#206

[@ChinaUnscripted]

You can read Dheeraj's writings at scholar.google.co.uk/citations?user=v5pwg0EAAAAJ&hl=en Follow him on Twitter @divyasobhani5742 Or on LinkedIn at tinyurl.com/DHEERAJ-linkedin

[@MrDrgdf]

Why he isn't yelling?

[@surojeetchatterjee]

Last ending part is very important.

[@Former0311]

@@MrDrgdf Because he would come across as a crazy man and would be ignored.

[@nerf2752]

you got to get Abhijit iyer mitra. he have some of the most interesting takes on India china situation.

[@exurgemars]

@@nerf2752 no, he's very cringe. I'd suggest actual china watchers, experts and servicemen. Could invite Shivshankar Menon, ex-IN chiefs, Nitin A. Gokhale.

[@DevDutta_STANCE]

I knew the USSR had sent about 10-12 subs in the Indian Ocean and Bay of Bengal to counter the USS Enterprise battlegroup but knowing that they moved 40 divisions of the Red Army to the Chinese border was a revelation. It's true, a lot of "experts" talking about the 1971 Indo-pak war just manage to say, "China chose not to interfere in this war" but stop short of saying why?? 😀

[@harish5242]

They had deployed there forces along with armord divisions in Kazakhstan

[@jamesmichaeljean7840]

Because it's a religious war between Hinduism and Muslims, China is a non religious country. China has a big issue with India over the Dali lama and the cia work together to make them look bad. 😂

[@Kaafiristani]

PRC and USSR went to war over that border in 1967/1968. those divisions were always there. On the Enterprise, the Carrier group was deployed to Vietnam, in 1971 the Americans were getting creamed in Vietnam. Only fools that the Americans would get involved in another war. Hence there are no records of any skirmish with the Americans. It's a myth created by the Pro Russia lobby in India.

[@mitchellwilley7208]

Thank you for this video, now i understand the reasoning behind India doing what it does. You can't blame them.

[@ZuhaBuba]

Thank you, love from India. Long live America

[@jolode6319]

​@@ZuhaBuba😐😑😑

[@FindTheTruthBeforeTheEnd]

🇮🇳 + 🇺🇸 = 💪

[@jamesmichaeljean7840]

India is scared of ccp. It's too late India, China will not nuke you as your position is too close with nuclear fall-out. They will shoot bioweapon in new delhi alone will kill 30 million people.

[@MegaAshfire]

@@ZuhaBuba simp

[@randomlifts]

India clearly is the country that the global south should ally themselves with.

[@TheFlagUnit]

and why is that? They are beholden to the West. They cannot even fully advocate for themselves, when the time comes. Why would the global south trust them???

[@alexanderchenf1]

How is Argentina and Brazil allied with India? Nobody in the Global South has allied with India.

[@icet6665]

🤣🤣🤣

[@malianwong]

WHY....????

[@UphillJunkies]

​@@malianwongbecause china is US pet

[@DogsRSweet]

I always love seeing the opinions of people that aren't as clear of allies to us or China on these issues. India's position as a complex nation in the alliance standpoint makes their outside opinions more valuable and enlightening than simply listening to our own reports of it

[@chintakgurjar8426]

I think it’s more of racial thing when it comes to India for western countries. Western countries aligns good with their white counterparts. It’s evident.

[@DogsRSweet]

@@chintakgurjar8426 I wouldn't say that about places like Russia and their allies that are white. And america is close allows with multiple Asian nations

[@chintakgurjar8426]

@@DogsRSweet that’s in recent otherwise it’s more evident. Russia is the only exception for US

[@DogsRSweet]

@@chintakgurjar8426 currently, but it has always had issues with other eastern European nations. With the rise of communism and such, the relationship with that part of the world has been rocky for around 100 years. Russia is most recent, but since the break down if the USSR, Russia has been an issue. There could be a racial component, but it isn't the only reason. Or even a major reason. The USA has the best relationship with a nation that is not prominently white when it has a similar governmental structure. That is also the same for Russia, where their closest allies are those with similar athoritiarisn governments like China.

[@chintakgurjar8426]

@@DogsRSweet Have you done fact check? What you said have large exceptions and rather I wouldn’t call as exceptions at all. US have smooth relations where there are no democracies. Look just some recent past. How can you deny those things? Come on open your eyes look deep inside. India have learned from its past we learned bitter lessons not since independence but since last 1000 years. You need more insight and subject knowledge.

[@rationalsamrat3247]

USA spent 2 trillion dollars and 20 years replacing Taliban with Taliban .as an Indian i seriously question the motives of USA .

[@Adnancorner]

Thank you for questioning these people want to be poodle of the British crown to engineer the great reset where you'll own nothing and be happy" these YT'ers are nothing but funded by 10 or 20 shell companies ultimately owned by company based out of London and NY.. Wion news owned by a company in NY. They pretend to be Indian but they are owned by 51% NY company.

[@wwctw]

Motives from Vietnam war to Ukraine is for corrupt politicians in USA to swindle millions of dollars behind the war expenses and earn kickbacks from arms manufacturers. Another source is aid for unaccounted corrupt regimes especially dictatorship.

[@ankurdutta3277]

@@Adnancorner And which company is that? I was curious by your comment and it took me 2 google searches to find Wion is owned by Essel Group and Zee media. Zee media has divided stakes of 1/3 with 1 part being public and the other 2 companies are Indian. Essel group is 100% owned by a MP in India. Leave the 51%, where is the connection with NY in the first place?

[@user-yq9ex7hr1i]

@@ankurdutta3277 good reply with facts.

[@rationalsamrat3247]

@shevashevasheva777 so well that they let their european partners go into recession because they want to continue supplying ukraine with weapons in debt format ukraine will be paying back usa for next 50 years the amount is 140 billion dollars worth of weapon.

[@jsthereforfun1648]

Nehru was always a blunder on side of India whatever he had taken decisions mostly harmed India with his arrogance

[@wonderworld7721]

Actually we Indians create that poisonous Congressi monster and his family today to suck our own blood, it is our fault !!.. look at Kerala election 2023, electricity, water everything is free vote bank politics, appeasement, bribery politics, but not free education, people empowerment politics !!... what U can expect from an uneducated, nefarious, harmful poisonous Family and their established notorious company party Congress, which is not even the real one !!.. "least educated people means more chance to win the election", that's it !!..

[@3datul]

Now we have RAHUL GANDHI ! RAUL VINCHI SON OF [BTC] ANTONIO MAINO !

[@hiihello7625]

I think it's more complex than that Because while there indeed were some extremely bad decisions, there were some extremely good ones like establishment of IITs as well

[@wonderworld7721]

@@hiihello7625 : yes, actually more, for Ex : Bhaba atomic center, ISRO, IITs, etc. but they r all *Showpieces*, for making Us(general people) fool and won national election, first of all and secondly, they(congress family) r the great devotee of the Western culture and their leaders, so it's an opportunity for those western leaders to control India according to their interest, so they(west) started to spend money and who is getting those money ? same, nefarious congress gandhi family, the money is for their family benefit and not for the benefit of our country(India) !!.. and when U ask any question, they will say that 'we have plan on their Paper', but on the Ground, big *0* !.

