Mystery on County Road M | Full Episode

[@48hours]

Click here to watch more “48 Hours” full episodes: kzbin.info/aero/PLcFHkKbd_jTJiRmfUfLX2Ay_hnf5j3cxH

[@AlexSvidesskis]

How about some new stuff. An why are all the episodes quilty. Aren't there any where there innocent at the end?.....

[@picilocarnal]

Sorry, but I think he is guilty.😓

[@picilocarnal]

@@AlexSvidesskisthose cases shouldn’t make it court. If they’re not guilty, they shouldn’t even be charged.🙄

[@caoimhehayden5214]

@@AlexSvidesskis

[@AlexSvidesskis]

It happens all the time tho ​@@picilocarnal

[@gj5990]

Daughter just said dad doesn’t lie. Yet they caught him in multiple lies.

[@bonnielarson4160]

Lies that make no sense, over and over.

[@maryjane4432]

Yeah hopefully they will realize soon dad isn’t a good person.

[@vladimirthenailer2035]

Not everyone can answer questions under pressure I’ve seen a man condemn himself before for something has nothing to do with.

[@Ellewatch-y3j]

She will overlook anything because she doesn’t want to believe he murdered her Mother

[@janpierzchala2004]

I decided - after verdict in first minutes - not to continue with the feature, reading from many that he's a liar. If he wasn't a liar the case would become so exciting.

[@Laura-tp8wz]

Didn’t the kids have anything nice to say about their deceased mom?😢 RIP Barbara 🌸

[@dk237]

Right!

[@angelinat6816]

Right, seems like their dad has been manipulating them for a long time

[@jean9l187]

Good point. And they had harsh words for the aunt who spoke at sentencing.

[@straightforward]

They loved them both...isn't that nice enough?

[@nanaman]

The mere fact that they had zero interest in speaking up for her. Gives the impression that they were NOT ALLOWED to do so even while she was still alive. Domination of women controls the “whole” of the family.

[@dspencer5211]

It’s such a waste of time interviewing the accused’s family members. They are blinded by love and loyalty to the point where they don’t realize how irrational they sound

[@lorishu48103]

It can help us in dysfunctional upbringings to see this denial in others so we can have any hope of seeing through trauma bond in ourselves but no not helpful to a court inquiry

[@beancheese3148]

Yeah it does bring some more negativity their way but it’s also nice to hear the other side’s objections. I think their statements helped me solidify the fact that he did this and the kids never knew what was happening behind closed doors.

[@internetcensure5849]

👍

[@mogbaba]

You like only to hear convicting statements?

[@evaj7567]

Exactly that’s exactly what I think too, don’t they see all the evidence like they’re so blinded by family and loyalty

[@keepitsimple4629]

Todd said he was going by 2 friends' homes to fix windshields, yet his wife had to be at work at 8. Why would he make her late? Cause he was lying.

[@remycallie]

The clincher here is that he was going to make her late, yet she didn't call to say she would be late. You could possibly imagine that he asked her to go with him so he could pick up a truck (then she could drive herself to work in their car) but why not just leave a half hour early so she wouldn't be late? And if for some reason they couldn't leave early, she would certainly call the school to say she would be late.

[@keepitsimple4629]

@@remycallie exactly.

[@theresa78201]

He clearly wanted to go to a rural area where no cameras would record what he planned to do.

[@Valeria-mq3qn]

❌1) friend needing his services ❌2) other friend needing his services ❌3) his wife needing to go to work/different direction not giving her coworkers the heads up ❌4) THE SCRATCHES ON HIS NECK There were more but I don’t want to type all of it. I genuinely was and still am trying so hard to see things from their children’s perspective, but all of these things aren’t adding up. ❌5) He never gave a *solid* or *logical* reason as to why they were there in the first place. Either he is up there on the “Unluckiest People In The World” list, he was hiding something, or he is guilty. So sorry for his and Barbara’s kids. So sorry for Barbara and all of her loved ones.

[@oldhickory4686]

I'm curious about life insurance, and if he needed to make it look "accidental".

[@sarahs5340]

The scratches on his body and neck, the fact that no truck went by as recorded by the horse ranch surveillance cameras, the three different stories and outright lies he told along with her unusual injuries made me believe she was ended by her husband and the scene was staged.

[@blingqueen2235]

I take the recording of the truck driving by with a grain of salt because it could’ve turned off that road before the cameras, but I agree with everything else you said. He def looks guilty.

[@countfosco8535]

She was ended? You have all the makings of a jury foreman.

[@EnglishItaliana]

The pipe was blown off a truck that does not exist or did not pass by their car!

[@aliciamarcel3620]

And changed glass for extra money. So he knew all about glass

[@shadywillow3308]

EXACTLY 💯 and where's the DNA from under her fingernails????? Did they not scrape underneath her nails in the autopsy since he had all those scratches?!?!? I've read and seen other cases where YES definitely that cricoid bone was shattered during strangulation!!!!! He beat her too all the bruises and scratches and the trauma to the back of her neck too!!!!!!! He did this and the jury got it right!!!!!!

[@gj5990]

My ex and I technically had no domestic violence/trouble issues anyone knew of. If I would have died they wouldn’t have known the truth of our relationship behind closed doors. I kept it from the kids, even my best friend till much later. They couldn’t believe he was two different personalities and would have thought I was wearing the pants (he would overly dote on me and act like I was the one in charge, in public). I started to secretly record the truth because I knew no one would believe me. So sad. I hope those kids find healing in the truth.

[@JY-tq8dr]

Oh wow. Your story has me thinking now. The one thing I could not reconcile is Todd had no motive. No infidelity and no financial issues and no record of abuse. But reading your story makes me wonder… was Barb being secretly abused and nobody knew it?

[@RachelDarleneGilliland]

I'm so sorry. I believe you.

[@dr.jenniferma3914]

This is what I believe was going on.

[@cindytrayer4279]

That’s the life living with a narcissist.

[@marshareed1438]

You’re so right! For 24 yrs everyone thought that I had the perfect marriage. On our 30th year I got free.

[@BlkMagickGaia3]

He flat out lied THREE times about why he was on that route and his kids don't see how problematic that is ? Wow

[@joannegregory3024]

Yeah his daughter actually said he doesn’t lie…… except he did

[@charlotted6247]

He hadn't thought out that part of his lie. Why were you on that road .. ummm well those stories will be verified ... He forgot about it. That poor woman.

[@muddydog6605]

These types of cases are doubly hard. Murdered by your husband then betrayed by your children. They know.

[@OneRyLove]

I wish they would’ve asked them about that lol they are delusional

[@brandisuperstar]

He's created a pathological mess! He believes his own lies, therefore his kids do too! Scary!

[@richardherdman2121]

So let me get this straight. A windshield installer blames the death of his wife on a freak windshield accident on his way to (3 nonexistent) windshield installation appointments?

[@missmicheleeexo2269]

😂 but his daughter says he never lies!

[@richardherdman2121]

@@missmicheleeexo2269 hahaha...I mean did he think because the first part was true everyone would automatically believe the other 2 lies?

