$3 VS $60 Colored Pencils | CHEAP VS EXPENSIVE! Which pencils WIN?

[@vincentknws]

Honestly what this taught me is I should use crayola for details and my more expensive ones for for shading and other technics.

[@secretfolders6069]

Or you could use oil based for details...

[@fnjf2901]

Polychromos are the best for details, way better than crayola, crayola’s lead is more likely to break, has less control and may not layer and can break your paper more easily

[@victoriaschneider6426]

U fu

[@0pianostudio034]

@mr noxious try Caliber lol Whenever I sharpen them I can just pick off the lead ☹️😢👽😩

[@serenityjewel]

Exactly, she's shows that Crayola layers fine and it's not going to hurt your paper just doing details. People just like paying more money to feel superior.

[@lir3379]

I only buy three "colors" of Caran D'ache - black, white, blender. Other elements to be considered for colored pencil general use (wax or oil) is room/color core temperature & humidity effects on paper mediums. Quality content in this video. Thanks.

[@vincentknws]

Yes I use black, white and blender more than any other color and the white actually shows up. Sometimes I use the cheap white colors to blend as well.

[@MileinaJuarez]

I can strongly suggest the Derwent drawing white and black. They’re known to be amazing. The white is even better than the luminance and not as expensive at all. I love that black and white.

[@rebekah1362]

I just discovered Holbein Works "soft white" pencil, out of prisma, derwent pastel, sargent charcoal white and polychromos it is the most opaque white pencil I've ever used. The lead is softer than them all, more buttery than prisma by far. If you don't have it, do try and see how it performs for you.

[@aribolden8006]

I completely agree with you. Although I also use Derwent Chinese White when I need to lay down a lot of color, it is absolutely amazing. For details I use Polychromos Black as the other two are too soft to be able to get really tiny lines.

[@VitasArtworks]

I think an advanced artist is able to use "bad" supplies and draw a great picture. But for an beginner it's more difficult to get good results with "bad" supplies. I think great supplies are a good investment while improving. With better supplies some things are much better and easier to work with. So I think also beginners should use good art supplies. Maybe not the most expensive ones.. But good ones. For example no artist grade but student grade art supplies. And I think quality is more important than quantity.

[@Morticia147]

Yes, you can make a beautyfull drawing but it will fade super quick - it's not worth putting time in this cheap crap if you take art even slightly seriously. They belong in coloring books thats it.

[@sf1292]

Meh I still suck... I think my ruler changes length every second fr

[@edwardhisse2687]

Lightfastness only matters when you're good enought to sell or put your work on the wall and have it sit there. Even proffesionals illustrators and designers don't waste money on artist grade if they know they will sell prints and not originals.

[@Miss_Distress]

Despite loving almost every media there is, I spent my adult life hating coloured pencils. Developing arthritis didn’t help, as I always found pencils too much strain on my hands. After getting into coloring with gel pens this year I wanted more flexibility and decided to test pencils once more. This time I watched some reviews and decided on polychromos. I am IN LOVE! And they are so forgiving which is the opposite of how I’d always found cheap pencils before. I’m so glad I tried and would recommend every beginner try good quality pencils first. Beginners need better quality. Professional artists can do more with subpar ingredients!

[@bunnysm]

@@Miss_Distress Polychromos are actually pretty hard I would say. Caran D'ache, Prismacolor, Arteza, and even Faber Castell Goldfaber are mostly wax-based and much softer. Just saying, this in case you wish to further reduce the strain on your hands. They all can be used together anyway.

[@campyarts]

Wow! I loved your work with Crayola, I might even prefer that side over Carandache especially for the $3 price.

[@parulpatel9179]

Ur art is amazing!! I just subbed

[@lol-je3kh]

HOLY SHIT THATS SOME GOOD ART ON YOUR CHANNEL

[@zhongli1139]

ur talented as hell

[@abcd-mo5mo]

ur art is so good wtf

[@Judyc6811]

WHOA! I LOVE YOUR ARTWORKS!!