[@subasthapa8323]

@@hiihello7625 Nehru was visionary who wanted peace in this region, if you are accusing him for partition then he had no choice or power to curb that bcoz both Jinnah (Muslim League) and Hindu mahasabha already decided for partition and there were huge backing for each side. Only way India could be united was by declaring India as an atheist social rupublic country likèn China where religion politics is given to zero importance. As far as China India war go in 1962, India should have come to table with free minds, since what China was claiming was right, it was a British demarcation of the border or should I say British occupation of Chinese land commonly prevalent in northern or north Eastern region where both people & geography was historically belong to Tibet(China).

[@joeyjoejoeshabadoo1411]

This guest has given me a much better understanding of why India's attitude towards the US. I must admit I've never understood the US position towards Pakistan. I guess it's because of its proximity to Afghanistan and the US involvement there.

[@maycodes]

Yup, It may be Pakistan can act as backup station in case of adverse situation in Afghanistan. But Pakistan always overplayed the US with talibans and chinese.

[@chintakgurjar8426]

US will never ditch Pakistan for India. India have no friends except natural partner Russia. Russia and India always gonna need each other to fulfill their security concerns.

[@Itried20takennames]

It is bizarre to expect that the US would not have political relationships with both Pakistan and India. India and Pakistan have a rocky history, but that doesn’t mean the rest of the world must pick one or the other. Would India let Egypt or Iran demand that India can’t have any geopolitical contact with Israel? Or would India be fine with China telling India that it can’t talk to Australia, or the US, or Canada, whoever China is mad at this week?

[@Aashu299]

It’s much deeper than that. Pakistan to this day is a servant state of US. Ex-PM Imran Khan directly accused US of regime change in Pakistan. Pakistan won’t survive a month without US support.

[@surajs5913]

​@@Itried20takennamesIndia doesnt claim to be the flagholder of "freedom and democracy" and then support an autocratic regressive state whose institution has been captured by its armed forces. The usa has no value in pakistan now except as a knife to twist into India while India's relations with israel iran and egypt all have both historical roots and are based on one to one interactions rather than as a strategic monkeybalencing to gain geopolitical advantage. India and Indians will always ve wary of usa just because of this fact - that the torchbearers of democracy aka the usa continues to tacitly support a nation lime pakistan that has not seen one democratically elected govt complete its full term.

[@exurgemars]

This is the kind of India-related podcast by China Unscripted I'd waited for for 4-5 years. A very knowledgeable guest, that puts across the India story vis-a-vis China quite eloquently. Thoroughly enjoying this episode. Perhaps you could Invite former NSA & China diplomat Shivshankar Menon next? He's a respected voice on China affairs in India.

[@exurgemars]

A small correction though. The guest mentions India had an upper hand in 1967 in Sumdorong Chu. The venue of 1967 war was the Nathu La & Cho La passes. The Sumdorong Chu standoff occured in 1985, in response to which, India launched Operation Checkerboard.

[@beluga9596]

What a level headed n deeply knowledgeable man . Forgot one small thing though about 1962 : IAF ( airforce of India ) was never allowed to mobilise against the chinese aggression in the Indian terrorist because ' you cannot bomb your own people '

[@saurabhade1079]

That's lie.

[@sahilsinghnegi7041]

​@@saurabhade1079 says who?

[@Red.bulldozer3]

Nonsense

[@saurabhade1079]

@S SN General B N Kaul in his memwaor. Can't comment further explaining, as my earlier comment doing it got deleted.

[@sahilsinghnegi7041]

@@saurabhade1079 it was nehru who showed ignorance.

[@revelationsix]

As an American, I am embarrassed that the US government cannot be trusted by anyone. I've spent 27 years in Asia, and I've seen this with my own eyes.

[@johndoe-vc1we]

Let the bullets fly and watch how fast USG becomes welcome

[@revelationsix]

@@johndoe-vc1we Really? You might need to get out more. I've watched how the US betrays its friends. But, you go ahead and keep watching TV.

[@rationalsamrat3247]

USA Spent 20 years and 2 trillion dollars replacing taliban with taliban . No country will trust USA after witnessing this nonsense.

[@kuchbhikahinbhi712]

Truthfully Trump was your only president who somehow bridged the confidence and trust gap that your other leaders created over the years. Need someone like him in office again to trust American 'govt' & call them friend.

[@mr.whostheboss9884]

@@johndoe-vc1we We have fought five wars, two of which with the US on the other side; we never got any help and managed; why do u think we will need it now. PS : I think the US will be the reason for its own demise.

[@Aurkus23]

I didn't even know there was a China India war, I only knew about the small border clashes these past few years. Thank you for bringing on such a smart individual to explain these things.

[@siddharthatalukdar4227]

India China War happened in 1962 and a skirmish in 1967

[@cuckoonut1208]

That's because it was more of an extermination rather than a war.

[@HTeo-og1lg]

The best book to read of the details of the war in 1962 is the one by Australian Historian, Neville Maxwell for the following reasons: (1) Written contemporarily immediately after the war ( a criterion used by historian for more authenticity of an account as it is more amenable to contemporary peer verifications of its factuality), (2) Written by an academic historian, not media personnel or politicians (discipline of academia for citations in collaborating facts). Title of book : India's China War. By Neville Maxwell. [London: Jonathan Cape, 1970. 475 pp. £5.] Reproduced for online by Cambridge University Press: 17 February 2009 edit: ps. Dr Maxwell was an Australian diplomat to India, and later in 1967, Maxwell joined the School of Oriental and African Studies, University of London, as a senior fellow, during which he wrote his book India's China War.

[@icet6665]

THERE IS NO WAR. THIS IS A FALUN GONG CHANNEL TO PROMOTE ITS ANTI CHINA PROPAGANDA.

[@annegribben444]

Wow THANKYOU... that was an EDUCATION.... now i understand why India feels Russia needs its loyalty because Russia came to its aid.... and I also now understand why India does not trust or hasnt trusted the USA.. In my experience....India has HAS EXTREMELY STRONG SPIRITUAL WISDOM AND PRINCIPLES.... and these STAND EXTREMELY HIGH .. far far higher than trinkets and money wads.... AND THAT WAS HOW COUNTRIES WERE OVERALL..... REAL IN THEIR OWN OWN STRENGTHS.... and China has sort to go to the poorer countries .....TO PROMISE THEM COMMODITY WEALTH ... as a savior messiah country ... AND I DONT BELIEVE CHINA COULD EVER DO THIS BREAKING UP OF INDIA . THRU ITS SUPERFICIAL BEADS AND BLANKETS CON ARTISTRIES.. So THANKYOU INDIA...this was a MARVELLOUS TALK FROM INDIA ....I BOW TO YOUR VALUES TO BE PROTECTIONIST AND UNDERSTAND FULLY THAT CHINA AS A TOTALITARIAN MINDSET CANNOT AND WILL NOT EVER WITH THIS REGIME IDEOLOGY EVER SEEK TO SHARE. PHYCOLOGY STATES THAT TOTALITARIANS CAN NEVER SHARE THAT THEY COULDN'T BE TOTALITARIAN IF THEY EVER DID ... THAT THEY ONLY COPY THE SHARING WAYS OF OTHERS TO TROJAN HORSE IT TO GET IN TO GET TOTALITARIAN POWER OVER TIME TO THEN FULLY OPRESS AND DOMINATE.. India is not foolish AND ITS STRENGTH OF CHARACTER IN HIGH WISDOMS WOULD NEVER ALLOW SUCH NONSENSE..... Thankyou again . Far more of this please .AROHA FROM NEW ZEALAND.