[@artetface]

You got it straight 😏

[@helenmcdonnell2585]

Clearly not very imaginative

[@2msvalkyrie529]

Hmm....when you put it that way.....🤔🤔.??

[@jamessherosick2747]

It's kind of sickening to see how you can pay experts to say anything you need them to say.

[@tobyresch4189]

No surprise, the scumbag lawyer was the same guy who defended Avery.

[@jenniferl6553]

so true

[@pinky567]

That’s why they are called paid experts. I worked for a ENT dr. That was a paid expert. Emphasis on paid

[@anns1921]

Agreed! And honestly the word "expert" makes me cringe in any situation.

[@vernicemendoza661]

Why are they only reminiscing about their father and none of their mom? Just curious 🧐

[@JJ-iq8mi]

Could be editing.

[@jimwerther]

Because Erin Moriarty directed the interview that way. Somehow she thinks he's innocent. And Moriarty is a lawyer!

[@khadijahmuhammadkebe9062]

That is a huge assumption!​@@jimwerther

[@jimwerther]

@@khadijahmuhammadkebe9062 How so?

[@TheVeek192]

What knowledge do you think that the audience out here has. ''Just curious'' is such a lame tag on to questions. DUH. The question mark indicates that you want to know something. Just curious.

[@EvelynInColor]

"He doesn't lie" says daughter. But dad lied 3 times about where he was going...

[@JY-tq8dr]

The daughter saying “he doesn’t lie” is the worst! Everyone lies. It’s a fact.

[@StandlyRichards25]

@@JY-tq8drI don’t lie

[@Reservedintrovert]

@@StandlyRichards25You just lied

[@cchan4739]

As a medical doctor myself I think he is guilty as sin. When I saw the medical examiner's report and the extent of injuries... that sealed the deal for me. Glad he's where he belongs.

[@internetcensure5849]

Sin is not guilty by itself but those who do it are.

[@auzieblo]

​@@internetcensure5849 reeeaaaallyyyy? Wow, I bet you feel that making that comment makes you sound so intelligent and deep 🤭😁

[@angelinat6816]

@@auziebloand I bet you think you’re cool for this response🙄🤦🏾‍♀️

[@AidaShawJ.D.]

@@internetcensure5849oye vey! It’s just an idiom. Everyone knows guilty applies to the person! Karen! Or Captain obvious! Pick one.

[@AidaShawJ.D.]

As a non medical person, I think he’s guilty too. You don’t need a medical degree just read the medical examiner’s report and listen to his lies.

[@jasefernandez]

the kids are sadly delusional

[@es5605]

And their father is so selfish, expecting his kids to sell their homes and everything of value to pay for his defense and new lawyers. Dear kids, open your eyes, your poor mom suffered and died at the hands of your father. 😢

[@darma99]

Yup... How could the jury can see clearly that he is lying, but the children didn't even give a little suspicious? I mean forgetting where they wants to go that morning is already weird cause he remembers any other thing, but...lying 3 times?? How could they still believe him? Especially after there's a witness saying he didn't see any broken windshield?

[@Findpepperbridge]

Only parent they have left

[@tinamariewebb4449]

@@FindpepperbridgeI agree I think they are so afraid of losing the only parent they have left that they have convinced themselves of his innocence.

[@internetcensure5849]

blind affection for their killer father!

[@pjnix5618]

This dude totally beat his wife to death and then staged his version to cover up.

[@MT-oi2ty]

He looks crazy

[@MiGhost3]

Where were the skid marks going off the road? Looks like he parked it that way. If a pipe went thru the windshield, why did he remove it? It's that tampering with evidence? Did cops look for forensic evidence on the pipe?

[@jessicahannah2522]

@@MiGhost3 I'm pretty sure these competent, experienced, investigators covered those obvious things.

[@dianegreyson8787]

​@@MiGhost3 Both sides (twice) had to have looked into every bit, so it's this show that's skewing the story a certain way. Too many questions left.

[@alisongreen7576]

Daughter is asked about missing her mom and dad, and finally we see tears- over her father’s absence. When talking about her daughter, she says it’s sad “he’s not around”- not “they”. And she and her family can visit her dad, but her mother is dead….yet only the loss of her father elicits any emotion. That is really, really, really…..weird.

[@LionofJudah222]

That did not sit very well with me either. Their mother is gone, really gone; they can at least still visit their father... yet they only recognize the father missing from their lives??

[@MT-oi2ty]

They seem to favor their dad over their mum.

[@CircaBEFORE]

There is a chance their responses were edited out by 48 hours about their mother.

[@cycleoflife5849]

He has scratches on his body so have they not examined the nails of the deceased wife if there were skins on it?

[@irishecker]

good point! there's no mention of this

[@JY-tq8dr]

I agree!

[@m.mh92]

That was literally what I said out loud when I saw the scratches !!

[@pilarelkins6682]

Very smart...thats all they would Had to do. ...

[@bonnielarson4160]

theoremfact.wordpress.com/2017/08/01/barbara-kendhammer/ They did, his DNA was found.

[@HearMeowt_YT]

HE DID IT… its not complicated. No truck on video. His MANY lies. No explanation on why he was going away from her work, when she had NEVER been late without calling before.

[@MiGhost3]

She was already dead before he staged the accident.?

[@HearMeowt_YT]

@ yes

[@CB-vg1wq]

Also, she did NOT call her mother, like she always did. She was incapacitated.

[@MissyM3]

And the passer buy who didn’t see damage to the car or barb & todd

[@saritacruz3020]

What innocent explanation is there for him to lie, again and again, about his reason for going the wrong way? That's what I can't get past.

[@TawnyC_]

He's a pathological liar.

[@tylizzy8583]

@@saritacruz3020 Thank you!!!

[@namelessgrace6319]

Me too! That's the main thing that makes him seem guilty.

[@cathyprosser1050]

Exactly!

[@Kamase318]

🎉​@@TawnyC_How would you know if he's a pathological liar?

[@cheri7054]

If he killed her with a gun like kids suggest that would be to obvious he did it. So he takes a pipe and pretends it's an accident from the road. Glad the jury saw the truth

[@criminalitycollective]

Yeah I thought the daughter’s comment about the killing with a gun was troublesome. It’s too obvious like you said. She goes on to make other troublesome comments like her father doesn’t lie which he blatantly did and acknowledged in the case.

[@Steve-os3wq]

Exactly!

[@4catmom14]

Plus, it might not have been planned and it happened in moment of anger.

[@cheri7054]

@@4catmom14 I think it was planned. He takes her away from her job and claims he's going to get some wind shield from two to three other people.The people he was suppose to see said they never met or had plans to meet them. So why is he traveling in a distance that didn't make sense

[@Highland_Moo]

Guilty. I was a nurse and the ME’s report basically told the truth…..that she was killed by her husband rather than a random pipe puncturing the windscreen and her. Couple that with the scratches on him and the fact a truck couldn’t be accounted for. Also, he was caught out in many, many lies. I feel bad for the children, but their loyalty is misplaced. Their mother was killed by their father.

[@steelhurricane4041]

Freak accidents do happen.

