6 years it is excellent SUV no any issues or problems and now waiting for my 2024 Cayenne Hybrid

[@thamarmontanez6315]

Best review I’ve seen so far. I had a Mercedes ML350 and it worked great. After that I tried Land Rover, Jaguar and Maserati. I ended with the Maserati. But after few years and spending so much money in gas I ended up with the X5 50e.

[@paulk.4261]

Excellent review! I personally went with the 2024 Cayenne...and the BMW was the other potential option...but the Porsche was clearly better suited for our driving needs.

[@starjag85]

How Porsche is better for certain driving needs?

[@paulk.4261]

@@starjag85 X5 for us felt like a good SUV whereas the Porsche felt more like a sports car disguised as a SUV.

[@marchhares1]

I've got an X5 with the comfort seats and it is incredibly comfortable, I did try the Porsche Cayenne and the Range Rover, but they were not as good as the X5. But the Porsche and the Range Rover are very nice cars. As always its down to preference. Thanks for the great review.

[@Raj_1201]

X5 is cheapest

[@eldismemushi]

Excellent choice, same here .

[@THExKINGxKINGx]

Lol what you are actually delusional. I had a fully loaded x5 and is inferior in every way compared to the Range Rover I had after and especially the cayenne I have now.

[@Raj_1201]

Enjoy your made-in-USA x5 👍🏽

[@eldismemushi]

@@THExKINGxKINGx brooo you never had an X5 🥴 X5M is in every aspect better than Rr and cayenne , I had many cars before from VW Touareg to Cayenne and nothing close to X5M .

[@ricardoyomiricardo714]

The X5 is Incredible ❤it’s my dream

[@RC-bx5jo]

thanks for the review, i can say after having had 3 BMW for about 12 years total, i have had one issue, on the older one: a cam shaft sensor fixed for 100$. anything in the past 10 years, nothing.

[@roberttalkachov1880]

I own a Range Rover sport it is more luxurious and comfortable with beautiful high class interior features .

[@ronydagher1523]

I have owned all three SUVs over the last 5 years or saw The most reliable has been the Range Rover sport with porsche Cayenne gts next and the BMW x5 last It is about time for the Range Rover to shake off the bad reputation for reliability

[@amirveyseh10]

Great informative, honest and consices reviews! Super helpful!

[@jonbiasetti7037]

Great, practical and informative review, as always. I always buy Cayennes, after having driven the BMW and Land Rover options. BMW looks pedestrian to me and I am not a fan of their design. Range Rover Sport is a nice vehicle but I already own a full size Range Rover so do not want two cars from the same family. By the way, I have had three Range Rovers, no major problems, frankly, maybe I got lucky. Nothing steers and handles like a Porsche, so, if you like, as you said, to drive, Cayenne is it, if you want to cruise, the other two are fine options.

[@ISHANTth1lq]

Agreed .

[@carhelpcorner]

Three Range Rovers!? Out of curiosity how long did you keep each one for? Glad to hear they treated you well.

[@jonbiasetti7037]

@@carhelpcornerabout 6-7 years each. I like new tech. Only reason why I traded them in. Just ordered a new 2024 RR. Should get it in the fall. Love the new design. I just picked up a new 2023 Cayenne Turbo. Love it. And prefer it’s interior to the new 2024s.

[@macandcheese9387]

My 4th Range Rover (a 2023) is due in in a few weeks…test driving Cayenne tomorrow just to be sure, but I haven’t had issues with the RR Sport. I keep them 3 years.

[@yannickdunya2511]

@@jonbiasetti7037 ... Still driving my 2017 RRS, and never had any issue whatsoever. Sometimes, I just wonder if people don't exaggerate with their reliability issues... I'm seriously debating between the 2023 cayenne and the RRS.

[@trevorconway4415]

I’m on my 5th Range Rover in 15 years and I’ve never had a fault, that’s why I buy them

[@DumbDogIsDumb]

Great video. I love that you give an honest assessment, warts and all. Too many reviewers sugar coat problems and it’s not doing consumers a favor. Just got the X5 and love it. The Porsche was very nice too, but the BMW was a little more comfortable with the merino leather and the excellent 20 way multi-contour seats. I have no Illusions about cost of ownership or resale. Got the full extended maintenance plan and platinum warranty for as long as they sell them because I don’t want hassles. Any maintenance or problems, it gets dropped off at the dealer and they can deal with it. As far as resale, it’s paid for so no worries about being upside down and all cars are highly depreciating assets, so I consider them lost money. Anything I might get for trading it in 7 to ten years from now will just be a nice surprise. None of these cars are sound financial decisions. They’re super comfortable, performant, safe and enjoyable. Sometimes that’s worth more than money. If cost of ownership was a concern, I’d drive a Honda or Toyota.