[@bapparawal2457]

Namaskar from India .

[@maycodes]

There are 250 million Buddhists who are not allowed to practice their religion openly. Although Buddhism originated in India, but Most followers are in China, and CCP punish them, sell their organs. It's pathethic.

[@hiihello7625]

Love New Zealand 🇳🇿 from India 🇮🇳

[@chintakgurjar8426]

Wow I have lived in New Zealand for couple of years. How you came to know spirituality in India’s context? It’s true we are fighting endless and meaningless wars and show of dominance on each other. This leads us no where. But this is also one of reality we have to face. Maybe that’s the nature of universe. Constant striving for existence. But really makes no sense 😂

[@roshanthapa8487]

So nice to see you reply Ma'am. Sending love from India.

[@sydneydesouza9719]

I am 86 year Goan Indian American retired Engineer 50 years in India & 36 years in Georgia US I agree completely with Dr Deeraj Chaya & his way of expressing Indias attitude. I lived in India from 1937 to 1986 & agree completely with him

[@Dr_MKUltra]

Excellent analysis, closer ties with India should be a priority for the US.

[@RPSartre01]

No not at all

[@Eric-ue5ed]

The US should support India’s permanent seat on the Security Council.

[@Dangermonkey1000]

americans are unreliable

[@ranfak]

lol and got overflow by indian isn’t it . If china and Russia can do what we for their own interests, india is no difference they will do even more crazy sht .. Indian are even more crazy on making stories, hope it’s will not be another mistake of USA lol

[@indianslay.........8064]

​​@@RPSartre01 yeah I agree with you we don't want USA which invaded countrys all around world for oil and resources we can handle CHINA by ourself and we stand on our own ground to project power in the world not by invading.....

[@EugenioMagay-fc7gm]

I stand by India because it's a Fellow Democratic Country where FREEDOM is REAL and NOT FOR SALE

[@0ldb1ll]

You're joking. India is currently supporting Russia and is also known as a country that is still controlled by the caste system.

[@EugenioMagay-fc7gm]

@@0ldb1ll Russia supported India when No Democrat country would NOT!!! as Caste system that is in their culture a form of Ranking system or highararchy on who gave birth to them RESPECT that culture if then Leave and shut up!!!

[@SILOPshuvambanerjee]

@@0ldb1ll As an Indian I say that caste system is followed on remote villages. As for Russia, we don't want them to totally ally with China. We already have two hostile neighbours with nuclear power.

[@pritish3484]

​@@EugenioMagay-fc7gm China is much more casteist than India. The top caste is CCP leaders.

[@pranavingale6850]

​@@0ldb1ll country controlled by caste system, 😂😂😂😂😂, i can hear your tiny little brain rattling around in your skull like a little bean in a maraca 😂😂

[@TheLoyalOfficer]

NEHRU was the problem with the 1962 war between China and India. He and the Congress Party neglected the Indian military. India paid the price.

[@gurindersingh8109]

Hindu India sena is corrupt cruel and lawless which can't last in battlefield. Indian military killed more Indians than enemy soldiers in battlefield

[@allensonu]

when people was dieing of hunger nehru was smoking imported cig underground by ladies, hes the greatest con man of India

[@TheLoyalOfficer]

@@allensonu The whole attitude of the early Congress Party was anti-military. Not just indifferent, but anti. In modern war, 14 years is a long time.

[@yj9032]

Good joke. If it were not for Nehru, India would’ve broken into a million pieces.

[@TheLoyalOfficer]

@@yj9032 I'm not saying Nehru was a bad guy necessarily. He accomplished a lot of good things for India. But he was caught with his pants down by China in 1962. That's just a fact.

[@michaelleader633]

China seems to get itself into a lot of situations where it seeks revenge... 😅

[@Lightning613]

🤔 hmmm seems most bullies tend to do that.

[@michaelleader633]

@@Lightning613 I don't know about that, mime never seem to learn. ^^

[@alexanderchenf1]

Not the first time. Mao’s era was like this

[@michaelleader633]

@@alexanderchenf1 OH, I know. What gets me is it is the definition of insanity. Doing the same thing, the same way and expecting different results. ;)

[@alexanderchenf1]

@@michaelleader633 you are describing the voters of Chicago and San Francisco.

[@tseringphuntsok756]

India should work to restore the buffer zone (Tibet) between India and China.

[@ishowsports008]

Tibet is an Ancient civilization not just some buffer zone. There freedom is inevitable.

[@1carusGG]

I believe its too late now. The intervention should've been done in 1962 itself, before China occupied Tibet. Also bear in mind that China doesn't care about casualties, so it will happily massacre the Tibetans, if at all they pose a resistance. The only way to counter china is to build a large counter offensive and get Russia to play along with the west.

[@Adnancorner]

@@ishowsports008 "civilization" ...... BS, "suck my tongue" was dalai lama was saying to that kid during the ceremony... its nothing but a warlord system where certain section of the population lived off the rest of the population like a parasite. pretending to be all holy and noble nonsense.

[@maycodes]

Buddha watched it, Blood of Tibetians will be avenged

[@KKPR533]

Wholeheartedly agree with you

[@derbezacesanchez3779]

Congress should invite Mr. Chaya to set them straight on China's war ideologies.

[@zenmaster2564]

Brilliant and very level headed man. India does have people who will speak their mind.

[@ramabullgaming1419]

Also after 1962 which was a loss due to political lack of commitment in 1967 India again had a clash with chine where India pushed back chinese and border was quite for so long till again in Galwan.

[@SHadowKillerDj]

Damn, my boy Matt did not even get a single word in this whole interview lol. Good content though, keep up the good work you all do at providing information to the general public about the CCP and their evil doings.

[@ChinaUnscripted]

Want to know a secret? HIs connection actually crashed for the entire interview. That's why he didn't say anything lol

[@siuwong4588]

@@ChinaUnscripted LOL Where is Shirley? Missing her so much!

[@SHadowKillerDj]

🤣 ah now that makes sense. I was like man this is very odd of him not to say anything, not even a funny pun

[@lynettecarter9887]

Can only happen to mat ❤😂

[@saurabhade1079]

@D Jenkins Looks like you are not following all the episodes on this KZbin channel. Its obivios what's happening to regular watchers of this KZbin channel.

