2024 Giant Defy Advanced Pro Impressions: What's it Like to Live With?

[@71hutchy]

I’ve taken delivery of my Giant Defy Advanced Pro 0 2024 only this year and am very impressed ! Have ridden a couple of 125km odd rides now. I’m 53 years old and have been riding with some bunch rides here in Melbourne. I was concerned that being an “endurance” bike that it may lack some outright speed whilst chasing down other riders etc. However after putting my cycling buddies to the torch last weekend on their Giant Propel Dura ace & Trek Edmonda etc you soon realise that it’s all about your fitness levels rather than outright aero etc. Having said that i find it to be very fast and climbing is a dream. The smooth ride is an absolute pleasure. I’ve fitted Continental GP 5000 str 30mm from new . Smooth as silk ! Having switched to Ultegra Di2 for the first time and pairing the shift and power meter units with my wahoo bolt is a revelation. Who would have imagined you could see what cog your in on your cycle computer ! This weekend cannot wait for my 113km Cadel Evans Great ocean peoples ride Geelong Australia with the Challambra hill at 16% gradient. Thinking the 34/34 combination will be a winner here 👌

[@daviddawn9043]

So is it slower or faster than your riding mate

[@71hutchy]

@@daviddawn9043 I believe I’m definitely faster on this bike now . Love it 👍

[@daviddawn9043]

@@71hutchy I thinking of going to one I just can't get on with my caad12 or dogma I ache whilst riding .47 and I think it is time for me to try something bit more less aggressive

[@71hutchy]

@@daviddawn9043 You won’t regret buying the new Defy . Yesterday I was near the end of my 125km ride and was on a section of road near home thinking how harsh my old bike was on that piece of road. The Defy is smoother which is very nice when you’re starting to get fatigued near the end of your ride . Like David Arthur says you’ll find you’ll probably ride faster because you’re more comfortable and it’s true .

[@AF-cg2es]

I picked up the Giant Defy Advanced Pro 2 and it's been a breeze riding from Hampton to Port Melbourne and back. Super light weight

[@NeilCaplan]

A comparison between the two bikes would be great. I'm sure there's plenty other folk out there who, like me, still want to go as fast as possible but are older or have terrible flexibility so need to get an endurance geometry. Very much interested in the Defy for seemingly not just making the bike heavier or too relaxed just because it's in endurance category.

[@raymondelliot4605]

I’m 62 years old and own a Giant Defy Advanced 2 which I bought back in 2019. I love the bike, I renewed a few parts on it, rear free hub, bottom crank bearings and the usual brake pads which I did all myself. Its quite easy to work with. The only thing I couldn’t do myself was the bottom head bearing as the cables run through it. The top one was easy. I put it into the Giant shop for that. The 11/34 is great for me as I live in Scotland and there are a lot of hills around my area. I keep meaning to get mudguards for it. It’s coming up to 5 years now since I bought it and it still looks good and in very good condition.

[@mikeward2922]

i'm nearly 60, in Virginia hills in USA. I'm looking to upgrade from a bought used Trek Domane. How's your hill climbing experience?

[@charlessinclair8111]

At age 77 I sold my race bike and bought a BMC Roadmachine. Absolutely no regrets! It’s probably the best riding bike I’ve owned and that is partly due to the fact I had a full professional bike fit. I think it would be great to compare the Defy with the Roadmachine as they seem to lean a little more to the Sport side of the equation.

[@rickmoughton7968]

I am 62 and I have a BMC Roadmachine and agree it’s an incredible ride. Absolutely love it

[@jimtro4403]

About a month ago I bought the 2024 Defy SL1 (Ultegra Groupset) for a killer deal and so far I love it but I just have just been able to do quick laps around the block due to the weather here. Today should reach 52 degrees F (11 C) so I am going to take her for a proper ride!!!

