230218 써클 차트 뮤직 어워드 Aespa 에스파 Full ver "도깨비불 Illusion + 걸스 Girls" 4K 60p 2023 Circle Music 직캠 Fancam

[@winterescapeeeee]

2:15 "KIM MINJEONG!!!" THAT FANBOY IS SO RELATABLE

[@young3558]

윈터 라이브 진짜 기깔나다

[@nyz6]

long haired winter just hits different 🥲❤

[@anonymoushuman1781]

Winter is sooo 🔥🔥🔥

[@namelessfan8795]

WINTER, MY LOVE, YOU ARE ON FIRE

[@aprilianti_resti0266]

DAMN WINTER VOCAL🔥🔥🔥🤯

[@mybmyacc]

EVERYONE SLAYED THEY SHOULD SING LIVE MORE 😭😭 AND MY GIRL WINTER !!!!! YES! SLAY !

[@boyyyo]

YES WINTER. YOU ARE THE QUEEN.

[@y.748]

winter killing this stage

[@soyiesows8834]

HELLO WINTER! YOU ARE THE BEST ⭐️🤩

[@sonetaeyeon1100]

Winter always stood the most when it comes to performing live

[@doangiang9611]

Winter's live vocal and dance is insane. Her stage presence was improved alot. I'm proud of her 😭

[@Official_NashwynArt]

its live?

[@daniel0037]

​@@Official_NashwynArt yes it is

[@doangiang9611]

@@Official_NashwynArt yes, you watch carefully at 2:30, the backtrack was super small and hard to hear

[@notyourproblem3745]

@@Official_NashwynArt ofc see the actual live performance not fancam and you hear the winter's high note flat at 8:20 but she slayed tho.

[@doangiang9611]

@charsi anjum bro, ur ears is okay ?

[@alexcxa_013]

Minjeong u're makin my heart flutter

[@arinn42]

우리 윈터언니 라이브 대박이다잉💙💙💙😍 너무 예뽀💞💞💞

[@klorydeman54]

Best vocal, Best visual, Best perform, Best dance, Queen🔥

[@vegantirex]

애들이 이렇게 생 라이브 항상 부르면 좋겠다, ㅈㄴ 잘해

[@winterescapeeeee]

WINTER'S VOCALS IS WAY WAY MORE STABLE THAN MY LIFE

[@iengsophaphuongkeo342]

@@puriwuri1752 still hater can’t accept lol🥱

[@lolag367]

@@puriwuri1752 or maybe because she is good at singing live

[@mybmyacc]

@@puriwuri1752 LOOOOOOLLLLL that's a compliment actually, when a singer singing live but others think it's prerecorded u know she's good

[@doangiang9611]

@@puriwuri1752 thank you ur compliment because you think Winter's live vocal is pre-recored. I know she is good at singing live 💅

[@ae-karinasunbaenim2819]

@@puriwuri1752 keep crying

[@deonuuuu]

I am still amazed how Winter can hit high note with straight face

[@블랙맘마-y6j]

윈터 고음 성량 존나 흔들림 없는 시몬스급임 춤 빡세게 추면서 라이브 존잘임 믿듣 윈터라이브

[@hoshiyouarenotatiger]

시몬스 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 윈터님 음색 너무이뻐요

[@user-uc6df7jd2]

진짜 라이브라고 생각하는건가 ㅋㅋ

[@이름-v5l8w]

@@user-uc6df7jd2 혹시 귀에 문제 있으세요?ㅠㅠ

[@먄먄-w4t]

@@user-uc6df7jd2 이정도면 진짜 신천지급 아닌가? 누가봐도 라이븐데 잘하면 라이브 아니래ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 에스파를 까기위해 귀머거리 자청하네 ㅋㅎ

[@이름-v5l8w]

@@user-uc6df7jd2 얘, 고음에서부터 음 갈라져서 라이브 티나는건 들리지도 않니?💢💢 최소한 영상을 끝까진 보고 판단을 하던가✋ 그리고 mr없이 쌩라이브 하는 아이돌이 4세대에 존재나 하겠니ㅉ.👀👀 나ㄹ 에셈 빠순이로서 억까 봊.나. 못참아🥵🔪🔪🔪💢

[@hfpurva]

winter sp is amazing 👏

[@lilac101]

