240911 New Jeans Emergency Live full - backup [ENG SUB]

[@SamK1604]

these young girls standing up against a billion worth company oh lord i am so proud of them and scared of what can they do to them.

[@Dafty2k]

Yea but they can stand up against them without supporting a literal pedophile or some disgusting hype ceo🤮

[@imzaina]

Weren't u sacred when mhj openly harassed and balmed other groups??

[@wobbly4674]

​@@clarisse6607its not as easy as you say honey, debts contracts exist...they may even face lawsuits and stuff all they want was to be treated better but all they got is treated like thrash so if standing up for that is childish than idk what maturity means to you

[@poplikesodayeah3388]

@@clarisse6607you’re being childish here. Grow up! Dcking company stan

[@SamK1604]

@@clarisse6607they are not being childish, they are asking for justice and fair treatment. Their company is isolating & bullying them and you defending hybe is unreasonable.

[@LovefromPluto]

Correct translation for Hanni’s story: Hanni: Something happened to me recently. The 4th floor of the HYBE building is where we get our hair and makeup done, so a lot of other artists and staff come and go there. One day, I was waiting alone in the hallway, and another artist team with their manager passed by. The artists and I greeted each other, but when they came back out a bit later, I heard their manager say, “Ignore her,” right in front of me. He said it loud enough so I would hear. To this day, I still don’t understand why I had to be subject to that. Minji: When I heard about this from Hanni, I was shocked. How in the world could the manager of another team tell the members to just ignore her, and make his words loud enough so that she would hear it? He said such words that we wouldn’t even believe, and refused to acknowledge that this happened or even apologize for it. We have no idea how many more incidents like this will happen to us going forward and have anyone who will protect us from things like this. We’re worried about how we will continue to be ostracized here. Hanni: All I wish is for things like this to not happen to anyone. But because this has already happened once, now I fear that this will happen again. In fact, I told the new Ador CEO about this incident, but she told me that I have no evidence and that it was too late anyway. Experiencing that, I realized there is no one here to protect us. There is no one here who truly cares about us. Instead, I was treated like a liar. Prior to this, Min Hee Jin would always fight for us. The new leadership staff said they would be there for us, but for months all they have done is make excuses without solutions. And when I finally brought up an incident that directly happened to me, they instead put the blame on me. It makes me worried and scared about the future.

[@flyhigh798]

@@LovefromPluto well the manager did right. He knows these brats are mhj's minions and it is safer for them to ignore them. And every newjeans members except haerin deserves to get ignored because they can't just shut their mouth without praising someone whose under investigation for SA

[@idkwhatmynameis204]

​​@@flyhigh798 antis try to drag newjeans without mentioning mhj challenge go!

[@d-4azerty755]

But she is OK when her manager name drop any other groups ?

[@Yumeekanau]

I cant explain how disgusting u are for calling them brats and what did haerin do what did they do to be ignore like this i hope u actually grow up

[@ecam1529]

Its common for managers to keep their artist away from scandals. And obviously these days, the NJ members are activitely looking for that (as this video proves) whatever the reason is

[@janettplanett]

this is the most courageous thing i have seen from a kpop group in a LONG time. no matter what happens this is such a brave thing for them to do and im so proud of them

[@Shin_yuki_]

It's just stupid. They should have remained silent. They just destroyed their own career.

[@mimichy]

@@ken72615all they did was call out their company’s unfair mistreatment against them. what’s the issue there? do idols not deserve respect and care for all the work they do? for all the money they make these companies ?

[@poplikesodayeah3388]

@@Shin_yuki_OMG. So staying silent is better?! Its giving trash mindset. If you have experience mistreatment you SHOULD SPEAK UP. And you should FIGHT FOR IT. And Im proud that NJ are doing these, they dont juat follow blindly to hybe.

[@이안-x4t]

If they are under SM, would they dare to do this?

[@5oul-eat3r]

@@Shin_yuki_so they should have just took the mistreatment and stayed silent? that’s what you’re saying?

[@lumiereforlilies]

i stand with newjeans. these young girls so determined by their dreams to go big are just so brave to even speak a word about this. i’m so proud. i will until the end of my life defend you, nj.

[@Touka_]

👍

[@fuadali4456]

I stand with newjeans too❤❤🥲

[@LiezelMcheaven]

True 😢

[@TYC365]

Koreans understand the background and how K-pop works better than anyone else. A number of lawyers said NewJeans' live broadcasts were the best they could do, and that it would work in their favor in court disputes. NewJeans and their parents agreed with Min Hee-jin from the beginning. NewJeans' live broadcast position was to emphasize once again that NewJeans is with Min. Parents and Min representative have long protested against HYBE's unfair treatment. They also protested that Hanni was ignored. However, HYBE ignored their protest. If anyone thinks NewJeans and their parents, their fans, lawyers, Koreans are being gaslighted by Min Hee-jin, that's a real fool. Min Heejin didn't attack other artists. She complained to HYBE that HYBE was producing other artists the wrong way. She has worked with many K-pop artists. Girls' Generation, SHINee, EXO, Red Velvet, NCT, f(x) and V of BTS. Many artists respect her. SM Chairman Lee Soo-man has worked with her for 16 years and even offered her a CEO. Without trust, such an offer is impossible. Producer Bang respected her, too. He suggested CBO, saying, "I'm a successful fan." It was a good start, but she didn't follow his orders, which caused problems. There was no reason to obey his orders because she moved to the CEO of ADOR. He must have felt angry and inferior for not following his orders. Min Hee-jin said that my goal is for NewJeans to live happily. To do that, she said that her job is to teach them well for seven years and help them grow into great artists without me. Producer Bang's anger ruined their plans. Koreans hope that the visions of NewJeans and Min Hee-jin will come true.

[@jyr6453]

At this point, it doesn’t matter if you’re for MHJ or for HYBE. The girls are currently being mistreated and that’s something that needs to change.

[@Qwert_567]

It does matter. The girls clearly voiced who they stand behind and who did care for them. They trust MHJ and oppose the treatment of Hype. You should get the point.

[@aishaladen]

No. It does Matter. Newjeans member support min hee jin. Its disgusting and wrong

[@jyr6453]

@@Qwert_567 I’m just saying we need to keep the focus on supporting NewJeans, no matter whose side you’re on.

[@Qwert_567]

@@jyr6453 if you wanna side with NJ, you should know who is good for them. You hear them. They want MHJ and if that’s what they need, we should support them.

[@Eot04]

kzbin.infoUgkxfqPATsMhtb-QAYAI6tWH5XRLoGONKdH8?si=LcOQqFBCbU9QNr89

[@xanny2853]

FOR INFO: SOME TRANSLATION IN THIS VIDEO HAS A MISTAKES SO IT MAY CAUSE SOME MISUNDERSTANDING.

[@Gangster_Hampster]

*A lot of translation

[@neekoko4962]

even the korean subs aren't fully accurate, it's all automatically generated :\

[@unknown_8588]

I caught this info the moment it translated bunnies to “burnage ppl” i was like now who is this new character in this game

[@ick5353]

The biggest issue with this translation is that, regardless of the mistakes, it's a literal translation. English and Korean grammar structures are vastly different so how thoughts and sentences are conveyed may be confusing for English speakers. Where a basic English sentence structure would be - subject-verb-direct object, Korean structure is more like subject-direct object-verb, and often times the subject is not stated just implied through context.

[@Eot04]

kzbin.infoUgkxfqPATsMhtb-QAYAI6tWH5XRLoGONKdH8?si=LcOQqFBCbU9QNr89

[@wavefromearth]

I find it very funny, people want groups, soloists, idols etc. to talk about the situation they are in, standing against their toxic company,but when they actually do it,they judge 'em and treat them like liars like some people are doing, they are not to blame,blame MHJ or HYBE but not these girls,at this point don't matter if you like Newjeans or not, they're asking for help mentally and physically,stop hating them,they are the victims here, if you're going to do it just do it in your head, don't spread mean comments about them.

[@Neighbor8773]

Yes I agree some people are being excessive trying to down play their words and experiences, I appreciate their bravery, but I can’t help but feel this was not the right move for their career as new jeans, making demands against hybe and saying mhj did nothing wrong when she’s being held accountable for numerous misdeeds….

[@munalisaaa8560]

Right like when stuff like this actually happens they hate on them so much. You want people to stand up for them companies but when they do, they get so much hate. So much company Stan’s out here.

[@munalisaaa8560]

@@Neighbor8773I honestly don’t think it was. They’re going against a multi-billion dollar company that can easily blacklist them. Also, they might not know what MHJ or they want to act like she did nothing wrong. I don’t know though it could be so many reasons they said what they said. Hopefully they come out the victors.