[@JungleJargon]

Indians are cool really.

[@EchoLog]

Indians and indonesians are some of the coolest fuckers around. Kinda gotta be cool to make it where its so hot 😅 Fascinating history and essential perspectives for the "west" to pay attention to, especially right now.

[@anishmaitra5934]

we are. thanks

[@dhruvseoni8418]

As an Indian, I can verify this.

[@ineedpowers5151]

❤❤

[@jamesmichaeljean7840]

Makes me feel like I am buying a big gulp in 7-Eleven. 😂

[@shrinivaspai]

Love how much Matt spoke in this podcast 😂

[@insearchof9090]

"we understood that India has no friend in this world". This is why India never follows the deals as presented. It sniffs it, tastes a bit, throws some bit, adds somes customises it and uses it.

[@yabadaba9369]

We don't customize we reinvent

[@jogindersharma9566]

Indian is quite different. India will help any country if required even if there is no friendly gesture from that country.

[@yomamasohot6411]

If you only knew Indian history you would come to know why it thinks this way. If you want to live in your bubble and think Indians are a bunch of idiots who are incapable of critical thinking then so be it.

[@nobody4u77]

​@@jogindersharma9566that is such a stupid strategy .

[@shubhamrudola3860]

The map of India shown at 20:44 is false(specifically the J&K region).... POK is missing.

[@therash09]

O yaar ye sab ch*****pa har jagah mat kiya karo. Log hanste hain bhaai. Ya to ham is ilaaqe ko fauj ke zariye vaapas le len, ya phir is tarah ki rondoo baaten karni chhod den ki naksha galat dikhaya hai, sahi karom vagerah. Ye sab haar ki nishaani hoti hai yaar. Ye sab baaten koi naheen sunega.

[@suppiahmurugesan8343]

China is presently going through economic crisis. Bharat has to be vigilant now. In fact Bharat has to be proactive in protecting her borders and take tactical steps in relation to all strategic positions.

[@shreeraaman1667]

Yep, you can’t trust those snakes 🐍

[@EdmundLam-ku8ro]

Endia is call Bar-rat😂😂😂

[@alexjensen990]

This was highly informative! I particularly enjoyed the discussion of the disconnect between Western and Eastern thinking. As a multicultural American with partial Asian heritage its really frustrating to discuss the China situation with other Americans who don’t have any Asian ancestry. The motives, incentives, flaws, etc are very different. Most Americans refuse to believe that China has been at war with the West and primarily the US for decades because Americans think only of open physical combat as war. Meanwhile, the Chinese are currently at war economically, socially, politically, and in many other ways. Why are they collecting genetic information and material from ancestry websites, clinics, etc? Because they are attempting to build a genetic weapon that will destroy specific ethnic cultures without kill the Han Chinese. Its that simple. The information is otherwise useless to anyone. Why are they unleashing applications into the world that they don’t allow within their own country? As a prong of their war plan they want to destabilize other countries in whatever way they can. That includes making as much of the population incapable of the ability to learn due to short attention spans, obsession with apps that are a true waste of time, etc. Why are they partnering with Mexican and South American drug cartels to smuggle drugs into the US? They can kill 10s of thousands of Americans without getting their hands dirty. If you look at the strategy objectively you realize that this is not only wise, from a total annihilation perspective, but very obviously what the CCP is doing. Does that mean that everything that the CCP does is to this end? Yes. Everything that they do it to accomplish a couple of aims. First, stay in power within whatever border they control. Second, destroy everyone and everything other than the rightful rulers of the world, namely the Han Chinese under CCP control. They will never stop.

[@Spashth]

Completely agree. I hope more westerner people can understand this. I visited U.S. and I noted that an average American do not even see China a threat however in India it is just opposite because of our past with Chinese. Nehru was stupid he called China a brother. He was like most Americans today.

[@viktorcalais3722]

​@@Spashth Nehru called China "Brother" and he called Edwina "Mother". 😅😅😅😅

[@syeansim1693]

U R living in a "warped" universe...

[@viktorcalais3722]

@@syeansim1693 and you and your family?

[@syeansim1693]

@@viktorcalais3722 IN THE JUNGLE OF AMAZON...HaHaHaHaHa

[@wumaofiftycent-eq3bf]

To sum up: US cannot be trusted. Taiwan cannot bank on US to protect them.

[@wumaofiftycent-eq3bf]

@Varaha Shakthi when US left veitnam, NVs and Veitcongs enjoyed wrecking vengeance upon defeated South Veitnam army. It went on for years. Family by family they tortured, raped, played like cat and mouse. It was compared to sadistic atrocities commited by PLA on Tibettans during invasion of 1950s

[@poppinc8145]

China's expansionism should have been apparent from their 1969 war with the USSR where they tried and failed to take territory in the Russian Far East, and their 1979 invasion of Vietnam which they also lost. Throughout the 70s they backed the Khmer Rouge who genocided their own people and routinely fought border clashes with Vietnam. Then throughout the 80s until the early 90s, China routinely fought border clashes with Vietnam. After the fall of the USSR, China bullied countries in Central Asia and forced them to give up land which China annexed, from Kazakhstan in 1998, Kyrgyzstan in 2002 and Tajikistan in 2011.

[@Junokaii]

China wants their Qing Dynasty borders back.

[@alexanderchenf1]

I wouldn’t say China lost its Vietnam War. Capturing territories was not the aim of Deng Xiaoping. His strategic goal for China as a whole was economic prosperity. So the explanation that attacking Vietnam was to support Pol Pot contradictory to that goal. Deng also wanted to improve relationship with America, so teaching Soviet’s pawn a lesson would do the job. But most importantly, the goal of attacking Vietnam was to mobilizing military support for Deng - to consolidate power.

[@poppinc8145]

@@alexanderchenf1 China ideally wanted to regime-change Vietnam, since Vietnam itself had toppled the Khmer Rouge earlier in 1979. Regime-changing Vietnam would have essentially made it a close vassal to China, functionally the same as expansionism. It's not farfetched to assume China might take territory as well.

[@ajay262134]

China has border with 14 nations and it has border disputes with 23 nations 🤦🏼🤦🏼

[@alexanderchenf1]

@@poppinc8145 you make no sense. You have fundamentally misunderstood Deng Xiaoping’s strategic focus after the Cultural Revolution. Study Deng’s priority.

[@whosagreekgod4135]

Wow, that was of if not the most interesting interviews I've ever seen. It also paints a very concerning picture about stability in the economic world and why the West needs to decuple from China and have better relationships with other countries and develop more robust and self sufficient industries at home. If only we didn't have a bunch of filthy communist in every branch of Western politics... I was one of those people who used to joke about India becoming a world superpower by 2020 guy but after hearing this I have a lot more respect for India and their independence from outside influences. Very good interview.

[@anomaly2990]

Aside from East Turkestan/Xinjiang and Tibet, the Chinese also seized Inner Mongolia in 1947.