[@twocameras5212]

I recently purchased a 2025 Giant Defy Advanced Pro 0. I am really pleased with the bike, comfortable but not as upright as the Roubaix it replaced. In the Australian market, Giants are much better value than the competition.

[@timc2827]

Great video! A SL8 vs Defy comparison over a long distance would be great. For us mere mortals, it seems like the benefits of a endurance bike really start to show on long rides.

[@Richiemouse]

Thanks for this, I really like the look of the Defy. It seems like it would suit my needs perfectly, 59 only been cycling for four years but doing around 120 miles a week and want to step up from my Giant Fastroad SL1.

[@stefanodirector]

I think Giant really nailed the ultimate allrounder-go anywhere bike with this Defy.

[@abdulmajidhussain7942]

Compare the prices, and you can't go wrong with the defy. One I'm definitely thinking of getting in the coming months.

[@Richard-qe7st]

Can I suggest you buy one in Australia and have a free holiday and take it back with you? I can’t get my head around the UK prices for Giants - the same bike in Australia is AUD8k (RRP). That’s about £4.2k yet Dave said this was nearly £6k in the UK?

[@deanf2259]

My local shop are a long time Giant dealer. I must say more I see of the current Giant range the more I would consider buying a one. Although I don't need another bike. They have the new Defy in stock and it is a fantastic looking bike. Giant paint colours and finish have greatly improved. I like the very classy and unstated designs. Dave you are right about the lower stack on the new defy. As a person who rides with a slammed stem long and low position from racing and also a small or extra small. Many of the current endurance bikes have far too much stack for me. The Defy geometry would be idea for me. I can see a new Defy in the your stable soon Dave.

[@Kirkend]

I purchased this bike last week and had first ride out today. Yes it’s a lot of money, yes it’s overpriced and no I don’t need this level of technology as I cycle mainly for fun and fitness. However, whilst I don’t need it I wanted it and first impressions were fantastic. Really comfortable and smooth, I’m 5’7 and went with the small which is perfect for me. The servo assisted brakes are top notch and give you a lot of confidence. Overall I’m really pleased with the bike and that’s what matters to me. I will wager Dave trades in his TCR and opts for both the speed and comfort which this Defy Pro delivers.

[@tonyjames5444]

Hi with the small do you get toe strike at all? Also I'm 5ft 7 and when I tried a small TCR my knees were hitting my elbows. Really like the small as it's stiffer and obviously lighter. Obviously the geometry of the defy will differ just wondering if you've had similar issues.

[@Kirkend]

@@tonyjames5444 This was an initial concern for me when I took a punt and opted for the Small. As you probably know with this Defy you are the top end of size for the XSmall and at the bottom end of sizing on the Medium. My other two bikes are Mediums but I have to say when riding this Defy it really does feel for the first time that Ive actually got the correct size for me. Appreciate thats just my personal opinion but the bike is comfortable to ride, its very nimble, the Di2 is super slick and overall so far I’m still happy I opted for this bike and in the Small. Hope thats some help to you, its a few quid if you get it wrong so might still be worth making a journey to nearest bike shop who has this model in stock just for peace of mind.

[@tonyjames5444]

@@Kirkend Trying a small again on Saturday, been advised to change the stem from its default 90 to 100 or 110, that aside it comes with 170 cranks and 40cm bars which a fitter recommend I get.

[@yvesn58]

Hard to see the color very well even in the video. Can you describe more?

[@yvesn58]

@@tonyjames5444 Is it easy to change the stem because of the cables that go inside ?

[@antoinecdc]

Excellent, informative and lively review as always!!! Love my Defy and now a bit jealous of the new 2024 Defy series...

[@OscarOverlanding]

Thank you! I just purchased the Defy Advanced 1 and can't wait to get some miles in!!!

[@andrewgibbons8159]

How's the bike going? Carbon slr1 wheels?

