2024 Ohio State vs. 2023 Michigan: Who was the better team? | The Big College Football Show

[@BrianFarstvedt]

OSU losing to Michigan both years answers this question.

[@klav5930]

Again who won the game in 2023?

[@williamgilicinski6414]

This is about Ohio State at their peak in 2024. Why even mention the game in 2023, that's a different team. Which team had to go into overtime to scrape by in the post season and which team dominated four top ten teams back to back. And you know Ohio State was at their lowest in The Game this year... a far cry from their peak (The entire point of this video)

[@klav5930]

I get it, but that’s what everybody is saying there was no low point to this OSU team this year! They went into the 〽️ game trying to prove they were now a tough team running the ball down 〽️throat and it back fired! This team should have went undefeated this season point blank! They were only wounded from the embarrassment of losing to the real team that was down this year at home!

[@afridgetoofar1818]

Ohio State vs Notre Dame? Ohio State won, bro

[@ProskieThePeople]

Why is this even a question...... they played 4 times we know who is better plus who got more hardware

[@coreywahl524]

Soft

[@coreywahl524]

If they’re plush why couldn’t the National Champs beat them?

[@coreywahl524]

Because the college committee decided for a 12 team series. I’ll admit Ohio woke up during the playoffs but that still doesn’t change the fact they lost to an inferior Michigan team in 2024. Michigan also beat OSU in 2023 and don’t give me that crap about signs. Day had over a month to change their signs.

[@newyorker3556]

@@Marcel-x1tnot a Michigan fan but you know Michigan would win

[@coreywahl524]

@Marcel-x1t Thats probably the dumbest most delusional thing I have heard. But it doesn’t surprise me you believe that because a vast majority of OSU fans seem pretty unhinged. I mean look at all the death threats they were sending to Day and his family before he won the Natty. How about you get off Elven Whiners for a bit. Nothing is happening to Michigan despite what they tell you. If something does happen it’s going to be so minor it won’t matter. All of the OSU fans will start bitching and complaining again because they have to beg the NCAA to give Michigan handicaps to beat them now apparently. Oh wait they tried that in the 2023 game and failed.

[@webmoore4353]

Well2024 and 2023 Michigan beat Ohio and Michigan was undefeated last year. Michigan wins the very time. Best champion

[@mgoboski]

Which one went undefeated, and which one lost to Davis Warren?

[@afridgetoofar1818]

Also, Michigan is the only team in college football history to beat FIVE top-5 teams. Oh wait, that’s Ohio State 😂

[@finnmacdiarmid3250]

Day has twice as many CFP wins as Harbaugh during UM’s run. Let that sink in.

[@mgoboski]

@Marcel-x1t that's the best you got? OSU fans were convinced they would beat Michigan last year after Stalions was gone and guess what?... Ya lost!

[@coreywahl524]

You OSU fans are truly a delusional bunch.

[@mgoboski]

@Marcel-x1t oh NOooo, you got us! We feel so bad now 😂

[@freeclimb5487]

This question is a joke right... I mean 15 - 0, Big10 Champions, National Champions, only team in history to win 5 games against ranked opponents in last 6 games. 19 players on NFL roster??? Vs. a 2 loss team that lost at home to a 6-5 Michigan Team. Don't make me laugh. Hell, if they played again right now this years Michigan team would still beat them. Smh

[@finnmacdiarmid3250]

UM last year couldn’t run the table this year. End of story. UM knew TCU’s play calls in the 2022 playoff and still lost. Lose the bias, it’s starting to look bad for the university

[@samuelgainey8336]

Nobody knew anybody's plays. That take has aged badly.

[@jeremystrong3354]

Michigan won The Game THIS YEAR. They wouldn’t beat 2023 Michigan.

[@ReganSouth]

‘23 Michigan strangles ‘24 Ohio St.

[@newyorker3556]

Not a fan of neither but that Michigan wolverines 2023 team would win by 10 minimum if they played in the final against Ohio states 2024 team

[@josephmarkell9742]

To not take Michigan is absolutely wild

[@coreywahl524]

Soft

[@SectionZ1996]

@@Marcel-x1tfunny because osu has the vacated season😂

[@blevins2408]

2023 Michigan. Next question

[@coreywahl524]

Ohio soft

[@1234MarioDuane]

Michigan, no question! 15-0 beat Nick Saban, Won the Big! What are we debating?

[@finnmacdiarmid3250]

And is still under investigation for cheating 😂 Where’s the UM dignity here?

[@SectionZ1996]

@@Marcel-x1tsorry not sorry Michigan didn’t cheat it was nothing but a story. Only osu fans are running with that narrative.

[@jofi4580]

Last time I checked, 15-0 is better than 14-2. That coupled with the fact that they played head to head just adds more for UM.