[@dxohwf]

​@@munalisaaa8560no, everyone supported loona, exo, and omega x when they stood up to their company because they had valid reasons. i have no reasons to support newjeans flimsy claim of mistreatment, they make fifty fifty look good.

[@lilmishti7858]

Exactly, u am so hlad that i found someone who thinks like that!! I seriously nither support hybe nor min hee jin... Who i support in new jeans, these 5 girls, and what ever halos them, what ever makes them safe, protected and happy, i am gonna support that, wether that be bringing in min hee jin again or they wanting to leave the group or anything they want, i jsut want them happy and safe, chasing their dreams and being successful 🙏🏻 i dont want these kids to suffer, they don't deserve it at all!!

[@JanDigital-tx3vk]

They know what's at stake, yet they were brave enough to speak up. Knowing the cancel culture in Korea, and how women in general, are discriminated for the longest time, this might just be the end of their careers. And it shouldn't be. Who else will stand up for them amidst all this, if not them, themselves? I am not even a fan, but I am here as a human being voicing my support. Stay strong.

[@aevelq]

i don’t think either hybe or min are innocent in this situation, they’ve both had their faults but this is very brave of them to do, especially in this industry. it’s rare we’re able to see idols standing up for what they believe in, lots of respect to them honestly. hang in there girls

[@Gangster_Hampster]

양비론 ㅈ되네 ㅋㅋㅋ 하이브한테 얼마 받음?

[@StaRRend]

It’s honestly so sad how deep mhj has her claws in them. She should not be calling teens and asking for comfort in the middle of the night, let alone all the crazy shit she’s said about them.

[@ifayouknow]

​@StaRRend hey can you tell me more about what mhj has done and spoken about the girls, please? Ik about the song or mv controversies but thats all ik

[@beommpy4413]

@@StaRRenduhm. it was haerin that called mhj at night when the first news came out and was the one worrying

[@dankim1311]

please explain to me how min is not innocent

[@m3llie.369]

the fact that it got to the point where 5 girls are standing up to a multi billion dollar company because they KNOW how helpless they are, shows the extent to the mistreatment and injustice they have been subjected to because of HYBE and the new leadership.

[@Eot04]

kzbin.infoUgkxfqPATsMhtb-QAYAI6tWH5XRLoGONKdH8?si=LcOQqFBCbU9QNr89

[@Eot04]

Awww poor girls, with their tables thanks to HYBE 🥺🥺🥺

[@Haerinx87]

@@Eot04 Army simpleton ⚠️ Defending fatty bang

[@TouLor-ji3pi]

@@Eot04why do you put HYBE on a pedestal? They got lucky with BTS and the rest of their groups suck. Lol. NJs is their next big bet.

[@정온유-q2e]

KOR Bunnies is going to sue hive and Mr.Bang. Help us. Pls pray for Newjeans. All Bunnies in the world.

[@gaon_jeong]

What they said in live(for those who cba to watch the whole live) 1. Hanni tried to say hi to one of the artists in hybe but then their manager said "ignore her" right infront of Hanni. Hanni talked abt this problem w the compnay but they just blamed her and did nothing abt it 2. Hybe told them they were not gonna touch any of their works or producing BUT Hybe fired their MV directors and deleted their works on KZbin as soon as they fired MHJ 3. Hybe fired Minheejin without letting them know. They found out by news like we all did. 4. Newjeans said Hybe's been sabotaging them and been bullying them+Minheejin 5. Newjeans wants Minheejin back. And said HYBE is being inhuman

[@lauraf4176]

Oh boo-hoo,they were probably instructed not to speak to them because they are traitors to the company. They already had something to whine-imagine if they actually had a valid reason to bring something up

[@catcake_on_the_run]

@@lauraf4176 ...

[@lilly-1357]

@@lauraf4176wth…

[@lilly-1357]

@@quosa-5735i don’t think they are..

[@Touka_]

👍

[@Watcheryou]

SPEAKING UP IS A BASIC HUMAN RIGHT. GO GIRLS! YOU ARE BRAVE!

[@AICHEF3]

They braved up in dugging their own graves🤦🏻‍♀️

[@lovelylia5912]

Well they were and probably are being groomed by min so

[@garimzz3783]

Blaming HYBE or Min Hee Jin for their own setbacks only highlights one's bias. It's their own actions that have led to this situation. An early disbandment wouldn't come as a shock-it's a consequence of their own doing. They ought to concentrate on their work instead of portraying themselves as victims. These girls are lit digging their own grave.

[@Berriesare]

For mhj? This is reckless I say

[@wavefromearth]

Please guys stop blaming these girls,they just want someone to protect them,being able to stand against a huge company is a pure act of respect and courage,I ask that at least once instead of blaming them, try to support them even if you are not a fan,they deserve support.

[@zerotwothree]

🙌🏼‼️‼️‼️‼️

[@Meeiyui]

For real they really do need support. Standing up against the company would most likely lead to huge consequences.

[@Faceon6790]

You have to understand that they also support the other groups like lesserafim and illit to get hated. That's not right.

[@stellakatula1439]

If they were just focus simply on that then I’ll take them seriously. But they’re literally advocating for MHJ to be ceo again that’s what all this is about the other stuff is just there to fill space. If it was truly about support they’ll let the new ceo do that but they’re not even giving her a chance. Plus everything they’re asking for MHJ can do it in her role as creative director, she doesn’t need to be ceo to create stuff

[@galaxyforever-m3u]

@@stellakatula1439 dumb and deluded

[@zboi18]

I am not a Bunny but i am standing with the girls!. They don’t deserve to be treated this way at all! HYBE wake up your bloody idea! Thank you girls for standing up and being so brave!❤️

[@AmidatOmotoye]

Same I think they are really brave to do this despite the consequences they might face

[@poplikesodayeah3388]

True

[@billbenjamon9276]

Leave Hybe shit. Go us label

[@myheartbeatskkj2361]

They can always leave Hybe when they are able to. However, MHJ has something to do with the toxic environment NJ is in. Now, I do believe some of the mistreatment and/or unfairness NJ dealing is uncalled for. However, blaming Hybe solely and completely is not right either. At this point, they just have to deal with it, stand up for their beliefs and keep their heads up high. MHJ was just terrible in how she dealt with the business aspect without considering NJs future.

[@Meeiyui]

Yeah even though I'm not a Bunny but this time Newjeans' situation looks serious and they really looked like they're being mistreated. I also support Newjeans on this. ✊

[@cornfield5253]

it takes immense courage to stand up as one person to a company as wealthy and powerful as hybe so to see all five of these talented artists choosing to deliver their own thoughts in front of the entire world is worthy of immense respect because nobody in the position of a kpop artist would even think of doing something like this. hats of you to you newjeans

[@hihihiloo8381]

It's let me think fx😢

[@parkmilan4453]

They are gonna face legal consequences for supporting a criminal this is not braveness its being batshit crazy and dumb

[@mrs.halchalamet7733]

@@cornfield5253 I kinda feel like hybe is going to terminate theri contract or even worse keep them as it is and ruin their careers

[@Eot04]

kzbin.infoUgkxfqPATsMhtb-QAYAI6tWH5XRLoGONKdH8?si=LcOQqFBCbU9QNr89

[@ShivalikaSingh]

Totally agree with you!

[@31mabugnutin]

Not a stan of NJ but it is courageous of them to speak up. Kpop stans can be hypocrites.. People moan about how exploitative the kpop industry is but the moment a kpop group speaks out about their experiences and mistreatment, they turn on them. These girls decided on their own to livestream and they’re being called brainwashed and foolish for going against their company? How condescending and misogynostic to deny them their own agency. Just because they are young doesn’t mean one gets to dismiss them, especially if there are staff bullying them and creating a hostile work environment. One doesn’t have to be a fan of their former CEO but that is a person they trust and respect. It’s clear how Hybe has failed this group, perhaps sabotaged them along the way. I wish them all the best.

[@charlim2479]

So true!

[@MedUuUsin]

EXACTLY!!!!!

[@Kisaragi_eki]

They clearly asked help from their fans! Bunnies we need to support them! And wtf is wrong with people. You guys dont understand what they're going through or know what really happened to them.What they have to deal with in their personal life. Where is your common sense people. They know what they're talking about and they really need help. I always support you newjeans!

[@appllepiee235]

How help

[@Ameliya-3048]

@@appllepiee235yea how do we help

[@LostDLA]

Open your eyes, we're just fans, what are we going to do?? They're fucked up, this is so immature, i love them so much, but this live is going to take them to the ground

[@Kisaragi_eki]

​@@appllepiee235defend them.