[@OscarOverlanding]

@@andrewgibbons8159 it does not have the carbon wheels….this is my next upgrade! I love the bike!!! I had a professional fit it to me and it is an absolute pleasure to ride and hammer out some miles. 105 Di2 and hydraulic brakes are spot on and the frame and fork have a really nice balance of stiffness and compliance! Thank you for asking!

[@EmmetFardy]

My Defy Advanced Pro 2 arrives next week. Looking forward to it since November.

[@markmancini3346]

I’d like to see a comparison between the Defy and Cervelo Catalonia.

[@mariospatronis7337]

Great review. Thank you very much David. I am ordering it now though I know it's overpriced. But it is what it is. We cannot regulate the market... Could you comment on the mudguards? Weight etc Was thinki g for raceblade pro xl...

[@bobfine4877]

Great video David, always appreciate your reviews. I have a 2016 Cervelo R3 and this looks like the perfect replacement as my riding aligns to more endurance rather than “race”. I’m 60+ rider who puts in 10,000 KM/year. Appreciate hearing from any owners of this bike to get your thoughts

[@davidarthur]

Love the Cervelo R3 - had been on the lookout for a decent second hand one actually... Reckon the Defy will be a very nice upgrade from that indeed

[@nicholasclarke5180]

Great video, David - thanks. I'd love to see a comparison between the Defy and the Tarmac SL8. My inclination would be to go with the SL8, as I like to chase Strava PRs. But if the Defy is very nearly as fast and noticeably more comfortable (not to mention far cheaper), then perhaps I should reconsider? If you do compare them, I'd be very interested to see numbers that show the time/speed difference between the two bikes over your usual segments.

[@3rdcatchopper408]

It’s not about the bike, biggest gain is a good diet and getting your weight down as low as possible wile still being healthy. Your falling into the bullshit trap and tripe spesh come out with. Get a cheaper bike and have a holiday on the cash left over 👍🏻

[@kmervar]

Highly appreciate the comparison to the Enve Melee. Both comfort and performance wise.

[@xosece]

very nice bike. Wish there were more videos about flat bar bikes like the Canyon Roadlite 6 (2023) with its Deore XT 12 gears drivetrain, 1X chainring 46T, and 10-51T cassette, so suited for basically anything. It's light, it's fast, very well priced. I got the Pathlite 6 (not the Roadlite, but that one is more performance oriented), and I have a road bike plus a MTB and the concept is excellent

[@kalsmith509]

I have this exact bike on order. Very much looking forward to your final review !

[@Kiop328]

The comparison to the SL8 would be great!

[@andrewgibbons8159]

Hi David, i picked up my giant defy advanced pro 1 today. Thank you for your advices. 😊 keep up the good work

[@davidarthur]

Awesome! Thank you!

[@LagunaRider1961]

My obsessiveness with keeping a clean bike would never allow me to live in the UK 😂 Always look forward to your videos David! Cheers from Southern California!!

[@daviddawn9043]

To hot where you are lol.

[@robm509]

Some of us over here only ride our bikes to enjoy the cleaning ritual after the ride 😜

[@BigBailBikesandBeer]

I ceramic coated my bike the week I brought it. All I need to do is give it a rinse with a hose /wipe with a cloth after a ride and it's as good as new again. The UK does not allow you to ride regularly on roads without mud and debris flicking up. Oh and dont even start me on pot holes!!

[@AdyWalter]

I have a 2022 Defy Advanced 0 with Sram Rival Axs (black and orange) and really enjoy it. Was the right price at the right time.

[@stevenarvola5647]

I just picked this one up - hoping the rain lets up to get a longer ride in

[@AdyWalter]

@@stevenarvola5647 I know what you mean, it's been relentless for months 😔. Enjoy your new wheels!

[@ianfurqueron5850]

The idea of an endurance bike is interesting to me, although when I look at the specs of currently available "race" bikes, they look considerably more comfortable than my current 90's vintage Colnago or even my 2016 GT Grade that doesn't fit very large tires by current standards.