[@dumdum8880]

This guy is great. May I humbly suggest Jeff Nyquist as a guest. He's also a strategic analysis who is at least equal to this guy. Worth hearing

[@SokhomPrins]

The untold story about the world tragic has never been told or heard of. The reason is no one know accept I am alone. For example there is no such thing as communist. And that mafia Xi stole the world and My book Love of Life - A Miraculous Story! is on the way.

[@theaborigine1119]

It's not like Indians aren't aware of China's threat, Since India became the Republic of India these great Indian intellectuals kept warning India Bhim Ramji Ambedkar...Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel...George Fernandes...And today S.Jai.Shankar I mean there is a reason why Prime Minister Modi made a technocrat bureaucrat foreign minister of India, S.Jai.Shankar was India's longest-serving ambassador to China...From top bureaucrats to businessmen to military planners who are China experts are working under Modi this can't be a coincidence and recently one of his top men was attacked by an American institution which was backed by China's lobby that's why Indians don't trust America...

[@giannivendone2807]

India should be invited to be part of the G7 to become the G8.

[@johndoe-vc1we]

White boysclub

[@carloschu7127]

Most of G7 already is inviting India, but India did not reach half of China industrial power, yet.

[@johndoe-vc1we]

@@carloschu7127 nobody calling China to G7

[@carloschu7127]

@@johndoe-vc1we and ? You dont understand english ?

[@johndoe-vc1we]

@@carloschu7127 so you're jealous then. Got it.

[@rickbarrington]

Wow. That was intense. Dr Chaya is one impressive guy. Everything he said makes total sense. Decision makers in India and the west need to spend more time talking to him to checkmate China

[@yoghajanakiraman9986]

U guys should interview Security & Defense Analyst Abhijit iyer mitra.I'll be thunderous riot to see ur collaboration.

[@saurabhade1079]

He is pretentious ch*tiya. Don't embarrass us, having to watch his foolishness on this KZbin channel.

[@dhruvseoni8418]

Definitely

[@neelj5155]

Lol, f no.... I'd rather be gaurav arya or vaibhav

[@ahamasmiarinm]

Nope, not AIM. Too prejudiced, pessimistic, too much inferiority complex, too much naval-gazing. Totally unsuitable for a global audience.

[@user-ez3il1yy6i]

Good Job You Guys ... China Has A Massive Inferiority Complex . 💯

[@nunyabiznes4471]

Actually, I think the CCP has a god complex. Ironic since the CCP is evil.

[@rokuhelper]

I think another 1/2 hour or so with Dr. Dheeraj would be appreciated

[@utshooo]

Please call him again. Not many clips of this extra ordinary man.

[@Boombox69in]

americans love indians! together, we're unstoppable

[@wonderworld7721]

plz stop it, it is boring !!.. he already told that "we do not have like minded friends in this world" !!... so the comment is totally irrelevant, unworthy waste of time..

[@divyanshuchadha8210]

Thank You for introducing me to Dr. Neeraj

[@adityajoies]

You should invite Abhijit Ayer Mitra, Matt and him will get along fine because they have the same sense of humor.

[@ahamasmiarinm]

Nope, AIM is very very pessimistic and too much of naval-gazing. Not an ideal candidate for international audience.

[@adityajoies]

@@ahamasmiarinm You talk as if international audience are kind of aliens to Indians Or we are like aliens to them!

[@ahamasmiarinm]

@@adityajoies I only said that you don't go out in your night pajamas, do you? You dress up decently. I thought it won't be so difficult to understand.

[@shamikghosh1131]

The only person on Indian yt who should be invited is Mr. Abhijit Chavda

[@adisura9904]

I like this dude. And Major Gaurav Arya. No offence to Prof Nala pad, but I find it hard to focus on the conversation with his kind of delivery. Cheers from India China Unscripted.

[@thesuperflexibleflyingtaoi8866]

Your work is so important and also I find it very good, that you include the indian perspective since its such rich in experience in many aspects. Its a rising star and in my central european perspective I think India should get much more attention for their improvements as a much MUCH better example of a free and peaceful world. Thanks for this great talk!

[@hiihello7625]

Thanks and love from India

[@thesuperflexibleflyingtaoi8866]

@@hiihello7625 we must stand together brother, nobody should be left behind

[@hiihello7625]

@@thesuperflexibleflyingtaoi8866 Yes brother Btw you are from which country?

[@thesuperflexibleflyingtaoi8866]

@@hiihello7625 germany and I have worked with some indians at work. generally I can say you guys are pretty smart and nice, so I hope everything will work out fine for you guys over there

[@hiihello7625]

@@thesuperflexibleflyingtaoi8866 Oh Yeah, Germans. We have pretty good relations currently ( and historically as well) especially among students. Germany is definitely one of the most sought after countries to pursue higher education Though sadly, you guys are suffering from recession. Hopefully, things turn out pretty well for you guys

[@abhipatil1]

Dr. Dheeraj has great knowledge about Geopolitics.

[@VeteranExpat]

India demands respect and also gives respect. China claims superiority and respects none. Respect for none will never gain respect.

[@cewldood1]

This video deserves more views. The host did a better info vlog than many Indian news shows.

[@livingpurgatory3]

Fascinating. Thank your guest please. What a charming man.

[@gowthamval]

Dheeraj words here is absolute. It convey exactly what india and indians think and our way of thinking.

[@David_Lo_Pan]

The best defense against communist authoritarian dictatorship is to strengthen democracies from corrupting influences and nepotism. It takes an active and concerted effort of the people, to ensure that our democratically elected politicians are truly representing our interests. We must also address what hostile communist countries are doing, both domestically and abroad. Democratic Nations must stand together against their lawlessness in defense of global security, human rights, and enforce International Law.

[@emperormuzziesxijinping4822]

That is issue CHINA HATED INDIA CUZ OF DEMOCRACY.

[@ranfak]

Lol nice joke. Now go and drink some tea

[@wwctw]

And not bribable and vulnerable to external influences.

[@kumarvivek1866]

Well, you can also say that it's easier for usa to control other democratic nations.

[@jamesmichaeljean7840]

Usa is a republic, not a democracy. How can your freedom be real when the Muslims living in India can't vote. Not a democracy. 😂 What country are you referring to then?

[@themtoniraniremaxbroker2447]

Brilliant Analyses By Both these Gentlemen, Dr Chaya is Awesome and he nails it in great Detail. Best Wishes.

[@krishnaaithal6730]

Mac, whose sense of humour we Indians seemingly don't get, was very, very quiet in this entire episode. Mac, are you springing some new humour on us unsuspecting Indians?? On a serious note, I find Mac just as engaging and insightful as Chris, not to speak of his wonderful sense of humour. Your channel is doing a wonderful job and I follow you closely. 🙏

[@bdeshpan]

It’s Matt, not Mac 😊

[@krishnaaithal6730]

@@bdeshpan Oops.. Apologies to Matt. It was an error on my part and not any misplaced sense of humour.