[@AlamNaDiz]

This is the right mindset when buying a luxury vehicle. Luxury and comfort comes at a price but the happiness it gives us is priceless.

[@Null_pointer_exceptn]

I second that, you don’t buy these cars with financial burden in mind. Just ordered my 2024 x5 last week

[@DumbDogIsDumb]

@@Null_pointer_exceptn You’re going to love it. Picked mine up a week and half ago. It’s a real pleasure to drive.

[@Null_pointer_exceptn]

@@DumbDogIsDumb waiting for it !!

[@scooter5940]

Exactly, and I have had a couple of Hondas and a couple of Mazdas in my younger days. Now I have a Mercedes GL with an X5 on order, and my wife drives an Audi convertible. When I was younger, I was backing my boat out of a berth on a river where we had stayed overnight, after crossing Lake Michigan. Some clown on land is watching me and says to his buddy “a boat is a terrible investment”. And I’m thinking that odds are, he’s too foolish to ever be able to comfortably afford a boat, because they most definitely are NOT investments so that is just a naive statement. Just like luxury cars, boats are significant expenses, and if you don’t both enjoy them, and earn enough to have the extra money left over after your housing expenses and other necessities, your college and retirement savings, etc. - you should not buy them. Many people who do, shouldn’t - but that’s their business. Just don’t pretend a Toyota is a BMW - it’s not.

[@usmanladan1515]

I will pick the X5 any day.

[@SlyGuy1985]

Yeah anyone would who only has $50k to spend 😂😂😂😂 and doesn’t care about rep performance

[@tevzuss4386]

@@SlyGuy198550K? Why did I pay 86K for x5 then? 😂

[@manniefresh2022]

@@tevzuss4386why did you ??? Lol

[@barrybirchmore3540]

I have just changed my BMW45e for a new X Drive 50e in the UK I am regally getting 58-62 miles on a full charge. I don't know if the spec in the USA is different to be only getting 40 miles on a full charge !!

[@drrcohen1]

No, you are correct, actually the X 50 E is getting about 50 miles of range for me in the US. They published 40 miles but I don’t know anyone getting close to that and almost everyone is exceeding 50 miles.

[@eugenek3467]

Great comparison, thank you!

[@nguyentai8]

Your range for Cayenne EHybrid is incorrect.

[@pgpogo]

Have a 2023 x5 and never regretted it for a minute

[@mayormsuthu1465]

The BMW X5 is the best choice of the three no debate about it 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉❤

[@leobrown6875]

Test drove all these last week .and the porsche is just better. The bmw is ok, but looks are mmm the range rover was nice, but i would worry every time i took it on a trip .so i ordered the cayenne with every extra cant wait

[@tpmdvideo1421]

Tried all 3. Went with the x5. Love the performance and design with one major exception the split tailgate. I run and cycle. Immediately after a workout I rest sitting in the cargo area. The salesperson could not tell me how much weight lowered gate could support. He researched and reported 500 lbs. I have my doubts about that. Another issue with the gate….When placing something in the cargo area, you must lift higher over the lower tailgate like it’s a pickup truck. BMW ……. Forget the split tailgate. My last complaint is for $72,000 you don’t get real leather but a interior synthetic material. 😢

[@thomasprymak9203]

Thanks for this detailed, all-encompassing, and balanced treatment, Sher.

[@ddpr4723]

I enjoy watching this guy. He knows his stuff and very honest. I’m not convince what car to buy yet but I’m close. I just had the Range Rover and indeed service is very expensive any little thing cost you a fortune. Paying $1,800-$2,000 for service is insane but I did enjoy the ride very well. I have it to my daughter. I probably will get the Lexus 500h

[@frankhujsa821]

This is an excellent review. No fluff and exactly the information that someone wants if they are actually cross shopping these three. Thank you!

[@MorTTime]

I got a X5 45e little over year ago, no issues, and truly fun car to drive. Performance is there when you want it, very responsive, and 50 MPGe on a tank on 1k long trip . Wife drives on electric to and from work each day. Highly recommend.