[@akashpandey7466]

They think they are politicians where ppl will come to the street and protest against them..

[@damiann4734]

They are the only ones who know what is happening behind closed doors and know what's good for future success. Anyone who is criticising them are talking nonsense because they are just speculating or hating on NJ for no real reasons. If you have been enjoying NJ work, please continue to support them and also support their decision. Dont judge their decision from speculation or their age. They are different and not comparable to any ordinary teenagers. Some say they were manipulated because they are young, yet they are the ones who are famous because they take matured steps to accomplish their dreams. The person comment negativity is sitting hind youtube saying they are wrong...

[@llosyhuk]

Exactly, they can't be compared to 11-year-old girls who attend a regular school. They are already idols who have trained for years and already have a job and, on top of that, they have a contract with a large company. Therefore, they are mature enough to be able to freely express themselves and make their opinion known in case they do not agree with the labor laws that exist. People forget that they are being mistreated. Being ignored by your coworkers is a very serious type of abuse.

[@Terror16326]

They are manupulated and that middle girl is acting weird. Seems like some girl removed that black thing from camera that means MHJ was with them and there were atleast 3 more people with them in the room. All the information about there music and all is nonsense. MHJ was never involved in there production. No credits of her in the music. They are supporting a person who hide the sexual assault in there company. They are siding the person who was responsible for hate train for many idol groups. They are not adults. They are not that mature to understand whole matter. I am an adult and now I am in university last year but still I discuss my life decisions withmy parents and when I was there age I was immature and I was not that aware about the situation around me. Every one goes through many thing in this age and they are brainwashed that what I know and what is this man hanni is complaining like a brat about that manager like a little child. They are still child mentally and immature. They don't know what the life truly is. They are behaving like a brat..m

[@michaelblue4619]

yeah people thinking they know better than the girls themselves are stupid af. legit keyboard warriors just projecting.

[@ainetoile4787]

They are at that rebelling age that's why they seem and act brave. You know how around those age they tend to act without thinking. And honestly new jeans seems dramatic too feel like they're the one carrying and causing fire to these drama actually. Yes they are worried about the future but doing this doesn't seem appropriate either nor mature either. I mean their future hasn't even come either but they're already thinking and acting out like this. Some people would label this as attention seeking. Feels like they just burn more fire on fire when there's no need to this extend. I mean there's no need to do this kind of live like why so. It's wild behavior it's dramatic from their side. Seems like they are the ones inviting themselves to be inside this drama. I'd be mad if I was their manager or ceo like this is just extra drama from them. They are such brats and they don't know better.

[@damiann4734]

@@ainetoile4787 from what I've said, you still go ahead and group them in the same category as an ordinary but also rebellious teenagers. Everything that you've said has no basis. It's just a bunch of what ifs and feels. We aren't working with your feelings here. Ofcourse there's always consequences for any action and I'd give then benefit of the doubts that they have thought it through.

[@jennd2515]

People saying that they should stay quiet is really concerning. I hope those people can advocate for themselves, and don't accept mistreatment in their everyday lives. I really hope it's not adults saying it, too. I can understand when you're a minor having that mindset. Still, when you go into the real world, you realize that staying quiet can kill you emotionally, mentally, and even physically. - Please show empathy for these young girls.

[@Lotuaoki]

Honestly, imagine working a job and your bosses and people around you mistreat you. Why should anyone stay quiet and put up with that?

[@wadiputhere]

How is it mistreatment? Being ignored? Oh wow, poor girls... siding with a criminal and getting all sad and shocked when artists dont want to be involved with them because of it. MHJ is a criminal, and she insulted those girls. She manipulates them into making them and everyone else side with her.

[@OhnOoOSunOoAtEnI-KisPhOnE]

Sorry but they kinda should have not said anything, this just made everything worse

[@yenattack]

@@OhnOoOSunOoAtEnI-KisPhOnEtbf if they’re going to be “shelved” regardless, they might as well scream and shout if they’re gonna be “disbanded” either way. 😭

[@ren8854]

Finally, someone said it. I even read a comment that said these girls should just shut up and sing and dance like what they're paid to do. Like jesus, i know life is hard but there's no need to turn into lifeless apathetic monsters that validate workplace harassment as just "part of life". They wanted to fight, as naive as it sounds, and despite knowing the risks, it is still admirable.

[@kayyy435]

Just by looking at the girls they seem really mentally exhausted they’ve been through so much why can’t it just end?! If I were standing infront of them I would give them a big hug and tell them that everything will be ok!! I’m praying for you New Jeans stay strong!💪❤️

[@あい-b7q9c]

this is a proof that they're ARTISTS, they're not just money makers tools for a deadshit corporation. WE STAND WITH NJWS!

[@felixfors9340]

Emotional reasoning is not good a idea

[@danniancamjoy]

WE STAN WHIT NEW JEANS

[@あい-b7q9c]

@@felixfors9340 well, their emotions are being dragged over concrete. they're being mistreated, ignored and bullied. so i guess emotions are an important part of the matter. they should be happy working on their full album and preparing for a global tour but instead they're sitting sad and guilty due to hybe's poor management.

[@shx2970]

@@felixfors9340music and art is emotional not some bland, greedy corporate bs that hybe pushes for

[@lowandhigh7044]

MNH did that to them she threw those girls under the bus and still throwing them she bullied other groups and smeared them and all of what NWJ is going through is because of that selfish woman ​@@あい-b7q9c

[@thanhxinhdepvodichsieucapv3497]

those girls are so brave, standing up for themselves against giant cooperation like just wow, this is how you actually change the kpop industry

[@d-4azerty755]

this is how you get put on hiatus for 4 years.

[@markagdan6406]

​@@d-4azerty755 Really?

[@Ruth_m0]

I’m sorry but this reminded me of something the starbucks girl said 💀

[@kingkong-gm6pp]

They are gen Z... im not surprised

[@appllepiee235]

@@d-4azerty755fr but 😢

[@aiforus]

NJ young women, brave and mature for their age. Sensitive and strong. Please continue on the path you have made together and don't let anything deter. Many many support you NJ!

[@Genevieve-s3q]

It's the Adult faults at first from the commenced...but after something happen to Han ..the manager should have spread kindness and love instead of telling others artist to ignore her it's like telling the person to ignore the existence

[@3iecv_]

I feel so bad I’m gonna cry

[@AdrianaIngaG]

Me too🤧🤧😭😭😭

[@bunnylae6702]

Whyy They decided to support MHJ💀 not just defending themselves

[@sufviz3626]

​@@bunnylae6702true but we dont know how whats actually happened behind closed doors. If theyre supporting her its for a reason.

[@bunnylae6702]

@@sufviz3626 It could be a reason that also it's not ethic at all 💀 Just read everything that happened

[@sufviz3626]

@@bunnylae6702 i have lol and though i agree mhj isnt a good person nor very innocent as shes bodyshamed the girls and stuff i do believe theres things we dont know about. njs have worked with her for a while who's to say she hasnt done something for them before

[@Pietersend]

Damn, it's sad these girls have to go through this difficult situation. Especially at their age... I fully support and root for NewJeans. I hope things will go well soon. Get em girls!

[@javeregaspi8769]

imagine how scared they are right now. Stand with Newjeans

[@BubbleGum-e7x]

Can yall stop saying they ruined their careers? They obv know that this livestream would make Hybe treat them worse but they have to speak up about the mistreatment if it’s happening, they can’t just stay silent

[@jennd2515]

Yup! This!!

[@sarabeatriz5569]

What mistreatment though? Like, i get that being ignored by another label's management probably feels bad but that's not mistreatment

[@knyaw7436]

@@sarabeatriz5569 wtf? being ignored is not a big problem but to say that in front of you is a BIG problem. what is your definition of mistreatment?

[@sarabeatriz5569]

@@knyaw7436 the stuff that loona and tvxq went through feel more appropriate to call mistreatment. This, while bad, isn't really enough to make a case

[@umlikewhocares]

@@sarabeatriz5569they clearly have not revealed everything for legal reasons, they know it’s best to use the worst undisclosed information for the lawsuit if they choose to file one!! I’m sure after the 25th we will know more but I believe this is an attempt at trying to gauge Hybe’s response/they can probably also gather more evidence with what happens after this 🤷🏻‍♀️

[@karthika_karthika_2006]

"plz... don't harrass our ceo" meanwhile their ceo harrassing every one 👄💀

[@thegirl2826]

They want Hybe to bring things back to normal and let the production and management stay as it was, although they stated they want their CEO back they never said what you stated they said. they're asking for our support and help.