[@srinivasanranganathan7159]

Excellent analysis by Mr. Dheeraj Paramesha Chaya who has so eloquently broken the events on the basis of the miscalculations and misinterpretations of the thinking of both India and China that has led up to the present day status quo. Likewise both India and the US deviating from their core democratic value systems had drifted apart driven by narrow objectives, national ego and a lack of foresight. The mist and haze over each others misunderstanding has melted away in the face of shifting political rearrangements and growing stature of India in the comity of nations. The video is so enjoyable, factual and eye opening. Thanks.

[@subodhsarin4247]

This Dheeraj is typical academia, very intelligent and analytic. One should appreciate he has got this down absolutely correct - China is a bully, and only understands strength and aggression. India is playing defence against China. The defence is spread over many hundred miles of the border. To deter China, India should initiate aggression in an area of their own choosing, at a time of their choosing. China shouldn't ever have the assurance that we'll be playing defence all the time.

[@Morningrilled]

As a pilipino i stand for India love friends from Philippines 🇮🇳❤️🇵🇭

[@medialcanthus9681]

Sure, you will be the next Ukraine 😂😂😂.

[@gautamdey4167]

Years later, in 1962, the Chinese aggression against India created international concern. In March 1963, Sudhir Ghosh, an Indian emissary of Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru, had a meeting with the 35th US President John F Kennedy in Washington DC, USA and shared with him a letter from Nehru dated January 5, 1963, "on the problem posed by the military power of Communist China". He also showed the president the following excerpt from that Mother India editorial dated November 11, 1950, referring to it as "the last testament of Sri Aurobindo". Though this was not written by Sri Aurobindo himself, it is clear from the full content of his letter to KD Sethna on the Korean War that the editorial represented his general views on the subject. "The basic significance of Mao's Tibetan adventure is to advance China's frontiers right down to India and stand poised there to strike at the right moment and with the right strategy - unless India precipitately declares herself on the side of the Russian bloc. But to go over to Mao and Stalin in order to avert their wrath is not in any sense a saving gesture. It is a gesture spelling the utmost ruin to all our ideals and aspirations. Really the gesture that can save is to take a firm line with China, denounce openly her nefarious intentions, stand without reservation by the USA and make every possible arrangement consonant with our own self-respect to facilitate an American intervention in our favour and, what is of still greater moment, an American prevention of Mao's evil designs on India. Militarily, China is almost ten times as strong as we are, but India as the spearhead of an American defence of democracy can easily halt Mao's mechanised millions. And the hour is upon us of constituting ourselves such a spearhead and saving not only our own dear country but also all South East Asia whose bulwark we are. We must burn it into our minds that the primary motive of Mao's attack on Tibet is to threaten India as soon as possible." Sri Aurobindo Signature November 11, 1950 To quote from Sudhir Ghosh's own account: The President read the words of Sri Aurobindo's last testament several times over and said: "Surely there is a typing mistake here. The date must have been 1960, not 1950. You mean to say that a man devoted to meditation and contemplation, sitting in one corner of India, said this about the intentions of Communist China as early as 1950?" ◼

[@UMS9695]

Dr. Paramesha has done a superlative job! 👏👏👏

[@patriot0971]

Indians have been their own worst enemies when dealing with China and Pakistan. Recognizing Chinese occupation of Tibet, not recognizing Taiwan as an independent state, refusing a permanent seat in UN and nominating China to take it. What did that buy India ? grinding poverty, sanctions and animosity from the West, exclusion from world capital markets and investments. Modi Ji should connect the Indian economy permanently to the West and use our markets to get concessions and support to disconnect China and Pakistan, and take over PoK.

[@poppinc8145]

Dheeraj Chaya seems intelligent and more importantly coherent, unlike Madhav Nalapat who spouts a whole lot of incoherent extrapolations and half-baked conspiracy-theories that aren't even true.

[@sp7186]

Yup as an Indian he just seems like a relative going off the boil and ranting randomly during a gathering lol

[@emperormuzziesxijinping4822]

Every people has different way of explaining.

[@poppinc8145]

@@emperormuzziesxijinping4822 It's not just a difference of explaining. Half of what Nalapat says is completely bullshit.

[@rakeshmohan6278]

Thank you! I've had that same impression of him and was shocked that Nalapat is even invited to these types of interviews.

[@vickboss6751]

True

[@jacobsamuel9963]

Who made china big??? Americans and multinational corporates????

[@snathan3198]

One of the most realistic and detailed discussion on the China Han Communist Maoist government and the challenges it poses to the free world.

[@inotaishu1]

I still don't understand why China is considered post-colonialist. Even the vast majority of the Qing empire was never colonized by anyone. In fact, China today is colonist.

[@chilarai1]

Nehru was advised by the Brits not to use the Indian Air Force which was far more powerful than the the Chinese air force in 1962. The reason given to my understanding was that the Chinese would attack major Indian cities. India could have smashed the chinese in Arunachal Pradesh if the IAF was used because in the high altitude Tibet would not have allowed any meaningful Chinese response. The Indian pilots were highly trained and fresh out of WW2.

[@satishmaurya3404]

Gandhian ideologies are bogus and were reasons for India's many losses. Nehru and Gandhi both wanted to disband army post independence. This attitude weakened the defences

[@nobody4u77]

Left wing ideologies always have deep mistrust of armed forces and world around they first weaken them and then they get defeated by an external enemy they never learn or get captured by enemy or get replaced by a right wing regime which is more competent.

[@shantanushekharsjunerft9783]

An individual from the most powerful think tank in India said recently in Europe that we should never underestimate CCP’s ability to piss people off so much that they all become open to alliances.

[@captainnemo8072]

Where did you find him? I've never seen Dheeraj on the usual strategic Indian shows.

[@ajay262134]

The real strategic thinkers do not even talk much and thereby never seen and heard by common public.

[@vips078]

​@@ranfakStopping support to Pakistan and solve the border issue then India and China can be friends

[@anonymouslyopinionated656]

because he's a serious think-tanker.

[@exurgemars]

@@vips078 they're killing our troops and grabbing our lands, having been laying out and enacting plans to encircle India for decades and you want them to be your friend? Some folks live in their own la-la-land.

[@deeptobhattacharyya3249]

Stop watching 9pm drama lol, I support BJP and still don't watch that crap, all the specialists they bring are just clowns

[@sureshmachmanda8296]

Mr.Chaya is thorough with his topics.excellent.

[@lindaalbright255]

Apparently India's "ultimate plan" was to break dependence on ties with China (self-reliance). Is China's plan the mirror image -- that is to unilaterally and preemptively cut the ties before independence from those ties can be achieved? For example China could refuse to manufacture such things as prescription drugs, rare earth minerals, consumer electronics etc. Perhaps the two strategies will proceed at approximately the same rate so that when China is strong enough to refuse manufacture, the rest of the world will be able to say "we didn't need you anyway".

[@saurabhade1079]

Basically yes. And its next 2 - 3 years for India, if current Government returns

[@yami7509]

if they could that is, they would but since they didn't do that.. means they need that capital

[@sundramkumar5613]

​@@yami7509 true that in my opinion china is a manufacturing based economy and if they'll stop manufacturing then how they'll earn. Any country bans imports and not exports. If china will do that then it will make other countries scared of China(that same thing can happen with them too). It will increase the pace of decoupling from China. Just my povs..