[@marceld8961]

Ohio State couldn't even great this year Michigan team, what makes people think they better than last year team.

[@znet2723]

Very weak year for football. They can't beat a 6-5 Michigan team. How could they beat the 2023 Michigan team? Ever think maybe those teams they beat weren't that good? None of those teams would have been in the CFP last year.

[@johnstacyii4827]

One team went unbeaten.

[@finnmacdiarmid3250]

And cheated to do it 😂 get real.

[@BuddyRob890]

@@finnmacdiarmid3250lmao and we beat you this year with no qb? Osu fans stay stupid, here’s a binkie for you little bro state

[@SectionZ1996]

@@finnmacdiarmid3250lol how stupid are osu fans even if Michigan so called cheated and it was exposed you still lost to Michigan in 2023 and the temu 2024 version you buckeyes fans deserve a ride to the national championship on the short bus.😂

[@terrywalton1266]

The team that won in 24 were backups last year...no will johnson..no colston loveland! Go blue. Blake corum for 150 on this team. Mikey sainristil and rod moore locking 🔒 them boys..he talking 100 yards stop it. Mhj scored on a drag route while will was in zone. Don't matter..we'll see u next year in Ann arbor.

[@marceld8961]

If this Ohio State team couldn't beat this year Michigan team, what made you think they can beat last year Michigan team lol 😂. Plus Michigan went undefeated in their run to the championship.

[@benbusse7208]

Michigan EASY.

[@deanzachariades6365]

No contest. 2023 Michigan. They went 15-0 while dealing with all the adversity in the world. They lost their coach for 6 games. not to mention the entire country was rooting for them to lose, including the Evil Empire Alabama. Ohio State won the title and good for them. But the only one who had to deal with adversity was their coach.

[@coreywahl524]

If OSU couldn’t beat a worse version of Michigan in 2024 what makes you think they can beat a more talented version of them?

[@freeclimb5487]

Delusion.

[@coreywahl524]

Whatever helps you sleep at night pal.

[@SectionZ1996]

@@Marcel-x1tlol I can’t beat Michigan so I have to create a cheating scenario and run with it. Didn’t osu cry about the flu in 2021?

[@SectionZ1996]

⁠@@Marcel-x1tespn is about as accurate as a cnn broadcast.

[@robertm8252]

If you go position by position, coach by coach, it is not even close. Michigan 2023 is better at every spot except WR. The Ohio State DL players this year would be second and third rotation guys on the Michigan 2023 team. Caleb Downs was the difference maker on the OSU defense this year. Oh, and he also took two Ls from Michigan in a year. Dumb question. Michigan works 2024 OSU.

[@freeclimb5487]

The ○hio DL would be rotational players on this years Michigan team.

[@finnmacdiarmid3250]

Lay off the copium Buddy

[@Tigerssteamrollthetwins]

Will Johnson was hurt in the second half of that Ohio State game

[@freeclimb5487]

Will Johnson didn't play at all in that game. You're thinking of Donovan Edwards.

[@Tigerssteamrollthetwins]

@ I’m talking about the 2023 game. Will didn’t get cooked Marv marv only had 54 yards because the guy said will got burned by marv

[@johnstacyii4827]

Michigan beat osu this year. Playing at their peek is someting osu hasn't done against Michigan in awhile.

[@-sdot83]

2023 Michigan, Will Howard would have been under pressure the whole game, now as great as Will Johnson was ill give the edge to Smith but other than that Michigan woulda just controlled the clock and other than Smith getting his they wouldn’t have been able to do shit with 2023 Michigan defense, hell they couldn’t do shit with 2024 Michigan defense

[@ryank6557]

Being objective here, Michigan was a better, more consistent team throughout their natty year, but ohio state I think is more talented and had a better, more dominant peak in that run. It all depends on when the teams would play. Michigan wins easily through the first 13 weeks, Osu team wins comfortably weeks 14-17

[@iRacerJared]

So OhioSoft needs its peak to win and Michigan just needs to be awful to win got it

[@afridgetoofar1818]

I’ll take the team that didn’t steal signals.

[@coreywahl524]

Just want to point this out there “sign stealing” is allowed.

[@BrianFarstvedt]

I’ll take the team that duly served unfair suspension time.

[@BlackMountainCycles]

*The team who didn’t cheat for half the regular season, and beat 5 Top-5 teams on their way is clearly the better team.*

[@coreywahl524]

You are why people call OSU soft.

[@BlackMountainCycles]

@@coreywahl524 you mean *YOUR NEW NATIONAL CHAMPIONS THE OHIO STATE BUCKEYES*

[@coreywahl524]

Greta job doesn’t change the fact they still lost to an inferior Michigan team this season. The video is on comparing 2023 Michigan vs 2024 OSU.