[@ghanabaaremeyawabas3074]

​@steelhurricane4041 Oh keep quiet already

[@Aspectus]

"If this could happen to Todd, it could happen to anybody...that murdered their wife"

[@irishecker]

😂

[@bradduranso534]

Ok, I said this exact same thing outloud in the beginning of the video, right after that guy said it. (I included the same as you) which I was saying outloud to myself just as I'm scrolling through the comments and see your exact same addition. Too funny. My bad for the stupid long comment. I thought the Planets all aligned for a min there... 🤪

[@Aspectus]

@bradduranso534 🤣🤣🤣

[@Hof79905]

@@bradduranso534i thought the exact same thing 100%.

[@Eirini1]

@@bradduranso534seriously Guilty

[@WatercolorMama2345]

Hmmmm… a guy who makes his living with windshield replacement has a wife who dies from a pipe going through their windshield? Nah… nothing to see here 😎😎😎

[@KenyanBunnie]

Toad Pipehammer couldn't even get the pipe to strike the windshield one time to push his ridiculous story. How does a pipe from a speeding truck fly off and hit the windshield twice, the second time being the killer. Embarrassing.

[@sherylrodgers4817]

😂😂😂 nothing to see here 😂😂😂

[@EvelynInColor]

Right. And the kids are wondering why he would go through such trouble if he wanted their mom dead. Because he is familiar with it. It's not the same trouble for them or anyone else who doesn't have their dad's work background 🤔

[@ChiefVictor]

What are the odds right?

[@promogiftsa1269]

I was thinking the same Justice was served

[@Leila3i5]

medical examiner: the injuries are consistent with strangulation family: but why would he go through all that trouble of getting a pipe? cameras: there was no truck family: but why would he go all the way out of his way up north? defendant: I was going to replace so and so's windshield 3 independent witness testimonies:: there were no plans for him to come replace my windshield family: but that makes no sense! Why would get go up north where there are few people likely to see him? I still don't get it 🤦🏻

[@MatshidisoLutshaba-ge3lg]

denial is a river in egypt fr

[@bradduranso534]

As my grandpa would've said about the familys inability, or lack of comprehension on how daddy did all this. "The Apple don't fall to far from the tree." 😂

[@CoffeeCrazy]

Exactly, I personally feel that the greatest evidence was the lack of a truck. You could only see his car driving past the camera.

[@ivydickson7596]

​@MatshidisoLutshaba-ge3lg i think you are referring to cleopatra, in de Nile

[@auzieblo]

​@@ivydickson7596what??? Lol.

[@Nisie23]

Why he would go thru this trouble?!?! So he wouldn't get caught! Duh. Wake up son!

[@Janadu]

And the daughter brags about how many guns dear dad owned. Like if he shot her they wouldn't be able to trace it back to one of those guns. I think the daughter and son are a few bricks short of a load.

[@kkbartist]

​@Janadu honestly it makes sense when you've dealt with a narcissist father, the fog is so thick

[@ballistic350]

The worker driving by and saw no windows broken or them in the car, then that sealed his fate, hes guilty,

[@diox8tony]

the picture they showed during that.,,,I also didn't think the window was smashed..i was confused how they got a picture ahead of time, then i saw the smash...If i was in a car driving by, i may have never seen it, glare, overcast days with solid white sky...etc

[@Steve-os3wq]

Agreed!

[@Yusuave]

The kids are in denial, the evidence speaks for itself, sometimes people just snap

[@deealex1402]

ofcourse they are,they dont believe that their father would do this, yet almost in all cases like this 90% of the times, the partner is to blame. most of these cases are made by partner to their wifes. sad reality that violence againt the women is out of control,its case after case after case... so many female victims.

[@terrorsquadlith]

how did he stage this ? Explain

[@Yusuave]

​@@terrorsquadlithcan you explain why he gave conflicting stories about where he was going? He still couldn't get his story straight a year later during trial, so you really can't blame brain fog.

[@yyy-zn6xu]

the problem with what you said is that it is lacking motive to snap and no real investigation to the character of the person they suspect killed his wife...

[@Yusuave]

Don't forget the accident conveniently occurred out in the sticks where no cameras were present and he had no response for where they were headed and changed his story THREE times.

[@SonFlowrDayz]

There is literally NO truck seen coming or going during the timeframe their car went by…. That’s because there was no truck. If there is no truck, his entire story or recollection of events is now dismantled. It always amazes me how the children in these cases act as if their mother never existed in the way they stand firmly behind the dads… the evidence is clear. He killed your mother. They are in extreme denial and need therapy.

[@trudyburgoyne808]

Exactly!!

[@mrsbluesky8415]

They really didn’t even talk about her or missing her or show emotion about her during the interviews. But when talking about HIM, the tears flowed. Very strange. My parents died years ago and I still tear up when talking about both of them.

[@SonFlowrDayz]

@@mrsbluesky8415 at all! That was strange to me. I get that they have had a traumatic event occur and that is their only surging parent, but my God use your brain. And I am very sorry you are now without your parents. I will remember you tonight in my prayers ❤️

[@tinkietinkie2684]

They actually said there wasn't a truck seen matching his description, so there were trucks. Just a detail.

[@gailnovak2593]

If there was a truck I’m sure whoever was driving it got scared and hid it away for eternity, in a shed or barn.

[@lexiaaforever437]

I hope sooner than later his daughter will realize her father isn’t who she thought. She didn’t even express her feelings about her mother . That’s sad .

[@Olivaro10]

How do you know she didn't express her feelings about her mom? This could be editing.

[@jimwerther]

Erin Moriarty directed the interview to make it seem like dad's the victim. Blame Moriarty.

[@Lilithly]

What a horrible thing to suggest. She probably said loads of things about her mum, but how would we know?

[@TheVeek192]

The fact that they didn't talk about their mother in the video does NOT mean that they didn't talk about her in the interiew.

[@annazaman9657]

The scratches on his face, bloody knuckles, all the lies, different route to work, the strange injuries. Very . Plus the other truck would have happened to be going at an enormous speed for the pipe to enter the windshield like a spear

[@TheOneinthewoods]

A pipe can go thru a windshield going 55 mph

[@remycallie]

Geoffrey Loftus is the ex-husband of Elizabeth Loftus -- one of the world's foremost experts on memory. She has made a career of testifying for the defense by impugning the memory of eye witnesses. Here we have Geoff providing an opinion that helps the defense by saying that traumatic events interfere with the processing and storage of short term memory -- which is true. But knowing where you were going when a traumatic event happened isn't short term memory. If you were on a plane flying to see your new grandchild and something traumatic but non-physical happened (it was hijacked, it almost crashed into the ocean) you might be very confused (and even completely wrong) about a lot of the events surrounding the incident, but you wouldn't forget why you were on the plane. And you wouldn't change your story about it three times -- "I was going to see my grandchild...uh no I was going on vacation...uh no I was on a business trip."

[@Eirini1]

lol so true

[@dianecripps204]

I had a brain injury from a motor vehicle accident. Can't remember anything around the accident but can remember where and why I was going.

