351: Who Owned Fadak: Lady Fatima or the Muslim State? | Our Prophet

[@Thaqlain]

Are you dependent on KZbin and social media to gain Islamic knowledge? Download the Thaqlain App today by visiting app.thaqlain.org Also, if you found this content beneficial, please take a moment to donate at thaqlain.org/support.

[@tasneembootwala8308]

Allahumma Salle ala Muhammad wa aale Muhammad

[@sonabarnes6670]

Good, alhamdulillah. This subject needs to be brought forward. 👍

[@rabbannibey1128]

Agreed.💯✅

[@MultiAmmar2000]

يا مُمْتَحَنَةُ، امْتَحَنَكِ اللهُ الَّذِي خَلَقَكِ قبل ان يخلقك فَوَجَدَكِ لِما امْتَحَنَكِ صابِرَةً وزعمْنَا أنَّا لكِ أوّلياءٌ، ومصدّقونَ وصابرونَ لكلِّ ما أتانا بهِ أبوكِ صلّى اللهُ عليهِ وآلِهِ وأتى بهِ وصيُّهُ، فإنّا نسألُكِ إنْ كُنّا صدّقناكِ إلاّ ألحقْتِنَا بتصديقِنَا لهُمَا، لنبشّرَ أنفُسَنَا بأنَّا قد طهُرْنَا بولايتِكِ .

[@Better-editz_]

Inshallah you make more lectures

[@Thaqlain]

Ilahi Ameen 🙂

[@shia__313]

Mashallah agha Jan . So I checked your apps on Google very interesting ❤ Specifically the news section.you share that janaza Ayatollah shikh Mohsin Ali Najfi. We are All student Very tn..... I reading the mandrasa of shikh Mohsin Ali Najfi❤.

[@fsz88]

❤🤍🤍🔥🔥

[@rabiasaeed2206]

Quran is beyond Time and Revelation its message is Applicable till end of Time make it simple. The critics will never be satisfied no matter what evidence is presented. My Stance about this Dispute among Muslims.

[@baraslim]

Brother Could you please ask sayed muhammad baghir about controling fadak land in the time of sayidina imam ali become caliph We heard (common knowled) that sayidina imam ali do nothing on it (I do not believe that) Even marwan ibn al hakam (sayidina uthman son in law) control it before (era sayidina uthman as caliph) And marwan was also the one who wages war in bashra (jamal) and siffin with Muawiyah So after siffin prace treaty, Hejaz (fadak position) was control by sayidina imam ali Thank you

[@Thaqlain]

As Imam Ali said, both the oppressor and the oppressed had passed away.

[@baraslim]

@@Thaqlain Ok 2 caliph and sayeda Fatimah? What you mean about sayidina imam Ali said So... Who control fadak? I believe will not on marwan control as previous caliph did... Who control? (As I told, our ahli sunnah side always claim that sayidina imam Ali do nothing on fadak... I already told... I do not believe that... Is impossible to abandon such us great money) That was I mean Hope u understand brother And hope sayed can explain it

[@thelordknows]

​@@baraslimThe reason Imam Ali did nothing and he himself said was because if he did anything, the people ​would accuse him of worldly desires. He even said "what will I do with Fadaq or any other worldly position". Read his book called Nahjul balagha, in letter number 45.

[@baraslim]

@@thelordknows So who control fadak? It is impossible that wealthy fadak will abandon Leave alone untreated It is impossible in marwan control I do not believe sayidina imam Ali not aware this matter ### Sayidina imam Ali was the most knowledgeable and cleaver, most iman and taqwa and know how politic and society After Rosulullah saww We learn how politic (ruler) corrupt history Who ever control the board, control the crowd History made by ruler/winner

[@Thaqlain]

As if Imam Ali was thirsty for control. One has to understand the mindset of Imamah. For that, this clip should help: kzbin.info/www/bejne/eqmnY2CXaNudq5I

[@thecritiquer9407]

Prophet gifted land to many sahabas. there were many sahaba's land that was taken back by Caliph Umar back stating it belong to muslim state. so even is this wrong act? y it appears like Umar's rule was c😂mmunist

[@thelordknows]

The Fadaq land was exclusively given to lady Fatema through the order of Allah swt. Many sahaba may have lands but it wasn't Allah's order to them to acquire that land.

[@syedalizaidi5391]

If you’re comparing Fatima (as) to sahaba you need to reevaluate your Islam. Her status is above all Sahaba as she is the leader of women in Paradise - have some respect. Her land getting taken is 1 Million times worse than a sahaba’s land being taken. Umar taking people’s land is also unjust as he has no authority over what the Prophet previously did.

[@thelordknows]

@@syedalizaidi5391 did you even read my comment?? When did I say she was above the sahaba. I'm not comparing her status to the sahaba. She is well above the sahaba. Stop putting words into mouth please.

[@syedalizaidi5391]

@@thelordknows My apologies, my respond was meant for the original comment 🙏🏽

[@Thaqlain]

Were the rest of the companions 'part of the Prophet'? Was their anger and happiness the anger and joy of the Prophet? Were they the ones for whom the 'Verse of Purity' was revealed? And yes, if he confiscated private lands unjustly, then an injustice is an injustice.

[@saidkhan5086]

I'll advise sayyid, to stop quoting Shi'a reference

[@africa241]

He quoted one, and everything else was Sunni sources. There is no problem at all in doing that.

[@Thaqlain]

And what is the reason for such advice?