[@thepandaman]

I wanted to give thanks about your review of the Strael a couple of years ago and follow-up mentions of it, as it was in part what helped me decide to go for one. Got it a couple of weeks ago and absolutely love it.

[@davidarthur]

Glad it was helpful!

[@fnqadv1162]

I am in the market for this exact spec bike right now, was really keen on the Canyon Endurace until they put that stupid top tube storage on it - I couldn't live with that. At the moment the Giant is in the lead.

[@chrisscott8362]

The canyon top tube storage looks sooooo cheap. Like a TV remote battery door. I bought the Defy Adv 0. Very happy with it.

[@BigBailBikesandBeer]

Got a 2023 Giant advanced 2 in October. I have upgraded the wheels (DT Swiss pr1600 with Goodyear F1 tires), front chainset (Ultregra) and saddle (Selle Italia novus boost carbon) and I love it. Had spinal surgery in 2011 and wanted something a bit more relaxed than a race /aggressive geometry. Really happy with my choice and the advice given by my LBS to make my decision as I initially wanted a TCR. It's still fast enough for me , climbs well and rides problem free. Plan on getting some deeper wheels in the spring but other than that I will leave it as it is. Been using the "stock wheels" and tires on really wet/muddy lane rides through out winter and despite being heavier they are ok

[@antoinecdc]

Exact same bike here with an upgrade to Zipp 303 firecreset wheels and the Specialized ultra premium saddle (not that the original Giant saddle wasn't great - it is! - but needed a 155 mm). Absolutely love it. Sooooo comfy and super fast as well!

[@Windband1]

Thanks mate. Good review! Endurance bikes are def all I ride at my age. 😉

[@wimbemong2375]

How would you compare it with a BMC Roadmachine?

[@gavinkeegan8678]

Thanks love your imformation i have a 2025 Defy Advanced pro 0 in to weeks to put through some tests gravel and road

[@wildsurfer12]

Looks like my 2021 Defy Advanced 2, which is also a great bike!

[@eoinjobrien]

Great video - thanks. Those are some pretty mucky roads you're riding - proper winter cycling! Have a Defy Advanced Pro 1 coming next week and really looking forward to getting out on it.

[@andrewgibbons8159]

Hi. Did you get your defy advanced pro 1? I want to 2024 model. Any regrets ? Pls

[@eoinjobrien]

@@andrewgibbons8159 It's a cracking bike - no regrets.

[@andrewgibbons8159]

@@eoinjobrien likewise. I got mine and love it 🤟🙂

[@rickhutcherson6447]

Yes, please compare the Specialized and the Giant! Can comfort beat out aero for mere mortals?

[@davidleonard3716]

Another great review David. Good looking bike as well.

[@davidarthur]

Thank you kindly

[@mikerolfsen4500]

Great stuff as always David! Love your insight!

[@davidarthur]

Glad you enjoyed it!

[@nickoutdoors8119]

Great video. At age 46 I sold my giant tcr and bought a trek domane gen 4

[@FrenchFries1]

We'd highly appreciate a comparison between the Defy and the Tarmac

[@Stu_he]

What are your thoughts on the Defy or a Fairlight Strael?

[@slantedorbit]

Surprised to discover that the primary difference geo-wise between a Defy and a Revolt is headtube angle (and thus wheelbase). No doubt the compliance features and tire clearances are different but still interesting.

[@tommilano5431]

I’m a fan of this bike. I would get it as a 1 bike collection. I don’t need anything wider than 38mm to ride gravel, and since it’s closer to a road bike, it’s the Goldilocks of bikes.

[@grantwilliams2912]

I wish it was feasible for Giant to offer a few more geo options, as for me, it’s become longer and lower than ideal. I suspect the majority of bike fits would intro quite a few spacers. Pearsons Forge is an interesting frame as they have used a lot of bike fit data to result in a different format

[@sabaffira]

As I age, I have moved from Propel to TCR and soon Defy as I hit 50

[@arhu74]

How does the tcr compare to the propel?