[@remycallie]

@@dianecripps204 Right, that is the typical pattern of a serious head injury. It's like turning off your computer without saving -- all the unsaved memory (that is, the short term memory that has not been transferred to long-term storage) is going to be lost. However, here we're not even talking about a head injury -- just the panic surrounding a traumatic event. That's going to keep you from noticing and/or remembering things during and after the event, but it shouldn't keep you from remembering what happened before, especially well before, which is when he would have decided not to take his wife directly to her school.

[@maxinef6654]

Why did he keep lying about where he was going?

[@carlotaestrada9869]

Sounds like Barry Morphew

[@jessicahannah2522]

I'm going to tell you something surprising, in case you're ever on a jury. The prosecutor definitely knows this. Memory of witnesses to a trauma event are very, very unreliable. Many have ZERO memory of what happened immediately prior. But our human brains want to fill in the blanks, particularly if someone is questioning us. We also want answers. This phenomena of witness memory around trauma events is very well known. There have been many studies done on it. Even in a class I took in college, they staged a well-known experiment around this. During a lecture, the doors burst open, and a woman and two men run into the lecture hall. They shout some words, they create a disturbance in several locations and in different ways. Then they run out. Everyone in the hall is asked to immediately write their witness statements. This is filmed by a uninvolved party to make sure of accuracy (before cell phones/cameras). A few days later, the professor shows us the results of the witness statements. It's been a long, long time but I'm remembering the basics here if not precise numbers. Of 80 witnesses, 10 remember a fourth person. There was only three. Twenty thought it was three men. It was two men and a woman. Seven said she was blonde. Fifteen said she had long hair. She actually had chin length brunette hair. Fifteen said she wore blue jeans and a yellow plaid shirt. She actually wore blue pants (not denim) and a BLACK shirt. Fifty said the two men were the same age or close to it. One was 15 years old, the other 28 years old. NO ONE remembered that the lights were briefly turned on/off (two seconds). Twice. Right down the line, a lot of discrepancies in witness statements. We all saw the same thing, and we all remembered different things. There were very few that got all the details correct. Thus, to this day, witness testimony is not greatly relied upon in many cases and can be disputed readily. Add in a traumatic event, and intense questioning, and the brain wants to fill in the blanks it doesn't know readily, and it's not hard to have someone 'lie' at the moment. I have no skin in this game, on this case. I don't know if he's guilty or innocent. But do not give so much weight to things like 'lying' or witness statements. Just like the construction worker who said he went by at 8 a.m. That is a start time for most jobs, was he late? Why did he notice it? Why didn't he stop to help if it was in the ditch? Was he speeding? Could he hear it happened on his normal route and just inserted himself saying he saw it? WITNESS STATEMENTS CANNOT BE TRUSTED.

[@michaelbiggs1254]

Todd is guilty. His kids are deluded. End of story.

[@JJ-iq8mi]

💯 %

[@eraldadevole]

How sad they’re this much in denial. Poor Barbara

[@redacted2275]

No, the death is sad, honey, not the denial... don't project your expectations in someone else's tragedy. That's foul.

[@a-wr4zi]

@@redacted2275 talk about projecting...

[@Eirini1]

@@a-wr4ziyup

[@rundogrun297]

Children rarely know the truth and details about their parents marriage

[@AltClev37]

I bet the wife was getting ready to leave him for whatever reason and he snapped. She had way too many injuries that he couldn’t explain. Also his hands and neck were very telling.

[@grandmaoldschool7011]

Yes, her autopsy was very telling. Covered in bruises was not from a pipe in the windshield.

[@Jkaye13]

@@grandmaoldschool7011 And yet there was testimony that there were no bruises noted on her in the second trial.. and that her injuries could have been the result of a car accident.

[@TwoTrees777]

I think this man's sexuality has been his biggest secret IMO

[@awesomebeautiful8782]

​@@Jkaye13it wasn't a second trial, it was an evidentiary hearing. And the Doctor Who testified in the evidentiary hearing did not conduct the autopsy, she was relying on photos.

[@240amar]

100 percent guilty. He took a different road and then this incident happened. How come they didn't find the so called truck ?

[@lunav9827]

Guilty! One day the daughter will see it . The son seems like he’s already there . May she rest in peace. Hope he rots in jail . His hands show the whole story .

[@Buchyvon1]

You picked up on the son, too? There was a time when the interviewer asked them a question and the daughter answered but the son’s eyes showed he knew she was wrong.

[@christinecupic6871]

I noticed the son was keeping a bit quiet!

[@BrooklynBaby-bl7mj]

this guy is guilty as hell and for me it's" changing the road for no obvious reason + no evidence of a truck passing by + we have a witness and a cctv footage " the kids are in denial because they lost both of their parents at once hope they'll heal from this traumatic event sooner

[@tolulola7680]

I feel like the son thinks dad is guilty, and he is just going through the motions....

[@HomeSchoolWithMrsJim]

It's written all over him

[@michaelm.3210]

Alas, when the daughter makes a point, and then TURNS to her brother, he just sits there silently. Seems strange, indeed.

[@bigg1091]

TRUE

[@sierrashere6957]

Right

[@tracyshaffer4510]

If he wasn’t guilty then why so many lies? You don’t need to lie if your innocent

[@sandrabentley8111]

Shock & horror.

[@maryanne7161]

​@@sandrabentley8111I still wouldn't lie even if I were in shock. When he knew he was the prime suspect, he should have spoken the truth cos the truth always sounds the most believable!

[@FredPorlock-1892]

@@sandrabentley8111🤣🥂well played.

[@ronaldwilson9525]

I’d love to give the guy the benefit of the doubt but why would she miss work when she never did? Why did the people he claimed to be doing work for deny that work needed to be done? The suspect was his own worst witness. I’d vote guilty if I was on that jury.

[@deidradahl2802]

Correct, also there was no truck going by.

[@sadiestoltzfus9798]

The problem for me is Todd had no motive for killing his wife.

[@ronaldwilson9525]

@@sadiestoltzfus9798 That you know of. Unless you can read his mind you don't know his real feelings or motivation.

[@deidradahl2802]

@@sadiestoltzfus9798 Well, only he knows.

[@Scorpio-unicorn14]

​@sadiestoltzfus9798 how do you know that?

[@SaraTHTM869]

My husband was the pastor that did this funeral. Heartbreaking for our community and church family.

[@TawnyC_]

And her kids.

[@skysix5733]

I appreciate your comment. So often in the true crime scene, these cases just become entertainment and armchair detective work (and I am guilty of that)

[@KenyanBunnie]

Y'all really believe he is innocent?

[@Emiliapocalypse]

I’m sure this was a shocking event for the whole community!

[@dianagonsalves]

Hope the children are able to move forward. This seems a sad tragedy. At least Barbara's safe with the Lord

[@runningdastreetsVA]

What a monster. He destroyed his whole family. Those poor kids are suffering so much 😢

[@alisong2328]

A father who loved his kids would not continue to have them use every dime to keep trying to get him out prison. He would want them to live their lives and have a good future.

[@vincedidiana5781]

Just playing devil’s advocate. Unless the father is innocent.

[@jenniferl6553]

@alisong2328 good point. todd doesn't love anybody but todd

[@jenniferl6553]

@@vincedidiana5781 seriously? he's GUILTY

[@vincedidiana5781]

@@jenniferl6553 I said I was playing devil’s advocate. I too think he’s guilty.