[@AICHEF3]

@@thegirl2826i think they couldve done better in their careers without this live. Things can never go back to same again. Hybe wont trust them because they went behind their backs. Even if they leave hybe- no other corp would trust them

[@asylaikapas19]

@@thegirl2826Open your eyes😢 They speak so harshly. Like we want to continue working with Hype and then hype is inhumane company.After this,hype will not cooperate with them.But they expected this.After 10 days they will disbanded and leave hype to MHJ

[@Minha_ly28]

@@thegirl2826 back to normal lol you mean secretely harrassing other groups. hybe should never take MHJ back.because for the sake of NJ they could lose other groups especially BTS.

[@karthika_karthika_2006]

@@thegirl2826 girl.. i support NJ they are talented but I can't support min hee jin🙌🏻

[@Lilpulse12345]

These girls are so brave, I’m so proud of them for speaking up against a multi billion dollar company. They have worked so hard and should not be treated the way they have been treated by their new management.

[@user-by3nd4rm6c]

Prestige should never get in the way of advocacy for humane treatment

[@Hyunwoo13]

seeing them happy on the stage while they have this big problem makes me sad let's support them :((

[@Touka_]

That fake happiness..

[@lucy_zhang]

You really cannot blame these girls for being this attached to MHJ. Idgaf about MHJ but it’s high time for everyone to realize that unfortunately she’s the only adult in their company that gives a fuck about NewJeans. No matter what, I'll support and root for NewJeans.

[@302-sigraviee5]

If you sad MHJ get out from hybe , you can join her to get out from hybe. We need peace & please get out & pay the pinalty cost. Pleasse , we don't need your drama anymore

[@lucy_zhang]

@@302-sigraviee5 You're obviously illiterate. I never said I'm sad about MHJ. I said I don't give a fuck about her. I only care about the girls.

[@lucy_zhang]

@@Ihatedululumin Illiterate #2.

[@SolitudeDayys]

@@302-sigraviee5well then tell hybe to give NJ to MHJ without being petty as*holes

[@florlscnt]

If she really did she wouldn’t have put them in this position, it was HER OWN FAULT that she got fired. If she was more professional she wouldn’t have gotten demoted like this. Yes I can’t blame them, because they’re young and naive, but I can easily blame the responsible adult that couldn’t act her age and is manipulating them for her own gain. If she could easily insult them and their appearance I don’t think she’s being genuine

[@ngocbich936]

I hope a miracle can happen to them. They don’t deserve this. These young, talented and kind hearted girls. We love you and will stand by you!

[@namahn2049]

They start talking at 7:35

[@chaeriipham]

thank you!

[@lawaii444]

NO YOU DIDNT 🙂‍↕️🙂‍↕️🙂‍↕️

[@Angelinav-g4m]

Thanx

[@idkwhatmynameis204]

The fact they waited so long just so that as much bunnies as possible could join the live :(

[@anamikagogoi-xh4rb]

Thank

[@cowboyspit_]

I’m so incredibly proud of these girls for their bravery in standing up to such a large corporation at their age. No person should have to deal with this amount of pressure, and stress. I will stand behind them until the end, Bunnies love you forever NewJeans 💗

[@Eot04]

kzbin.infoUgkxfqPATsMhtb-QAYAI6tWH5XRLoGONKdH8?si=LcOQqFBCbU9QNr89

[@roshnimallik2337]

Tbh, NEW JEANS HAS THE BIG POTENTIAL TO REVOLVE THE KPOP INDUSTRY, remember how a debut album had the whole kpop industry in their hand. I am not a bunny but I SUPPORT NEW JEANS. They are smart enough to know who is good and who is not. NEW JEANS all the way.

[@taniyapanwar6175]

I guess they are definitely right in there place. But they are working in a company. It's there work place do you think hybe will hire minheejin again for them even though after her leaving stocks of hybe were increased. At the end of the day it is business for new jeans and for company to because they have to earn. They have expenses to pay. It is true that new jeans came out and telling people about the mistreatment they are receiving is great. It would have been better if instead of minheejin they would have said they need better work environment and security with that people will target hybe and ask them to give better treatment. But now people think it's done for minheejin so they are taking it lightly and new jeans is also getting blamed in return

[@다인공주]

어린 애들이 회사랑 맞서싸운다는것 라이브를 킨다는거 자체로 정말 힘들었을 것 같다..할수있는 일이 위로 댓글다는거 밖애 없어서 너무 미안해. 버니즈들은 뉴진스를 보고 위로하는데 민희진 대표도 없어진 지금 정말 뉴진스는 어디에 기대고 위로받을 수 있을까.....정말....너무 속상하다

[@amiraaaahh_]

why are we arguing over this and not sending the girls all the support we can as possible? Both Min Hee Jin AND Hybe are wrong here, we have to understand and connect from the girls perspective! It must be horrible 😣

[@scarlettlav]

Agreed a lot of people who don’t know what’s going sitting behind their computers thinking they work at Hybe and know what’s going on is pissing me off, we do not know, I don’t like MHJ and I know she’s no angel but if someone at Hybe is really protecting the girls and give them security and arent but treating them like dirt, I do believe the girls are groomed by MHJ but Hybe is the worst party that it made it looks like she’s the lesser evil. Now the girls have no where to go, it’s funny how people are protecting the girls saying they’re minor when they feel MHJ is predator but now attacking the girls because they feel they're siding her? Attacking minors where it fits your narrative, urgh so annoying.

[@wolf-from-tambov]

@@scarlettlav Мин Хи Джин, это вообще не зло. Для девочек, она добро в чистом виде.

[@nishimura__123]

thanks for posting this♥️ i am so worried abt them😢

[@TramNguyen-qw5hz]

As an IVE stan I fully support Newjeans. These girls are very smart and brave and know how to stand up for themselves when there's no one on their side. I remember when a HYBE gg debuted (Mr Bang's favorite gg of course not Newjeans), KBS posted contents on KZbin praising the HYBE gg and mocking IVE while Jang Wonyoung was still MC for music bank. Such a dirty media move of them. When Newjeans debuted there was no dirty media like that from KBS that's why I'm on these girls side. HYBE has the power and money to manipulate the media and for a long period of time IVE and AESPA was under some crazy hate trains. I'm all for IVE, AESPA and NEWJEANS because they're not playing dirty tactics to succeed. I'm so glad Newjeans stood up and exposed that company. That guy has a huge ego because he was losing to a woman, he was not happy there is the top 4th gen girlgroup is in his company because he thinks his favorite gg in the same company should be more successful. Bruh

[@arshchaudhary4096]

I love mature fans especially those who Stan Newjeans, Aespa, Gidle and IVE together. These groups are the only ones who actually deserve to be 4th gen top ggs, extremely hardworking and talented. I hope all their fans come in unison instead of being in fanwars and support all of them together like a one big fandom❤

[@princessbubble3082]

You have a great point actually!!

[@hsu0l1206]

*BTS Jungkook's support for New Jeans is such a great thing.* *He sympathized and expressed his convictions as a person and as an artist.*

[@nmixxinka]

Pls tell me where and when he supported them🙏🏻

[@SlayBaseOne]

Liar

[@youdonotneedtoknow45]

His account has been hacked 🙄

[@Akshay-v2n]

Stop noob things please, their is no evidence of him supporting newjens or clips

[@ashleya2596]

@@youdonotneedtoknow45 u just made that up.. they literally came out and said it was him lol.

[@MadaraxUchiha]

Stay strong NewJeans, you will get through this despite all of the bad things that happened! Bunnies don't stop supporting our NewJeans ❤

[@daniellesanchez9129]

TBH coming from a performing and events management company, I resonate with these girls. I have worked with a director similar to MHJ, and surely there were days and times where their ways are questionable but the output done is outstanding. I started being a fan because of the way their concepts are delivered, always connected and detailed, a wonderful work of performing art. If the concepts they have been planning have been infringed, limited or worse, scraped, I would be upset too. They're ignored in the company, the people who have worked with them and have been with them from the start, working up together for whatever success they are receiving, are now being replaced, I'd be upset too. It takes a whole ass team of 35 people who have trust with each other to get a play working, how much more for their productions? NJ isnt NJ without their team.

[@vickiegibbons8765]

i reckone the male bigwigs got scared of her success she gets with her production and creative team. if you go back through her work its always top notch. so what if she said some unethical shit, i bet all the men so a LOT of unethical shit about others especially any women in the industry. SK is known for treating women badly.

[@Bunny-gm8yu]

Its so brave of them to stand up for themselves and speak out against hybe. They are being mistreated and bullied. Instead of this , some mfs are still keen on the point that they always talk about mhj. Of course , she was the only one who actually cared for them. If u still support hybe , u r either stupid or straight up hater. Rn , i just want them to get out of hybe , i dont care about muisc , i just want them to be happy. Forever ❤ newjeans

[@kevinappearshere]

Those who claimed themselves bunnies and support the girls, but dissing MHJ badly from months ago, come out to APOLOGIZE! ASSHOLES!