비주얼 춤 노래 😍 역시 에스파구나 😍 특히 윈터 라이브 최고야 👍

[@imyourhtm]

Impressed Wow winter vocal are amazing

[@Julia-im6op]

Aespa’s vocals is so good 😵‍💫😵‍💫

[@jungminjeong2281]

winter is the real ace 😭😍not only her visual she is also good at dancing and singing😍❤even she can rap too ❤

[@doomsverse]

winter did so well in supporting the vocals for this stage her voice was full and she was doing the adlibs she was the one doing the "ha!" adlib in illusion chorus at 1:30! overall all of them did so good but winter and her live vocals is amazing

[@바보Queen]

Winter and Karina were amazing, Illusion has so much swag, winter added a little more stank on that hip wiggle

[@ricco_g750]

na im in love with winter

[@aeriyu7094]

Damn winter's vocals is next level 😲

[@WindyDay_]

이 착장으로 무대를 다시 볼 줄이야.. 에스파 라이브 실화냐 가슴이 웅장해진다..🥹

[@jadeshin4320]

I'M SO PROUD OF THEMMMM 🥺😭 They must be so tired already with preparing for their 1st concert and stressed with all the drama that's going on in SM right now AND YET THEY KILLED THIS PERFORMANCE. 💯You guys did so well!! I'm even proudER now to be a MY🤍

[@noneazzo]

winter's vocal another level

[@user-pb3ke3ds8y]

윈터 진짜 미쳤다.....

[@calvyn9701]

Winter has taken her singing to the next level.

[@bruno_malta13]

Why winter’s voice sounds more powerful than before? Oh my goodness

[@charlottekatakuri6529]

i think shes work really hard at her voice the other members to they are just getting better and better

[@Lyf4rMusic]

I believe it may be due to their concert practice they've been lately :)

[@Kimnojam]

She's pretty confident too...

[@hyunlixxie2662]

winter was so energetic here esp during the girls dance break, and her vocals are the most stable

[@firstlc3484]

Winter is an ACE!!

[@sunflowersyeppi]

Winning high note 🔥

[@lilac7910]

Frr🔥🔥🔥🔥

[@JI-zc6ot]

winter's live vocals!!! WOW

[@jungminjeong2281]

2.15 seconds I heard fanboy winter screaming "KIM MINJEONG" 😭😍

[@wtr5805]

winter👍👍👍

[@so-youngbae5991]

믿듣윈터❤❤

[@markleeismylee1511]

WINTER, THE QUEEN OF TALENT, VISUAL, AND PERFORMANCE🤌😭 ALL THE GIRLS DID SO WELL❤️❤️❤️❤️

[@은솔-d1d]

콘서트 준비 때문에 바쁠텐데 준비하느라 얼마나 힘들었을까,,엣깅이들 항상 화이팅 사랑해❤️‍🔥

[@flukeoctora4682]

their live vocals literally insane

[@mahalicious27]

Live vocals are insane. I'm so proud of you gurls. 😘😘😘

[@leen5949]

winter is truly killing it these days

[@peaceminus1]

how is it that winter has such perfect vocals, pretty face and body, amazing personality and is a very good dancer... IT girl??? definitely(karina also ngl, that woman so fine it hurts to see her)

[@세섬-s2i]

라이브 미쳤어..

[@jemelee991]

I'm so speechless with aespa performance. Damn that Winter's vocal, everything is on🔥🔥🔥

[@Nene66699]

Winter winter 🥹❤️❤️❤️

[@byeom]

aespa’s live vocals slayage!!! they did amazing wow i love them sfm

[@rara1138]

In Winter we trust, her live vocal, her dance, her aura, her stage presence, her visual , she is an ACE indeed.