[@kkbartist]

​@@vincedidiana5781 honestly, even if I was unjustly prisoned I would still be like literally go and grieve and live and just visit me sometimes

[@Savage3OO6]

When something is flying at my head, I do not, nor would I ever, lean forward in an attempt to dodge it. I would lean to the right, left or backward 100% of the time. Since she was in a car seat with a headrest, backward was not an option, so I'd expect for her to move her head to the right or left. There's no way she received an injury to the back of her head from leaning forward when the pipe is flying at her.

[@gailnovak2593]

Could be from impact after the pipe hit her-these things happen in seconds-I doubt she even saw it

[@bohg9999]

23:14 "He has like 28 guns in the basement..." Very reassuring 😮

[@thjonez]

the logic 🤪 their brains went right out the windshield

[@IndelibleHD]

What's the problem with owning 28 guns?

[@sandrabentley8111]

​@@IndelibleHDI'll ask you the same question. Why own 28 guns? Weapons of death.

[@thetruthhurts-j7j]

@@sandrabentley8111 we have something here called 2A.

[@maryanne7161]

​@@thetruthhurts-j7jOK , but, 28 guns??

[@Komediennekymd2009]

I remember this story. He did it

[@marketwizard1977]

same...he is 100% guilty

[@Kari.F.]

The coffemug hit her in front of the throat and then flew around and hit her in the back of the head? And the pipe hit her in the front of the head AND the back of the head because she ducked? This truck with the pipe came TOWARDS them when the pipe fell off the side of the flatbed, hit the ground and accelerated towards the windshield of their car? This is confusing to me, because none of it makes sense. Nor does any aspect of his story. A lot of murders happen without an apparent motive. Maybe she wanted to divorce him? The wouldn't have been the first couple to put up a good show for the kids.

[@btrueeth]

Laws of physics outta the window!!

[@nicoledenning8090]

you nailed it

[@eddiehoppe]

Just way to many injuries for a pipe going straight through the windshield i think.

[@easternkiwiz]

Exactly, the defence's argument to explain back of the head trauma - oh she ducked. But if she ducked then how did she sustain all the frontal face and neck injuries?

[@larrynelson3329]

Guilty

[@MJ-ji6mv]

It always makes me incredibly sad for the deceased Mothers in these cases when the kids are die-hard believers in their dads, who are found guilty. I understand not wanting to believe your father is capable of such a thing and not wanting to lose both parents, but.. Where's the same love, care, and justice for their Mom?! It's like these murderous dads are idolized in their kids' eyes, and the mother falls to the wayside. I do, however, feel sad for the terrible position they are in. So sad

[@xxNinjaclanxx-id9rs]

Text book cognitive dissonance

[@Mary.Quantum426]

Yes, the Morphew case in Colorado is a perfect example of this. He's still free as they don't have enough evidence, and his two grown daughters idolise him.

[@awesomebeautiful8782]

Men like this raise their children to be as dismissive of others as they are.

[@headlessviolin]

I wonder if it’s because there dad is still alive and that’s all they have as their dear mum has gone just an idea

[@MJ-ji6mv]

@Mary.Quantum426 Yes ma'am, it is. I am always sickened by footage of them hanging on him and idolizing him. I think of Suzanne often and continue to pray that they do not stop pursuing justice for her. 🕊

[@sara32884]

He did it for sure. Taking a different route to replace a windshield (that no one needed) before dropping your wife off at work? That would've made her late. He's more than guilty...

[@jessicahannah2522]

God I hope you are never on a jury. Truly.

[@ghanabaaremeyawabas3074]

He sure fixed his screen to appear as though a pipe went through

[@FredPorlock-1892]

That son knows the truth. It’s in his eyes.

[@bigg1091]

True

[@normajoskenbeamora4747]

@FredPorllock-1892 TOTALLY AGRE WITH YOU FRED.BOTH OF THEM KNOWS WHAT HAPPENS, THE GIRL TO. WATCH WHEN SHE TALK AND LOOKS HIS BROTHER SIDE, JUST LIKE SAYING, DON'T GHANGE MY WORDS.

[@rayandowilliams1674]

I said the same thing his sister is manipulating him

[@sierrashere6957]

I thought the same thing

[@emilyholt1898]

I thought the same about the daughter. She knows.

[@doyouhearme8041]

Todd was on his way to change my windshield also and I didn't even have a car😂

[@jesussaves8965]

🤣LOL

[@gigiong]

😂😂😂

[@makeithappen1598]

😂😂😂😂

[@Eirini1]

lol 😂

[@akouviaholouvi8812]

😅

[@infiniteeservices9309]

Family never really wants to know the truth. Because all this evidence and some family members still don’t believe this man killed his wife. Guess it’s like when women are abused in relationships and think they are being loved. Nomatter how many people tell them it’s not right, 😢

[@earthrooster1969]

Speaking of which, most (normal) families work in ways of denial and status quo..

[@BellaLeoLicorice]

It is horrible to see their children in such denial, especially the daughter. It is like her mother's life meant nothing to her. It is obvious that Todd made up the story about why he drove there that morning and what happened. To me their marriage doesn't sound happy, nor perfect. Happy couples I've seen who are in good marriages have shared interests and friends and also have individual interests and friends, It is not healthy to be living in each other's pockets 24/7. It seemed like Todd was extremely possessive, who phones their wife every morning on her break at work? Poor Barbara never got the chance to relax and spend time with her workmates. From when she was 16. he was right there, every minute of every day apart from when she escaped to work and even then he dropped her off, phoned her and picked her up. She had probably finally decided she wanted to do something without him and I'd say that is what enraged him.

[@beautifulone5509]

There is so much that they didn't talk about. Like internet searches or talking to her friends.

[@chrisnoneyabiz4072]

There's a lot of codependent people out there. I've worked with so many people that have to spend every single break either talking to or face timing their partner. 😑

[@BellaLeoLicorice]

@@beautifulone5509 I always wondered if she had any friends or if she was meant to make do with Todd.

[@mimimonster]

Kids want to believe so badly that he didn’t do it. Poor kids. They deserved so much better and so did their mom. Such a shame. 😢

[@cherylstaples1790]

The cricoid fracture, bloody knuckles, THREE lacerations on the BACK of her head...he is a murderer.

[@marianalandivar3002]

He killed her at home. And put her in the car

[@donquixote8462]

Wow, you're probably right, that didn't even occur to me (or get mentioned as a possibility). Would make sense as to how he staged it so quick. She was already dead, he knew where he would drive to and try to stage the accident..also explained why she never made the calls she needed to make if running late.

[@Jkaye13]

With the son there..? Their son was grown, not a child.. he testified that they didn't even have words with each other, that it was a normal morning. It's pretty hard to imagine two people in a drag out fight for your life, and there not being any noise, or things broken and moved around the house.

[@jenniferkalchik6712]

I think he did it at the farm, they checked on right after they left their home that morning. He had to of done it in steps, he just couldn't of done it all in 5 minutes.

[@jimwerther]

He did it at a rental property they had

[@erikschultz6865]

Possibility. Which is why time of death is so important. (But that can only be a window at best).