[@Yunjin___]

Mistreated lmao that happens when you support a woman who did so much shit

[@bhavyagoel4222]

I feel so bad for these girls. They're being mistreated from each direction, I can't imagine what it must feel like.. the fact they spoke up is brave itself! Proud of them for that!

[@zingestrella]

I WILL FOREVER SUPPORT NEWJEANS NO MATTER WHAT!!

[@clarisse6607]

You'll support 5 normal girls soon cuz Newjeans isn't theirs. I wish for them to leave and let Hybe put New members in Newjeans.😇

[@diahayucandra3387]

Me too 😢

[@Doyoujustlovethepain]

What the f is wrong with you ​@@clarisse6607

[@johnnysins7246]

​@@clarisse6607you know jf they do that, no ones going to support the new NewJeans with different members right? Kinda like the current Fifty Fifty

[@mimichy]

@@clarisse6607newjeans won’t be the same without these 5 girls

[@abelmp1334]

this is absolutely crazy, im sorry but as a bunnie i want them to be happy and if this is what they are fighting for then i support them

[@clarisse6607]

If one of your parent is a dying alcoholic would you still support? Cuz if not you're a hypocrite, why support these girls when Min hee jin and them are the problem!?

[@Insomnia0224]

It is ridiculous that these young kids need to use live stream secretly to express their true perspectives😢

[@minh4183]

They’re very brave. I support them. The adults messed up so bad.. but the kids faced the consequences.😢

[@Loveempress2821]

Fr

[@yq._.marina]

I hope the situation don't get any worse and that they will be fine

[@onosyosono]

MHJ seems to not be the best human being in the eyes of a lot of people BUT don’t be naive guys. If those girls and their parents supports this woman, it’s probably because we don’t have the entirety of the painting. Some truth remain among the industry and we will probably never know the whole story. I just hope all the girls of New Jeans will overcome this delicate situation (I love each of them and profoundly wish them the best)

[@luvboomxo]

they are not children anymore. they know whats right and whats wrong. maybe WE are getting the painted picture. to them, someone is wrong with the company.

[@NDk-kr5uj]

@@luvboomxoas a korean who understands korean and live in korea western people are brainwashed by HYBE... in KOREA the story is actually different! What's ACTUALLY Happening is the most koreans are on Min Hee Jin's side. As a fan this is so crazy and frustrating that HYBE tries so hard to spread misinformation and make 민희진 look bad.. newjeans had much more creative direction with min hee jin around and if ur up to date as soon as min hee jin got fired their policy and up coming collaborations all got SHUTDOWN... so if u don't speak korean and don't live in korea and only believe the media you don't know anything and being brainwashed by HYBE.. they are paying channels to create and spread misinformation.. sorry for my bad english

[@kvttysun]

@@luvboomxo newjeans fucking got emotionally groomed by min heejin, that is reasonable for them to think min heejin is good. also their mind is still like a childs, they are barely grown adults yet. all of the adults in their lives failed them.

[@cmool]

@@kvttysunyes she is a creep

[@onosyosono]

@@luvboomxo They’re not children anymore I agree with you, but imo it’s evident that a lot of things are not shared with us. Just Imagine that in trials (in general) public do not have access to the entirety of the details so let alone the music industry (estimated by several billion dollars), the K-POP one ? With the most prolific company at the moment (Hybe). I absolutely do *NOT* think we (commoners) get the ‘accurate’ painted picture. If we have a picture, it’s only coming from the media, that is since a very…very long time ago doesn’t work to share the blatant truth anymore, but to ‘influence’ the public opinion under the order of those wealthy company or from powerful people. NDA are not myths, pressure from big company are not fictions, and mastodon like Hybe have more control than you think. So yes. *I* will trust the girls and their family to choose what’s best for them (I’m pretty sure they’re more informed than you or me in this whole situation)

[@shhimzz]

Closed minded people be commenting as if they really know what is really up on their sleeves, smh! Even if I'm not their fan and saw this situation they're in, I'll be probably side with them, side with the truth! They know what they are saying and that's why they're speaking up about that issue regardless of what others might say to them, I believe to their CEO because I've had done my "research" to that issue, let's not be fooled just because it's a "big company," the truth is the truth! Lastly, let's not have that kind of mindset that "they're young what do they know?" Because it doesn't mean you're young means you know nothing, these girls are smart enough to speak up. For the blind people, get your fact-check!

[@Ricky911_]

It's genuinely so infuriating to see these comments by people saying that she is grooming them and such just for having a close relationship with their boss. The girls have worked with Min Hee Jin for years. Saying that they are young or that they are being manipulated is essentially calling them stupid when the only stupid people are these braindead netizens. How dare they think they know better than all 5 members and all of their parents, who actually work with Min Hee Jin? These comments are completely ridiculous

[@imonthenextlevel522]

That closed minded people are from Taiwan’s Dcard🎉🎉

[@Ihatedululumin]

​@@Ricky911_okay not grooming fine but after everything came out about min hee jin still supporting her .. Do you guys want hybe to feed them more?? Lol😂 just teenage wtf 😂 don't be victim minded and do publicity stunt like min hee jin

[@rae2443]

exactly people are so irritating. the only people who are currently living in this situation and sees how it TRULY is are Newjeans.

[@stephysunisav1194]

​@@Ricky911_💯

[@heartz4emiii]

oh please mhj knows damn well what she was doing, after all the harassment, accusations, scandals, lies, etc. that she did, no one could ever forget about her past. Don’t even get me started when she was still on SM. I stand with newjeans but I do not support about that they want mhj back.

[@pandaa5708]

same, mhj copying other group saying that other group copying them

[@garimzz3783]

exactly

[@garimzz3783]

Blaming HYBE or Min Hee Jin for their own setbacks only highlights one's bias. It's their own actions that have led to this situation. An early disbandment wouldn't come as a shock-it's a consequence of their own doing. They ought to concentrate on their work instead of portraying themselves as victims. These girls are lit digging their own grave.

[@kitalgi777]

YOU ARE REALLY BRAVE GIRLS! REAL BUNNIE WILL ALWAYS BE WITH YOU 💙

[@priincessss]

I understand their frustration as someone who has been mistreated by higher authorities that we’re supposed to look out for me. I really do hope they don’t get deeply traumatized by this experience, I love newjeans so much❤. I really wish they had even a single worker by their side…hybe really messed up & then again , them making requests in this way would be seen as disrespectful, I stand w them still.

[@calmvibesgivememoree33824]

Adults abusing them. It’s too much. please stop I was shocked that one of the managers in hybe said to ignore her that’s so mean… how you even do that? Just bullying

[@imzaina]

U accept somone to give u princess treatment when your ceo literally bassed harrased them publicly??

[@musicbox6144]

OmG managers nOt taLking to thEm ? That’s abuse , nooooo that’s worse then abuse. that’s murder 🤦‍♂️ considering all the bullying they allowed against other groups. manager not speaking to them is something baby’s cry about . That’s just so weird

[@creamisoul6255]

Stop being dramatic omfg

[@calmvibesgivememoree33824]

@@musicbox6144I’m Korean. But why are most Koreans on her side? It’s because Koreans have already seen many unjust things in articles that are not known abroad. There have been countless unknowns of wrongdoing abroad. In Korea, articles have poured out a lot, but some ARMYs deliberately mistranslate a few articles in favor of Hybe and post them on Twitter. (Except for all the unfavorable articles) Foreigners believe that Lol, it look so ignorant. MHJ also have something wrong. But when comparing all the things including many events that were only disclosed in Korea (which foreigners don't know well), people all think Hybe's fault is definitely big. That’s why most of Koreans are mhj’s side. So don't judge by looking at a fraction of what happened without knowing everything. It's ridiculous too see foreigners asking why Koreans side with mhj. Have you ever thought that a lot of fabricated stories have been told to foreigners? Haven't you ever thought there would be many things that haven't been told abroad other than what you know? You don't think there are many things you don't know, but you’re only stuck with what you see, so that’s why people say that foreign fans are ignorant ㅉㅉ 왜 한국인들 대다수가 MHJ의 편이겠니? 여태 해외에는 알려지지않은 부당한 일들이 수없이 많다. 한국에서는 기사로 엄청 많은 내용들이 쏟아져나왔으나 몇몇 외국인들은 일부 Hybe에 유리한 글들만 일부러 잘못 번역하여 날조해서 트위터에 올린다. 외국사람들은 그걸 또 그대로 믿고 있다 ㅋㅋㅋ 진짜 무식해보인다. MHJ도 분명 잘못한점이 있다. 근데 왜 한국사람들은 MHJ 편일까? 수많은 부당한 일들을 이미 기사로 다 접했기때문이다. 그니까 제발 무슨 일들이 있었는지 다 알지도 못하면서 극히 일부만 보고 판단하지마라. 한국인들은 대체 왜 mhj의 편을 드냐고 따지는 글을 보면 진짜 어이가없다. 니네한테 전해진 얘기가 날조된 얘기가 많다는 생각은 안해봤니? 니네가 알고 있는 일 외에도 전해지지 않은 일들이 많을거라는 생각은 안해봤니? 니네가 모르는게 많다는 생각은 못해보고 오직 니네가 보는것에만. 갇혀있으니까 외국팬들이 개무식하다는 소리를 듣는거아 ㅉㅉ