[@MitoMitoDraw]

The Luminance and Polychromos pencils makes the "CHA-CHING" sound whenever I twist the pencils it into the sharpener.

[@gabib.1780]

They indeed do

[@dagoosetm3299]

Thats why i said screw sharpeners and use a craft knife 💀

[@beckywebster90]

I use the luminance for commissions and presents, I have the crayola 100 set and love them for color books, practice shading, etc. For the price, they are not bad. But I love my luminance, polys and DLF 😀

[@shortienoob980]

@BloopBulp Derwent Light-fast

[@hopibethelbaptistchurchpas7767]

Just remember lots of pressure can cause lots of wrist pain for some... So a mid range soft pencil can make hours of art more enjoyable. So if this you, remember that. Also God loves you.

[@EthosArts]

The final result turned out great. I wonder how well the white caran d'ache could finish blending/burnishing the Crayola side.

[@sinbincreations]

This versus video is the one I've been looking for! My kids and I (and my prismacolors) thank you ☺

[@saisiri1719]

Honestly to say, seeing your drawing without thinking anything else + your voice, is so relaxing and calming.

[@amandagermany5933]

Love how you really put both pencils through the paces. Great comprehensive testing.

[@peachion2]

I have always loved Caran d ache. The smoothness and feel of them makes it possible to focus on the art, and not on the pencil. Working with crayons pencils was always hard.

[@TheTerrylwg]

This is a brilliant idea for an episode! I love Crayola and have used them for years without complaint, but you showed me some things I had never realized before, i.e., the lack of dark colors and the shine compared to Caran D'Ache, as well as the lightness of the white and black in comparison. All very good to know.

[@Eli_withablueheart]

What this video taught me is that I just suck at drawing and my supplies don’t matter.

[@sinbincreations]

Me: Watch this kids, you'll see why my pencils aren't for you... Kirsty: *Does Kirsty things and makes me look like an idiot in front of my 8 and 10 year olds* 😑😅🤣

[@saritah5663]

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@jessica76311]

Hey Kirsty! I love your videos. I'd love to see a comparison for colored pencils(cheap and expensive), on different papers like cheap sketch paper and other expensive paper. Thanks.

[@blackbat908]

Pretty self explanatory, cheap thin paper obviously won’t take many layers. Just your common sense, Jessie.

[@grannysharp772]

My absolute favorite for coloring without using any blending solvents or blending pencils is Luminance then Polychromos. I use them together a lot.

[@Sawfly1369]

I love the side by side comparison. I wish more people done this.

[@we4r119]

It’s really great to see how many layers of colour you are using to create the detailed look you are going for. I had no idea that you need to go over the colours so much. I’ve learned so much from this video. Thank you. x

[@tailsprower25212]

Wow, I literally don't have words, I truly did not know you could make such beautiful artwork with crayolas. Now i feel really inspired. The art supplies really doesn't make the artist though it can help.

[@rebekah1362]

I actually can tell the drawing was done with two different pencils and tbh, I like the crayola side better. It looks more vibrant and colorful. Perhaps it's because she had to build up values more? It just looks richer and has more depth of color and doesn't look unnaturally smooth. It's a beautiful portrait study, she really showed what skill does with limited supplies. Nice work!! Great encouragement!

[@sixteen.candles.4644]

I like it too

[@kathleencommerford9664]

I swatched the crayola next to Fabre castell and some of the crayola were as good if not better but not all. As you said more vibrant

[@LuDogg805]

I use Cryola, RoseArt (out of business) and CraZart... all cheap colour pencils... but with them I drew a blue cloacked Mother Marie (11 x 14 inch) drawing which I sold for 250 USD. I like using cheaper colour pencils because I like to prove to financially-unfortunate people (just like I used to be), that a great artist can use anything cheap and still make a masterpiece.

[@RachelleByersArt]

Love the comparison you did showing the various techniques ❤️ probably my favorite part of this video!