[@lindaalbright255]

@@yami7509 Since China would if it could it is imperative to make sure that it can't "by all means".

[@jamesmichaeljean7840]

​@@lindaalbright255 when China began to show their military might to the USA and stop answering their requests for a meeting, they are already telling usa to fk off. 😂

[@PC-tz6rw]

Brilliant, brilliant, brilliant!!!

[@lifeinaspiral]

Dheeraj is Amazing. Love his deep insight. how come I never saw this guy yet.

[@alexanderchenf1]

I need to correct Chaya on one point: 1962 was not a year within the Cultural Revolution (1966-76). But it was a year not long after the Great Famine. A starving bear is infinitely more dangerous than a well fed bear.

[@Dangermonkey1000]

elephant never forgets.....revenge will be taken when china fall in taiwan trap

[@sreyanshuchaterjee3962]

Starving bear fed with rice from India, courtesy nehru

[@shermanpeabody6102]

Now China is the world's largest producer of agricultural commodities. And 190 Million Indians sleep hungry every night.

[@alexanderchenf1]

@@shermanpeabody6102 Complete crap. China is dependent on food import particularly from the US and increasingly from Russia. China is entering into a famine.

[@trusfratedbunny2215]

@@shermanpeabody6102 Lmao, such crap..India is infact one of world's largest producer & supplier of agricultural goods overall including Rice & Wheat whose stocks r pilled in our National food reserves way way more than required..It's so much that India can feed it's whole population without any further agri production if covid lockdown continued for straight 3-4yrs, We r literally building more food storage capacity so our extra production can be stocked without getting damaged for long. On one side where Indian Gov. providing tonnes amount of agri stuff like rice, wheat, pulses to it's more than 180 million ppl for free every month Along with supplying tonnes of amount of crops & agri food as free aid to afganistan, srilanka, lebanon, etc as well as Exporting to egypt, turkey, europe, china and other nations at the same time (coz we have just too much fertile land & Read abt our Green revolution that was brough by india in india after we suffered draught, thus food shortage back in mid-90s and When our request got denied upon asking food help from western leaders including leader of US that time, As solution We ain't asked our ppl to start eating just anything including exotic insects, animals to deal hunger like Mao's China did, Instead we bought green & white revolution for making india self-independent & self-sufficient both in agri and dairy food stuff) While on other hand today china's most fertile agri lands turned into urban real state or industrial areas, so they r producer still at same time importer of food products and encouraging it's ppl to eat less when dine-out like share food if in group instead of ordering for all,etc

[@sauravghosh7064]

my god Dheeraj is so blunt,so raw, no sugar coating

[@Scribemo]

Great talk. Thanks for having Dr. Chaya on your show. The disadvantaged trade we all hold with China will gradually change with the aging of their population, and collapse of their economy. More economic independence will also be necessary. As pointed out by the good doctor in the case of Nigerian students in India: the players and playing board will shift.

[@yomamasohot6411]

He meant the Nigerian students in his class in the Uk because currently he is teaching at the University of Hull, UK.

[@Scribemo]

@@yomamasohot6411 thank you! I made an improper assumption. International students are fueling the Western post-secondary school system. It's unfortunate for both the costs students have to incur as well as the brain-drain it often eventually leads to through emigration from a source nation in the global South to a host nation in the global North. While individuals from the South do benefit to some degree, we in the global North indebted to these students. I wish there was a way to help keep brains in the global South in a way that's beneficial for both global South and North. I have no clue what the solution could be. We have major demographic challenges in the global North, and our economies are boosted by this brain and money transfer to a degree.

[@AkWar9]

They way he avoided to speak about the corruption and deliberate negligence of Nehru doesn’t sit well. It’s not like Nehru did not understand what China was doing and what it wanted. It’s just that allowing China to take over in every aspect was a part of the deal. Him and his decedents are wealthy with Swiss accounts for a reason.

[@yomamasohot6411]

Bhakt spotted.

[@AkWar9]

@@yomamasohot6411 what’s bhakt.

[@yomamasohot6411]

@@AkWar9 You

[@PC-tz6rw]

​@@yomamasohot6411and how about the arsewipe that you have developed into for the Gandys?

[@chandrudsahijwanisahijwani9885]

Tibbat Inner Mongolia Cantonaise Shinjhiyang Taiwan Manchuria is not Part of China

[@RV-pr9oq]

US has to realize that instead of using India as a client state it should really partner with India like it does with Israel that will be good for the world. Russia will not come to India's side if there is a war with China. USA, Israel and EU should fully back India and support India. Deeds speak lot more that talk. India does not need satellite imaging like it needed during the Chinese war. I think both China and the west underestimates the capabilities of India which is actual good for India for an element of surprise.

[@sandeepkumarkhuntia8839]

Chinese policy well understood by Indians as their culture was derived from Indian influence 1- Identify your competitors/enemy, but behave friendly with them but action should be opposite. 2- Do not hurt your enemy emotionally to such extent, they would have retaliate you. Do your job to strengthen yourself and wait for the appropriate time without exposing yourself. 3. Hide your strength and make enemy always confused about your intention/policy. 4. Nations can be dealt with 4 ways. SAAM: Talk it through fabrication, use flattery to cajole, make your opponent believe that he is the master, lie to make him feel great. DAAM: Play on his greed, Pay him the price, offer him whatever he can’t refuse, reward him with women, pleasure, money, fertile land, DAND: Threaten him, strong arm your enemy. Either you do this or else? punish his kin, make him vulnerable through torture, use his weakness as the leverage, make horrible example out of someone to teach him a lesson. BHED: Use treachery or diplomacy to divide them into groups. By promising one thing one group, other thing to another group, let for the time being pledge anything knowing that you won’t be able to deliver later, promise of a better future either in this life or the next.

[@krishnabanerjee169]

excellent. after a long time heard such an excellent analysis. understood a lot of things i saw when as a foresters wife who worked on behalf of a german bank, toured interiors of China for quite a few years.

[@rodrickdavidson6815]

I worry about the safety of India. God bless India, and Russia. 💙🇮🇳🇷🇺💙🙏

[@vickboss6751]

Very apt analysis. As an Indian I would like to see US helping india in creating military industrial complex and win trust. By doing so US companies would also benefit in defense purchases. And the old mistrust would be scrapped and both nation would be best friends. US need to know that only india can be powerful partner in 2050. Uk Or Japan won't have that much to offer in comparison to india. Most people in India want close partnership between india and America

[@bestof467]

People still call 1962 India-China 'war'. It was border security of 120 Indians vs 5,000 Chinese troops. It did not involve the real bulk of Indian army or airforce because Indian PM (British favorite MI agent) already made baksheesh (bribe) deal with Mao. So while India got poorer, Nehru family got complimentary Switz passports due their huge multifigure Switz 💷💰💰accounts.