[@calmvibesgivememoree33824]

@@musicbox6144 This works because the number of ARMYs is far higher overseas. Don't be ignorant you a stupid kid

[@BP-rg8xp]

Since I can read Korean, I see a world of difference between the Korean and non-Korean fandoms about what they know and think of Min Hee-Jean's background and her role in this drama (obviously, there will be exceptions and shades of grey in this generalization). But dream on, if you think New Jeans is going to ditch Min Hee-Jean. MHJ is not just some random ho off the streets who got bored one day and hypnotized NJ. She's widely acknowledged as a K-pop industry leader by no less a person than Lee Sooman during her tenure at SM - heavily involved in the creative process of SNSD, Fx, Red Velvet, and Exo. Why do you think Bang Si-Hyuk/Hybe recruited MHJ from SM in the first place? After Bang's failure with Glam, he turned to her expertise to create a successful Hybe girl-group, but they had strong disagreement in their artistic vision and direction. Bang initially promised Min creative latitude and independence in the New Jean project with title of first BTS sister-group, but due to the creative differences spilling over to bad blood, Bang used the pandemic to put the NJ project on hold and launched his parallel project, stealing the thunder and attention initially. If Min hadn't carved out Ador as a semi-independent sublabel saddled with Bang's negative expectations for the NJ project's failure, New Jeans would never have taken off. And boy, did New Jeans smash the charts without any teasers or fanfare. Funny thing is that all these events are common knowledge among the Korean fans and the commentariat, the K-pop artists and creatives are pretty much on MHJ's side, like SES Bada, Girl's Generation Taeyeon, and YG's BlackPink creatives. BTS Taehyung V was positive about working with MHJ as an artist. More importantly, the New Jeans members are the ones most cognizant of her pivotal role in their formation and evolution. They aren't separate entities. There's a meme in Korea going around, where the New Jeans girls are the students in Dead Poet's Society hailing "O' Captain my Captain" and it's not for Bang Si-Hyuk or his twin sister the new CEO of Ador. At this point, Hybe wants to choke off and memory-hole NJ, and I can't help but think that a good number of you may be deliberately or unknowingly playing the role of corporate shills. It's like you're watching the Dead Poet's Society movie and calling Robin Williams the film's villain and mastermind. These NJ girls aren't stupid, brainwashed, or naive. They know who their real friends and enemies are in Hybe. And when BTS Junggook threw his support to New Jeans, he timed it after seeing this livestream and echoed their sentiment. He didn't give a qualification, dissing the NJ support for MHJ. When Danielle asked, "Did we do something wrong...", JK said "No, Artists are not guilty" specifically referencing her. So please stop ✋️ twisting and distorting JK's words that he was shading MHJ. If anything, Army fans remember the physical and emotional abuses Hybe inflicted on JK (at least, some Korean Army KZbinrs talk about it).

[@니니-s6p]

와 이렇게 똑똑힌 외국인이 있다니 정확하게 알고 계시네요

[@BP-rg8xp]

@니니-s6p 감사합니다. 지금 한국을 여행 중인데, 만난 한국분들 다 뉴진스/민희진 지지하고 방시혁 지지하는 사람 못 봤어요. I'm traveling thru Korea right now and come across a wide demographic. The Korean public seems well-informed, and literally everyone I come across are supportive of New Jeans and/or Min Hee-Jean. No one supports Bang Si-Hyuk or Hybe. That's just the hard truth in Korea, no matter how many echo-bubble chambers and hate-frenzies are constructed by Hybe to push a flimsy narrative among the ignorant, easily deceived, or purposefully hateful. But the emperor Bang Si-Hyuk has no clothes - fully exposed on Korean SNL.

[@keiraw_1]

wow this is so well explained

[@tanazizhar3914]

What I have noticed over all this matter is min hi jeen was so good with the girls helping them a lot in each and everything. Being their mental and physical support, but at the same time she (MHJ) was also doing unfair things with the other artist. And now Hybe dismissed MHJ, ignoring new jeans too. I understand that for the girls MHJ is a special one but, what MHJ has done can't also be ignored. New Jeans need a break right now for few months to be back with healthy mental health and continue with their future activities.

[@Meeiyui]

Most say "How can a company disband a group that makes lots of money for them", but actually Hybe is really mistreating them despite the fact that they're a popular group which benefits them alot.

[@bingmalsi864]

Bangs ego is the problem

[@xecor4450]

bro the person they made ceo for ador tried to steal the company. can they not stop them and the ceo for a bit. are you alright in the head my brother. Newjeans members are actually brainwashed and are acting as minions for mhj cant you see that how they talk about her and cant do anything without her. No wonder they gonna be put on hold. You think a corporation is purposefully not making money? just ask yourself this. If you come to any answer than "no" then you need to go out and face the real world and then ask yourself this question again

[@vickiegibbons8765]

yes something is off.

[@foodgirl69]

It's not about wanting Min heejin back but about no one protecting them and not knowing who to trust.

[@clarisse6607]

They said "we want MHJ back"????

[@so-sophiesticated1486]

@@clarisse6607they want mhj back bc they don’t trust anyone

[@aichikunpaiz4716]

​@@clarisse6607 Because there are no one to trust and they are getting mistreatment thats why they want MHJ back..if they are treat fairly i dont think there are issue

[@laryssalima4808]

@@clarisse6607 It's not their fault that MHJ had a fight with HIBE. They don't have anything to do with the company's internal fight, but they are still being harmed. They are within their rights to want to keep MHJ.

[@clarisse6607]

@@laryssalima4808 Who was gaslighting them and fat shaming them! You know what? Both MHJ and Newjeans worth each other, we need to put them in the same freaking bag! NEXT

[@remig.claremont4583]

Will support you whatever might happen you are all the original New Jeans =)

[@whyme1378]

Poor girls..sad to see them going through all these thing...

[@seiji909]

i have so much more respect for them now. for the girls to stand up for them selves this way, it's something we never see. i'm sure everyone is very upset they even had to do this, i'm so glad they did. they're so brave, i hope everything goes well for them.

[@lalina11]

Little reminder for everyone watching it rn . We don't know them in real life. We are just random kpop stans. The only people that know their relationship between MHJ and newjeans are themselves and not us. SO stop talking about this as an excuse to hate on the members. Them themselves said that MHJ has a special place in their group . So yall mind your fucking busniss. I'm so proud of them. That was veryyy braveee and wish them all the luck

[@kel_csw]

Period!!!

[@Touka_]

👍👍👍👍

[@loveleerhea]

Do they think they are BTS or something? Rookie idols daring to make complaints and telling the company who practically owns them is rude, undisciplined and frankly idiotic. This is an internal issue, not a situation where you go whine on live.

[@9131415485]

DO YOU NOT UNDERSTAND, THEY ARE BEING MISTREATED BY THEIR OWN COMPANY ARE YOU BLIND OR SOMTHING 🤮

[@79464f]

I think they were being forced to say this

[@kaligachunon5990]

No matter what you guys say. It’s evil vs evil. They’re trying their best to bring things back the way it was and I don’t blame them. I keep on seeing comments saying “mhj forced them to do this”. Let’s be honest, from their success and what they’ve achieved, I’ve never seen a group work so well with each other. This is what their ceo brought to the table, which they loved and ADORED. They’re doing this out of their own volition and I’ll continue to support them!

[@VisibleMRJ]

It's a talented CBO but a terrible CEO versus a big company that knows how to play the game. That's the whole story.

[@exhaust4246]

Im used to seeing them happy, always smiling, cracking jokes etc.. it was sad seeing thrm like this, i hope everything goes back to normal

[@athenarose533]

New Jeans will be marked in KPOP history forever. Not only for an amazing discography but for this level of courage. I have never seen a group stand up against their company public ly like this

[@111solecito]

This sounds so rehearse, they keep looking to the sides as looking for approval

[@Lrfeix]

at 2:14 someone turned on the camera? it wasn't Haerin, so who was it then? they clearly were not alone and someone was helping them. this is all so confusing

[@iscccvzzqzz4238]

maybe could be min heejin?