[@RC-bx5jo]

i also have a 911 and despite being a porsche customer, I would get the X5: i love the 911 for the driving feel, but the infotainment and dashboard layout is...funky at best (map hidden behind the wheel, really porsche?). Not to mention rattling. I'd go X5 because it's the most obvious, easy to use interface, and because frankly nothing justifies the extra price on the cayenne. I'd rather have a BMW straight 6, a legendary engine, than an audi V6 that one can get on an A4. regarding reliability, no one should buy a car like that off warranty IMO. Lease them, buy them out, sell immediatly, lease an other. Or extend the warranty.

[@ddpr4723]

Shari, which BMW X5 were you talking about including the Trim 23-27 miles/Gal? Please

[@sheldonfrancis25]

Excellent video. Great voice brother!! Thanks for the information. I am considering the Range Rover Sport. Thank you

[@rossfowler4105]

The Range Rover Sport is the only one of these three PHEVs to support 50kW DC charging, so is much quicker to charge on public chargers. It's also the only one of these three PHEVs to have a full size spare wheel. It's tough luck if you get a flat tire on the Cayenne or X5.

[@anitajerkin]

Right, because the X5s come equipped with run-flats...

[@Steve-yr5vi]

A full size spare kit is optional on the X5.

[@BruiserFL]

The Range Rover Sport holds it's resale value better than the BMW X5. My Supercharged V8 Range Rover Sport was one of the most reliable, best looking, and fun to drive vehicles that I've ever owned.

[@malcolmvella5533]

I’m on my second RR Sport V8 Supercharged! A great car!

[@lbentley516]

Do you still have it? If no, what did you trade it for?

[@bogdanpetroaia5384]

Mate is the worst car ever. Depreciating faster than anything ever. 😂😂😂

[@Twix_loves_domo]

Thank you ! This is the one I’ve been waiting on 😂

[@simonlaity2550]

X5 all day everyday!

[@salwalker7071]

Porsche Cayenne (Coupe) gets my vote!!!

[@jasmineprymak3020]

Fascinating review and useful comparison. I personally enjoyed the BMW X5 and was impressed by both the performance and the design (exterior and interior). Thans again!

[@user-wt2te7mi4i]

Best car comparison review ever, BMW all day every day

[@aaronchoi1987]

Great review. I had to choose x5m60 and cayenne S, test drove both, didn't like the bmw gage being too techy and being too many x5 on road and several my friends have x5, I went for cayenne s, great suv, but not the seats not comfortable if you drive for more than an hour on the road. start having back pain, so I got seat cushion from Amazon, got better. over all x5 and cayenne both nice suvs.

[@steeple001]

I’ve owned all three , X5 everytime

[@ted6462]

Happy owner of a 2022 Cayenne S.

[@Luminary2024]

I think BMW improvement in reliability and general superior affordability makes it #1 to buy used (2-4 years old post the major depreciation). I have a g05 x5 for some time now and it’s fairly all rounded and reasonably affordable.

[@Colotoddo]

I opted for the X5 50e and absolutely love the vehicle. Have 5k miles on it and have only tanked up once. Couldn't be happier with the comfort, performance and refinement.

[@Null_pointer_exceptn]

X5 any day

[@HN-ol7oz]

I pick the X5 because the Range Rover look interesting in design but too many BUT, the Cayenne is way too much for everyday driving and the RX is too average looking. However, I did not like the technologies and the luxury feels of this vehicle, the GLE 450 do a much better job.

[@cargopilot747]

I like the way all of them have the nav/entertainment screen integrated into the instrument panel. Most lower-priced vehicles have a screen that looks like a quick add-on, as though someone hastily put an iPad up there with half of it sticking out.

[@Quisqueyax]

Lower priced vehicles? Mercedes benz now comes with a Ipad Pro right there in front of your eyes. They are not cheap cars.

[@drakesestatesla]

He said "Zero to Highway speed" .... I like this guy, different and honest. (for now)

[@gregorytrane7828]

Excellent honest review. Porsche Cayenne all the way all day long.

[@AlamNaDiz]

Porsche Cayenne is the best choice.

[@Jason-nq1kv]

Cayenne👍

[@Quisqueyax]

All three are good, but the Cayenne reigns in the reliability arena.

[@ct4928]

Absolutely spot on mate ❤

[@danielsonscott3038]

As a Porsche fan i'd choose the Cayenne but the X5 looks more appealing to me!

[@richardgraham1175]

But if you have the gift of sight, it's the Range Rover every time!

[@MduNjeza]

I see my city, Cape Town in the background.

[@PP-oz2oj]

Excellent review. I was going to buy X5 but didn’t like the new interior in 2024 specially the ‘hook’ for the vent duct. Besides Porsche seems to have a better brand appeal.

