4k - To Buy or Not to Buy: Revisited

In this video I revisit an older video of mine where I discuss 5 movies I upgraded to 4k and 5 that I didn't with reasons why.
4K - To Buy or Not to Buy
• 4K - To Buy or Not to Buy
Intro designed by / tylerinternet
Follow me on my socials if you're into that sorta thing / shelf_tales
letterboxd.com... / tales_from_the_shelf

[@ColoradoKid303]

I’ll tell you right now. The ones you aren’t upgrading are MUST upgrades if you love those movies. They really are significantly better.

[@Talesfromtheshelf]

Perhaps I will one day!

[@jrlangdon89]

I have over 7300 in my collection

[@lanceyt9982]

The Warriors I agree if you don't like the Blu Ray release go ahead. I don't have a 4k player so I will stick with Blu Ray for now

[@AngelValdez-mr3fq]

I use my xbox series x as a 4k blue ray player. Playstation 5 can also play 4k dvd.

[@matthouston8411]

I have a ton of dvd, a few BD, and recently got into 4k quickly buying around 50 4k movies. BD discs look great, but 4k discs look like I am seeing it as intended. Sometimes mix and match is the way to go. Save money on the ones you want but don't stare at, buy 4k for the ones you love and rewatch. 4k physical is to streaming what a ferrari is to a ford pinto. no comparison

[@Talesfromtheshelf]

I very much subscribe to this method of thinking. Thanks for watching 🫡

[@austinwillcut4919]

I have that Warriors 4K, it's a pretty definitive release. I pre ordered Arrow's Silence/Lambs 4K as well.

[@Talesfromtheshelf]

Hell yeah very nice

[@stuartobrien78]

The Star Wars complete saga blu ray is the best picture I've ever seen. I only have a Full HD TV, so the contrast is also alot darker on my Dads Samsung Oled.

[@stuartobrien78]

Phenomena Synapse films 4k looks magnificent. Colours are rich.

[@bulletsforteeth5029]

I've recently upgraded to a 4k TV and player, both units are set up to play Dolby Vision and Atmos, which is a huge upgrade from standard DVD/BR content. So when looking at physical media, I'm looking for media that's compatible to my set up. I still buy BR's, but 4k UHD Dolby Vision/Atmos is a selling point for me to get that as close to the theater experience as possible, all I have to do is add popcorn.

[@Talesfromtheshelf]

This is a very important factor, I’m glad you brought this up. I feel like many people buy 4ks and aren’t using the proper set up to get the full potential out of their discs.

[@bulletsforteeth5029]

@@Talesfromtheshelf Well it clearly say's on many of the 4k cases what equipment you need for the best experience, some don't. You have to zoom in and look for the DTS and Dolby branding. As long as your TV and player are rated for both HDR10, HDR10+, DTS Audio, Dolby Vision/Atmos, you can get an awesome experience from both BR/4k physical media. It depends, sometimes BR's are a great value if they offer Dolby Audio/Atmos, that's a great buy on a budget, if you can get a 4k with both Dolby Vision/Atmos, with the bonus Blue Ray disk, even better. You should do a video on how to read the back of the box and zoom in on what people should be looking for on their given set up. People who don't own 4k TV's or players but are planning on upgrading in the future, will find value in sticking with blue rays, but might want to consider buying both the BR/4k packages so they have the 4k disk on hand when they upgrade. Great channel, happy to sub! 😁👍💯

[@994pt4]

Haha, I had the exact thoughts on Crimson Peak....have the Blu-ray and yep, I'm good. And yes, when I buy a Blu-ray and 6 months later they release the 4K I NEVER upgrade...not playing that game. Most of my 4K's are of older movies shot on actual film stock that benefit the most from 4K. good topic!

[@Talesfromtheshelf]

Great minds think alike!! Thanks for watching

[@johnpajestka5022]

With everything costing so much more I changed my process on buying 4k movies. It needs to be a huge upgrade or a favorite for me to buy the 4k disc. Modern TVs and players upscale really good and Nit ratings on new TVs for SDR is great as well. Don't feel like I'll ever regret just having the Blu-ray.

[@Talesfromtheshelf]

Strong agree

[@iloveblue7920]

Will you get the 4k of Silence of the Lambs ?

[@Talesfromtheshelf]

I’m good with my criterion

[@TheNotoriousNemo]

i am a new collector, so i only buy 4k movies, i got a nice 4k tv and surround sound system. Just recently the studio release of Drive 4k steelbook is coming out, I already own the second sight 4k, so to double dip or not? this is my first collector problem lol

[@Talesfromtheshelf]

Honestly this is a good time to get into it. When I got in in 2018, 4k wasn’t really the norm yet. So I was exclusively getting blu rays. From then on it was constant 4k upgrades being announced lol

[@AchtungEnglander]

Nothing worse than a recent acquisition on Blu, only for the 4K to get announced/released weeks after... Amen for editing your collection that speaks of who you are as opposed to buying everything on sight which becomes a strong case of diminishing returns and also you will suffer from huge buyers remorse.

[@Talesfromtheshelf]

Buyers remorse is real, man. I think too many collectors these days blindly buy everything without even considering whether they actually, truly need it.

[@AngelValdez-mr3fq]

NEVER Blind buy a 4k dvd. It's too much money to spend on a movie you have no idea if you like.

[@EcopiuM]

Any 4K that uses a moderate and upwards amount of DNR is an immediate no buy for me unless it the overall presentation is really remarkable. Saves me a good amount of coin given the obscene prices over here in Australia

[@Talesfromtheshelf]

Man I didn’t even think about the issue of being overseas with 4k. That certainly complicates things.