[@sabinahasanah3671]

Wintoo main vocal and main dance material 💖💖💖💖

[@prisrique]

aespa ot4 will never fail to give us the best performances! they're THE MOMENT. love you girls 🤍

[@crms6416]

The stable vocals of winter tho

[@Sibagyeon]

에스파짱스파갓스파사랑해

[@Yeeun2103]

오늘 가서 봤는데 와 잊지못한다 나의 첫 콘서트 너무 이쁘잖아ㅠ

[@nestheamarinava4654]

Aespa live vocals never disappoints 🔥

[@nomi9000]

minjeong’s vocals are out of this world, proving why she gets always the high notes

[@yaryawoleng4154]

3:09 winterrrrr slayed. the way she hit the high note and continued dancing just-

[@little.star423]

Kim Minjeong stable as always 🔥

[@youtubeaddicted]

에스파 라이브 진짜 미쳤다 컴백 시급하다

[@tan007]

Winter's live vocals!! Like damn-- she's stable af

[@luvkki]

winter vocals are insane

[@byunbaekyoong]

I just love it when you can really hear their vocals especially during adlibs and high notes 😍

[@lady_yve]

Our GIRLS are getting better and stronger each day! Ignore the haters and keep up the hype, MYs! ♥️🌙⭐🦋

[@rara1138]

WINTER really proved that she is the hexagonal all rounder Ace of Aespa.

[@aespafanboi]

the best visuals, the best vocals😼

[@smithdot5062]

aespa didn't come to play with their live vocal plus Karina (main dancer) highnote at the end of Girls is so satisfies

[@rhafaaaa]

Winter's really an ace. My ultimate kpop idol bias

[@subilynnoweight2090]

Gigi you never fail to amaze me 💯🔥✨

[@이현주-s6j]

와 오늘 4명 다 너무 잘했다 ㅜㅜㅜ 지려

[@mauny12]

They're so goooooooooood. Even though this show is very easy to distinguish between the backing track and the vocal, it seems like some people still have problem with their hearing and need to check their auditory nerve.

[@helloworld-sl2lw]

Kim Minjeong serving vocals

[@katgreer6113]

Honestly.. they are still dancing hard while maintaining their notes. High AND low..and low notes are harder to sing than it looks. Good job girls! We love you! ❤️

[@eleenong4116]

Winter live vocal so incane

[@danissegomez7953]

I really love Ning on high ponytail❤️❤️😍😍😍

[@zunairajabeen2694]

Winter always takes my heart away She is too beautiful and gorgeous Her vocal is too perfect and attractive Her rap is too perfect and powerful Her dance is too perfect and satisfying Her visual is overflowing Her stage presence is insane

[@xxyeyexx8367]

When it comes to live performances, WINTER never disappoints, she always slay.

[@mackiesa3385]

Minjeong so stable

[@rikerachmawati35]

WINTER 🔥

[@HeY-0_0]

aespa looked so gorgeous and charming, and their vocals and choreo were undeniably amazing..

[@nrrrsyyy7750]

Haters will say pre record but my girls always slayy with live vocallz PROOF them!

[@rimanuraini1734]

winter vocals ❤️🔥

[@hangngo8089]

Best vocal performance ❤

[@clairesauvageharmonie]

aespa ot4 never disappoints

[@aespa_girls]

vocals,rap,dance,visuals,good discography,amazing concept, nice personalities..aespa has everything ❤ Today's live vocals are amazing 🔥

[@ChamNguyen257]

OMG I'M.SPEECHLESS. AESPA SLAYS

[@rara1138]

Winter dance perfectly while belting the high note. She’s so great

[@Elaine0625]

Karina's voice is very stable!! So inlove with her! 💕

[@yoonaddict2527]

Winter getting the recognition for her skills is what I need for the day

[@namelessfan8795]

it's what we all needed. waited for a day like this

[@sowhat1674]

It makes me wonder why sm even bother with lip syncing. Aespa can clearly sing live really while while dancing. I don't expect them to sing live all the time, really questioning sm's motive.

[@cha5156]

winter is the moment

[@jungkookarmpit5568]

This girls never stop amazed me, how can they hit high note effortlessly? even Karina did high note along with fixing her bangs 😭🤣

[@sabinahasanah3671]

Minjeong slaaayy💗💗💗!!! Rap, Sp, Dance, Live vocal, Visual

[@user-ty4fj7jg5f]

라이브 미쳤다 고음끝음처리 음원보다 더 좋음ㅠ!!!

[@ilxveliam]

김민정사랑해김민정사랑해김민정사랑해

[@joyce32110]

winter's vocal during girls is just so amazing....

[@kpopstertube3563]

Winteeeeer!!! 🔥🔥🔥

[@flowers_n_kisses]

Okay but Winter’s deep voice>>>>

[@aregeegee2723]

Winter long hair suit her so much why do she love the hair cut on her