[@FOURMAUXPASCAL]

Vous oubliez ou omettez que le RRS est un tout terrain efficace voir tres efficace

[@AaronJiju64]

I would get the normal 6 cylinder non hybrid X5 but here in Ireland the base cheapest model is the Hybrid. The non-hybrid 6 cylinder is around €16,000 more then the hybrid which is making me want to just get the hybrid

[@Steve-yr5vi]

We bought the X5 50e, have had it for about 6 months now; BMW underrates the EV range, we consistently get better than 50 miles of EV only range from ours & we drive in a very hill area. We had a 220v ($300) outlet installed in our garage and with 220 it will fully charge in 3 hours or less. I would knock the run flat's on the BMW.

[@nguoixaxu3990]

good & honest review: that will draw people back for more!

[@costasl1282]

X5 for sure, preferably the M60 model.

[@tipsterlivindolfunrunner79]

Im on my 3rd transfer case in my 2017 Porsche cayenne..not to mention the high pressure fuel pump last month..81K miles and no warranty left..time t lease a new one!

[@michaeli1440]

I own the new Porsche Cayenne e-hybrid, and your electric range is too low - by some way. It comes down to subjective reviews on many items, but having driven all three models I feel the Porsche is simply in a different (higher) category than the other two . Although, all three are beautiful cars.

[@anitajerkin]

If you look at used car prices, there aren't that much difference between the Cayenne and X5, but the maintenance bills will certainly be higher on the Cayenne. Even basics such as oil change is significantly higher. Tits for tats, the BWW is a better all-around performer across the range, but yes, the Porsche badge is a bit more exclusive these days.

[@btpp12]

Cayenne E hybrid range is incorrect. Check your facts

[@macandcheese9387]

I laughed out loud when you showed the shot of the metallic pink Lexus. Sexy car, sexy car, sexy car, and then BAM a Hello Kitty scooter.

[@p.chrisr8106]

I drove X5 and very comfortable and smooth. Like the power and the drive. To be honest the size did not matter, it still feels like the X3. Love the X5

[@zakariabellot4946]

What about the Porsche cayenne turbo gt?

[@kamer7pl]

How come 25 kWh battery in Cayenne E-hybrid gave you just 40 kilometers of range? I think you got it wrong. My 18 kWh Panamera E-hybrid makes 60 kilometers and that car is not much lighter.

[@MrZakka1985]

The Rover for Style -> better to look The Bim for Life -> practical to drive And the Porsche simply for Passion -> all day & every day

[@Quisqueyax]

Thanks for the input at the end. I drove a mercedes gle and days later I drove a toyota Rav4. What bothered me was that the Rav4 was way better to drive, I mean comfort and feeling. I do like the GLE, but it feels to stiff, the steering wheel feels like a rock. You can buy 3 Rav4 with the price tag of the mercedes. Now you broke my heart saying that the cayenne feels stiff. I was wondering if Porsche was comfortable to drive like the Rav4.

[@Knightedddd]

X 5 is the best compromise of all

[@Shaurya_Pant]

In my experience, Range Rover has been perfectly reliable. No issues for me in the last 3 years, and I bought a second hand of 2012 model.

[@alexlee1501]

Lol Range Rover is the most not reliable what you talking about 😂I own Range Rover always got problem

[@midlandgeordie]

Don’t think range rovers are any more unreliable!

[@Prince-xy3km]

When it comes to comfort Range Rover wins

[@KDMusicprod]

I just signed up for "Car Help" membership. Looks like a great tool for buying a new car

[@redzoom7857]

I’m down to the X5, Cayenne, Q8, and waiting on the new GX to make a final decision (not thrilled on some of the options but I need to see it to be sure).

[@douglashamilton7426]

X5 50e has at least 70 miles/110 km in Europe on Batteries. The figures you have is for the e45.

[@tmarkpeterson391]

I agree with your rating however there are some other items to consider as well. First, the Range Rover Sport is being marked up by $10k at most if not all dealerships. Along with the dependability issues kicks it to last on my list! The Porsche Cayenne while arguably the overall best of the three, is in it's last year (2024) before it gets electrified. Which could make it a much better long term purchase for resell purposes. Finally the BWM X5 with the new refresh, to me is the best looking of the three and the ride quality is outstanding, if you stay away from the M model which is like riding the HULK. It only knows how to be a beast! However, if you want the most affordable, comfortable daily driver, its definitely X5. If money is not an issue, and you can find one....definitely go with the Cayenne! I would not even consider the Range Rover at this point with their greedy ass dealers and poor reliability!