[@ishowsports008]

That was in the Ladakh sector. Chinese walked into Arunachal in 1962. We had the worst of people in government who didn't care what happened that far from Delhi.

[@aussiemenace1924]

@himanshusingh6281 "First of all, we have to understand what communism is. I mean, to me, real communism, the Soviet communism, is basically a mask for Bolshevism, which is a mask for Judaism." - Bobby Fischer

[@aussiemenace1924]

@himanshusingh6821 "Why are gentiles needed? They will work, they will plow, they will reap. We will sit like an effendi and eat. That is why gentiles were created" rabbi ovadia yosef, MASSIVE funeral in israel

[@ajay262134]

Also let me add, these 120 Indian soldiers were not even geared for high altitude warfare.

[@pushpenderrana6190]

Nehru strategy gift Anand bhavan to the country and then claim to be a desh bhakt and then rule india in perpetuity

[@VYDEO]

China was never formally colonized, but the Opium Wars of 1839-1842 and 1856-1860 were fought to ensure that British opium merchants had access to Chinese markets. Hence china seems to be against India since then and it doesn't forget the past.

[@Eric-ue5ed]

It’s also true that Chinese thought is routed in the idea of constant warfare in which violence is the instrument of last resort, and that gray zone tactics or cultural influence and hegemony is a preferred form of warfare. Violence can be used as an advantageous tactic in certain circumstances however, especially against weaker or vulnerable positions on their foes.

[@mohananawli2101]

Brilliant discussion. Dheeraj is such an authority on the subject and Chris Fores doesn’t interrupt the flow and also asked the most pertinent questions to egg on the conversation

[@mariavaleriagiacaglia8974]

Thank you for this enlightening podcast!

[@Bobsaccount123]

Since the Invision of Tibet China became ambitious and working to control south and southeast Asia by controlling the water of Tibet and trade of Indian and pacific ocean. India and Taiwan both are main obstacles. Tibet is landlocked and used to use Kolkata India port so CCP hatched BRI plan. Laos Nepal Cambodia Myanmar etc all are already controlled by CCP.

[@astraydhurion7697]

It's important to stop focusing only on communism and marxism when it comes to analysing China's behaviour in international relations. Cause there are not the main components of Chinese mindset and way of thinking. The West is definitely overprojecting their own political standards and historical reading grids, completely neglecting China's cultural millennial specificities.

[@Vaeldarg]

Yeah, it isn't about communism, marxism, socialism, etc. Those are all just false ideologies that authoritarians use to gain popular support to be given enough power until they no longer need to care anymore about what the population thinks of them. The actual term that describes the true ideology is Fascism.

[@dhruvseoni8418]

Exactly. I’ve always viewed the CCP’s meta as just a continuation of the millennia of Empires before it. Middle Kingdom, unchallenged hegemons with suzerainty over the region, always wanting respect and obsequiousness in exchange for “freedom”.

[@astraydhurion7697]

@Dhruv Seoni You've just put the idea in good words. During the interview, Dr. Dheeraj Paramesha Chaya described China with two words: revenge and vengeance. To complete the picture, I would add (geographical) domination and (ethnical) uniformisation. To top it off, I want to point at China's yellow fever or its obsession for gold, forged by five centuries of an economy mostly based on silver standard money and a distrust in paper money.

[@kukulkhaan]

@@dhruvseoni8418 CCP = Heavenly golden court, chairman = heavenly emperor, what CCP says = will of heavens.

[@Bobsaccount123]

Mao built 3 highways from Beijing to Tibet with the permission from Dallai lama for better connectivity. That was the fatal mistake and lesson for all nations joining belt and road. Mao used same highways to invade Tibet in 1959. Dallai lama fled to India. Mao attacked India in 1962. This is the beginning of BRI plan and Chinese ambition.

[@pushpenderrana6190]

Chinese are businessmen wanting to rule the world and nothing comes free from them , countries well advised to deal warily with them, not be fooled by their offers of friendship and aid as its the entry point of their meddling in your affais, and eventual subjugation.Even superpowers like the USA have been subverted and loaned so much money deliberately by chinese to trap them.Now only the bill needs to be paid by the USA and finally subjugation and humiliatio is left for ordinary USA citizens which will be sooner rather than later

[@wumaofiftycent-eq3bf]

Best move for the India is to stop acting like a gentleman, adopt ccp way of thinking, and start supplying arms and ammunition to Tibet Liberation Crops (TLC)

[@Unitedworld4364]

Waiting for being 3 rd largest economy....

[@karangputih]

dream... . wake up and face the reality. India just too far behind China but talk too much

[@edpiv2233]

I have know this about China for decades and it is amazing to me that the American military strategists still do not know this, at least as shown by our policy. This is why I still think the west will lose the conflict w China.

[@pushpenderrana6190]

Already lost,my friend,youre hopelessly in financial debt with them,they call all the shots with you,only default and then subjugation and humiliation is left

[@bharadwajakambhammettu2836]

America wants India to be neither too strong nor too weak! Just the right size that is acceptable to America. The same principle applies to all of its “allies” aka “slaves”. The way it blew up Nordstream oil pipeline to cut to size the European economic powerhouse, Germany is a point in case. Not a murmur from Germany! That’s the right way to treat allies aka “slaves”. India hence doesn’t have any allies. It only has foes and opportunities for convergence of interests that is acceptable for sometime

[@chilarai1]

Lots of clarity from Dr. Chaya which filled in a few gaps for me. He is an excellent asset. And thank you to CU for bringing this to youtube.

[@Simon-ml4lu]

He is so right.

[@chandrudsahijwanisahijwani9885]

Tibbat is Integral Part of India

[@Hermit365]

Let’s not go overboard with wishful thinking. Tibet is a nation its own right. Unfortunately, it is under occupation and the world has decided to look away

[@maycodes]

Nehru stupidness costed us a war. Soft men create hard times.

[@nalindodello67]

Great Diskussion. Thanks to all participants . 👍🏾👍🏾👍🏾

[@bakairosan4126]

A very good discussion, Chris and Mat. I was Lil disappointed to see Mat so quite in this one. Mat , India is a country of 1.4 billion people, if there are people who don't get your humour, there are equal if not more , people who do get your humour. I have been following the channel for a while now.( I don't comment frequently on any channel i follow to be clear) But i had to come out and say something after i saw what happened last time.

[@sailendrapamidi]

His line was broken and so he could not participate. Its mentioned by Chris in one of the previous comments above.

[@shailendrapls7809]

If Tibet is another country than how come China is claiming territories that share borders with Tibet.

[@Red.bulldozer3]

😂

[@bapparawal2457]

And the territories don't even belong to Tibet that China is claiming on Tibets behalf.

[@Red.bulldozer3]

@@bapparawal2457 😂

[@pushpenderrana6190]

Burglar has invaded your house and forcibly become your neighbor, now hes eyeing your property and has also claimed previous owners territorial disputes with you as his own.China respects a kick in the arse ,agreements meetings etc are just a sideshow meant to distract and confuse you