[@SoonToBGoneGirl]

If I was on that jury I would have also found him guilty. He lied three times about where they were going that day. That to me would have sealed his fate as a liar. Second, why is there no trace of this mysterious truck? If a video shows their car going down the road then it should have shown the truck in question also. He is guilty.

[@jessicahannah2522]

Pay attention, if you are ever on a jury. Pay very close attention. First, there was exactly ONE blurry video from a distance. They even said "APPEARS to be SIMILAR to their car". Second, cameras fail. Or don't continuously record. Also, in his phone call to 911, he originally said he didn't know where the pipe came from. He said it fell from a tree or from a truck, THAT HE DIDN"T KNOW. Later he did say they had passed a 'flat bed type pick up truck". But the show doesn't say WHEN he said they passed it. What we see and hear on this program is cherry picked tidbits here and there, to support the verdict. All of them are like this. So you will not hear anything to convince you of their innocence. Just as we heard about two minutes of the evidentiary hearing post-conviction. We didn't hear all the evidence. or what the result was. They DID find a second pipe precisely like the one that hit the car, not fifty feet from the accident. The prosecution did tests to see if it COULD happen, and it showed that it could. They chose to not present that in court. Thus, no jurors would ever see that. Memory surrounding a trauma event is very faulty. VERY. Our brain wants to fill in the blanks with anything we know. It's a very well documented condition. He could be saying "well, I don't remember why I was on this road. I know someone who lives around here, must have been going to do work". I have no skin in this game. No clue if the man is guilty or not. I do not have access to all the evidence presented in court and without that (we only got the Reader's Digest version of the juiciest tidbits, for entertainment) none of us can determine guilt or innocence.

[@ShastaAnn]

I've been a court reporter for 37 years, so I've heard *a* *lot* of experts testify on just about every subject imaginable, and I have two things to say about experts: Number 1, no matter what opinion an expert has, you can *always* find another expert with the exact *opposite* opinion, and Number 2, if you ask ten different experts (who are experts in the exact same field) their opinions, you'll get ten different answers. Therefore, I don't put much stock in expert witness testimony.

[@jessicahannah2522]

Yup. I worked in the courts for decades and some of the things you hear absolutely shock you. You learn to keep a poker face, and never react. From opposing experts, witness statements that are thoroughly debunked, illegal acts that slip through a loophole, lawyers twisting everything around to insane reactions at verdict. The worst for me was family hearings. Seeing children given to clearly godawful parents broke my heart, but legally nothing we could do.

[@youtuber6193]

If it wasn’t for the scratches over his body, his bleeding knuckles and the 3 different lies he told about where he was going, I’d be inclined to believe his story. However, those bits of evidence are pretty damning. He looked like he’d been in a fight with someone who fought back. Therefore I think he’s guilty. He pulled over, beat her, and possibly strangled her, dragged her back in the car and staged the scene. The kids ask “why would he go to all that trouble when he has 28 guns and could’ve shot her?” Because he wanted to get away with it is why.

[@moniqueloomis9772]

🥇

[@awesomebeautiful8782]

Plus, no evidence of a truck going by on the video camera.

[@gailnovak2593]

@@awesomebeautiful8782maybe it pulled off of a side road-where the camera could not see

[@Komediennekymd2009]

48hrs NEVER disappoint

[@michellecg4771]

NEVER EVER!

[@patriceryan]

I would have liked them to explain why her cousins denounced him. 48 hours just dropped that juicy nugget into the story and left us hanging.

[@alyssstout8112]

@@patriceryanYes, why would they not look deeper into that? Nor did they look into the couple’s relationship in general.

[@jimwerther]

This episode TOTALLY disappointed. Erin Moriarty twisted herself into pretzels trying to make a murderer look innocent.

[@heathermetz6576]

Facts.

[@flipina]

The daughter and son didn’t even cry a little talking about their mom. Only when the dad was mentioned, and she didn’t even say what she missed about mom.

[@ClipZ_Gaming_1]

It’s a heavily edited 40 minute video. You have NO idea what she did or did not cry over. You know NOTHING about her or anyone you see on TV.

[@m.mh92]

@@ClipZ_Gaming_1 Okay Karin 🙄

[@alisong2328]

Well, it had been 6 years, and the focus of the show was their dad.

[@mrsbluesky8415]

@@ClipZ_Gaming_1neither do you

[@gaslitworldf.melissab2897]

She probably had morals and expectations. So, they favored Dad.

[@PigNewton]

I saw the picture of his hands afterwards, every knuckle was injured. He beat her to death, the mother of his children, complete scumbag.

[@terrorsquadlith]

he hit it on the windshield

[@dartdude4084]

He hit her and the windshield. Why punch the windshield? Cmon man

[@redacted2275]

Oh, YOU saw it? Then case closed! 😒 I hope you won't ever be in any judge jury.

[@ScoDucks24]

@@redacted2275the deciding factor is the photos of the car in the ditch WITHOUT a broken windshield like 5 minutes before he called 911…he absolutely killed her and punched the window to further push his narrative

[@whateverme86]

@@redacted2275we didn’t see it but there’s evidence he killed his wife. You don’t have to be a rocket scientist to understand evidence and putting the pieces together.

[@rameshrolla1574]

Guy does windshield repair for living and this happened through windshield...and his t-shirt says " I don't give a rat's ass".. can't be a coincidence I guess

[@bonnielarson4160]

And he didn’t have the glass with him to do the repair.

[@missmicheleeexo2269]

​@@bonnielarson4160well the fact he didn't have the glass with him to do the job isn't that concerning to me because according to him, he was going to take the guys truck to his house and do it. So you wouldn't bring it all with you if that was the case, you'd leave it at the place you're doing the repair. But the fact they asked the guy who Todd claimed was the one he was doing the windshield for and the guy said he didn't need a repair, never booked one, Todd was never coming to get the truck... THAT is the problematic part.

[@bonnielarson4160]

@missmicheleeexo2269 he didn’t have it at his house either, why make someone late to work to pick up a truck, to repair when you didn’t have what was needed, take her to work, get the glass, then get the truck, there isn't an urgent need to get the truck, so why go out of your way to make her late. He supposedly did everything for her, why would he make her late, why didn't they ask the kids about that, "was it normal for your mom to be late, would your mom normally go along with your dad to pick up vehicles?", my guess is no to either question.

[@furball192]

I felt the choice of shirt was odd, the adhd shirt as well

[@karenohanlon4183]

​@@missmicheleeexo2269 Todd changed the windscreen story that many times. He probably killed her with the pole thing then staged the windscreen smash. His daughter did not seem too concerned that the grandchildren would miss her mother. More vocal about Todd. The police seemed pretty certain he killed his wife. And he did have a motive we just don't know it. Could be Jekyll and Hyde personality. Guilty as...

[@WastingAwaytrying]

Just one look at Todd's crazy eyes and I know he's guilty!

[@Dulceeeeblog]

right??

[@JJ-iq8mi]

So dark and creepy.

[@MT-oi2ty]

Absolutely

[@ELYASELYAS]

He had like 28 guns! Yes, they'd all be traceable and be found out...