[@sabaffira]

@@arhu74 this is Propel from 2015. I find the TCR lighter and more responsive to acceleration with the climbing wheeIs. I developed a liking for climbs with the TCR.

[@arhu74]

@@sabaffira thank. I own a 2020 propel but looking for something new with less road buzz and easier to corner

[@sabaffira]

@@arhu74 when I first got the TCR it felt twitchy and needed getting used to. It’s still a stiff frame. Wider low pressure tubeless might make a difference.

[@htukmumfie]

vs specialized crux in road mode please (regardless of mudguards)

[@robber16]

Would you recommend those giant mud guards or is it better to go for the classic SKS or similar? What would you buy if it was your money?

[@HARRIS2065]

Thanks much....any issues with your seat post CLAMP not holding?

[@johncoates6039]

What’s your saddle height David? We like when you include bike size and such.

[@davidarthur]

76cm BB to saddle top John

[@3rdcatchopper408]

I’m not buying another bike again until the cycling industry sorts its shit out an stop charging us extortionate prices, making videos like this is adding to the problem justifying 6k for an average bike

[@wherearewe324]

Well, I guess you'll be riding your old bike forever then.. Enjoy 😉

[@andrewlancefield3730]

You can get bike cheap if that is all you can afford dude

[@3rdcatchopper408]

@@wherearewe324 eBay is a wonderful place

[@3rdcatchopper408]

@@andrewlancefield3730 I can afford it however doesn’t mean I like getting shafted from bike industry

[@scottwatson7844]

Yeah I can relate I have the Defy Advanced Pro from 2017 which is one model number down from this one and it cost me brand new £2899. So not sure I can justify spending out double for a bike which will ride pretty much the same.

[@goodeggnogg7038]

Love a fast winter bike...with mudguards!

[@southcityka]

Great video! I ride a 2023 Defy Advanced and I love it. My only problem with Giant is the look. The selection of colors is simply too small.

[@thsaintful]

i spotted an upside down bottle cage at 10:42 🤣 I am actively looking at the Trek domane, and i wonder how much it's weight is going to hold me back

[@rickmoses5081]

Great vid😊

[@adamcoatham]

Would very much like to see that comparison video - intrigued to see real world (not just wind tunnel claims!) data comparing speeds of race vs endurance bikes

[@abhimawa1]

If one reverses the logic & time, one will see the TCR as franken bike → the (rear) geometry of a Propel, with tubes profile of a Defy. Going back to the topic, IMO the Defy w/ Ultegra is highly sensible; geometry, components selection, gearing choice, even the cockpit (unless one can be comfortable being stretched for hours). It’s like a decent GT car that can take us almost everywhere. The simple tech also does make a lot of sense. Coming from MTB, I started with several full suspension bikes and settled on hardtail in the end, as the complexity of the suspension gimmicks just make little sense to me. This Defy should be the one bike one will ever need to have fun & stay healthy (attractive look, all-day comfort position, toyotta-like robustness, no drama). Nice video, Dave! 👍

[@apsbentom]

Can u do a comparison with a look 765 second generation?

[@andreacalzolaio2431]

I want an endurance bike, not a slow bike. this could be a valid option, but I always think of the aethos with more relaxed geometries. Let's see if 2024 will bring the hoped-for innovations

[@querubindeseo]

Please, I want to see a comparison of the defy with a specialized racing bike and if possible several kilometers on a flat section with watts to see real differences

[@niklaskristensson2231]

Good video with essential info. Great looking velociped.

[@OWilki]

Hi David, when is your full review of this bike due? I’m weighing up one but would be interested to see what you say in your review first 👍

[@davidarthur]

Give me a few weeks 👍

[@jarrahfitzgerald2752]

How does the 2024 Defy compare to the Revolt?