[@AzzieSempai]

This video was so well made. Thank you so much Kirsty, it was a delight and very inspiring to watch :)

[@aspiringartistbomby]

Damn Now i have no more excuses I am just extremly bad with coloured pencils Back to the drawing board thinking about how to improve

[@alenapoupa5925]

Thank you for the helpful comparison Kristy! Any plans to review Castle coloured pencils? They seem to be gaining popularity and I'm curious as to how they measure up against your current favourites!

[@kayfjones23]

Thank you, this was so cool to watch! I've only really had Crayola and some other off brand colored pencils so far, but will keep working with them until I'm more confident and willing to spend more on the fancier stuff. :)

[@lindatannock]

For a little step up, have a look at the Arteza stuff! I got their 72 set of watercolour pencils for only £27. A smaller set is even more affordable (and more than enough!), and their regular coloured pencils very affordable, especially if you're on a budget and don't want to go crazy, price-wise. I only just found the brand recently through a YT video. Not Caran D'Ache etc quality, but affordable decent quality!

[@mindylafler3456]

I love doing light layers when I am going for blends. Some of my best pages are Crayola. I won't buy anything else for the kids ever! Other brands have tried, but Crayola is "the bomb" in student/cheap pencils. I will say I honestly prefer the Crayola side.

[@coldmonalisa7793]

The companies watching the video: “Write that down, write that down!”

[@WillowDalliHowlett]

Tbh, I find that on tiktok many people just hate “bad” art supplies, tbh I use every day sharpers pencils and pens you would find in a peep class

[@fiery.mercaba]

"14:10" -- Ah, yes, sharpening of the pencils! This is a major differentiating matter for sure. Indeed, unless using a more expensive sharpener than like what Kirsty recommends over a regular sharpener, most cheaper pencils seem to be of too hard of a wooden casing & more prone to cracking as the sharpener's blade cuts into it. And often regular sharpeners that the person sharpening turns the pencil in to sharpen the pencil tend to experience breakage. As usual, @Kirsty Partridge Art, fantastic artistry, gentle demeanor, such great willingness to share artistic insights, &, though I've been drawing & painting from I was a little kid, there is so much information you generally provide that I'm always sure to be reminded of something I had forgotten along the way (especially since I've not had as much time on my hands as in the past to do much art) &/or to learn something new. Be blessed. 🙏🏼

[@precilago3352]

The comnparison between the two highlights several expensive art on the map M outerly impressed. Z👍👍👍keep up the good pose as always 💯🔥

[@pihu6465]

U r the art teacher i want U helped me a lot

[@flymoon24]

Your comment about sharpening is very useful as I have already found issues with this using hand held sharpner!

[@AFinn-ds1qt]

Would be interested to see what happens if you leave this piece under a UV lamp for an extended period.

[@Morticia147]

I think it would'nt take very long to see a very big difference.

[@MrAsingh1989]

To be honest, if someone is meant to create masterpiece after masterpiece NOTHING can ever stop them whether the tools are: 1. expensive, top-of-the-line quality, 2.inexpensive, or of “lesser quality”, 3. Brand name 4. Generic brand 5.“Knock-off” 6. Original “Authentic” if the individual if gifted with: skill, accuracy, patience eye for fine detail, Dexterity Passion Compassion Hyper focused mind And Biggest of them all HUMILITY AND MODESTY No power in the can stop a maestro to compose a MASTERPIECE. There is by no doubt, Ms. Partridge is beyond blessed with these gifts! I would like to Congratulate her for all the time, hard efforts, ups and downs, extreme focus she has spent mastering her craft… She is extremely blessed and lucky to master what she loves. I wish I can have at least 1/10 of her talent. Thank you Ms. Partridge,

[@hahaha00000]

I'm amazed that you're consistent even with cheap colour pencils

[@rebeccawilliams2410]

Oh wow this was amazing. I actually preferred the crayola side. Im brand new to this and I will definitely pick up a pack of crayola tomorrow and have a play around. Thankyou so much xx