[@joannegregory3024]

Exactly he wanted it to appear to be an accident, a gun of his would have been an accident

[@ELYASELYAS]

@ He would have had to explain why his wife suddenly decided to pick up a gun and, for example, clean it and accidentally discharge it. Also, gunshot residue and bullet trajectory are much harder to create convoluted narratives for, because the science is clear on both.

[@IMOO1896]

In my opinion, the fact that the pipe made 2 impressions in the windshield- impossible, if the pipe had penetrated the glass and somehow come back out then rotated and penetrated the glass again, the best I can come up with is the pipe would have hit horizontally the second hit, also Barbara would have asked hubby to take her to work then go to pick up the other vehicle, which there’s no substantial evidence the other vehicle existed. Then man is lying!

[@gjmbarusha6999]

My goodness, why are the suspects’ families always so naive. I hope I won’t be this naive when a family member of mine commits a heinous crime 🤦🏾‍♂️

[@lcam9241]

When not if?? Oh my. Let's hope they never do.

[@GanGster_Gato]

​@lcam9241 😂😂😂😂I know, right.

[@gjmbarusha6999]

@@lcam9241 some of us have serious trust issues 😉

[@LucyElizabeth83]

I think it would be so hard to comprehend a family member could do something so horrible. The evidence speaks for itself in most cases though and I couldn’t look past it.

[@ClipZ_Gaming_1]

Oh you definitely would be. Don’t judge them so harshly, it’s their father.

[@stephanielloyd4053]

Kids are in denial. Why wouldn't he use a gun? Pretty flipping obvious! He thought this would look like an accident!

[@LoremLipsumz]

Just because the fractured bone in the throat wasn’t the result of strangulation doesn’t mean he didn’t strike her in the throat. Biggest evidence to his guilt is there was no truck on video going the opposite way. He planned it, he had that pipe in his trunk.

[@KK-ol5ov]

Kids in denial, he is guilty but what is the motive? Just tired of her?

[@TawnyC_]

She was probably leaving him.

[@gj5990]

Some don’t need much of a motive other than their delusions or hate.

[@ballistic350]

They wasted their savings for their lying dad ...

[@pinkpugginz]

People on reddit said he was in major debt that she did not know about.

[@st-nw7tm]

He was literally texting her all day everyday. During her work breaks she would have to call/text him. Literally every break she had at work. He drove her to work everyday too. She literally was always with him. That sounds suffocating. Perhaps she was done with decades+ of that and wanted something different for herself.

[@OMundoParaIniciantes]

So, why was he driving in the wrong direction????

[@Janadu]

It always amazes me how families can be so delusional. I feel sorry for his kids, but they're old enough to accept reality.

[@xxNinjaclanxx-id9rs]

Text book cognitive dissonance

[@Janadu]

@@xxNinjaclanxx-id9rs And when the interviewer asked how she missed her mother, the daughter kept defaulting back to talking about her father. Something is hinky here.

[@ruthmelicharles5062]

They can't accept that their loved ones are monsters.

[@MariaKoroleva.Realtor]

As soon as I heard that he replaced broken windshields for extra income, I knew where the inspiration for his crime came from

[@jessicahannah2522]

I fail to see the connection. People who build houses, if someone dies in one, are they guilty? If someone works on cars and someone dies in a car, are they automatically guilty? He worked in a factory, absolutely no one said maybe that is where the pipe came from. A random pipe just appears when he needs it? Well, they DID find a second pipe, approximately the same as the one that hit them, about 50 feet down the road. TWO pipes? Hm. Must be the windshield that's guilty.

[@ghanabaaremeyawabas3074]

Exactly dear...same here

[@BusyMagnaBee]

Things that might cause a person to say .. hmmm. #1 - Why is he taking her with him to pick up a truck for windshield repair (for three different men who say they did not request the repair)? Why is he taking her with him and making her late to work .. when she is known for never being late? Deep Cuts on his knuckles, especially left hand (is he left-hand dominant?) Scratches on his neck and face How could he break the windshield by striking it with his hand from the driver’s seat? Why did he not try to flag down the person who drove by his car at 8:00 that morning? Did the person who drove by that morning see that the windshield was broken? Why would he take time away from rendering aid to his wife to pull the pipe out of the windshield? Did the pipe have Barbara’s blood on it? His fingerprints on it? Did the water jug have her blood or tissue on it to support the theory that her cricoid bone was broken by her striking the jug when she ducked to avoid being struck by the pipe?

[@truthbetold6942]

The witness said the windshield was not broken.

[@ReadtheBible88]

I would be honored if anyone would wish this old man Happy Birthday today. 92 years old and still going strong.

[@Sch586]

Happy 92nd birthday🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉

[@gitana6791]

Happy Birthday 🎂🎉

[@margota]

Happy Birthday! How blessed you are to live so long. ❤ I hope you feel loved and appreciated.

[@ReadtheBible88]

@@Sch586Thank you so much.

[@ReadtheBible88]

@@gitana6791thank you so much

[@deborahpeterson9223]

Gorgeous property, gorgeous wife. So...this dude is so homely! I'm sorry, but he had what most men would love to have, yet, he didn't deserve her. What is wrong with this dude? What a lying scumbag!

[@vioricarezik5492]

His children are in denial .I don’t see a lot of tears for losing their beautiful mother .The husband is a liar.

[@hallelujahhallelujah7694]

children know but they prefer to ignore the truth, because they refuse to live and lose their father too

[@xxNinjaclanxx-id9rs]

Yep, cognitive dissonance for sure

[@Yusuave]

It's 2024 people, no reason not to get a dashcam

[@btrueeth]

@@Yusuave money is one reason. Especially my case.

[@nicoledenning8090]

so true!

[@lencicollier6492]

EXACTLY!… Absolutely NO reason not to have a “dash-cam”… FWD & AFT facing… 👈🏽👉🏽

[@Gorgeous493]

I wonder why did they not dust the pipe to see if other finger prints would have been found. Maybe give origins of the pipe?

[@OneRyLove]

I honestly feel there is so much more they could’ve done. Small town investigators I guess

[@evapunk522]

They might have done that & didn't get anything off of it so it was possibly inconclusive & irrelevant to the investigation.

[@kiwigal8134]

His fingerprints would be on the pipe anyway, cause it stated in the video he had pulled it out of the windscreen.

[@gracendunge9212]

How did the pipe fly and shoot the wife at the back ??

[@MsTatu3]

His leg was really shaking when being interviewed

[@happygolucky7020]

it was an act trust me.

[@Ellewatch-y3j]

Yes, I noticed that too, he seemed extremely nervous to be interviewed about what happened

[@Eirini1]

@@Ellewatch-y3jyes

[@theresa78201]

He had not yet taken his anxiety medication that day.

[@peaharrison9071]

He claimed ^

[@John-ev3rm]

Take a step back and look at the totality of circumstantial evidence and the only plausible explanation is that he killed her.

[@brandoncox3316]

It is self evident to Everyone else that he killed Barbara, except his children....so sad 😔. RIP Barbara

[@barrymicockiner5773]

There is definitely enough reasonable doubt surrounding this case

[@mamamia8284]

@@barrymicockiner5773no there’s not, any doubt would be unreasonable.