[@alwaysbelievechrist4688]

a city cross custom conversions have always been around and probably better so you have the spare parts to have 2 completely different bikes in 1

[@amritv6889]

@David, would appreciate if you can share the information about the bike computer (garmin edge model ?), make of rear bike light and make of saddle bag. As you get a better value for your money, I think, it would make sense to buy 2024 Giant Defy Advanced Pro 1 (Unicorn color) then Pro 0 ? What are your thoughts on that ?

[@Yimchifung]

defy adv pro2 or canyon enduance cf7 axs？i want to buy a new bike。in china，the price of the two is about the same。please tell me your choice

[@antoinecdc]

Would love to see a comparison with the SL8!!!

[@sccxvelo]

Use CX bike best four worlds. Fast twitchy when needed, still comfortable for long rides, takes most gravel tires, and higher BB so can so do some trails.

[@paulglover5359]

This is the bike I want to buy, I would love to see how it compares to the SL8, though

[@lucamuller6729]

Hi David, how is the bike? Looking forward to hear from you about it, since I consider it as the best option for me. Cheers

[@ronbyrne6847]

a would to see a comparison between the Defy and tg TCR as I am contemplating buying one or the other. Many thanks.

[@davidarthur]

I have done that comparison sort of, have a look back through my older videos :)

[@bikemirror6620]

Please compare this with BMC's roadmachine

[@SkylarsRnD]

I really want to get your opinion on the Look 765.

[@raulsanchez7487]

Please compare the Defy against the SL8 thanks!

[@daviddawn9043]

Im thinking of moving to endurance in next few months

[@josep9599]

How does this compare to the TCR? Looking at one of these as my first road bike. I might be doing some triathlon training, but mostly just planning on riding solo for pleasure.

[@l.d.t.6327]

Defy vs. TCR: You get a bit more clearance, a bit more wheel base and fully integrated cables. The model David is riding (Defy Advanced pro 0) costs 6399 euro in continental Europe. The TCR advanced pro 0 with SLR1 wheels and Ultegra DI2 costs 5899 euro. Both are expensive, and in short, you're paying 500 euro for having 6mm more tire clearance, a longer wheelbase and hidden cables, compared to the TCR. In cheaper models that price difference is smaller, but it's still there. While last year's models are cheaper (Defy advanced pro 1 with non-hidden cables is 4099 euro for SLR1 wheels and Ultegra DI2), the biggest miss imho is not having a decent spec'd Defy advanced NON pro version with Ultegra (or even 105) DI2 and SLR2 wheels in the range of 3500-4000 euro. Because: why would you want an oversized / stiffer steerer in the pro version for something you won't race (as in: a defy)?

[@spinnetti]

More important, why are you on the big ring with that back gear lol. Great info as always :)

[@grahamekellermeier8280]

Great looking bike ideal for us old people.

[@thomasb7237]

How does the ride quality/bike geometry compare to a Contend AR?

[@brianridley1102]

That still looks quite low at the front end. As an oldie (60) so not as flexible as that bike not still a bit to race oriented front end ?

[@tedmanner1086]

Any way you can review the Commencel 365?

[@martingwynfawke]

Can it take rear paniers...

[@jirivenhoda9620]

Really nice review with lots of information, thanks. I am considering an endurance machine as my next road bike and Giant Defy is at the top of my list together with Cervelo Caledonia 5. How would you compare the two, David?

[@davidarthur]

Thanks. Well I reckon there must be a new Caledonia on the way so I'd be tempted to wait and see unless you're not worried about having the latest model

[@jirivenhoda9620]

@@davidarthur I am not obsessed with having the latest tech and Caledonia 5 is now in the shops with some pretty appealing discounts, so I'm looping back to my original question of Caledonia 5 vs Giant Defy Pro :) They seem, based on reviews, like a similar breed in the sense of simple endurance bikes without complicated gizmos and a bit of the sportier feel. What do you think are the key differences between them?