[@gaoasaurusg2159]

Perhaps some of your results are geographic or seasonal. As a blue water sailor working 90/90 ( 90 days at work on the ship and then 90 days off)...who likes to draw, I noticed a marked difference in my Crayola/Prisma/Faber/whatever was available for purchase in the country at the time b/c I needed to replace my most used coloures at different ports...during different times of the year and in different countries around the globe: temp/humidity having great affect. Note: The best set of pencils I ever bought was a super cheap set purchased in a grocery store in Vera Cruz Mexico. They performed the same everywhere. I would suggest doing this during each season. Additionly, I sharpen my pencils with a knife. I find it gives me more control and less waste than store bought sharperns. I have created in almost every medium, The only one I have found to be uneffected by temp/humid is making jewelry from glass beads and unwaxed dental floss( peyote stich ).

[@nicolarutherford9857]

I loved the finale result

[@nikahadasart3207]

Thank you for this video, usually I buy expensive professional pencils, but after this video I will change my mind

[@natalie.noodles]

This is pretty helpful-I use Crayola for realistic drawings....so this gave me some tips! I hope to get some nicer ones soon, because the Crayolas can be frustrating....

[@artisforus]

Woahhhh, I can't believe that it was made by 2 different brand. I think when someone look to it without watching the video they would say that it's made in just 1 brand pencil. Great outcome!!!!

[@chrisblevins755]

I can only hope and pray that my art will one day look anything like yours. It's beautiful.

[@SapigoDraw]

add practice to your to do list

[@rauchschwalbelp7693]

Crayola or however the cheap colored pencils are called in your country (because not every country has American brands) are usually made for children. Most of children have a very hard hand and can't adjust their grip and pressure very good. So the pencils have to be sturdy. I always wonder why so many art youtubers don't see that. You don't want a children's pencil to be soft. They would be destroyed in no time. And btw: You should turn the sharpener, not the pencil. Because when you turn the pencil, you push it around in the sharpener and it won't be so easy and smooth. When you turn the sharpener, you adjust it to the pencil and so the pencil doesn't get damaged. Especially since you seem to be quite....eager when sharpening your pencils.

[@stephaniejames-hall969]

Oh wow. I've been trying to prove to my art teacher that Crayolas matter too 😍😂 could I know what kind of power you use also?

[@vincentknws]

If she doesn't answer may I suggest building up is what helps alot.

[@joewoodchuck3824]

Crayola Lives Matter

[@mangoowtay]

@@joewoodchuck3824 haha, yes. 💚CLM💚

[@ladyseshiiria]

I never understood 1st comment or whatever. But I'm excited to see a comparison video!

[@sierrawander7108]

Recently started drawing again after 10 years of doing mostly computer-generated art. Bought the Crayola colored pencils. Personally, I find that the colored core breaks all the time whether sharpening or in use. They don't smudge very well. I haven't purchased any expensive colored pencils and probably won't. I plan on purchasing matte graphite drawing pencils. I haven't decided on what medium I'll use to do color work. An art teacher once told me that using cheap products can deter a learning artist. As a professional portrait artist, she said always use the products that you can afford. You'll always be striving for your best results Poor color products often produce poor color.

[@acelynntoelke6857]

I finally got a 72 pack of prismacolors and boy oh boy i love working with colors even more now! Before i only had crayola colored pencils, and i hated drawing pictures with color, but now i get super excited whenever i have free time to do art

[@ginabadeaux9319]

you are such an amazing young artist,i love to watch you create

[@mootpoint7053]

I don't care what you tools you are using. She LOOKS amazing!!! Wow you are so very talented!

[@mels287]

Thank you for being so objective in your explanations. I draw a lot with color pencils of all price ranges and you need to get a feeling for each kind of pencils. Once you have it, you can get great results even with cheaper ones. My all time favorites are the simple Crayola, Stabilo ORIGINAL, Castle Arts and Faber Castel Polychromos. The Caran d'Ache Supracolor are too firm mor my taste.