[@barrymicockiner5773]

@mamamia8284 Thats like, your opinion, man

[@charleylee4651]

And fyi, a young woman just went thru this,she was on a rd, behind a truck and a pipe went thru the windshield into her chest, she was able to call 911 and pull the car to the side of the rd.

[@jenna-a-gogo]

She was lucky. People have died from it. Whether or not that happened in this case is anyone's guess.

[@btrueeth]

Yeah! In this case, the pipe and the coffee mug been flying around in the car causing multiple injuries to just the woman's head and neck.

[@missmicheleeexo2269]

​@@btrueethI'm sorry but I laughed at your comment. 😂 It's just so ridiculous - the hoops they're jumping through to try and explain it away. The coffee mug hit her in the throat then wrapped around the seat and hit her in the back of the head? The pipe hit her in the front of the head and the back cause she ducked? Come on.

[@sandrabentley8111]

​@@btrueethno she had injuries and scratches on her body.

[@TimeSkipChapters]

⏱️ Timestamps by TimeSkip ⏱️ 00:00:00 - Introduction & Background 00:01:05 - Accident Details & Initial Response 00:02:06 - Investigation & Motive Exploration 00:04:08 - Eyewitness Accounts & Family Insights 00:06:00 - Todd's Relationship with Barbara 00:08:12 - The Day of the Incident 00:09:15 - Emergency Call & Todd's Account 00:11:32 - Police Investigation & Suspicion 00:13:57 - Medical Examination Findings 00:19:35 - Todd's Arrest & Trial 00:20:39 - Medical Examiner's Testimony 00:21:55 - Disputed Evidence: Windshield Analysis 00:22:43 - Prosecution's Argument on Intent 00:24:14 - Todd Kendhammer Takes the Stand 00:26:21 - Witness Testimonies and Family Impact 00:29:31 - Evidentiary Hearing: New Defense Team 00:30:22 - Forensic Pathologist's New Findings 00:33:22 - Controversial Evidence: The Pipe Incident 00:37:31 - Expert Opinions on Injuries and Cause of Death 00:39:13 - Jury's Perspective on the Verdict 00:40:10 - Missing Grandparents' Impact 00:41:04 - Prosecutor's Perspective 00:42:06 - Final Thoughts

[@Noellevrr]

Not all heroes wear capes 🙏🏼

[@nicoledenning8090]

wow impressive

[@marlonisaac1]

Thank you!!!!

[@sherylrodgers4817]

Guilty guilty guilty!

[@ftgjt21]

Reporter: "Tell us about your deceased mother" Children: "....we miss our dad" wtf??

[@mncedisinyathi3263]

Thank you. Watching from Bulawayo, Zimbabwe

[@Yusuave]

Y'all get internet over there in the mud huts? 😂

[@mamarobyn]

That's cool!

[@mamarobyn]

​@@Yusuavea little bit rude, you know, Zimbabwe is a huge thriving city. Well, I don't know about thriving. I think they've had some political issues. But people live like in homes and apartments there as well. Geez l o l.

[@nonjabulomakhathini6795]

​@@Yusuave so unnecessary and rude

[@NPitts-cw3oe]

I haven't even watched this yet. 48 hours has NO IDEA how they literally MAKE my morning!

[@Williamb612]

something about him having a side business of repairing car broken windshields feels off

[@judedonnelly4100]

THE DAUGHTER/SISTER WON'T LET HER BROTHER SPEAK !!!!!!!!!!!! SOOOOOOOOO ANNOYING !!!!!!!

[@JY-tq8dr]

I noticed this! The son/brother hardly spoke a word.

[@louispina2656]

She annoyed me so bad 😖😖

[@bonnielarson4160]

Maybe that's how mom was, and Todd got tired of it?

[@mrsbluesky8415]

He knows

[@caramileelliott1719]

Because she’s a narcissist like her dad!!

[@bocateeca]

When the daughter was asked what she missed most about her Mom, she gave no answer. I'm thinking that maybe they didn't have a very good relationship.

[@hawasada77]

Things are not adding up! He lied several times as to why he was on that road. The passerby saw the car on the side of the road but no pipe. The accident was at 8am, assuming she had to be to work earlier than 8am, she didn’t call her job.,She also didn’t call her Mom (assuming she called prior to work) He is definitely guilty

[@maminti2003]

On the photo with his wife before the "accident" I see a kind woman and a disturbed man with anxiety in his eyes. It is easy to see. He was not well mentally. This woman and man were worlds apart. His odd behaviour is not caused by the "accident".

[@LionofJudah222]

I saw that as well

[@molliemae6855]

I have a friend who worked as a state trooper in Ohio and she told me about a time when this couple were driving on I75 in Ohio and the female was in the passenger seat. Something had hit the windshield but not serious enough to stop the car. What ever hit the car wasn’t a big object. The man driving didn’t realize anything was wrong at first. It was night time. The female had her head turned from him. It was a little while until he realized she wasn’t talking anymore. That’s when he realized something was VERY wrong. The couple had been driving down the road, talking, laughing everything fine when something flew through the windshield and hit her in the head and killed her instantly. Remember what the speed limit is on the highway. It wouldn’t take a big object to do a lot of damage. She told me that over 20 years ago and I still think about how in an instant your life can turn upside down!

[@jenna-a-gogo]

The only person who knows whether or not that happened in this 48 Hours case is the husband. But it certainly has happened before, including in this story you cited.

[@btrueeth]

How do you explain all the bruising she sustained? If it was one hit and if that was sever enough, I can understand. But multiple wound on her head? The pipe and/ or mug will have to be flying around to cause multiple damage to her. And the husband didn't have any injury from any of those objects. Also the speed at which either the truck or his vehicle was going at, does really matter.

[@ChiefVictor]

Exactly why a window repair guy would think to stage the scene in this way

[@missmicheleeexo2269]

There's been plenty of stories/real life scenarios where items come loose from other vehicles traveling and it lands on someone's car or goes through the windshield. That's not a far-fetched idea. The problem here is that we have video of the entire road where Todd says this happened and the ONLY car on that road at the time... Was HIM!

[@mrsbluesky8415]

So the object broke the windshield but he didn’t notice anything wrong. Very sus.

[@breeze_and_sky]

the defense lawyers are so cringe...now they saying the pipe hit her in the back of the neck while the mug hit her in the front while Todd punched the windshield....lol

[@JJ-iq8mi]

😂

[@mefranmefran7133]

Why did she have bruises all over her body? Are they trying to say the coffee mug did that too? That's some powerful drink container to crush her throat and bounce around all over her entire body. Sounds like it was more dangerous than the pipe.

[@erikschultz6865]

Coffee cup thing is absurd.

[@MichelleLyn84]

I’ve been in a horrible accident where I hit a horse, it hit my windshield, I didn’t get any scratches at all anywhere. Even though my whole interior was caved in. There’s no way he got those scratches from that. I don’t even know if his knuckles would be busted open like they were from the windshield. Also it still doesn’t matter she didn’t call into work, he didn’t go where he was supposed to go, nothing adds up even if it’s possible. He could’ve recreated something that’s possible and be guilty at the same time!!