[@mrjames7246]

Bike looks amazing and not surprised it rides so well. I have a 2023 tcr and love it. It rides nearly as well as my c64 but cost under half the rrp. I'd love to ride this new defy to compare it to my tcr. Great video as always 👍

[@LTBlightthebeam]

I have the current model TCR and have never ridden a Colnago. Out of general curiosity what makes your Colnago ride better?

[@georgesteele9718]

What are your thoughts on the hook-less rims that come with bike?

[@davidarthur]

I've never had any issues with hookless in years of using them so for me they're fine, but I hear the concerns people have, some founded and some unfounded. With these 32mm tyres I'm only running 50psi

[@querubindeseo]

Please, what mudguard do you use exactly in this giant defy please??

[@davidarthur]

These are Giant's own mudguards

[@wordpress4373]

How come you dont have Cube Attain GTC on test?

[@davidarthur]

Working with Cube to make that happen

[@Tyrael2b]

I am interested in how the Giant Defy compares to the Giant Revolt- thanks for the great content. Ps would love to see the bike companies simplify their components/builds/cost of production and just give us top tier group-sets 🤣

[@jasonyltan7672]

Does it run the Giant proprietary headset bearings as well? Irritating if that’s the case.

[@johnhospod5202]

Which size in this frame would you recommend for someone 6ft tall?

[@andrewgibbons8159]

Hi. Question to the floor pls. Currently on an 8 yr old cube race bike. Upgrading now. Its either defy advanced pro 1 or Tcr advanced pro. Im 40. Enjoying my race bike atm. Will i regret buying the defy over the tcr ? Any advices pls and thanks.

[@davidarthur]

Hi Andrew, good question. I think if you want a race bike the TCR is the best choice but if you want a slightly more relaxed first with more comfort and like the idea of wide tyres then the Defy will definitely be a nice upgrade - if I was buying it's the one I would go for because it's still fast but a bit easier on an old back

[@andrewgibbons8159]

Hi David, I really appreciate the reply and the advice. My gut feeling is saying go for the defy. I have placed a deposit on it but could easily switch to TCR. I think my mind is set now on the Defy. Thanks!!

[@1968stevec]

What mudflaps did you order to extend the mudguard coverage?

[@davidarthur]

PDW ones

[@ignus16]

Press fit BB and hookless rims? no thanks..

[@thelastboyscout6790]

6k ! This is crazy !

[@davidarthur]

The range does start from just over £2k

[@robertherrera1546]

Which one is better domane or defy?

[@dennycrane2817]

BMC Roadmachine for me anytime. But used in mint condition of course 😎

[@robm509]

I'm sure they are incredibly strong, but to me those stays look like they would snap at the mere sight of a common British pothole.

[@josipX]

I would always choose the Giant Revolt over the Defy

[@blakebullock9656]

Thank you for all your hard work with these reviews! Great looking bike!

[@davidarthur]

Much appreciated!

[@daviddawn9043]

Is there a part 2 dave

[@davidarthur]

There will be a full and final review soon

[@vegtertom]

I was lucky to test the defy '24 SL 0 for a week and compare it to the TCR '23 pro 1. Found the defy to be racy. But still experienced lots of flex, resulting in (imo) significant lower responsiveness compared to the TCR. This give me doubt to wait for the new TCR. What do you think David?

[@davidarthur]

Interesting insight, in what way have you noticed the flex? Can't say I've noticed any flex from the bike, in fact I thought it was pretty stiff to be honest with you. I'm relatively lightweight though which might have an impact

[@vegtertom]

Mainly when starting to accelerate/stand on the pedals I experienced significant more flex/less stifness in pulling the bike or (core?) of the frame then the TCR (85kg here). Obviously there are differences, but I didn't expected this difference. Must say I am not an experienced testrider, but this is one of the reasons that make me doubt to wait for the new TCR in 24. Looking forward to your results and opinion;).