[@HuskyMama1009]

Well done! Great job explaining and demonstrating the sets! Since both have benefits, they could be combined in their strengths

[@m0m0withth3big3y3s]

This video really shows us that she can create great art even with cheap supplies.

[@blueviolets2022]

she could probably throw pencils at a sheet of paper and it come out a beautiful portrait! lol

[@theequestrianedits755]

I don’t know how your art is so good and realistic I try but they come out rubbish

[@NotThatBob]

I really liked this video. I will use Crayola for test drawings, figuring out color blending and background 1st layers. I think I save so much on supplies because the Crayolas do a good part of the initial work. Lastly, I won't put more than 2 light layers of Crayola simply because I'm worried it'll ruin the paper or somehow ruin the layers of Prismacolors. I think I'm being silly but I love the look of the Prismacolors.

[@sixteen.candles.4644]

The otherside looks softer.. But both are great. This vid shows me no matter what you have if the skill is there a masterpeice can be made.

[@thambaarts319]

You are really good at this

[@ChrisTheCritter]

To get a deeper black with Crayola, I layer with 'deep space', a dull blue hue found in to 100 pencil box.

[@ESUTERURE]

I bought the Crayola colors of the world recently. Haven't used them yet but from the reviews I'm pleased at my purchase.

[@fireberry1406]

What I learned from this is cheap can work if you have skills in shading and layering

[@franciscocontreras4450]

24:42 in video duration, you did such a magnificent job!!! 👍

[@WolfmanWoody]

You are a superb artist to produce a painting like that using the cheapest of cheap pencils. Absolutely marvelous. TBH, I even prefer the Crayola side, but that's looking at a screen. I understand it is different looking at the actual painting. FULL MARKS though!

[@sojiealmozoghi7783]

Can you draw a portrait with the light behind them like at sunset or something please?

[@magnuskallas]

From what I understand the main "thing" about higher end coloured pencils is the benefit of getting less "greasy" gloss. Same applies for black pencils, as I've learned from other reviews.

[@Morticia147]

No, the main thing is that they are LIGHTFAST and available open stock!

[@ChandrewsArt]

Some crayola pencils are lightfast! And some professional brands have certain colors that aren't! (I'm looking at you, prismacolor pinks.) Doing your own lightfastness tests is a great way to tell. Manufacturer lightfastness ratings can be a little iffy sometimes.

[@FernCurtis]

When working with any pencils, but especially the Crayola pencils, I always “buff” the image a bit and that gets rid of that “garish” shine.

[@sandyharless6936]

What do you use to buff the image?

[@MSharizyn]

When I use a sharpener, I turn the sharpener and hold the pencil still. It gives more control and better feel for when it's a good point.

[@randystache78]

You are a thorough tester! Absolutely love this comparison! Keep up the amazing work!

[@KashiGirl911]

Do the two types blend well together? ..so that you can use the more expensive ones for blending and add in details with the crayola?

[@pauljs75]

Depending on the nature of your projects or the type of art you do, another aspect is the ability to acquire individual colors outside of a set. (Some colors can and do get used up faster.) Sometimes that depends more on brand than price, but you're more likely to be able to do so with a more expensive artist's brand rather than something intended for kids or amateurs.

[@serenityjewel]

I like the Crayola side better but that shine is a no no.

[@AYYngel03]

Crayola is best for either beginners or cartoon artists, but for realism, it's gonna be quite a challenge. I tried them on brown paper and they are vibrant, same for black paper(depending on the brand of black paper), the white doesn't apply on the crayolas, but blending and layering is great. They're not lightfast, so I recommend putting them in a folder or anywhere that is dark(like your drawers), so light won't fade the colors.

[@sunilsamtani2629]

I loved ❣️how you explain very clearly...

[@DeathsAsylum.DW300s]

The softness depends on the color due to the contents/ingredients to produce that shade/color.