[@AngelValdez-mr3fq]

I only buy action/Sci fi in 4k. No comedies or horror because not being able to see everything clearly adds to the atmosphere.

[@Talesfromtheshelf]

I can respect this take

[@KirkRedgate]

We're similar collectors. Every release I buy is because I like the film and want it on my shelf. I don't have the money or space to fill my room with junk. Quality over quantity. I currently have about 60 4Ks, 200 Blu-ray's, and 100 DVDs that I didn’t want to get rid off. After Hours and The Warriors were must upgrades. I'm still gonna get Sleepy Hollow at some point, never owned a physical. Cool posters btw, Carnival of Souls and Night of the Living Dead, etc. I have those. Great films. I never make use of my posters, I must have tons lol.

[@Talesfromtheshelf]

Hey thanks for the kind words! Always nice to meet someone else with good taste and similar opinions. I appreciate it.

[@KirkRedgate]

@Talesfromtheshelf Indeed it is. Speaking of Carnival and Night... have you seen Messiah of Evil? I bought the Radiance Blu-ray a few months ago. It's like a mixture of the two. Amazing film.

[@gleamingtv3946]

Good points. I like upgrading to 4k on most but certain films I’m good with the blu ray(such as Crimson Peak, I like the movie but not enough to upgrade). but I have to say, I have that Roadhouse shout blu ray, and it literally looked like a dvd compared to the Vinegar Syndrome 4k, I was blown away. but overall I view 4k upgrading as a luxury that I don’t need right away (most of the time), waiting for price drops is when I like to swoop in for some 4ks.

[@Talesfromtheshelf]

Exactly, 4ks are like a luxury, not a necessity. If I ever get the chance I may get the road house 4k, but it’s not a priority by any means. Thanks for watching !

[@SFtheGreat]

When they make 4K like Aliens and the other AI botched stuff, I'm glad I still have my VHS. Other than that, any new release should just be 4K.

[@Talesfromtheshelf]

I agree man

[@SFtheGreat]

@@Talesfromtheshelf At this point, if you want to make 4K scan the original film again. Let's take LotR for example, the 4K isn't sourced from 4K transfers. The DNR is so absurd it removes details from the elements. And it still is not proper open matte.

[@jforester7]

Various factors determine whether or not I intend to go for 4K, or stick with Blu Ray. One big factor for me is whether or not the Blu Ray actually looks good. A perfect example of this for me is Blade Runner, the original. It looks absolutely gorgeous and I don't really feel a desire to upgrade. It's also a factor with that film that it's not exactly one of my favorite movies. My mantra with whether or not to upgrade to 4K or not is pretty simple, if you want to, do it, if you don't feel the need, don't. Pretty simple and not really something that requires any sort of community debate. It's fun to talk about though. Great video.

[@Talesfromtheshelf]

Thanks for watching !! I agree, while there are definitely a lot of criteria, at the end of the day it’s either a yes or a no. It’s so varied person to person that I enjoy the discussion.

[@AngelValdez-mr3fq]

I Do not own any blue rays. Only the ones that come with the 4ks.

[@jforester7]

@@AngelValdez-mr3fq Then you're missing out on a lot of good movies that either won't get a 4K anytime soon, or for sure never will.

[@Jumpman67]

I've heard there's a new version of T2 on 4k being worked on (as well as The Terminator). I'm hoping that restoration comes out better than the first one.

[@Talesfromtheshelf]

It’s James Cameron so we can only hope it comes out good haha.

[@mackjay1777]

Good points and I totally agree about 4K upgrade not always being worth it, over the blu-ray

[@Talesfromtheshelf]

Yeah I feel like more often than not, the blu ray is fine.

[@AngelValdez-mr3fq]

We need kill bill and reign of fire in 4k

[@Talesfromtheshelf]

Agree!

[@JohnDoe-bz4yl]

We need all of Mr Quentin Tarantino's movies on 4K

[@WilkysMoviesandMusic]

Thanks for video, it's interesting to hear reasoning behind what people choose to upgrade or not. Also you have a great practice keeping track of what you are spending and adjusting budget if needed.

[@Talesfromtheshelf]

Wilky! Thanks for watching man. I would encourage all collectors to track their spending, it is really important to hold ourselves accountable imo.

[@iloveblue7920]

I have T2 on steelbookblu-ray and heard the 4k is not great and will wait till it comes out

[@Talesfromtheshelf]

Good move imo

[@StephenAtt797]

everyone has their own constraints around upgrades - $$, space, etc. I favor 4K when buying new, I do upgrade my "must watch collectionis", but the overriding factor for me is the audio format. Asmost often, the 4K will have the upgraded audio: Atmos, DTS:X. I will often buy the Bluray over the 4K for movies when the Bluray has the same audio track. My TV, BR player and Nvidia Shield all offer 4K upscaling. So as shelf space is now my limiting factor, I'm going to limit my upgrades (already done star wars, harry potter, Indy Jones, etc). Not sure if I've ever watch everything already in my collection (mortality clock is always ticking)!

[@Talesfromtheshelf]

Really great points all around. Most people even if they have a great tv don’t always have great surround sound to really get the most out of their discs.

[@StephenAtt797]

@@Talesfromtheshelf Yes, I have heard polling that shows 80% of people only use their TV's speakers a real waste of Media experiences!

[@Holland_Oates]

It does seem weird to see just a bluray of Roadhouse when that should probably be the norm. We've been conditioned. 😂😂😂

[@Talesfromtheshelf]

I am tempted by boutique packaging just like anyone else haha especially for my favorite movies. I’m just able to say no more often than not.

[@BeyondTheGraveMedia]

Spread the word!

[@Talesfromtheshelf]

Thank you !!