[@starjag85]

BMW x5 used market is hot, looking at Cayenne and Range rovers used prices , seems like they depreciate more

[@lordbachus]

If you want to do some offroading? Only the rangerover is an option

[@proengermologia]

Porsche Cayenne 2024 e-Hybrid range is ~ 80 km.

[@AA010461]

You did not tested this cars...... Specially the 2024 CAYENNE...... The batteries are bigger (25,9KW), and that gives a 60 to 90 km of range in eletric use...... Not the 40km you said...... Range Rover is a nice SUV, but not in the same game of BMW and PORSCHE in chassis......... If I want to buy a SUV, I would go to CAYENNE....... Better car to drive (more fun), have the biggest EV range of the group (not as you said), and by far the most enjoyable one!!!!

[@rossfowler4105]

The Cayenne does not have the biggest EV range - the Range Rover Sport has the biggest EV range. The Cayenne's battery is 25.9kWh whilst the Range Rover Sport's battery is 38.2kWh.

[@drrcohen1]

The BMW has a 27 kW battery for 2024 and I am getting 51 miles of range no sweat

[@davidpimblett3573]

You’re spot on he doesn’t know the facts and gave wrong info , had all of them the BMW drives nicely but depreciated very quickly the Range Rover you’ll have to be prepared for electronic problems and garage visits 😢 the new model Cayenne beats both slower depreciation and great reliability.

[@fugaspapa2818]

mmm my plug-in hybrid they are going to deliver does 73miles i am told and is now P460E no longer the P440E. I have the 2021 P440E and i love it! i don’t think any RRS driver really wants an X5 and Porsche! naaaa. i don’t want an X5!😊

[@teriok6783]

Range Rover Sport is the best choice of the three.

[@Tenex007]

I have owned / driven most of these cars and I would say dollar for dollar, if you are looking for a combination of performance, comfort, fuel efficiency, resale value and on road / offroad capability, the range rover wins by a large margin. Range rover first edition diesel hybrid will be far more fuel efficient than the other two. BMW generally offers a tight grippy steering and good performance but a rugged drive. Nothing wrong with it but you don’t buy BMW for comfort. You buy BMW for looks and performance / steering. Porsche, well noone buys Porsche for comfort or fuel efficiency, they buy it for performance and for that reason, other than their race / roadsters I wouldn’t waste my money on a Porsche SUV

[@ted6462]

After having both Range Rovers and Cayennes, I would totallly disagree. The Cayenne is better in all the metrics.

[@bogdanpetroaia5384]

Yes will stay in garage to fix the car every 6 months 😂😂😂

[@krugmeup2162]

@@ted6462which one has the better ride over potholed roads?

[@mosswilson]

I would get a Lexus NX and put the rest into Tesla shares

[@PipenFalzy]

I bought the rx350. I was to scared to buy the porsche, BMW, Mercedes as well as the Genesis due to high repairs and reliability issues. I will admit the lexus is a little boring but will always be reliable and still looks sexy.

[@fragrancere2131]

good info

[@eldismemushi]

All day X5 my friend ❤

[@akiba1]

X5 engine is the best. Btw, is that speaker an AI avatar speaking a chatGPT script?

[@Techjunkiero]

The X5 IMO is the best option.

[@davidgreen4245]

The RRS 2024 is not a p440e that is the 2023 model! 2024 is a p460e. So the dash is changed in 2024 (there are no dials under the screen)

[@donatas8787]

Thank you

[@davidpimblett3573]

I’m pretty sure you’re info on the Cayenne is wrong 😮 you quoted 25 miles on a charge 😮 try 45 miles you did show the new 2024 model.

[@vp2777]

Cayenne is the best

[@Jason-nq1kv]

I love Cayenne!👍and hybrid save me gasoline bills

[@JRB41]

I’d get an X5 with a Porsche 911 cabriolet

[@wyndalegelbolingo259]

Next is pick up compare

[@nobsco3218]

Why this category not including Audi?

[@PipenFalzy]

Another brand that has a lot of reliability issues.

[@Thankyou_3]

Just get Lexus GX460 brand new while you can, you can drive it for 3 years and sell it almost price of what you paid.

[@carhelpcorner]

Very smart move! 👍

[@stevecook706]

Just under 50 miles electric range for the Cayenne, not 25 miles. I have one on order. Fact check.

[@LarryHopper]

Konichi Wa > Guten Tag > Cheers, Mate.

[@romulusswiss3467]

Cadillac Escalade!

[@mreddieotis]

Which car is more reliable???