[@melbright100]

this is a great tutorial i personally prefer the prismacolor but this gives good contrast to the different brands of pencils

[@ivmara9987]

If you're a pro or semi-pro artist, especially when you're taking commissions, don't just stick with the Crayolas and Faber Castell Classics or any kid's colored pencils, because your beautiful artworks made from it's pigments may turn into a waste when it fades, so switch to Polychromos and Luminance or Derwent lightfast instead. Lightfastness is still the most important at the end of the day.

[@yvonne_gao]

非常感谢你的留言

[@ivmara9987]

@@yvonne_gao what?

[@gtfoffmyproperty]

@@ivmara9987 "thank you very much for your message" that's how youtube translates the comment.

[@gtfoffmyproperty]

@@ivmara9987 I don't speak Chinese though

[@sagatisbeast]

You're amazing, wow. I use to think, not having the best material's were the reasons a drawing or painting would not come out looking good but you and another artists have shown me, that it's about the technique/skill that makes a drawing/painting not the material's. Side note. I know having better material's does help but it isn't the end all be all in my opinion. Take care 🙂 ❤ God bless.

[@WeblightDreams]

The comparison we all needed. Great video, enjoyed it very much. Both sides came out very beautiful.

[@Drawing_with_lillian]

It’s the artist that make the supplies good. Not necessarily the supplies.

[@prarthanarajan1152]

Wow. I love this picture. I hope my loved ones will get me the colored pencil academy subscription this Xmas.

[@dod1046]

Kirsty, I appreciate your information generosity. Thank you 😊

[@evelynm.8967]

Oh wow, the quality differences between the two sets are so obvious when shown side-by-side. I went with Faber-Castell Polychromos pencils. They look so creamy without even picking up a pencil.

[@vandrujemesk8651]

Great video and comparison of different crayons. I've watched older videos so far and now I've noticed a new hairstyle. I say it makes you younger. A complete young girl.

[@exlynaesthetic5609]

Well I’m gonna be honest but crayola has a really good detail and good but also does carandache also has a good thing but I think ima go With crayola

[@stateofdisorder1]

What I learned is that you are an AMAZING artist!

[@artifexmom3824]

Wow! That’s beautifully done and yeah, you’re right about the 2 products. ☺️❤️ Keep safe.☺️🙏🏻

[@abigailhumes4608]

Beautiful comparison!

[@christyschoonens2470]

Kirsty you are amazing at art you are literally my biggest art idle

[@severussnape4378]

To be honest, it just requires talent.

[@RADC00N]

I see no difference, that’s how talented you are.

[@chartreusecat6642]

My personal opinion, for what it's worth- both sides are equally gorgeous, just different

[@lm4112]

Prisma colors pencils feel so good though.... Its like creamy butter comingnout of the pencil

[@aashikachawla5826]

OMGGG I lovee your English accent Kirsty

[@kshrali]

Well, I use Crayola for darker areas and expensive ones for other technics. Same as pastels.

[@fuzzydragons]

crayolas were my first coloured pencil supplies and they did work pretty well when learning, then i progressed to more expensive pencils. you dont need to pencils that costs a lot, but they def can help

[@theleechqueen]

Impressive. It really comes down to one's skill and knowledge.

[@moramorandobianchi7093]

Amazing! Besides the comparison, which was very informative, but you are very talented!

[@Anthony-gq7dk]

great demo and superb portrait , well done Kirsty , excellent artist

[@Abby-th2or]

You are so incredible. As a young artist, I love your videos so much and wish that I could meet you. Thank you for everything you’ve taught. God bless!

[@pseudonamed]

thank you so much for this, very useful to help decide whether it's worth investing in more expensive stuff. My takeaway is: learn and practice and experiment on cheap pencils, then invest in mid-range like maybe Faber Castell when you want to upgrade, or want to maybe have higher quality for your best work or work you want to give others.. then save the super expensive stuff for if you are actually making money off the work, then it's justified.