[@lalina11]

They have their own manager and friends. Stop being so stupid

[@nina.27.]

probably mhj who’s grooming them to do this

[@five__55555_]

At around the 9:10 mark, they say they received help on setting up the live (in terms of the technical stuff such as setting up the camera, finding a location to do the live, etc. they can’t handle) from a trusted staff member

[@parkmankeun]

Hye-in said that it's not a live broadcast because Min Hee-jin ordered it, but that New Jins is doing it on its own.

[@roarinssi]

I'm so glad that they did this! The environment they experiencing right now must be really exhausting for them. WE WANT WHAT IS GOOD FOR OUR GIRLS, SO I REALLY WISH THAT HYBE WILL LISTEN TO THEIR CONCERNS!

[@snsdbtsNJfanz88]

It really breaks my heart seeing them couragely speaks or talk abt the issue arose. I love NewJeans Music so much since day 1. The identity in them via music which has been created by MHJ is something that I like. The more I listen to their music the more I like them... I hope their mental health is OK and strong. If it was true that HYBE did not protect them and ignore them it does break my heart. And I really want to hug them and comfort them. To the "People Out there" Please don't torture their emotions...just enough!

[@DefneNiaz]

5:18 you could see how much Hyein tried her best not to cry

[@medeatheesolon]

This is making me cry like literally. They don't deserve any of these things. They are so brave for this and i hope everything works out for them in the end.

[@trollof229antthevariable9]

I'm really proud of you girls for speaking out. Fuck it, man. Dont let these companies punk you. Anybody else would be glad to have you...i dont know the contract situation but any Eastern or Western company on Earth would be happy to give you what you want.

[@themoonlightbecoming]

Wrong translation list (too many so i wrote the main words that foreign netizen will misunderstand) 15:45 noble manager -> manager of that branch 16:10 it looks like i'm tired of everything -> i could hear and see everything 16:35 onential medicine -> Hanni (member) 16:47 Han -> Hanni 18:28 Minizen -> Min Hee Jin 18:50 nuclear weapons (what....) -> solve the problem 25:24 goods -> staff

[@mikulitsi1819]

I've not followed K-pop super actively nor that long (8 years) but I feel like this is unheard of? Group making their own channel just to do a live stream where they go against their parent company. Honestly I applaud them for their courage and I hope this gets resolved soon and that they don't get mistreated anymore.

[@chelseycheung5624]

Stand with NewJeans, girls you're soooooo brave, hopefully everything goes well! The truth will revealed at the end🥺

[@Joonpathy]

Standing with newjeans means supporting Mhj

[@ekashaffika2513]

Bunnies love you , we proud of you , newjeans didn't deserve to be like this! I love newjeans

[@mrs.halchalamet7733]

People who like giving their 2 cents on everything. I have one for you too. Does this thought ever crosses your mind that people who work in the industry all the staff of ador senior kpop idols and even 4th geb kpop idols all have shown support for newjeans indirectly or directly. Even the korean genreal public have sided with newjeans. All these people now this industry more than us as they are seeing it more closely and have more information about it which we as spectators will never get to know. Dont be such a loser and shit on innocent girls saying they are groomed and shit what they have done takes a lot of courage so many idols gets mistreated and say silent. And what's wrong in saying that min is an irreplaceable part of newjeans. As a bunny I plus 1 on that. There would have been no bp without teddy and you can also see how the girls were so thankful to him in their docu calling him the 5th member of bp, you don't drag them the same way not them I am inferring that you should I hope you understand why i used them as an example. Min had created nwjeans thats a fact it is her brain child. I just hope they have the last laugh

[@cookie-hz9fx]

EXACTLY WHAT IVE BEEN SAYING. THESE PEOPLE WOULD BELIEVE HYBE OVER ANYONE

[@Melissa-v5u]

At least Blackpink don't act like they can't live with Teddy.

[@mrs.halchalamet7733]

@@Melissa-v5u are you dense ,when did the girls say they can't live without her. They just stated newjeans needs min which is true.

[@cookie-hz9fx]

@@Melissa-v5u but we all know bp would be nothing without teddy

[@mrs.halchalamet7733]

@@cookie-hz9fx I thinks that's too bold of a statment. They would have definitely been popular but teddy literally made them stand out from the crowd in terms of music.

[@BaraSunshine]

Please protect this young girls. Bunnies it is all up to you

[@BOSS_567]

they're so brave but tbh im afraid abt their career after this😢hope everything gonna be okay.Stand with NJ

[@Dxodxo738]

I would never get this much courage 🥺😭 now i learn from the girls that are 5 or 7 yrs younger than me 🤌 theyre so brave to do thjs im proud of these girls and this is what idols need to be like ...

[@yeahdude100]

Supporting Newjeans all the way please please stay as a group❤❤

[@gamingmyst6968]

This all happened because of MHJ this is why that manager from the other group told him to ignore them. What they did is brave yeah sure, but now they're going to lose their jobs

[@LixLyn-n5j]

Honestly am so proud of this girls for speaking out unlike a lots of groups,no comparison but idols should be free to do whatever and speak their mind and not to pretend or deceiving which the industry/companies forcing them to,love you gurls,I hope things change for better❤and idols should be able to interact without issues,especially with other groups without making things and asking them to apologize for unnecessary things,I feel like the industry are the ones giving those weird fans chances to judge them and forcing them to not be real,and be themselves,kpop is now like a prison school,they need to let idols be free,they need freedom,and care love and support,no one is perfect they’re trying to be their best,kpop need to come to reality and be normal,setting hybe as an example but am referring to any other company,if y’all keep doing things like that,a lot of people will drift away from kpop,like the way its happening already 😔

[@User7hugfrji-o4d]

하이브 내에서 따돌림은 실제로도 일어나고 있었다. 팬으로서 너무너무 화가 난다. 왜 소속사는 이익을 창출하는 아티스트를 보호해주지 않는가.

[@bookie9757]

They only need their money this industry is dangerous and disgusting and things like are bound to happen

[@User7hugfrji-o4d]

@@aintnothing-vh3yc I feel like they were bullied because Min Hee Jin was in charge. Newjeans was treated really unfairly.

[@myjsfordays]

​@@User7hugfrji-o4dmhj tho brilliant lacks humility in my 'personal' opinion. and idea with no funds and support is only an idea. nwjns is her brainchild and that they're successful is undeniable but so is my first point.

[@SrZechs]

Yeah sure kimchi

[@WiseTreeJhs]

@@myjsfordays She has tried her best to protect those kids and has fought for them. If she had been humble, she wouldn't have been able to fight. If HYBE hadn't discriminated from the beginning, Min Hee-jin would never have had to come to the forefront.

[@foodgirl69]

We never know what happens in the background. So please don't blame the girls they are still really young and just want to follow their dreams.

[@xecor4450]

they dont just want to follow their dreams, they also want mjh and not want hybe. I wonder how that got in their minds.

[@yasminFaisal-qy9gi]

@@xecor4450wth? it clearly shows that mhj actually gives a fuck about them rather than hybe since they literally expressed that in the video.

[@user-by3nd4rm6c]

@@yasminFaisal-qy9gi We all understand MHJ gives a f*ck, the question is whether or not she's innocent enough to continue to foster and promote the groups musical identity, HYBE might not be the only guilty party here

[@your_mandie]

Someone was in the room with them and i can't deny that they may be manipulated to say all of it. Not the girls themselves turned on the camera, watch this moment attentive! And Hyein was also looking at someone behind the scenes.... Poor NJ 😢❤

[@LoveButterfly999]

I honestly wouldn't mind if NewJeans decided to disband in the future because I don't want these girls to be around Hybe anymore that is known to over work their idols, degrading girls/women, cash cow-ing their idols, stealing art, unprotecting their idols and disrespecting their idols.