[@SectionZ1996]

@@BlackMountainCyclescongrats to the 49 state champ bucknuts!

[@JasonArtrip]

Ohio State at their peak wins. Also OSU didn't have to cheat. Buckeyes win it 38-20

[@SectionZ1996]

What evidence do you have of Michigan cheating like nothing is going to happen to them😂 Michigan 35 osu 21

[@alale923]

Not even close. Kyle mccord osu vs will howard osu is a total dif animal.

[@coreywahl524]

If OSU couldn’t beat the shitty version of Michigan how are they beating a better version of it?

[@j_r_junior]

Which team needed to cheat against Nebraska and pre-Cignetti Indiana? That team is the worse team

[@coreywahl524]

Wow if they were cheating last season and were shitty this season due to them not having their signs you must have beaten them by over 20 right? Right???

[@j_r_junior]

@ who is “you”? I’m no Buckeye if that’s what you’re assuming. But nothing you said refutes the fact that Michigan WAS cheating in nearly half of their games in 2023 (and all of them in 2021, 2022, which helped them recruit the talent that was allowed to cheat its way to the playoff), nor am I arguing that this year’s middling Michigan team picked up an impressive win over the national champs

[@coreywahl524]

Sign Stealing is not against the rules. They didn’t have a competitive advantage. Besides if it was why did Michigan still keep winning after their sign stealer was let go and other teams had Michigan’s signs?

[@j_r_junior]

@@coreywahl524 in-person advanced scouting is against the rules. If there was no competitive advantage from it, why did they do it?

[@matthewboylez34]

To not take this 2025 Buckeye team is absolutely insane.

[@coreywahl524]

Why is it insane? They couldn’t even beat an unranked Michigan team.

[@matthewboylez34]

@@coreywahl524 Fluke game. 2023 Mich could never have the run OSU just had.

[@LC9842]

@@matthewboylez344 years in a row isn’t a fluke

[@matthewboylez34]

@@LC9842 This year clearly was. OSU beat all the teams that beat Mich. Texas whooped that Mich ass and OSU came in to clean the house you couldn't.

[@coreywahl524]

No you just lost. Your team couldn’t stop Graham and Grant. They bullied your team all game long.

[@BumfCromulent]

Ohio state by a lot to a little. This dont let um fans trick you, this team was NOT dominate and only won cause they knew every play the other team was running

[@coreywahl524]

Keep telling yourself yourself that. In 2021 Stallions wasn’t a member of the Michigan staff in 2022 OSU themselves admitted that they changed their signs before the Michigan game. I might also add they used wristbands. In 2023 OSU had a whole month to change their signs and still lost. Don’t get me started with 2024. Besides sign stealing is not against the rules. What is being investigated is “how” Michigan got the signs. Just move on and take your L’s. Your the national champions after all.

[@sharkbrrr]

Totally, even when stallions and jim were at home watching the game on television, our team totally memorized every play and formation in the game... smh. You clearly don't know ball when Michigan in 2023, beat 11/15 of their opponents by 3 or more touchdowns. This team was dominate because they would run down your throats and our defense was the best in the nation. You can't just come up with the excuse of "cheating" to win because if Michigan were to have lost in the playoffs last year, they would be made fun of for losing as "cheaters", but when they won people would immediately just come up with their coping strategy of calling them "cheaters". Michigan has been stronger, faster, and more mentally tough the last 4 matchups against Ohio State. You should really ask yourself why Ryan Day and Chip Kelly were too afraid to throw the ball to their outside receivers against this 2024 Michigan team because that is just embarrassing to lose against a make a wish quarterback like Warren who had TWO picks that game.

[@coreywahl524]

Howard did actually throw the ball that game. It was the second most times he did in the regular season. Mason Graham Kenneth Grant and the rest of the defense just terrorized him all game.

[@SectionZ1996]

@@sharkbrrrpreach! But you are preaching to the wrong people I’ve never met a bucknut fan with any common sense. They believe everything espn tells them.

[@matthewboylez34]

These sour Midagain fans are coping hard with this 2024 Buckeye team that has the most dominant wins vs. ranked teams. 2025 Championship - Bow to the Buckeyes

[@coreywahl524]

Yet you couldn’t beat a trash Michigan team who had Davis Warren as their quarterback.

[@sharkbrrr]

Correct me if i'm wrong here, but the last time Ohio State beat Michigan was a little over five years ago. To be more specific 1,881 days since I know a lot of Ohio State fans don't know how many days are in year.

[@matthewboylez34]

@ talk to the Nattty

[@matthewboylez34]

@ And before that Buckeyes beat Midagain 8 times in a row with one loss, then another 7 times in a row. Amnesia before 2020 I see.

[@coreywahl524]

If you are going to talk about history who owns the all time record?