[@stellakatula1439]

Lool saying all this as if the woman they’re fighting for to be ceo hasn’t done all that and more. MHJ misogynistic ass literally laughed, made fun of an ex employee who reported one of MHJ’ work minon for sexual harassment and MHJ also called the victim a bitch. Mhj who made minor group Newjeans debut with a song about a boy eating their 🐱 aka cookie. MHJ who used Spanish terrorist group/act ETA as aesthetic for Newjeans song with the same name even went as far as naming the characters in the MV after the leader of ETA, his wife & Child. She even filmed the MV in Spain. MHJ who used the tragic car accident of famous rapper Lisa Left eye’s death as an aesthetics. Lisa left eye who died in a red car when she was filming a doc in partnership with Coke. MHJ thought that tragedy was a great idea for Newjeans MV where the members crash their red car with similar built. With similar scenes as the documentary of Lisa’s last day. It f course the Coke was also filmed the same way. How sweet of course wasn’t just a MV but like most of Newjeans MV it was an ad for Coke. The level of disrespect to left eye is not even human anymore. MHJ who lied and named dropped illit so they can get hate & Newjeans gets sympathy points. By saying illit copied Newjeans copied HER, when nothing about Newjeans is original and never done before. Newjeans being parts from the 80s-90s-00s taken and just recycled in 2022. Majority of things MHJ claiming hers is just a bunch of ideas that was created by the black community & culture which this Asian woman is trying to take credit for. illit ended up getting hate & death threats cause of MHJ. MHJ who mentioned Lesserafim and literally named dropped Sakura and Chaewon. Blamed them for Newjeans not debuting first/later debuted. Blamed them for a lot of things including things that happened when the girls weren’t even under HYBE yet and was still in izone. Made up lies about lsf taking opportunities from Newjeans which helped officially kick start the lsf hate train. People sending the death threats, calling them slvts, saying they ceo personal S3x toys, wished death on LSF families abs so much much much more. MHJ who called her own “daughters” stupid, threatened to hit them if they didn’t thank her in their speeches, called a member fat, called then airheads who don’t know nothing but looking pretty. MHJ who said Minji isn’t as pretty now compared to when was younger, when she was a minor. MHJ who called you their fans brain dead stupid moron who’ll eat up and believe anything she says MHJ who kicked a girl out of the debut team because her shaman told her to over eye bags. MHJ who thinks this shaman has the soul of her dead sister and uses them to make every decision in her career. MHJ who’s obsessed with minors/little kids with their childlike un matured bodies. MHJ who didn’t tell Shinee they were gonna be shirtless for their photoshoot so they don’t exercise and build muscle, so they can instead let their childish body shine with its boyish charms. MHJ who was behind red velvet ice cream cake creative directions with a freshly debuted 16yro Yeri. MHJ who was behind a lot of SM groups questionable work that involved minors. MHJ loves to take inspiration from a minor Brookes shield, minor Nicole Kidman, lolita and many pedo related content. MHJ who has pics of a minor Brooke hanged up in her house as well Pedo movies/books. And pics of naked women all over her house which she invited all the members since they were all minors and likes to hangout alone with minor member Hyein because it makes her feel young again.

[@stellakatula1439]

@@PriyanshuSingh-w1qwow congrats you discovered what actually live singing sounds like

[@michaelblue4619]

@@PriyanshuSingh-w1q haha the good singing was never live. you think their produce 48 was live, but it's not. People don't sing like that when dancing hard live. They record it before the show without dancing first then they dub it over to make it sound more realistic. Gone are the days where they lipsync to studio tracks. These days they lipsync to live singing but it's sung and edited before the show.

[@Sahwa__kouhei]

Now am getting ,hybe was soo jealous of new jeans from the start . Hybe didn't showed faith in new jeans from the start ,but after they got famous hybe was ready with their backup plan illit . Hybe was doing all these planning plotting . Everyone can feel what's going on ,no artist of hybe is making reels or shorts with new jeans , they are loosing their team members , hybe saying its for them ........how ?? They can't even protect their artists .girls coming this forward is soo brave of them . ( And I also want to add because lots of comments about BTS are commenting ,it's not about BTS , why people who like BTS feels like it's their duty to stan for hybe ,even if hybe do wrong . Why army ,you feel it's like your duty . BTS are artists too ,they made it from 0 to 100 ,and whenever they got mistreated we always there for them . Then why when we try to protect other groups , army's feels like we are against BTS and only BTS deserve protection . ) I don't want to be in fight with anyone just because of kpop because I don't know you guys personally, but it's just my thinking because I love new jeans and if I believe in them i support them . Like you might will do for you favourite groups .

[@AnjaliSingh-ug6qk]

What are you saying girl. They appear in BTS song

[@danireinn]

i don't think hybe was jealous of newjeans, they have many groups which are way more popular and influential than newjeans. If anything hybe is TERRIBLE at managing groups and giving them the support they need

[@AnjaliSingh-ug6qk]

@@danireinn and i feel it's only happen after New jeans and mhj accusation. Because all group under hybe are happy and if they feel mistreated then they will also come forward. It's happened in every job.

[@MaddyTyler_]

El que trato de llevarse a newjeans ilegalmente no fue hybe sino mhj, si critican a uno el otro tampoco se salva, realmente alguien con buenos principios dañaría a otros para poder sonreír al final de día, crees que eso es ser buena persona? No es diferente a como califican a una empresa

[@lalina11]

@@AnjaliSingh-ug6qk WATCH THE FUCKING LIVE . THEY WERE LITERALLY SAYING IT HAPPEN SINCE THEIR DEBUT

[@SKZbunnyy]

Newjeans mean so much to me, I love them so much as a bunny and I really hope they will be able to continue together for a long time, I stand with Newjeans ♡

[@user-zw3pg7nl8yj]

if you want your artists to cooperate with you, first act like your age and handle things maturely instead of mistreating them. nj are very brave for speaking about this because they are clearly hurt.

[@wadiputhere]

How is it mistreatment? Being ignored? Oh wow, poor girls... siding with a criminal and getting all sad and shocked when artists dont want to be involved with them because of it. MHJ is a criminal, and she insulted those girls. She manipulates them into making them and everyone else side with her. Hybe put everything they have on their plate, yet they speak bad about the company that made them

[@Yurv-p3x]

There are many people who say that Newjeans can just leave Hybe, but they can't leave until their contract period is over. Hybe just want them to earn money for them, but inside hybe doent want to appreciate them. I hope MHJ to come back. She was the one who protected the girls.

[@golden_flower0901]

LMAOOOOOOO

[@Yurv-p3x]

@@golden_flower0901 LMAOOO you.

[@Ihatedululumin]

​@@Yurv-p3x😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 LMAO LMAO

[@beomiimi]

mjh groomed and manipulated them. NewJeans have no one but bunnies. That woman deserves to be in jail.

[@kevinappearshere]

Those people who say leave Hybe easily must have been living in their own bubbles and never been employed or something. GROW UP PEOPLE!

[@lavendertokkii]

What Hybe stans don’t realize is that you don’t know what goes on behind closed doors, we are not there. You do not know what kind of treatment these girls are receiving from that insane company. Hybe stans will always sound like losers when they openly diss Newjeans for supporting MHJ. All of this because Newjeans dominated the kpop industry and Bang is bitter about it because he didn’t have a role in their success. Hybe stans, stay mad. Newjeans deserves to work in a nontoxic environment, and clearly Hybe is far from nontoxic. I hope they leave that evil company.

[@Melissa-v5u]

Plz... If they want to they would.

[@NæptuneMy]

​@@Melissa-v5u??? What are you tyring to imply? They literally have to wait a long period before their contract ends, if that's not the solution they would have to pay a hefty sum to terminate it, people need to realize it's not always that easy.

[@blouptibloup]

​@@Melissa-v5uDo you not know about contracts? 💀

[@Melissa-v5u]

@@blouptibloup Can't u understand sarcasm? I meant that if they want to leave they would with the income they are making as Newjeans but they won't and Mhj won't let them cause they gonna be broke. But whatever, just pay up and leave if they are that desperate.

[@nathalytoledo6323]

You also do not know how much of this is true or false. After all, they are trained by MHJ, someone who lied several times and was exposed several times. When they talk about the mistreatment, you have 0 evidence to believe it is true, so sorry. You have no point. Because we do not know what is behind the screen, we cannot simply make a judgment. It is ALWAYS HYBE's fault.

[@varshas8525]

It is ridiculous how they are upset when a manager told another group to ignore them but support their ceo who literally dragged other group members through mud and led to their witch hunt by crying a victim publicly ...they are humans too ...what did other groups do to deserve such a treatment from your ceo in front of the whole world ???

[@IDK-Sean]

It’s sad what’s happening but but min hee Jin manipulated them to where they don’t see the bad that she’s done 😢

[@killme4795]

Min hee jin What did she do?

[@thecopycatcustomvintage]

How to crush your own career in one easy step.

[@ItAintJohny]

this is not an easy step

[@LeonJL00]

Well...they just signed their disbandment

[@joyr7502]

I’m so impressed by these girls. Like seriously I have MADE respect for NewJeans. May God bless them.

[@2.6.7.3]

Seeing them in this statement hurts my heart so much 💔